Contact Information:

Media Contact

Carole Gan

Twitter: UCDavisHealth

Kredyty mieszkaniowe Kredyty mieszkaniowe

Sprawdź aktualny ranking najlepszych kredytów mieszkaniowych w Polsce - atrakcyjne kredytowanie nieruchomości. - Press Release Distribution
RSS - Press News Release
Add Press Release

UC Davis study shows popular molecular tests

( (SACRAMENTO, Calif.) - Clostridium difficile is a common cause of infection and diarrhea in hospitalized patients, but a new study by UC Davis pathologists suggests that many patients are mistakenly diagnosed and do not need antibiotic treatment. As a result, patients are likely being over-diagnosed and over-treated, adding to concerns about antibiotic resistance, damage to the "good" bacteria that live in people's intestines, and increased health-care costs.

"It all depends on the type of test doctors use to diagnose patients," said Christopher R. Polage, associate professor of pathology and infectious diseases at UC Davis Medical Center and first author of the study. "Molecular tests are great at detecting C. difficile DNA in the laboratory but probably over diagnose a lot of patients in hospitals, if doctors assume that everyone with a positive result needs treatment."

On Sept. 8 Polage and colleagues reported results of a two-year study in JAMA Internal Medicine that examined clinical outcomes in patients with conflicting results by common tests used to diagnose C. difficile infection in the U.S. For the study, researchers evaluated 1,416 hospitalized patients tested for C. difficile at UC Davis, tracking the outcomes and severity of infection according to the results of toxin tests versus molecular tests such as PCR.

The surprising conclusion of the study was that newer molecular tests, which have been adopted by nearly half of U.S. hospitals over the last six years, are unable to distinguish infected patients who need treatment from patients who are colonized with the bacteria and do fine without treatment.

"Over the past several years there has been a movement nationally and around the world to change test methods for C. difficile diagnosis from traditional toxin tests to newer, molecular tests," Polage said. "This has been driven by concern that patients with infections were being missed, but very few studies looked at clinical outcomes to see if these concerns were justified."

In the study, patients diagnosed with C. difficile using a traditional toxin test had more severe disease, a longer duration of symptoms and greater risk of bad outcomes, validating their need for treatment. In comparison, patients who were positive by the new molecular test but negative by the traditional toxin test had milder symptoms and outcomes that were similar to patients without C. difficile, even without treatment.

"This finding caused us to question whether these patients really had a C. difficile infection or needed treatment at all," he said.

Polage noted that a large number of patients in acute-care facilities and hospitals are colonized with C. difficile without having an active infection and don't need treatment. Because colonized patients can be five to 10 times more common than those with symptomatic infection, he emphasized how important it is to use the test methods that can make this distinction.

"The reality is that diarrhea has many causes in hospitalized patients and sometimes patients with C. difficile colonization have diarrhea that has nothing to do C. difficile," he said. So, if you only detect DNA or the presence of the organism, you haven't necessarily proven that the organism is what's causing those symptoms. Yet, doctors routinely assume that all patients with positive molecular test results are infected and treat everyone with antibiotics, even when they might be better off left alone."

Treating patients for a C. difficile infection with antibiotics when they don't necessarily have an active infection contributes to antibiotic resistance and upsets the normal balance of bacteria in the intestines. It may even prolong diarrheal symptoms and increase the likelihood of transmission, he said.

"The more antibiotics we give, the more collateral damage we do to the microbiome, wiping out lots of beneficial bacteria that don't need to be treated. In addition, if we give antibiotics when they're not needed, we potentially perpetuate the cycle of C. difficile spread and infection."

Polage conducted the study because he wanted to know if the extra patients detected by molecular tests had clinically significant symptoms or any of the negative outcomes traditionally associated with C. difficile infection. After a five-year historical study showed no complications among patients with negative toxin tests, he decided to evaluate outcomes prospectively to determine if one type of test was a better predictor of clinical disease and outcome.

"We found that virtually all of the bad, negative outcomes occurred in the patients with positive toxin tests," Polage said. "This suggests that we should really focus on toxin-positive patients for treatment. There may be room for trying to improve the sensitivity of toxin tests and look for additional tests to help identify patients at greatest risk for bad outcomes. Apart from this, we need to understand that most toxin-negative patients don't need treatment and may not even be infected."

Data from the National Healthcare Safety Network (NHSN), an arm of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention that tracks hospital-acquired conditions, suggest that 40 to 45 percent of NHSN-reporting hospitals currently use molecular tests, either alone or in combination with other tests. Polage says that this translates to almost half of facilities in the U.S. potentially over diagnosing patients.

He said that hospitals that made the switch to molecular tests experienced a dramatic increase in the number of patients they reported with positive C. difficile infection. Many noticed an immediate doubling in the number of these patients, adding to concerns that they would be penalized for using a more sensitive test relative to other facilities.

"Our data suggest that these hospitals were really over-reporting C. difficile, over diagnosing these patients, and that these patients probably didn't have Clostridium difficile infection," he said. "So, some of the reporting differences between hospitals may be an artifact of testing rather than a real difference in C. difficile infections."

Polage recommends that physicians and laboratories move in a direction of defining C. difficile disease based on the detection of toxins and limit molecular tests to screening, similar to Europe and the United Kingdom.


This study was supported by grant number UL1 RR024146 and TL1 RR024145-06 from the National Center for Research Resources (CRP); grant number UL1TR000002 and linked award TL1TR000133 from the National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences (DLC); and grant number T32HS022236 from the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) through the Quality Safety Comparative Effectiveness Research Training (QSCERT) Program (DLC). C. difficile diagnostic test kits and reagents were received from Cepheid, Meridian Biosciences, TechLab, and Alere.


Blood and teeth samples accurately predict a criminal's age

Forensic biomedical scientists from KU Leuven, Belgium, have developed a test to predict individuals' age on the basis of blood or teeth samples. This test may be particularly useful for the police, as it can help track down criminals or identify human remains. When forensic examiners find traces of blood at a crime scene, they can try to identify the perpetrator on the basis of DNA. From now on, the blood samples can also be used to predict the criminal's age. This is also the case for deceased individuals: when traditional methods do not lead to identification, the ...

False alarm from the body may be responsible for acute pancreatitis

Researchers at Lund University in Sweden may have discovered one of the keys to understanding how the body develops acute pancreatitis. The results offer hope for the development of drugs that specifically target the disease. Within gastro research it is a well-known fact that the excessive activation of a type of white blood cells, neutrophils, causes the inflammation of the pancreas. Until now, however, there has been no satisfactory explanation for what causes neutrophil activation. Three research groups at Lund University have worked together to find an answer. "Our ...

Statistical model may identify patients who can benefit from surgery for mesothelioma

Chicago, September 8, 2015 - A new statistical model may help predict which patients are most likely to receive life-extending benefits from surgical treatment for malignant pleural mesothelioma (MPM), according to an article in the September 2015 issue of the Annals of Thoracic Surgery. Key points A new statistical model may help identify which patients will benefit most from surgery for malignant pleural mesothelioma. Younger age, no history of asbestos exposure, epithelioid histology, and a low number of affected lymph nodes were strongly associated with better ...

The Achilles' heel of HI virus

The Achilles heel of HI virus
Researchers at the University of Bonn have discovered how cells in the body can detect the genetic material of so-called retroviruses. The pathogen of the immunodeficiency disease AIDS, the HI-1 virus, also belongs to this group. At the same time, the HI virus appears to circumvent this important defense mechanism. The researchers are now presenting their results in the renowned journal Nature Immunology. The first line of defense of the immune system against pathogens is innate immunity. It is based on specialized sensor proteins, the receptors. These receptors detect ...

A new type of Au deposits: The decratonic gold deposits

Gold is a kind of rare precious metal and has a wide-range use. Gold price has been rising since the 80's of the last century. The great demand for gold has not only stimulated gold exploration but also led to the need of understanding the genesis of gold deposits. A number of models have been advanced to explain how gold deposits were formed, and several types of gold deposits are accordingly established, such as the Witwatersrand-type, porphyry-type, Carlin-type, epithermal (low and high sulphidation), and orogenic gold deposits. These popular models, however, can hardly ...

Injection drug use limits benefits of surgery for treatment of heart lining infection

Chicago, September 8, 2015 - Injection drug users who undergo surgery for infective endocarditis (IE) have a significantly higher risk of reoperation or death between 3 and 6 months after surgery compared to patients who develop endocarditis who are not IV drug abusers, according to an article in the September 2015 issue of the Annals of Thoracic Surgery. Key points: Patients with active injection drug use who undergo surgery for infective endocarditis have a 10-fold increased risk of reoperation or death between 3 and 6 months after surgery compared to non-drug abusers. The ...

Ants on the march in non-native conifer forests

A species of ant is thriving in habitats created by thousands of acres of coniferous forest planted in a UK National Park in the last 60 years, according to new research by scientists from the Department of Biology at the University of York and Forest Research, the Forestry Commission's research agency. The success of the northern hairy wood ant (Formica lugubris) in colonising plantations of largely non-native coniferous species in the North York Moors National Park supports recent suggestions that non-native plantations can have positive influences on forest-dependent ...

Canadian Researchers answer important scientific debate connected to heart disease

Ottawa - September 8, 2015 - Researchers from the University of Ottawa Heart Institute (UOHI), together with the teams of Dr. Martin Farrell at Oxford University, and Dr. Sekar Kathiresan at the Broad Institute, have found the answer to an ongoing debate in the cardiovascular scientific world. Dr. Ruth McPherson and Dr. Majid Nikpay, researchers at the UOHI's Ruddy Canadian Cardiovascular Genetics Centre, report that the genetic basis of heart disease is largely derived from the cumulative effect of multiple common genetic variants, rather than from a few rare variants ...

Children overcoming adversity

Making a plan can be the difference in overcoming a difficult childhood, while just thinking about those difficulties can drag down the child. A set of four new studies from researchers at USC and Southwest University in China suggest, contrary to prior belief, children in difficult situations need to do more than dream of a happier and successful future self: They need a strategy for becoming that person. Two of the studies found eighth graders performed better in school if they had strategies for becoming their future selves, as well as several options for becoming ...

Pitt researcher lands the cover of Developmental Cell by uncovering an evolutionary secret

PITTSBURGH--How did the elephant get its trunk? Or the turtle its shell? How, in general, did the seemingly infinite diversity of complex animal forms on our planet arise? The scientific pursuit of how such "evolutionary novelties" come about is one of the big mysteries that biologists are trying to tease apart. The University of Pittsburgh's Mark Rebeiz and colleagues provide some answers in a paper published today in the journal Developmental Cell. Even in the most complex organisms, the genetic repertoire is limited. If creatures don't evolve by acquiring new genes, ...


How your brain decides blame and punishment -- and how it can be changed

Uniquely human brain region enables punishment decisions

Pinpointing punishment

Chapman University publishes research on attractiveness and mating

E-cigarettes: Special issue from Nicotine & Tobacco Research

Placental problems in early pregnancy associated with 5-fold increased risk of OB & fetal disorders

UT study: Invasive brood parasites a threat to native bird species

Criminals acquire guns through social connections

Restoring ocean health

Report: Cancer remains leading cause of death in US Hispanics

Twin study suggests genetic factors contribute to insomnia in adults

To be fragrant or not: Why do some male hairstreak butterflies lack scent organs?

International team discovers natural defense against HIV

Bolivian biodiversity observatory takes its first steps

Choice of college major influences lifetime earnings more than simply getting a degree

Dominant strain of drug-resistant MRSA decreases in hospitals, but persists in community

Synthetic biology needs robust safety mechanisms before real world application

US defense agencies increase investment in federal synthetic biology research

Robots help to map England's only deep-water Marine Conservation Zone

Mayo researchers identify protein -- may predict who will respond to PD-1 immunotherapy for melanoma

How much water do US fracking operations really use?

New approach to mammograms could improve reliability

The influence of citizen science grows despite some resistance

Unlocking secrets of how fossils form

What happens on the molecular level when smog gets into the lungs?

Using ultrasound to clean medical instruments

Platinum and iron oxide working together get the job done

Tiny silica particles could be used to repair damaged teeth, research shows

A quantum lab for everyone

No way? Charity's logo may influence perception of food in package

[] UC Davis study shows popular molecular tests is a service of DragonFly Company. All Rights Reserved.
Issuers of news releases are solely responsible for the accuracy of their content.