(Press-News.org) ANN ARBOR, Mich. — When it comes to a cancer diagnosis, timing can be everything – the sooner it's found, the more treatable it is. But when and how often should someone get screened?
A growing number of educational, interactive tools known as "decision aids" – such as videodiscs, audiotapes, workbooks and pamphlets – are intended to supplement patient-doctor discussions on the pros and cons of timing, methods and frequency for different types of cancer screening.
A University of Michigan study found that despite strong recommendations from the medical community to use these aids to help patients make more well-informed decisions, there is lack of evidence on whether they work – which may lead to fewer doctors using them.
"We continue to see more cancer screening options and also conflicting recommendations on whether to get screened, which method to use and how often it should be done," says lead author Masahito Jimbo, M.D., Ph.D., M.P.H., associate professor in family medicine and urology at the U-M Medical School.
"Our goal was to determine whether decision aids could potentially lead to better shared decision-making regarding screening between the patient and the clinician. There is evidence that decision aids are fairly effective in improving patient knowledge but we found that they may not be used as well and effectively as they could be."
The study appears in CA: A Cancer Journal for Clinicians, a medical journal published for the American Cancer Society.
Decision aids are delivered as self-administered or practitioner administered tools designed to help patients understand the disease, associated tests and treatments and the risks versus benefits of different types of screening. They are designed to help address such issues as whether to get a stool blood test versus a colonoscopy for colon cancer screening or whether women under the age of 50 should get screened for breast cancer at all.
Researchers reviewed 73 decision aids for breast, cervical, colon and prostate cancers. Just half of the decision aids, 36, were evaluated for subsequent screening behavior. Only a quarter of the decision aids, 18, had been assessed for their effect on shared decision making. Little information was available on the feasibility and outcomes of integrating decision aids into actual practice.
"These decision aids are designed as tools to improve communication between patients and clinicians, so it's surprising that there is so little data to support claims that they improve shared decision making," Jimbo says.
With the push towards more sophisticated electronic health records, decision aids may become more available to patients looking for additional guidance on health decisions, authors note.
Certain screening options also continue to be debated among the medical community. The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force, for example, recommended against routine screening for prostate cancer, while other guidelines encourage doctors and patients to weight the risks and benefits. Decision aids may assist patients and doctors work through those conflicting recommendations together.
"Do decision aids help improve communication between a patient and physician and can that improved communication lead to better outcomes – those are the broader questions we need to answer," Jimbo says.
"There is also some disconnect between how decision aids can help if they're actually applied and physicians actually using them. As we see an increased emphasis on the importance of shared decision making between patients and doctors, we need to better understand what the most valuable tools are in aiding this goal."
INFORMATION:
Additional Authors: Gurpreet K. Rana, MLIS; Sarah Hawley, Ph.D., M.P.H.; Margaret Holmes-Rovner, Ph.D.; Karen Kelly-Blake, Ph.D.; Donald E. Nease, Jr., M.D.; Mack T. Ruffin IV, M.D., M.P.H.
Disclosure: Dr. Jimbo receives funding from the National Cancer Institute (Grant RO1CA152413).
Funding: National Cancer Institute (Grant RO1CA152413).
Reference: "What is Lacking in Current Decision Aids on Cancer Screening," American Cancer Society, Inc., doi:10.3322/caac.21180.
Study finds gaps in 'decision aids' designed to help determine right cancer screening option
With a focus on shared decision making between doctors and patients, more studies needed to determine how decision aids help guide choices for cancer screening
2013-05-10
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Revealing hidden fungal species using DNA: The importance of recognizing cryptic diversity
2013-05-10
Our ability to assess biological diversity, ecosystem health, ecological interactions, and a wide range of other important processes is largely dependent on accurately recognizing species. However, identifying and describing species is not always a straightforward task. In some cases, a single species may show a high level of morphological variation, while in other cases, multiple morphologically similar species may be hidden under a single species name. Cryptic species, two or more distinct species that are erroneously classified under a single species name, are found ...
Baylor University researcher finds earliest evidence of human ancestors hunting & scavenging
2013-05-10
WACO, Texas (May 9, 2013) -- A recent Baylor University research study has shed new light on the diet and food acquisition strategies of some the earliest human ancestors in Africa.
Beginning around two million years ago, early stone tool-making humans, known scientifically as Oldowan hominin, started to exhibit a number of physiological and ecological adaptations that required greater daily energy expenditures, including an increase in brain and body size, heavier investment in their offspring and significant home-range expansion. Demonstrating how these early humans ...
Exercise for patients with major depression -- What kind, how intense, how often?
2013-05-10
Philadelphia, Pa. (May 10, 2013) – Exercise has been shown to be an effective treatment for major depressive disorder (MDD), both when used alone and in combination with other treatments. There's now sufficient research data to provide specific guidance on how to prescribe exercise for depressed patients, according to a report in the May Journal of Psychiatric Practice®. The journal is published by Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, a part of Wolters Kluwer Health.
"Despite the substantial evidence supporting the use of exercise in the treatment of MDD, previous studies ...
Study supports alternative model for personality disorders in upcoming DSM-5
2013-05-10
Philadelphia, Pa. (May 10, 2013) – A new "alternative model" included in the upcoming Fifth Edition of the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM -5) lines up well with the current approach to diagnosis of personality disorder, according to a study in the May Journal of Psychiatric Practice. The journal is published by Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, a part of Wolters Kluwer Health.
The findings lend support to the new "hybrid" model, which combines the "core" dimensions of personality disorder with various maladaptive ...
Markets erode moral values
2013-05-10
Many people express objections against child labor, exploitation of the workforce or meat production involving cruelty against animals. At the same time, however, people ignore their own moral standards when acting as market participants, searching for the cheapest electronics, fashion or food. Thus, markets reduce moral concerns. This is the main result of an experiment conducted by economists from the Universities of Bonn and Bamberg. The results are presented in the latest issue of the renowned journal "Science".
Prof. Dr. Armin Falk from the University of Bonn and ...
Perfectly doped quantum dots yield colors to dye for
2013-05-10
Quantum dots are tiny nanocrystals with extraordinary optical and electrical properties with possible uses in dye production, bioimaging, and solar energy production. Researchers at the University of Illinois at Chicago have developed a way to introduce precisely four copper ions into each and every quantum dot.
The introduction of these "guest" ions, called doping, opens up possibilities for fine-tuning the optical properties of the quantum dots and producing spectacular colors.
"When the crystallinity is perfect, the quantum dots do something that no one expected--they ...
Background noise in the operating room can impair surgical team communication
2013-05-10
Chicago (May 10, 2013): Ambient background noise—whether it is the sound of loud surgical equipment, talkative team members, or music—is a patient and surgical safety factor that can affect auditory processing among surgeons and the members of their team in the operating room (OR), according to a new study that appears in the May issue of the Journal of the American College of Surgeons. The findings are the first to demonstrate that a surgeon's ability to understand spoken words in the OR is directly affected by noise in the environment.
"The operating room is a very ...
Ice-free Arctic may be in our future, say UMass-Amherst, international researchers
2013-05-10
This news release is available in German.
AMHERST, Mass., USA; COLOGNE, Germany; MAGADAN, Russia – Analyses of the longest continental sediment core ever collected in the Arctic, recently completed by an international team led by Julie Brigham-Grette of the University of Massachusetts Amherst, provide "absolutely new knowledge" of Arctic climate from 2.2 to 3.6 million years ago.
"While existing geologic records from the Arctic contain important hints about this time period, what we are presenting is the most continuous archive of information about past ...
Experience leads to the growth of new brain cells
2013-05-10
The DFG-Center for Regenerative Therapies Dresden - Cluster of Excellence at the TU Dresden (CRTD), the Dresden site of the German Center for Neurodegenerative Diseases (DZNE), and the Max Planck Institute for Human Development in Berlin played a pivotal role in the study.
The adult brain continues to grow with the challenges that it faces; its changes are linked to the development of personality and behavior. But what is the link between individual experience and brain structure? Why do identical twins not resemble each other perfectly even when they grew up together? ...
Bacterial infection in mosquitoes renders them immune to malaria parasites
2013-05-10
Scientists funded by the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID), part of the National Institutes of Health, have established an inheritable bacterial infection in malaria-transmitting Anopheles mosquitoes that renders them immune to malaria parasites. Specifically, the scientists infected the mosquitoes with Wolbachia, a bacterium common among insects that previously has been shown to prevent malaria-inducing Plasmodium parasites from developing in Anopheles mosquitoes. Before now, researchers had been unable to create mosquitoes with a stable Wolbachia ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Mysterious ‘Dark Dwarfs’ may be hiding at the heart of the Milky Way
Real-world data shows teclistamab can benefit many multiple myeloma patients who would have been ineligible for pivotal trial
Scientists reveal how a key inflammatory molecule triggers esophageal muscle contraction
Duration of heat waves accelerating faster than global warming
New mathematical insights into Lagrangian turbulence
Clinical trials reveal promising alternatives to high-toxicity tuberculosis drug
Artificial solar eclipses in space could shed light on Sun
Probing the cosmic Dark Ages from the far side of the Moon
UK hopes to bolster space weather forecasts with Europe's first solar storm monitor
Can one video change a teen's mindset? New study says yes - but there’s a catch
How lakes connect to groundwater critical for resilience to climate change, research finds
Youngest basaltic lunar meteorite fills nearly one billion-year gap in Moon’s volcanic history
Cal Poly Chemistry professor among three U.S. faculty to be honored for contributions to chemistry instruction
Stoichiometric crystal shows promise in quantum memory
Study sheds light on why some prostate tumors are resistant to treatment
Tree pollen reveals 150,000 years of monsoon history—and a warning for Australia’s northern rainfall
Best skin care ingredients revealed in thorough, national review
MicroRNA is awarded an Impact Factor Ranking for 2024
From COVID to cancer, new at-home test spots disease with startling accuracy
Now accepting submissions: Special Collection on Cognitive Aging
Young adult literature is not as young as it used to be
Can ChatGPT actually “see” red? New results of Google-funded study are nuanced
Turning quantum bottlenecks into breakthroughs
Cancer-fighting herpes virus shown to be an effective treatment for some advanced melanoma
Eliminating invasive rats may restore the flow of nutrients across food chain networks in Seychelles
World’s first: Lithuanian scientists’ discovery may transform OLED technology and explosives detection
Rice researchers develop superstrong, eco-friendly materials from bacteria
Itani studying translation potential of secure & efficient software updates in industrial internet of things architectures
Elucidating the source process of the 2021 south sandwich islands tsunami earthquake
Zhu studying use of big data in verification of route choice models
[Press-News.org] Study finds gaps in 'decision aids' designed to help determine right cancer screening optionWith a focus on shared decision making between doctors and patients, more studies needed to determine how decision aids help guide choices for cancer screening