(Press-News.org) ANN ARBOR –While record numbers of hospitals and doctors participate in electronic health information exchange efforts, which enable medical histories to follow patients as they move between healthcare providers, the long-term success of these programs is in question.
That's according to a new national survey of health information exchange organizations led by a University of Michigan researcher.
Health information exchange efforts come into play primarily when patients switch doctors or are admitted to a hospital. Because they give doctors access to patients' medical histories, they could improve diagnoses and reduce redundant tests, boosting both the quality and efficiency of care. They've been deemed a national priority, and $548 million from the 2009 American Recovery and Reinvestment Act was devoted to helping states establish them.
So it might not be surprising that since the research team's last survey in 2010, there's been a doubling in the percentage of U.S. hospitals that take part in an exchange program and a tripling in the percentage of participating doctor's offices. The new study counted 119 operational exchange efforts nationwide – a 61 percent increase from 2010. Today, 30 percent of U.S. hospitals and 10 percent of doctors' offices are involved in one.
"What we've seen is this federal money really has made a big difference," said lead study author Julia Adler-Milstein, an assistant professor in the U-M School of Information and School of Public Health. "What hasn't really moved, though, is the perception that the organizations haven't figured out how to fund themselves, which will be a big problem after the government grant money runs out in January 2014."
A full 74 percent of the exchange programs reported that they're struggling to develop a sustainable business model. Over the years, some organizations have closed their doors when grants ended. Adler-Milstein offers one explanation why:
"The health care providers are not willing to pay for the service at the level needed," she said. "They don't see enough value, and that's because much of it doesn't accrue to them. It goes to patients and to health insurance companies. The central challenge is that the incentives and the business model are not aligned yet for this to really work."
Will they ever be aligned, and what are some possible outcomes? Some believe health information exchange is a public good and that the government should make a long-term commitment to funding it. It's been suggested that a small payroll tax could cover the service. Others say the free market should determine the fate of health information exchange organizations. That could mean they're never permanently established, or that they find a way to make money. Adler-Milstein sees strides toward the latter.
"One piece of data that makes me a little bit hopeful is that many of these organizations are trying to figure out the broader role they can play in efforts to improve healthcare delivery," she said. "They're realizing that the data they have is very valuable for research and performance reports."
Beyond any immediate benefits to patients, exchange efforts could help enable large clinical studies across institutions. Such studies could, for example, explore how effective certain treatments or diagnostic tests are in a broad range of situations. Exchange efforts could also aid in the establishment of "accountable care organizations," voluntary groups of doctors and hospitals that agree to coordinate care and reduce duplicated services.
"If these accountable care organizations are going to be successful, they need to know what care patients are receiving," Adler-Milstein said. "If you want to know how things are going from a quality perspective, that requires data. It's a broader effort that's really about aligning incentives for healthcare, but underneath it all is health information exchange."
The study is published online July 9 issue in Health Affairs. It will also appear in the journal's August issue.
###
The paper is titled "Operational Health Information Exchanges Show Substantial Growth, But Long-Term Funding Remains A Concern." The research was funded by The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. Other contributors are David W. Bates, chief of the division of general internal medicine and primary care at Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston; and Ashish K. Jha, a professor of health policy and management at the Harvard School of Public Health.
For more information:
Julia Adler-Milstein: https://www.si.umich.edu/newsandevents/faculty-profile-julia-adler-milstein
"Why doesn't your health information follow you" – a blog post by Julia Adler-Milstein: http://monthly.si.umich.edu/2013/02/15/why-doesnt-your-health-information-follow-you/
Health info exchange: Short-term growth, but long-term concerns
2013-07-09
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Women who give birth to multiple babies after IVF are at higher risk of breast cancer
2013-07-09
London -- Women who give birth to multiple babies following IVF treatment are at a higher risk of breast cancer than those giving birth to singletons or who remain childless. Dutch investigators from the Omega study group said the explanation may not be the multiple pregnancy per se but a maternal trait related to a higher implantation potential and to breast cancer itself.
Although the results were derived from a large nationwide cohort study, the investigators emphasise that the findings should next be replicated in further studies and that presently there is no reason ...
Female obesity linked to lower rates of live birth and embryo implantation in the uterus
2013-07-09
London, 9 July 2013: An analysis of almost 10,000 first cycles of egg donation treatment at one
of Europe's largest IVF centres shows that female obesity reduces the receptivity of the uterus
to embryo implantation and thereby compromises reproductive outcome. The investigators
report that excess female weight "impairs human reproduction" and that "the reduction of
uterine receptivity is one of the mechanisms involved". As a result they advise weight reduction
before pregnancy in any type of conception, including ovum donation.
The study is presented today at the ...
Large UK population study finds no increased cancer risk in children born after assisted conception
2013-07-09
London, 9 July 2013: Children born as a result of assisted reproduction (ART) are at no greater
risk of cancer than children born spontaneously in the general population, according to results
of one of the largest ever cohort studies of ART children. "This is reassuring news for couples
considering assisted conception, their subsequent children, fertility specialists and for the wider
public health," said the investigators.
Results of the study were presented today at the annual meeting of ESHRE by Dr Carrie
Williams from the Institute of Child Health, University ...
Women working shifts are at greater risk of miscarriage, menstrual disruption and subfertility
2013-07-09
London, 9 July 2013: Shift work, which encourages sleep deprivation and patterns of activity
outside the circadian rhythm, has been associated with a greater risk of ill health and loss of
well-being in some (but not all) studies.(1) However, little is known about the effects of shift
work on reproductive health and fertility.
Now, a study reported today at the annual meeting of ESHRE, by Dr Linden Stocker from the
University of Southampton, UK, indicates that working shift patterns is associated with an
increased risk of menstrual disruption and subfertility.
The ...
Egg banking for social reasons
2013-07-09
London, 9 July 2013: Egg freezing as insurance against age-related infertility is a growing trend in
many countries. Women who bank oocytes for use at some time in the future hope to buy a
little time in their search for a suitable partner.
However, a study from one of Europe's largest centres in reproductive medicine suggests that
many of those banking eggs believe they will never use them - even though they still recognise
the experience as "positive". The majority of those who did (and did not) freeze their eggs
wished they had done so at an earlier age.
The study ...
Research demonstrates the influence of temporal niches in maintaining biodiversity
2013-07-09
By studying rapidly evolving bacteria as they diversify and compete under varying environmental conditions, researchers have shown that temporal niches are important to maintaining biodiversity in natural systems. The research is believed to be the first experimental demonstration of temporal niche dynamics promoting biodiversity over evolutionary time scales.
The temporal niches – changes in environmental conditions that occur during specific periods of time – promoted frequency-dependent selection within the bacterial communities and positive growth of new mutants. ...
Tumor-suppressor Protein Gives Up Its Secrets
2013-07-09
Genetic mutations aren't the only thing that can keep a protein called PTEN from doing its tumor-suppressing job. Johns Hopkins researchers have now discovered that four small chemical tags attached (reversibly) to the protein's tail can have the same effect, and they say their finding may offer a novel path for drug design to keep PTEN working.
In a report published on July 9 in the journal eLife, the Johns Hopkins scientists describe how a cluster of four phosphate groups, first found 13 years ago to bind to PTEN's tail, controls its activity.
"Now that we know ...
What warring couples want: Power, not apologies, Baylor study shows
2013-07-09
The most common thing that couples want from each other during a conflict is not an apology, but a willingness to relinquish power, according to a new Baylor University study.
Giving up power comes in many forms, among them giving a partner more independence, admitting faults, showing respect and being willing to compromise. The study is published in the Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology.
"It's common for partners to be sensitive to how to share power and control when making decisions in their relationship," said researcher Keith Sanford, Ph.D., an associate professor ...
Scientists image vast subglacial water system under West Antarctica's Thwaites Glacier
2013-07-09
AUSTIN, Texas — In a development that will help predict potential sea level rise from the Antarctic ice sheet, scientists from The University of Texas at Austin's Institute for Geophysics have used an innovation in radar analysis to accurately image the vast subglacial water system under West Antarctica's Thwaites Glacier. They have detected a swamp-like canal system beneath the ice that is several times as large as Florida's Everglades.
The findings, as described this week in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, use new observational techniques to address ...
Bird vaccine for West Nile Virus
2013-07-09
University of British Columbia researchers have developed a vaccine that may halt the spread of West Nile Virus (WNV) among common and endangered bird species.
WNV, a mosquito borne pathogen, arrived in North America in 1999 and is now endemic across the continent. In 2012 alone, WNV killed 286 people in the United States, and 42 people have died from the virus in Canada since 2002. There is currently no effective vaccine against WNV infection in humans or birds.
Common birds such as crows, ravens and jays, and endangered species such as the Greater Sage-Grouse and ...