November 05, 2010 (Press-News.org) New Jersey nursing home residents and medical patients may see less access to the courts for negligence claims after two recent court decisions.
A recent appellate court decision ruled that residents can be required to arbitrate their claims against a nursing home despite a state law to the contrary. Another case held that, under certain circumstances, doctor-patient arbitration agreements are enforceable.
Federal Law
As early as 1925, Congress began to favor arbitration as an alternative forum to the courtroom for resolving disputes by passing the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA). The FAA requires states to enforce arbitration agreements with the same level of deference given to other types of contracts. The act also preempts inconsistent state law.
The United States Supreme Court has acknowledged the benefits of arbitration. These can include simpler rules of procedure and evidence, the opportunity for more cooperation between parties, and more flexible scheduling. But arbitration can also have drawbacks, such as when the composition of a panel of arbitrators does not seem fair to both parties.
Nursing Home Cases
Far too many nursing homes fail to provide adequate care to their residents. As a result, residents and their families find themselves having to fight back through litigation against nursing home injuries .
To protect residents' right to bring these cases, the New Jersey legislature passed the Nursing Home Responsibilities and Rights of Residents Act in 2003. The law prohibits nursing home facilities from imposing any agreement that requires residents to waive or limit their right to sue the nursing home. Nursing homes cannot enter contracts under which residents waive their right to sue for negligence and agree instead to arbitrate any future claims.
New Jersey Appellate Courts Resolving Apparent Conflict
A New Jersey appellate court recently ruled that despite the state law prohibiting predispute binding arbitration agreements between nursing homes and their residents, agreements to arbitrate medical negligence disputes will be enforced. In Estate of Ruszala v. Brookdale Living Communities, Inc., the court ordered the parties to arbitrate their dispute pursuant to their agreement. The court reasoned that the Federal Arbitration Act preempts New Jersey's Nursing Home Responsibilities and Rights of Residents Act.
In other words, the federal policy in favor of arbitration trumps the state law designed to protect the rights of the elderly and infirm. But the court found the following provisions of the parties' arbitration agreement unconscionable and therefore unenforceable:
- Limitations imposed on discovery
- Limitation of compensatory damages available to resident
- Prohibition against punitive damages
Because of these restrictions, nursing homes do not have a blank check to force residents into arbitration, even after the Ruszala court ruling.
Patient-Physician Predispute Binding Arbitration Agreements
In a subsequent case, Moore v. Woman to Woman Obstetrics & Gynecology, a New Jersey appellate court ruled that arbitration is also a valid forum for resolution of disputes between doctors and their patients. The court found that some patient-physician agreements to arbitrate are enforceable; enforceability will be determined based on whether certain substantive and procedural requirements have been met.
The Moore court found that an expectant mother could bind her unborn child with an agreement to arbitrate the wrongful life claim. In contrast, the father, who was not present in the doctor's office and did not sign the agreement, was not bound to arbitrate and could therefore instead sue the physician in court.
In health care cases, enforcement of agreements to arbitrate depends on the circumstances surrounding execution of the contract. In particular, the question is whether the patient was given adequate notice of the existence of the agreement and also provided a copy of the agreement after signing.
Current Status of Arbitration Agreements With Patients
The New Jersey Appellate Division has changed the way that claims involving medical negligence can be addressed in the state. Hospitals and nursing homes may increasingly try to rely on predispute binding arbitration agreements. Patients must be careful to protect their rights and not allow all disputes to immediately go into arbitration. Victims of nursing home abuse or neglect, or other medical negligence, should contact a skilled attorney to discuss their situation and the appropriate forum for bringing a claim for damages.
Article provided by Kirsch Gartenberg & Howard
Visit us at www.kghlaw.com
New Jersey Courts Rule on Required Arbitration Agreements for Patients
New Jersey nursing home residents and medical patients may see less access to the courts for negligence claims after two recent court decisions concerning arbitration.
2010-11-05
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Impaired Driving Charges and Retrograde Analysis
2010-11-05
When Time is an Element of a Crime
Unlike some crimes, impaired driving charges like DUI and drugged driving have an element of timing that any prosecutor must prove to obtain a conviction against an alleged drunk driver.
Under Pennsylvania's DUI statute, title 75 section 3802(a), subdivision (1), "general impairment" is defined as driving, operating or controlling a vehicle "after imbibing a sufficient amount of alcohol such that the individual is rendered incapable of safely driving...". An impaired driver can also be convicted under the "general impairment" subdivision ...
Is Tort Reform Really the Solution to High Health Care Costs?
2010-11-05
According to studies published in the most recent edition of the health care industry journal Health Affairs, medical liability costs (i.e., those spent in defense of, or to prevent, medical malpractice actions) is a mere 2.4 percent of America's overall health care budget. These studies, performed by a joint group of researchers, attorneys and doctors, present conclusions that directly contradict the popular view that medical malpractice/negligence lawsuits are the leading cause of the so-called "health care crisis."
Important findings of the study include:
- So-called ...
New IRS Rules for Tax Preparers
2010-11-05
The IRS has issued new rules amending section 1-6109-2, requiring paid tax preparers to be registered with the IRS. The final regulations provide that for tax returns or refund claims filed after December 31, 2010, tax return preparers must obtain and use a preparer tax identification number (PTIN), rather than a social security number (SSN), as the identifying number to be included with the tax return preparer's signature on a tax return or claim for refund.
For some practitioners, a significant change created by this regulation is the requirement that the term "tax ...
Jumeirah Raises Funds for Medecins Sans Frontieres with the 9th Swim Burj Al Arab
2010-11-05
Jumeirah's Wild Wadi Waterpark and Medecins Sans Frontieres (MSF), with the support of the Red Crescent Society, are preparing for the multitude of enthusiastic swimmers who flock to Wild Wadi Waterpark for the ever popular Swim Burj Al Arab. In addition to a reduced entrance fee and revised age categories, this year all participants will be timed using computerized timing chips.
Keen swimmers can register in the competitive event or Family Swim for a minimum donation of 275 AED, which gives them the chance to compete for a variety of prizes. There is also a 'Best Fundraiser' ...
Fasthosts Offers UK's First 24 Core Dedicated Server Package
2010-11-05
Fasthosts Internet Ltd, a leading web hosting provider, and Technology Sponsor of The Great Exhibition 2012, today unveiled its most powerful server to date and a first for the UK dedicated server market - a 24 Core Dedicated Server. Currently offered half price for the first 3 months, Fasthosts' Dedicated Servers offer enterprises a powerful and secure server platform and far greater flexibility than on-premise solutions.
A Dedicated Server is the ideal solution for IT professionals and businesses that require robust server operations for applications and data storage ...
Kuoni Launches Google Gadget Ad
2010-11-05
Kuoni has launched a new Google Gadget Ad which offers a fun, interactive and fast way to find holiday inspiration and their very best offers in just three easy steps.
Kuoni hopes that the new Gadget will offer the perfect way for customers to get inspired and get up-to-the-minute latest offers.
Google has said that "past gadget campaigns have shown that 50% of people who see the ad, interact with it."
The Kuoni Google Gadget combines convenience with Kuoni's knowledge and experience, offering a fun and informative way to quickly check out the best deals Kuoni ...
Standard Life Enhances Active Money SIPP
2010-11-05
Standard Life has introduced two new enhancements to its active money Self Invested Personal Pension Plan (SIPP) in response to adviser feedback.
In addition to its Commercial Property Team a new SIPP Specialist Investment Team will help advisers support high net worth clients with complex investment needs. Where clients are considering a specialist investment in their SIPP, advisers will now be able to contact this 12-strong team to discuss suitability and options. The team will then be able to give a comprehensive assessment the same working day.
In addition, Standard ...
Tesco.com Signs Major Deal with Dragon's Den Winner
2010-11-05
Tesco.com has partnered with MyDish.co.uk to enable customers to upload and share their favourite family recipes on the Tesco Real Food site using MyDish technology.
In addition, customers can enjoy online 'foodie' conversations within the Real Food community sharing their favourite hints, tips and recipe ideas.
Tesco is also making it easier for customers to shop for their recipe ingredients. Customers simply find the recipes they want to make from either Tesco Real Food or MyDish.co.uk, click 'add to shopping basket', and in just a few seconds all the required ...
Eurostar Launches Eurostar Plus
2010-11-05
Eurostar, the high-speed passenger service that links the UK with the Continent, has launched Eurostar Plus, a collection of special offers and discounts for travellers journeying to the continent to help them get even more from their Eurostar ticket.
Eurostar Plus is accessed via the Eurostar website and brings together a range of offers under different 'badges' including culture, shopping, food and destination information. The range is expanding quickly and is already an invaluable resource for travellers planning their trip.
Eurostar Plus features offers under ...
Sky, WWF and Global Action Plan Join Forces to Challenge UK Schools
2010-11-05
Sky, WWF and Global Action plan have launched a new online resource, the Sky Rainforest Rescue Schools Challenge that will challenge primary and secondary school students to reduce their carbon footprint in order to help protect the rainforest,
The Sky Rainforest Rescue Schools Challenge will encourage schools to be more aware of the food we eat, the energy we use and the stuff we buy. It will integrate into the curriculum, covering subjects such as geography, citizenship, science and numeracy. Using an array of teaching resources and interactive learning tools, teachers ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
QUT scientists create material to turn waste heat into clean power
Major new report sets out how to tackle the ‘profound and lasting impact’ of COVID-19 on cardiovascular health
Cosmic crime scene: White dwarf found devouring Pluto-like icy world
Major report tackles Covid’s cardiovascular crisis head-on
A third of licensed GPs in England not working in NHS general practice
ChatGPT “thought on the fly” when put through Ancient Greek maths puzzle
Engineers uncover why tiny particles form clusters in turbulent air
GLP-1RA drugs dramatically reduce death and cardiovascular risk in psoriasis patients
Psoriasis linked to increased risk of vision-threatening eye disease, study finds
Reprogramming obesity: New drug from Italian biotech aims to treat the underlying causes of obesity
Type 2 diabetes may accelerate development of multiple chronic diseases, particularly in the early stages, UK Biobank study suggests
Resistance training may improve nerve health, slow aging process, study shows
Common and inexpensive medicine halves the risk of recurrence in patients with colorectal cancer
SwRI-built instruments to monitor, provide advanced warning of space weather events
Breakthrough advances sodium-based battery design
New targeted radiation therapy shows near-complete response in rare sarcoma patients
Does physical frailty contribute to dementia?
Soccer headers and brain health: Study finds changes within folds of the brain
Decoding plants’ language of light
UNC Greensboro study finds ticks carrying Lyme disease moving into western NC
New implant restores blood pressure balance after spinal cord injury
New York City's medical specialist advantage may be an illusion, new NYU Tandon research shows
Could a local anesthetic that doesn’t impair motor function be within reach?
1 in 8 Italian cetacean strandings show evidence of fishery interactions, with bottlenose and striped dolphins most commonly affected, according to analysis across four decades of data and more than 5
In the wild, chimpanzees likely ingest the equivalent of several alcoholic drinks every day
Warming of 2°C intensifies Arctic carbon sink but weakens Alpine sink, study finds
Bronze and Iron Age cultures in the Middle East were committed to wine production
Indian adolescents are mostly starting their periods at an earlier age than 25 years ago
Temporary medical centers in Gaza known as "Medical Points" (MPs) treat an average of 117 people daily with only about 7 staff per MP
Rates of alcohol-induced deaths among the general population nearly doubled from 1999 to 2024
[Press-News.org] New Jersey Courts Rule on Required Arbitration Agreements for PatientsNew Jersey nursing home residents and medical patients may see less access to the courts for negligence claims after two recent court decisions concerning arbitration.