(Press-News.org) ROCHESTER, Minn. — A new study of attitudes about health care costs reveals that an overwhelming majority of U.S. physicians feel a responsibility to address costs, but prioritize their obligations to patients' best interests over cost concerns. Results of the random survey of 2,500 U.S. physicians are published in this week's Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA).
"Physicians feel stuck in a difficult position," says lead author Jon Tilburt, M.D., Mayo Clinic's Biomedical Ethics Program and Center for the Science of Health Care Delivery. "Despite their sense of responsibility to address health care costs, physicians consistently express a commitment to the best interests of patients even when it is expensive. Given this finding, we recommend that cost-containment strategies aimed at physician behavior should focus on innovations that not only promote savings but also preserve physicians' commitment to individual patients."
Survey highlights include:
The vast majority (85 percent) agreed that "trying to contain costs is the responsibility of every physician."
Most (76 percent) reported being aware of the costs of tests or treatments
they recommend.
Nearly 80 percent endorsed prioritizing patients' best interests over issues of cost.
Most ascribed "major responsibility" for reducing health care costs to trial
lawyers, health insurance companies, and pharmaceutical and device
manufacturers. In contrast, most (59 percent) thought practicing physicians were only "somewhat responsible."
Researchers also assessed physicians' attitudes about strategies to constrain health care spending. Major findings include:
Most expressed enthusiasm for cost-containment initiatives aimed at improving the quality and efficiency of care, and favored improving conditions for making decisions based upon cumulative medical evidence. For example, 69 percent were very enthusiastic about promoting chronic disease care coordination, and 63 percent were very enthusiastic about limiting corporate influence on physician behavior.
Physicians' opinions were mixed on making payment changes to control costs. For example, 65 percent were not enthusiastic about paying a network of practices a fixed, bundled payment for managing all care for a defined population, and 70 percent were not enthusiastic about eliminating fee-for-service payment models.
"We found that physicians' degree of enthusiasm for various cost-containment strategies was associated with practice setting and compensation structure," says Dr. Tilburt. "Salaried physicians and those in larger institutional practice settings reported a significantly higher degree of cost-consciousness compared to physicians whose compensation is based on billing and those in small or solo practices."
###
The study was funded by the Greenwall Foundation and the Mayo Clinic Program in Professionalism and Ethics. Co-authors include Matthew Wynia, M.D.; Robert Sheeler, M.D.; Bjorg Thorsteinsdottir, M.D.; Katherine M. James; Jason S. Egginton; Mark Liebow, M.D.; Samia Hurst, M.D.; Marion Danis, M.D.; and Susan Dorr Goold, M.D.
About Mayo Clinic
Mayo Clinic is a nonprofit worldwide leader in medical care, research and education for people from all walks of life. For more information, visit http://www.mayoclinic.org/about and http://www.mayoclinic.org/news.
Journalists can become a member of the Mayo Clinic News Network at http://newsnetwork.mayoclinic.org for the latest health, science and research news and access to video, audio, text and graphic elements that can be downloaded or embedded.
Shelly Plutowski
507-284-5005 (days)
507-284-2511 (evenings)
newsbureau@mayo.edu
Mayo Clinic-led study: US physicians, patients' best interests, health care costs
2013-07-24
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Direct nitrogen fixation for low cost energy conversion
2013-07-24
A simple, low-cost and eco-friendly method of creating nitrogen-doped graphene nanoplatelets (NGnPs), which could be used in dye-sensitized solar cells and fuel cells, is published in Scientific Reports today. The work, carried out at Ulsan National Institute of Science and Technology (UNIST) in South Korea, could be a step towards replacing conventional platinum (Pt)-based catalysts for energy conversion.
The search for economically viable alternatives to fossil fuels has attracted attention among energy communities because of increasing energy prices and climate change. ...
Athletes need to be careful to monitor diet, weight to maintain muscle mass
2013-07-24
CORVALLIS, Ore. – Athletes seeking a healthy performance weight should eat high fiber, low-fat food balanced with their training regimen in order to maintain muscle while still burning fat, according to a report by an Oregon State University researcher.
The United States now has a record number of overweight athletes, a population many think of as untouched by the obesity crisis. Nationally, more than 45 percent of high school linebackers are obese, and the number of overweight students entering college level-sports is increasing.
In a peer-reviewed literature review ...
Oxygen -- key to most life -- decelerates many cancer tumors when combined with radiation therapy
2013-07-24
DALLAS – July 23, 2013 – A multidisciplinary team at UT Southwestern Medical Center has found that measuring the oxygenation of tumors can be a valuable tool in guiding radiation therapy, opening the door for personalized therapies that keep tumors in check with oxygen enhancement.
In research examining tissue oxygenation levels and predicting radiation response, UT Southwestern scientists led by Dr. Ralph Mason reported in the June 27 online issue of Magnetic Resonance in Medicine that countering hypoxic and aggressive tumors with an "oxygen challenge" – inhaling oxygen ...
Valley networks suggest ancient snowfall on Mars
2013-07-24
PROVIDENCE, R.I. [Brown University] — Valley networks branching across the Martian surface leave little doubt that water once flowed on the Red Planet. But where that ancient water came from — whether it bubbled up from underground or fell as rain or snow — is still debated by scientists. A new study by researchers at Brown University puts a new check mark in the precipitation column.
The study finds that water-carved valleys at four different locations on Mars appear to have been caused by runoff from orographic precipitation — snow or rain that falls when moist prevailing ...
New species of Hero Shrew found in equatorial Africa
2013-07-24
Scientists at Chicago's Field Museum and international collaborators have described a new species of Hero Shrew – the mammal with the most bizarre lower spine on Earth. The interlocking vertebrae of the Hero Shrew render the spine four to five times more robust relative to body mass, a condition not found in any other mammal. The spine has been an enigma to evolutionary biologists, with no known adaptive significance.
This new species of Hero Shrew, named Scutisorex thori, possesses features that may represent intermediate character states between the only other known ...
When bar fights get mean, bystanders intervene
2013-07-24
People are more likely to try to break up a bar fight when they believe the conflict is too violent, or has the potential to become more violent, according to an international team of researchers.
Bystanders break up about a third of the fights that occur in bars and are most likely to intervene in conflicts between males, said Michael Parks, who recently earned his doctorate in sociology at Penn State.
These bystanders used nonaggressive interventions to break up about 65 percent of the fights between two aggressive males. Most bystander interventions were classified ...
Choosing a wave could accelerate airplane maintenance
2013-07-24
Ultrasonic waves can find bubbles and cracks in adhesive bonds holding airplane composite parts together, and now aerospace engineers can select the best frequencies to detect adhesive failures in hard-to-reach places more quickly, thanks to Penn State researchers.
Different ultrasonic modes work best for different materials and configurations using the right one will locate more flaws with higher precision, according to the researchers. The selection process could save time and effort for engineers who perform maintenance on complex structures made from composite materials ...
Estée Lauder clinical trial finds link between sleep deprivation and skin aging
2013-07-24
In a first-of-its-kind clinical trial, physician-scientists at University Hospitals (UH) Case Medical Center found that sleep quality impacts skin function and aging. The recently completed study, commissioned by Estée Lauder, demonstrated that poor sleepers had increased signs of skin aging and slower recovery from a variety of environmental stressors, such as disruption of the skin barrier or ultraviolet (UV) radiation. Poor sleepers also had worse assessment of their own skin and facial appearance.
The research team, led by Primary Investigator Elma Baron, MD, presented ...
Researcher develops peer-led program to help individuals with HIV adhere to treatment plans
2013-07-24
COLUMBIA, Mo. –Individuals diagnosed with HIV nowadays can live long, healthy lives if they follow their medical treatment plans; however, nearly half of individuals with the virus fail to get needed medical help or to continue treatment, according to previous research. Now, a nursing researcher at the University of Missouri has developed a peer-led intervention that helps individuals with HIV adhere to their treatment plans that can improve their quality of life.
"Being 'peered' is different from being doctored, nursed or counseled," said Maithe Enriquez, an associate ...
Pathways activated in most K9 bone tumors not driving the worst bone tumors
2013-07-24
Many cancers show inappropriate activation of a cell signaling pathway called NOTCH. In the developing body, NOTCH tells brain cells to grow and proliferate. It should be quiet in the adult body, but cancers restart NOTCH to drive their own growth, far and beyond the rate of healthy tissues. A Colorado State University and University of Colorado Cancer Center study expected to find NOTCH signaling elevated in K9 osteosarcoma samples, gathered from patients at the CSU Flint Animal Cancer Center. What they found surprised the researchers: overall, NOTCH signaling was elevated ...