PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Spirit of NHS is willing, but flesh is often weak, finds largest ever study of culture and behavior

High quality care in England often mired in unclear goals, excessive box ticking and regulation, and variable staff support

2013-09-10
(Press-News.org) A lack of clearly defined goals, a surfeit of box ticking and regulation, and highly variable staff support are stifling the almost universal desire to provide high quality care in the English NHS, finds the largest ever analysis of its culture and behaviours, published online in BMJ Quality & Safety.

While there are many examples of exemplary and innovative care, the sorts of issues which came to light in this year's Robert Francis Inquiry into the failings at Mid-Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust are likely to be found elsewhere, even if not to the same extent, suggest the authors.

They base their conclusions on a two-year research programme spanning the period from 2010, following the initial inquiry into Mid-Staffordshire, to the passing into law of the latest reconfiguration of the NHS in England - the Health and Social Care Act in 2012.

The research programme aimed to uncover the prevailing culture and behaviours in the NHS in England using a wide variety of sources.

These included 300 interviews with senior level executives, managers, and frontline staff; numerous patient and carer surveys; hundreds of sets of board minutes and published datasets on performance in all types of NHS trust; and cultural (ethnographic) case studies of hospital wards, primary care practices, and emergency care departments, totalling 650 hours of observation.

The analysis of all the data showed that there were many 'bright spots' of excellent care, practice, and innovation across the NHS in England. But it also indicated 'dark spots' of poor care, harried, distracted staff, and evidence of structural and cultural factors which threaten the quality and safety of care.

"Though Mid Staffordshire may have been one particularly 'dark spot' in the NHS, organisations throughout the NHS are likely to have at least some shadows," write the authors, adding that their analysis showed that "there was little confidence that care could be relied on to be good at all times in all parts of organisations."

Key issues to come to light included: Unclear/disjointed goals leading to 'priority thickets,' which eat up resources but which provide little in the way of clarity or coherent strategy Excessive box ticking to comply with external requirements rather than improve services Multiple regulatory bodies and other external agencies serving different but overlapping functions, leading to ambiguity, fragmentation, and competing pressures Poor intelligence on which to base decisions/improvements Highly variable staff support and a lack of respect and appreciation 'Comfort-seeking' behaviours,' which focus on making a good external impression and view staff who raise concerns as trouble-makers and whiners A lack of integration, leading to time-wasting, frustrating barriers, and gaps in care Indiscriminate or inappropriate use of quality improvement management techniques and a belief in 'magical thinking' - that the initiative will solve many problems quickly and easily Variable quality management

The authors make several recommendations for improvement, which helped to inform the recently published government reports on patient safety in England.

The first of these recommendations is that the NHS must have "clear and explicit goals that are coherent from ward to Whitehall."

Second, they say that organisations must have good intelligence on their performance if they are to improve. "This means actively seeking uncomfortable and challenging information from patients and staff," and acting on it, they emphasise.

Third, NHS organisations need to constantly review, strengthen, and improve all their systems, and focus on developing cultures that are person - rather than task - centred.

"It is especially important that organisations do more to ensure the engagement and health and wellbeing of their staff because our research shows strong links between staff experience and patient mortality rates," said Professor Michael West, who led the study. "Looking after patients requires looking after staff."*

The study emphasises the need for coherence of national direction."This is essential to avoid dispersing responsibility and accountability, and creating confusing messages and signals," write the authors.

"As the new bodies move forward, including NHS England and Clinical Commissioning Groups, it is important to avoid creating further competing priorities, and instead ensure focus and coherence," they say.

The study concludes that improvement in the NHS can build on the excellent progress already made by many organisations.

"The NHS is far from unique in experiencing challenges," comments study author Professor Mary Dixon-Woods. "Every health system in the world is grappling with patient safety problems. But the NHS is uniquely well-placed to address them."*

### [Culture and behaviour in the English National Health Service: overview of lessons from a large multimethod study Online First doi 10.1136/bmjqs-2013-001947]


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Testes size correlates with men's involvement in toddler care

2013-09-10
Men with smaller testes than others are more likely to be involved in hands-on care of their toddlers, a new study conducted by anthropologists at Emory University finds. The Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) published the results of the study Sept. 9. Smaller testicular volumes also correlate with more nurturing-related brain activity in fathers as they are looking at photos of their own children, the study shows. "Our data suggest that the biology of human males reflects a trade-off between investments in mating versus parenting effort," says Emory ...

ER visits after surgery: Study finds high rate among seniors & lots of variation among hospitals

2013-09-10
ANN ARBOR, Mich. — Nearly one in five older adults who have common operations will end up in the emergency department within a month of their hospital stay, a new study finds – a surprisingly high number found in the first national look at the issue. What's even more surprising? The wide variation between hospitals, in keeping their older surgery patients from needing emergency care after surgery on their hearts, hips, backs, colons and major blood vessels. Some hospitals had four times the rate of post-surgery emergency care for their patients, compared with others. In ...

The new face of Medicaid: Incoming enrollees may be younger; more white men, smokers, drinkers

2013-09-10
ANN ARBOR, Mich. — States that choose to expand Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act to millions of uninsured adults may see an increase in younger people and white men qualify for the coverage, a new University of Michigan study says. Potential new enrollees are also generally healthier than the current Medicaid population, with less prevalence of obesity and depression – but they are more likely to be smokers and heavy drinkers. The new group of potential Medicaid beneficiaries may also cost less than what lawmakers projected, according to the study that appears ...

In-home intervention improves routines that reduce risk of childhood obesity

2013-09-10
In the battle to reduce childhood overweight and obesity, several in-home factors have been identified as reducing those risks – participation of children in regular family dinners, getting enough sleep and less time watching television or other "screen time." A new study appearing in JAMA Pediatrics describes how a home-based program that helped at-risk families improve household routines was able to slow weight gain in a group of young children. "While childhood obesity rates may have stabilized in some population subgroups, overall rates remain stubbornly high, and ...

Study reveals why warnings may be ineffective at teaching young people about risks

2013-09-10
Campaigns to get young people to stop smoking may be more successful by focusing on the positive benefits, such as having more money and better skin, rather than emphasising negative outcomes like increased disease risk, a study from Wellcome Trust researchers suggests. The findings reveal that young people have greater difficulty in learning from bad news to interpret their risk of future events, which might explain why they often do not respond to warnings. We all make decisions based on what we believe may happen in the future as a consequence of our actions. We ...

Frequency and cost of critical care treatment perceived as 'futile' by physicians

2013-09-10
In one of the first studies of its kind, a joint UCLA/RAND Corporation study addressed the prevalence and cost of critical care therapies provided in intensive care units (ICU) that were perceived by physicians as "futile." Reported in the Sept. 9 online issue of JAMA Internal Medicine, researchers found that the majority of patients received appropriate care, but 11 percent of patients received treatments during their ICU course that their physicians perceived to be futile. The study took place at a single health care system. Advances in medicine have enabled critical ...

Futile treatment in critical care common, costs can be substantial

2013-09-10
Critical care treatment for patients that was perceived to be futile was common and cost an estimated at $2.6 million at one academic medical center during a three-month period, according to a report published by JAMA Internal Medicine, a JAMA Network publication. Physicians often perceive as futile those intensive care interventions that prolong life without achieving an effect for the patient that would be viewed as a benefit. Thanh N. Huynh, M.D., M.S.H.S., of the David Geffen School of Medicine at the University of California, Los Angeles, and colleagues sought to ...

Household routines may help reduce BMI in minority children

2013-09-10
An intervention to improve household routines known to be associated with obesity increased sleep duration and reduced TV viewing among low-income, minority children, and the approach may be an effective tool to reduce body mass index (BMI) in that population, according to a study published by JAMA Pediatrics, a JAMA Network publication. Racial and ethnic minority children and those who live in low-income households are disproportionately overweight and it is urgent to develop an intervention for them, Jess Haines, Ph.D., M.H.Sc., of the University of Guelph, Ontario, ...

Undervaccination appears associated with increased risk of whooping cough

2013-09-10
Undervaccination with the diptheria, tetanus toxoids and acelluar pertussis (DTaP) vaccine appears to be associated with an increased risk of pertussis (whooping cough) in children 3 to 36 months of age, according to a study by Jason M. Glanz, Ph.D., of the Institute for Health Research at Kaiser Permanente Colorado, Denver. "Undervaccination is an increasing trend that potentially places children and their communities at an increased risk for serious infectious disease," according to the study. The study involved children born between 2004 and 2008 and cared for at ...

Brain circuitry loss may be sign of cognitive decline in healthy elderly

2013-09-10
White matter loss in an area of the brain known as the fornix may be associated with cognitive decline in healthy elderly patients and may be helpful in predicting the earliest clinical deterioration, according to a study by Evan Fletcher, Ph.D., of the University of California, Davis, and colleagues. Atrophy in the hippocampus is well recognized in the later stages of cognitive decline and is one of the most studied changes associated with the Alzheimer disease process. However, changes to the fornix and other regions of the brain structurally connected to the hippocampus ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Largest imaging spectro-polarimeter achieves first light at the NSF Daniel K. Inouye solar telescope

The heart of world’s largest solar telescope begins to beat

Society for cardiovascular angiography & interventions scientific sessions 2025 features latest clinical innovations in cardiology care

Tumor microenvironment dynamics: the regulatory influence of long non-coding RNAs

Research update: Plant-based calamari that rivals real seafood in texture

Rethinking stroke risk in patients with atherosclerotic carotid stenosis

New approach makes AI adaptable for computer vision in crop breeding

Moffitt Cancer Center launches new podcast, The ImmunoVerse, hosted by CEO Dr. Patrick Hwu

Evidence blasted into space: Mystery why some meteorites look less shocked solved

Immune system warriors predict the future of autoimmune blood vessel disease

Canadian experts urge protection for children from escalating heat in schools and child care settings

Awkward. Humans are still better than AI at reading the room

No more copy-pasting: DNA base editing for better Lactobacillus strains

AI provides reliable answers with less computational overhead

‘System rife with blame’ could threaten parents’ mental health when their kids struggle with school attendance

Nature positive: lots of rhetoric, little reality

Breakthrough approach for diagnosing TB could significantly improve detection

New era of aid cuts and conflict threatens educational lifeline of youngest learners

World Hormone Day 2025 – global endocrine community unites to raise public awareness of the small steps everyone can take towards good hormone health

Daily doses of peanuts tackle allergic reactions in adults

Herpes zoster vaccination and dementia occurrence

UTEP launches artificial intelligence think tank to address regional challenges

Sun earns UTA's highest research honor

Association for Chemoreception Sciences (AChemS) 47th Annual Meeting

Age-related genetic changes in the blood associated with poor cancer prognosis

Atomic imaging and AI offer new insights into motion of parasite behind sleeping sickness

Maternal childhood trauma may lead to early metabolic changes in male children

Helping computers perceive and interact with the visual world

New precision mental health care approach for depression addresses unique patient needs

Metabolic syndrome linked to increased risk of young-onset dementia

[Press-News.org] Spirit of NHS is willing, but flesh is often weak, finds largest ever study of culture and behavior
High quality care in England often mired in unclear goals, excessive box ticking and regulation, and variable staff support