(Press-News.org) Contact information: Alan Williams
alan.williams@plymouth.ac.uk
01-752-588-004
University of Plymouth
Is clinicians' decision making affected by 'precious baby' phenomenon?
Study suggests clinicians' decision making could be affected by method of conception
Parents who conceive through assisted reproductive technologies (ART) are likely to receive different medical advice in relation to prenatal testing than those who conceive naturally, academics have suggested.
An international study has revealed that almost 45% of clinicians would immediately recommend a 37-year-old mother undergo amniocentesis – an invasive prenatal test which screens for Down's syndrome – if she had conceived naturally. However, just 19% of doctors would recommend the procedure for a mother whose baby had been conceived through assisted technologies.
Previous research papers have suggested parents who conceive through ART may be more likely to opt for birth by Caesarean section, rather than a natural birth, in an attempt to minimise any perceived risk to their baby. But the academics, in a paper published in the Human Reproduction scientific journal, suggest there may now be evidence that doctors are also affected by the so-called 'precious baby' phenomenon.
Dr Yaniv Hanoch, Associate Professor in Psychology at Plymouth University, co-wrote the study. He said: "Some pregnancies are deemed by parents to be more valuable than others, particularly if conception has taken several courses of assisted reproductive treatment to achieve. But you might expect clinical recommendations regarding pregnancies to remain consistent, particularly when it comes to tests for serious medical conditions. However, this study demonstrates there may be a tendency for clinicians to be affected by the nature of the pregnancy before determining the parents' wishes."
The study was undertaken by Dr Hanoch alongside Dr Naama Srebnik and Dr Avi Tsafrir, from the Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology at Hebrew University, Jerusalem; Dr Talya Miron-Shatz from the Center for Medical Decision Making, Ono Academic College, and Dr Jonathan J Rolison, from the School of Psychology at Queen's University, Belfast.
It used answers from around 160 obstetricians and gynaecologists, who completed an anonymous questionnaire based around a hypothetical scenario, with around half told the expectant mother had conceived naturally and the other half told ART had been employed.
In total, almost a third (31.9%) immediately recommended amniocentesis, while a further 31.3% recommended the procedure having sought further clarification about the apparent high risk to mother and baby. However, this figure differed when the nature of the pregnancy was taken into account.
The clinicians' breadth of experience and use of the procedure were also taken into account, with results showing longer service in the medical profession to have some correlation with their willingness to offer amniocentesis.
The researchers added: "Even without a medical indication, more clinicians would recommend amniocentesis to a woman with normal screening test results in a spontaneous pregnancy than to one who had undergone ART. Thus far, researchers have provided only indirect evidence to support the claim of differential management of ART pregnancies, but our findings show they do not appear to be immune to the 'precious baby' phenomenon."
### END
Is clinicians' decision making affected by 'precious baby' phenomenon?
Study suggests clinicians' decision making could be affected by method of conception
2013-11-04
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Quantum 'sealed envelope' system enables 'perfectly secure' information storage
2013-11-04
Quantum 'sealed envelope' system enables 'perfectly secure' information storage
A breakthrough in quantum cryptography demonstrates that information can be encrypted and then decrypted with complete security using the combined power of quantum theory and relativity ...
Why tumor cells go on dangerous tours
2013-11-04
Why tumor cells go on dangerous tours
Tumors become highly malignant when they acquire the ability to colonize other tissues and form metastases. Researchers at Ludwig-Maximilians-Universitaet (LMU) in Munich have identified a factor that promotes ...
Gravity and the robot satellite attitude problem
2013-11-04
Gravity and the robot satellite attitude problem
Using an in-orbit robot to capturing a malfunctioning satellite that is tumbling out of control is currently just a theoretical idea. However, research inspired by nature to be published in the forthcoming issue of International ...
Leicester scientists map structure of key complex in the immune system
2013-11-04
Leicester scientists map structure of key complex in the immune system
New study reveals the structure of complement component C1 – a target for complement-mediated diseases including strokes and heart attacks
Leicester scientists have mapped the "bouquet-like" ...
Transmitting stress response patterns across generations
2013-11-04
Transmitting stress response patterns across generations
From a new study in Biological Psychiatry
Philadelphia, PA, November 4, 2013 – Children of survivors of extremely stressful life events face adjustment challenges of their own, as has been most carefully studied ...
Researchers warn of the 'myths' of global medical tourism
2013-11-04
Researchers warn of the 'myths' of global medical tourism
A team of British researchers, led by the University of York, is warning governments and healthcare decision makers across the globe to be wary of the myths and hype surrounding medical tourism.
In an article, ...
New chemistry: Drawing and writing in liquid with light
2013-11-04
New chemistry: Drawing and writing in liquid with light
University of Helsinki researchers have manufactured photochemically active polymers which can be dissolved in water or certain alcohols. The new soluble, photosensitive polymer was created by doctoral ...
Population Council to present more than 40 studies at International Conference on Family Planning
2013-11-04
Population Council to present more than 40 studies at International Conference on Family Planning
Research will highlight development of new contraceptive technologies, strategies for expanding access to family planning, and efforts to promote gender equity
NEW YORK ...
Global change: Stowaways threaten fisheries in the Arctic
2013-11-04
Global change: Stowaways threaten fisheries in the Arctic
New study predicts a sixfold increase in the number of potential invaders by 2100
Just think of the warty comb jelly or sea walnut, as it is also known. It has caused tremendous damage to fisheries in the Black Sea ...
Mutations linked to breast cancer treatment resistance
2013-11-04
Mutations linked to breast cancer treatment resistance
Gene sequencing reveals mutations in estrogen receptor
ANN ARBOR, Mich. — Researchers at the University of Michigan Comprehensive Cancer Center have identified a type of mutation that develops ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Salk scientist Joseph Ecker awarded McClintock Prize for Plant Genetics and Genome Studies
ADHD: Women are diagnosed five years later than men, despite symptoms appearing at the same age.
Power plants may emit more pollution during government shutdowns
Increasing pressures for conformity de-skilling and demotivating teachers, study warns
Researchers develop smarter menstrual product with potential for wearable health monitoring
Microwaves for energy-efficient chemical reactions
MXene current collectors could reduce size, improve recyclability of Li-ion batteries
Living near toxic sites linked to aggressive breast cancer
New discovery could open door to male birth control
Wirth elected Fellow of American Physical Society
The Journal of Nuclear Medicine Ahead-of-Print Tip Sheet: October 10, 2025
Destined to melt
Attitudes, not income, drive energy savings at home
The playbook for perfect polaritons
‘Disease in a dish’ study of progressive MS finds critical role for unusual type of brain cell
Solar-powered method lights the way to a ‘de-fossilized’ chemical industry
Screen time linked to lower academic achievement among Ontario elementary students
One-year outcomes after traumatic brain injury and early extracranial surgery in the TRACK-TBI Study
Enduring outcomes of COVID-19 work absences on the US labor market
Affirmative action repeal and racial and ethnic diversity in us medical school admissions
Cancer progression illuminated by new multi-omics tool
Screen time and standardized academic achievement tests in elementary school
GLP-1RA order fills and out-of-pocket costs by race, ethnicity, and indication
Study finds HEPA purifiers alone may not be enough to reduce viral exposure in schools
UVA Health developing way to ID people at risk of dangerous lung scarring even before symptoms appear
How can we know when curing cancer causes myocarditis?
Male infertility in Indian men linked to lifestyle choices and hormonal imbalances
An acoustofluidic device for sample preparation and detection of small extracellular vesicles
The advent of nanotechnology has ushered in a transformative era for oncology, offering unprecedented capabilities for targeted drug delivery and controlled release. This paradigm shift enhances thera
A prototype LED as thin as wallpaper — that glows like the sun
[Press-News.org] Is clinicians' decision making affected by 'precious baby' phenomenon?Study suggests clinicians' decision making could be affected by method of conception