PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

'Saving our fish' needs more than a ban on discarding

2013-11-11
(Press-News.org) Contact information: Lisa horton
press@uea.ac.uk
44-016-035-93496
University of East Anglia
'Saving our fish' needs more than a ban on discarding Banning the practice of throwing unmarketable or over-quota fish back into the sea is just one of the measures needed to deliver sustainable fisheries according to new research from the University of East Anglia (UEA).

Research carried out by UEA with the Centre for Environment, Fisheries and Aquaculture Science (Cefas) and published today in the journal Fisheries Research reveals that a ban will only help future fish stocks if it is accompanied by other measures to reduce total fishing mortality.

Approximately half of the fish caught in marine fisheries are thrown back into the sea, but very few survive. The practice has bedevilled politicians, fisheries managers, scientists and fishermen for many years.

The move to ban discarding has gained widespread public support through the campaigning efforts of supermarkets, pressure groups, chefs including Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall, and other celebrities such as the band Coldplay and the comedian Ricky Gervais. The new European Common Fisheries Policy (CFP) which is expected to enter into force in 2014 intends to ban the wasteful practice for all quota stocks by 2019.

The research team combined information on landings by English trawlers in the North Sea with data on discards collected by onboard observers. They then used this data to assess how a discard ban will impact the catches and profits of different segments of the fleet.

Key findings: A discard ban alone may not reduce unwanted catches. A ban in isolation does not create a strong incentive for selective fishing. Catch quotas (where all fish caught are counted against a limit) create strong incentives to avoid regulated species, but not other species. Profits of some parts of the fleet may be hit unless catch quotas are set differentially. Vessels catching the least fish may see the largest profit declines under catch quotas.

Lead researcher Harriet Condie, from UEA's school of Environmental Sciences, said: "We took into account data such as catch and discard figures from fishing trawlers, fish prices and landing costs, to calculate whether banning the practice of discarding will offer enough of an economic incentive to fish sustainably.

"The most important measure to safe-guard over-exploited fish stocks is to reduce the number of individuals being caught. But our research shows that a discard ban in isolation may not result in a dramatic reduction in unmarketable catches of all species.

"If all fish have to be landed, we will get better information on exactly how many fish of each species are being caught and the state of fish stocks. But the fact that fish can no longer be thrown back into the sea will not automatically make their exploitation any more sustainable because we show that there is no significant incentive to avoid catching them.

"We went on to investigate whether a discard ban in conjunction with different management scenarios would work – such as reducing fishing effort and limiting the amount of fish that can be landed.

"We found that a ban combined with catch quotas has the greatest potential to incentivise more selective fishing, but only for regulated species such as cod, haddock and plaice.

"Experience from elsewhere in the world shows that discard bans are only effective if they are enforced by high levels of surveillance or there are economic benefits from landing fish that are currently discarded. But neither of these options is straightforward as policing fisheries is expensive and economic incentives can encourage increased catches of unwanted fish," she added.

Prof Alastair Grant, who supervised the work, said: "As welcome as the public's awareness about discarding may be, our research shows that a move towards the sustainable management of European fish stocks will require more than just a discard ban as the landing of all fish does not itself make exploitation more sustainable.

"A fish that is landed and turned into fishmeal makes as little contribution to future generations as one that is thrown back into the sea dead. The biggest challenge is to reduce fishing mortality, and national and international politics have always made that politically difficult to achieve."

Thomas Catchpole from Cefas said: "Choosing the right measures can be complicated and sufficient time is required to allow fishermen to adjust to a new management approach.

"The recently agreed reforms to the Common Fisheries Policy took years to secure but the policy now includes a phased introduction of a discard ban (completed by 2019) and legally binding commitments to set quotas at levels that achieve maximum sustainable yields of commercial fish stocks. In the interim governments have funded research to quantify and redress the impact of discarding. Catch-quota trials have been funded as have projects to design and use more selective fishing nets.

"A catch quota system provides the potential to remove many of the technical regulations currently in place, which will give fishermen increased flexibility in how they operate their businesses. This will be helped by decentralising the management of European fisheries and using a more regional approach, which was another agreed aspect of the reformed CFP."

### 'Does banning discards in an otter trawler fishery create incentives for more selective fishing?' by Harriet M, Condie, Alastair Grant, and Thomas L. Catchpole, is published in the journal Fisheries Research on November 11, 2013. The research was funded by the Department for Food and Rural Affairs (Defra).


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Fast-mutating DNA sequences shape early development; guided evolution of uniquely human traits

2013-11-11
Fast-mutating DNA sequences shape early development; guided evolution of uniquely human traits Gladstone-led study reveals new insight into origins of our species SAN FRANCISCO, CA—November 11, 2013—What does it mean to be human? According to scientists ...

Un-junking junk DNA

2013-11-11
Un-junking junk DNA A study led by researchers at the University of California, San Diego School of Medicine shines a new light on molecular tools our cells use to govern regulated gene expression. The study was published on line in advance of print November ...

Research reveals roles for exercise and diet in aging, depression

2013-11-11
Research reveals roles for exercise and diet in aging, depression Lifestyle changes in diet and exercise show promise for learning, depression in teens, and more SAN DIEGO — New studies released today underscore the potential impact of healthy lifestyle choices in treating ...

Research reveals new understanding, warning signs, and potential treatments for multiple sclerosis

2013-11-11
Research reveals new understanding, warning signs, and potential treatments for multiple sclerosis SAN DIEGO — Scientists are gaining a new level of understanding of multiple sclerosis (MS) that may lead to new treatments and approaches to controlling the chronic disease, ...

New evidence on the biological basis of highly impulsive and aggressive behaviors

2013-11-11
New evidence on the biological basis of highly impulsive and aggressive behaviors For want of a receptor: Some behaviors shaped during early development SAN DIEGO — Physical and chemical changes in the brain during development can potentially play a role in some delinquent ...

Gun use in PG-13 movies has more than tripled since 1985

2013-11-11
Gun use in PG-13 movies has more than tripled since 1985 Researchers worry about effects on teen viewers COLUMBUS, Ohio – The amount of gun violence shown in PG-13 films has more than tripled since 1985, the year the rating was introduced. In fact, the most popular ...

Young breast cancer patients with poorer financial status may experience delays in seeking care

2013-11-11
Young breast cancer patients with poorer financial status may experience delays in seeking care Researchers who sought to determine why breast cancers are more deadly in young women found that only a minority of young women experience long delays between the time they detect ...

Experts examine success of cognitive behavioral therapy in treating older veterans' depression

2013-11-11
Experts examine success of cognitive behavioral therapy in treating older veterans' depression Researchers have found significant and equivalent reductions in depressive symptoms for both older and younger veterans undergoing Cognitive Behavioral Therapy ...

Transcription factor may protect against hepatic injury caused by hepatitis C and alcohol

2013-11-11
Transcription factor may protect against hepatic injury caused by hepatitis C and alcohol More damage seen when FOXO3 suppressed, according to report in The American Journal of Pathology Philadelphia, PA, November 11, 2013 – New data suggest that the transcription ...

Brainstem abnormalities found in 'SIDS' infants, in both safe and unsafe sleep environments

2013-11-11
Brainstem abnormalities found in 'SIDS' infants, in both safe and unsafe sleep environments Study reinforces that some babies have underlying vulnerability BOSTON—Investigators at Boston Children's Hospital report that infants dying suddenly and ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

“Quantum squeezing” a nanoscale particle for the first time

El Niño spurs extreme daily rain events despite drier monsoons in India

Two studies explore the genomic diversity of deadly mosquito vectors

Zebra finches categorize their vocal calls by meaning

Analysis challenges conventional wisdom about partisan support for US science funding

New model can accurately predict a forest’s future

‘Like talking on the telephone’: Quantum computing engineers get atoms chatting long distance

Genomic evolution of major malaria-transmitting mosquito species uncovered

Overcoming the barriers of hydrogen storage with a low-temperature hydrogen battery

Tuberculosis vulnerability of people with HIV: a viral protein implicated

Partnership with Kenya's Turkana community helps scientists discover genes involved in adaptation to desert living

Decoding the selfish gene, from evolutionary cheaters to disease control

Major review highlights latest evidence on real-time test for blood – clotting in childbirth emergencies

Inspired by bacteria’s defense strategies

Research spotlight: Combination therapy shows promise for overcoming treatment resistance in glioblastoma

University of Houston co-leads $25 million NIH-funded grant to study the delay of nearsightedness in children

NRG Oncology PREDICT-RT study completes patient accrual, tests individualized concurrent therapy and radiation for high-risk prostate cancer

Taking aim at nearsightedness in kids before it’s diagnosed

With no prior training, dogs can infer how similar types of toys work, even when they don’t look alike

Three deadliest risk factors of a common liver disease identified in new study

Dogs can extend word meanings to new objects based on function, not appearance

Palaeontology: South American amber deposit ‘abuzz’ with ancient insects

Oral microbes linked to increased risk of pancreatic cancer

Soccer heading does most damage to brain area critical for cognition

US faces rising death toll from wildfire smoke, study finds

Scenario projections of COVID-19 burden in the US, 2024-2025

Disparities by race and ethnicity in percutaneous coronary intervention

Glioblastoma cells “unstick” from their neighbors to become more deadly

Oral bacterial and fungal microbiome and subsequent risk for pancreatic cancer

New light on toxicity of Bluefin tuna

[Press-News.org] 'Saving our fish' needs more than a ban on discarding