PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

A decline in creativity? It depends on how you look

2013-11-15
(Press-News.org) Contact information: Peter Kelley
kellep@uw.edu
206-616-5903
University of Washington
A decline in creativity? It depends on how you look But new research from the University of Washington Information School and Harvard University, closely studying 20 years of student creative writing and visual artworks, hints that the dynamics of creativity may not break down as simply as that.

Instead, it may be that some aspects of creativity — such as those employed in visual arts — are gently rising over the years, while other aspects, such as the nuances of creative writing, could be declining.

The paper will be published in Creativity Research Journal in January 2014. The lead author is Emily Weinstein, a doctoral student in the Harvard Graduate School of Education.

Katie Davis, UW assistant professor, and fellow researchers studied 354 examples of visual art and 50 examples of creative writing by teenagers published between 1990 and 2011. The question they pursued, Davis said, was "How have the style, content and form of adolescents' art-making and creative writing changed over the last 20 years?"

The artwork came from a monthly magazine for teens, the writing from a similar annual publication featuring student fiction. The researchers analyzed and coded the works, blind as to year, looking for trends over that time.

The review of student visual art showed an increase in the sophistication and complexity both in the designs and the subject matter over the years. The pieces, Davis said, seemed "more finished, and fuller, with backgrounds more fully rendered, suggesting greater complexity." Standard pen-and-ink illustrations grew less common over the period studied, while a broader range of mixed media work was represented.

Conversely, the review of student writing showed the young authors adhering more to "conventional writing practices" and a trend toward less play with genre, more mundane narratives and simpler language over the two decades studied.

Still, Davis said, it's too simple to just say creativity increased in one area and decreased in another over the years.

"There really isn't a standard set of agreed-upon criteria to measure something as complex and subjective as creativity," she said. "But there are markers of creativity — like complexity and risk-taking and breaking away from the standard mold — that appear to have changed."

The researchers also note that the period of study was a time of great innovation in digital art, with new tools for creative production and boundless examples of fine art a mere click or two away, serving to inform and inspire the students in their own work.

Davis said that while previous research has typically studied creativity in a lab setting, this work examined student creative work in a more "naturalistic" setting, where it is found in everyday life.

She added that with data from such a naturalistic setting, researchers cede a degree of control over the characteristics of the sample being studied, and the findings cannot safely be generalized to all American youth.

"It remains an open question as to whether the entire U.S. has seen a decline in literary creativity and a parallel increase in visual creativity among its youth over the last 20 years," Davis said. "Because society — indeed any society — depends on the creativity of its citizens to flourish, this is a question that warrants serious attention in future creativity research."

### The paper's other co-authors are Zachary Clark and Donna DiBartolomeo, former graduate students at Harvard.

The findings are also discussed in Davis' recent book with Howard Gardner, "The App Generation." The research was funded by the James and Judith K. Dimon Foundation.

For more information or a copy of the paper, contact Davis at 206-221-7741 or kdavis78@uw.edu; or Weinstein at 914-420-1454, or emily_weinstein@mail.harvard.edu.


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Study finds social networks are key to city violence

2013-11-15
Study finds social networks are key to city violence A new study of gun violence in Chicago, led by Yale sociologist Andrew Papachristos, reveals that a person's social network is a key predictor in whether an individual will become a victim of gun homicide, even more so than race, ...

Starting dialysis after -- not before -- conception may improve birth rates in women with advanced kidney disease

2013-11-15
Starting dialysis after -- not before -- conception may improve birth rates in women with advanced kidney disease Study's findings may help guide care of young women who need dialysis Washington, DC (November 14, 2013) — Women with advanced kidney disease who start ...

Scientists identify the world's most irreplaceable protected areas

2013-11-15
Scientists identify the world's most irreplaceable protected areas This news release is available in French. Gland, Switzerland, 14 November 2013 (IUCN) – A new scientific study has identified the protected areas most critical to preventing extinctions of the world's ...

UMD, Google & gov. create first detailed map of global forest change

2013-11-15
UMD, Google & gov. create first detailed map of global forest change COLLEGE PARK, Md. -- A University of Maryland-led, multi-organizational team has created the first high-resolution global map of forest extent, loss and gain. This resource greatly improves the ability to ...

Stanford researchers home in on roots of Caribbean populations using new DNA analysis method

2013-11-15
Stanford researchers home in on roots of Caribbean populations using new DNA analysis method STANFORD, Calif. — Those of us who want to learn about our ancestors — who they were, where they came from and how they mingled (or didn't) with others ...

Deciphering genetic echoes from the past: Illuminating human history

2013-11-15
Deciphering genetic echoes from the past: Illuminating human history Historical records are often used to learn about ancestry but a new approach, using genetics, is currently being applied. In a recent study, published in PLOS Genetics, scientists from the Stanford University ...

Stanford scientists create a low-cost, long-lasting water splitter made of silicon and nickel

2013-11-15
Stanford scientists create a low-cost, long-lasting water splitter made of silicon and nickel Stanford University scientists have created a silicon-based water splitter that is both low-cost and corrosion-free. The novel device – a silicon semiconductor coated in ...

High marks for Columbia's new public health curriculum

2013-11-15
High marks for Columbia's new public health curriculum The architects of the Columbia MPH reflect on its rationale and design, and report feedback from students and faculty A fully re-envisioned Master of Public Health program was launched by Columbia ...

Has the idea of 'zero deforestation' lost its meaning

2013-11-15
Has the idea of 'zero deforestation' lost its meaning Separate targets for gross deforestation and reforestation would increase progress toward forest conservation, climate change mitigation goals ARLINGTON, Va. (November 14, 2013) – What exactly does "zero ...

Quantum world record smashed

2013-11-15
Quantum world record smashed A normally fragile quantum state has been shown to survive at room temperature for a world record 39 minutes, overcoming a key barrier towards building ultrafast quantum computers. An international team ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Study reveals global inequalities in cancer research funding

England’s forgotten first king deserves to be famous, says Æthelstan biographer as anniversaries approach

Experts urge the medical profession to confront the global arms industry

Personalized risk messages fail to boost colorectal cancer screening participation

Something from nothing: Physicists model vacuum tunnelling in a 2D superfluid

CRISPR’s efficiency triples with DNA-wrapped nanoparticles

For the first time in 40 Years, Panama’s deep and cold ocean waters failed to emerge, possibly affecting fisheries and coral health

Depression may make learning to avoid unpleasant events harder

Study sheds light on how pediatric brain tumors grow

Rare seasonal brain shrinkage in shrews is driven by water loss, not cell death

AI co-pilot boosts noninvasive brain-computer interface by interpreting user intent

Black adults face heart failure nearly 14 years earlier than white patients

Study detects multidrug-resistant KPC-producing bacteria in Chilean wastewater for the first time

New artificial intelligence model accurately identifies which atrial fibrillation patients need blood thinners to prevent stroke

Safety of factor XI inhibition with abelacimab in atrial fibrillation by kidney function

Combination of mini-camera and AI predicts recurrent heart attack

Study Reveals Details of Overactive Immune System in Patients with Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (ME/CFS)

UTSA and UT Health San Antonio complete merger to become The University of Texas at San Antonio

Helicobacter pylori screening after acute myocardial infarction

Solar Orbiter traces superfast electrons back to Sun

GaN-based electron beam technology from Nagoya University startup poised to overcome critical semiconductor manufacturing challenges at KIOXIA

Circle versus rectangle: Finding ‘Earth 2.0’ may be easier using a new telescope shape

Metformin changes blood metal levels in humans

Long-term anticoagulation discontinuation after catheter ablation for atrial fibrillation

Fractional flow reserve–guided complete vs culprit-only revascularization in non–ST-elevation myocardial infarction and multivessel disease

Participation of women in cardiovascular trials from 2017 to 2023

Semaglutide and tirzepatide in patients with heart failure with preserved ejection fraction

Changes in biology of internal fat may be the leading cause of heart failure

Transcatheter or surgical treatment of patients with aortic stenosis at low to intermediate risk

Promising new drug for people with stubborn high blood pressure

[Press-News.org] A decline in creativity? It depends on how you look