(Press-News.org) Contact information: Shilo Rea
shilo@cmu.edu
412-268-6094
Carnegie Mellon University
Improve learning by taming instructional complexity
Carnegie Mellon and Temple researchers offer fresh perspective for educational research
VIDEO:
From using concrete or abstract materials to giving immediate or delayed feedback, there are rampant debates over the best teaching strategies to use. But, in reality, improving education is not...
Click here for more information.
PITTSBURGH—From using concrete or abstract materials to giving immediate or delayed feedback, there are rampant debates over the best teaching strategies to use. But, in reality, improving education is not as simple as choosing one technique over another.
Carnegie Mellon University and Temple University researchers scoured the educational research landscape and found that because improved learning depends on many different factors, there are actually more than 205 trillion instructional options available.
In the Nov. 22 issue of "Science," the researchers break down exactly how complicated improving education really is when considering the combination of different dimensions — spacing of practice, studying examples or practicing procedures, to name a few — with variations in ideal dosage and in student needs as they learn. The researchers offer a fresh perspective on educational research by focusing on conclusive approaches that truly impact classroom learning.
The findings were published only a week after CMU launched the Simon Initiative to accelerate the use of learning science and technology to improve student learning. Named to honor the work of the late Nobel Laureate and CMU Professor Herbert Simon, the initiative will harness CMU's decades of learning data and research to improve educational outcomes for students everywhere.
"There are not just two ways to teach, as our education debates often seem to indicate," said lead author Ken Koedinger, professor of human-computer interaction at Carnegie Mellon, director of the Pittsburgh Science of Learning Center (PSLC) and co-coordinator of the Simon Initiative. "There are trillions of possible ways to teach. Part of the instructional complexity challenge is that education is not 'one size fits all,' and optimal forms of instruction depend on details, such as how much a learner already knows and whether a fact, concept, or thinking skill is being targeted."
For the paper, Koedinger, Temple's Julie Booth and CMU's David Klahr investigated existing education research to show that the space is too vast, with too many possibilities for simple studies to determine what techniques will work for which students at different learning points.
"As learning researchers, we get frustrated when our work doesn't seem to make an impact on the education system," said Booth, assistant professor of educational psychology at Temple who received her Ph.D. in psychology from Carnegie Mellon. "But much of the work on these learning principles has been conducted in laboratory settings. We need to shift our focus to determine when and for whom these techniques work in real-world classrooms."
To tame instructional complexity and maximize the potential of improving research behind educational practice and student learning, the researchers offer five recommendations:
1. Because trying all educational options — more than 205 trillion — to find out what works best is impossible, research should focus on how different forms of instruction meet different functional needs, such as which methods are best for learning to remember facts, which are best for learning to induce general skills, and which are best for learning to make sense of concepts and principles.
2. More experiments are needed to determine how different instructional techniques enhance different learning functions. For example, the optimal way to memorize facts may be a poor way to learn to induce general skills.
3. Take advantage of educational technology to further understand how people learn and which instructional dimensions can or cannot be treated independently by conducting massive online studies, which use thousands of students and test hundreds of variations of instruction at the same time.
4. To understand impact, build a national data infrastructure in which data collected at a moment-by-moment basis (i.e., cognitive tutors tracking daily how a student learns algebra over a school year) can be linked with longer-term results, such as state exams and performances in a next class.
5. Create more permanent school and research partnerships to facilitate interaction between education, administration and researchers. For example, the PSLC, funded by the National Science Foundation (NSF), gives teachers immediate feedback and allows researchers to explore only relevant theories.
"These recommendations are just one of the many steps needed to nail down what's necessary to really improve education and to expand our knowledge of how students learn and how to best teach them," said Klahr, the Walter Van Dyke Bingham Professor of Psychology at CMU who directs PIER, the university-wide graduate training program in education research. "They're also in line with how Carnegie Mellon — an educational research powerhouse — approaches education by studying the intersection of instruction, cognitive psychology, computer science, statistics, philosophy and policy."
###
The NSF and U.S. Department of Education funded this research.
For more information, watch Koedinger, Booth and Klahr discuss instructional complexity in this video: http://youtu.be/eY_eHCdDGjQ.
Improve learning by taming instructional complexity
Carnegie Mellon and Temple researchers offer fresh perspective for educational research
2013-11-22
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Researchers identify lifestyle factors linked to a healthy pregnancy
2013-11-22
Researchers identify lifestyle factors linked to a healthy pregnancy
Modifiable factors such as weight, diet and drug abuse could be targeted for change
On bmj.com today, researchers identify certain lifestyle factors that make it more likely for a woman ...
Dreading pain can be worse than pain itself
2013-11-22
Dreading pain can be worse than pain itself
Press release from PLOS Computational Biology
Faced with inevitable pain, most people choose to "get it out of the way" as soon as possible, according to research published this week in PLOS Computational Biology. ...
UEA researchers pioneer first patient-specific 3-D virtual birth simulator
2013-11-22
UEA researchers pioneer first patient-specific 3-D virtual birth simulator
Computer scientists from the University of East Anglia are working to create a virtual birthing simulator that will help doctors and midwives prepare for unusual or dangerous births.
The ...
Lowering 3 risk factors could cut obesity-related risk of heart disease by more than half
2013-11-22
Lowering 3 risk factors could cut obesity-related risk of heart disease by more than half
Research looks at blood pressure, cholesterol, blood glucose
Boston, MA — Controlling blood pressure, serum cholesterol, and blood glucose may substantially reduce the ...
Lowering blood pressure, cholesterol and blood sugar could halve obesity-related risk of heart disease
2013-11-22
Lowering blood pressure, cholesterol and blood sugar could halve obesity-related risk of heart disease
Controlling blood pressure, cholesterol, and blood glucose may substantially reduce the risk of heart disease and stroke associated with being overweight ...
Astronomers reveal mystery of brightest ever gamma-ray burst
2013-11-22
Astronomers reveal mystery of brightest ever gamma-ray burst
New research explains celestial phenomenon recorded earlier this year
For the first time, a team of astronomers from around the world, including experts from the University of Leicester, have used ...
Research reveals details of how flu evolves to escape immunity
2013-11-22
Research reveals details of how flu evolves to escape immunity
Study shows that seasonal flu escapes immunity with single amino acid substitutions
Scientists have identified a potential way to improve future flu vaccines after discovering that seasonal flu ...
Cosmic finding ushers in 'new age of astronomy'
2013-11-22
Cosmic finding ushers in 'new age of astronomy'
UD researchers part of international team that identifies very high-energy neutrinos coming from outside our solar system
Neutrinos can zip right through your body, the walls of your house, entire planets, even ...
Rutgers-Camden nursing scholar develops tool for ostomy care
2013-11-22
Rutgers-Camden nursing scholar develops tool for ostomy care
CAMDEN — Nurses caring for ostomy patients will now be equipped with an essential new tool that provides them with the first comprehensive guide to optimize ostomy management and enhance patient safety. ...
Healthy lifestyle before conception may increase likelihood of a healthy pregnancy
2013-11-22
Healthy lifestyle before conception may increase likelihood of a healthy pregnancy
Leading a healthy lifestyle in the months prior to conception as well as during pregnancy could potentially decrease the chance of complications
Leading a healthy lifestyle ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Fig trees convert atmospheric CO2 to stone
Intra-arterial tenecteplase for acute stroke after successful endovascular therapy
Study reveals beneficial microbes that can sustain yields in unfertilized fields
Robotic probe quickly measures key properties of new materials
Climate change cuts milk production, even when farmers cool their cows
Frozen, but not sealed: Arctic Ocean remained open to life during ice ages
Some like it cold: Cryorhodopsins
Demystifying gut bacteria with AI
Human wellbeing on a finite planet towards 2100: new study shows humanity at a crossroads
Unlocking the hidden biodiversity of Europe’s villages
Planned hydrogen refuelling stations may lead to millions of euros in yearly losses
Planned C-sections increase the risk of certain childhood cancers
Adults who have survived childhood cancer are at increased risk of severe COVID-19
Drones reveal extreme coral mortality after bleaching
New genetic finding uncovers hidden cause of arsenic resistance in acute promyelocytic leukemia
Native habitats hold the key to the much-loved smashed avocado’s future
Using lightning to make ammonia out of thin air
Machine learning potential-driven insights into pH-dependent CO₂ reduction
Physician associates provide safe care for diagnosed patients when directly supervised by a doctor
How game-play with robots can bring out their human side
Asthma: patient expectations influence the course of the disease
UNM physician tests drug that causes nerve tissue to emit light, enabling faster, safer surgery
New study identifies EMP1 as a key driver of pancreatic cancer progression and poor prognosis
XPR1 identified as a key regulator of ovarian cancer growth through autophagy and immune evasion
Flexible, eco-friendly electronic plastic for wearable tech, sensors
Can the Large Hadron Collider snap string theory?
Stuckeman professor’s new book explores ‘socially sustainable’ architecture
Synthetic DNA nanoparticles for gene therapy
New model to find treatments for an aggressive blood cancer
Special issue of Journal of Intensive Medicine analyzes non-invasive respiratory support
[Press-News.org] Improve learning by taming instructional complexityCarnegie Mellon and Temple researchers offer fresh perspective for educational research