PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Research funding has become prone to bubble formation

2013-11-22
(Press-News.org) Contact information: Vincent F. Hendricks
vincent@hum.ku.dk
45-40-16-80-63
University of Copenhagen
Research funding has become prone to bubble formation "In finance, the first condition for a bubble occurs when too much liquidity is concentrated on too few assets. The second is the presence of speculators. In science, similarly, if too much research funding is focused on too few research topics, and all researchers speculate in the same fashionable scientific templates to attract funding, a potential science bubble may be forming," explains professor of Formal Philosophy Vincent F. Hendricks from University of Copenhagen.

In the article "Science Bubbles" just published in Philosophy and Technology, professor Vincent F. Hendricks and postdoc David Budtz Pedersen trace the mechanisms that can result in science bubbles. They point to the past decade's massive investments in cognitive neuroscience as a potential bubble – culminating with President Obama's recent endorsement of the one billion dollar Brain Activity Map Project and the European Commission's 500 million euro Human Brain Project.

"These investments have been preceded by a dramatic rise in fields that attach 'neuro' to some human behaviour or trait with promises that the techniques of neuroscience will explain it – and into game-changing explanations of the human mind," Budtz Pedersen says and adds that studies have shown that peer reviewers and lay citizens are more likely to find explanations of e.g. psychological phenomena more convincing when they contain neuroscientific information, even when it is not relevant to the explanation.

Incentive structures pull researchers in the same direction

Budtz Pedersen and Hendricks show how the 'breakthroughs' and' turning points' promised by many neuroscience projects – when combined with the fact that recent studies indicate a number of neuroscience publications seem to lack the statistical power to back their findings – have the potential to become a fully-fledged science bubble. In other words: the value of the neuroscientific promises and the investments made in them may turn out to bear no relation to the actual value of the scientific results.

A central cause of this is, according to Budtz Pedersen and Hendricks, the institutional design and incentive structures within science funding and research management, where traditional scientific incentives such as academic capital and reputation are being replaced by monetary incentives and competition.

"Numerous international studies of research management document how many Western universities have set up financial incentives and reward systems to encourage researchers to publish in high-impact journals on popular topics that generate research funding. This means that researchers often will have very little interest in spending time on problems that break away from mainstream or do not lead to publishable results, and they will tend to they dress their research claims up in ways that appeal to policy makers and external evaluators," Professor Hendricks points out.

Scientific lemmings

The structural reforms of research management may, Budtz Pedersen and Hendricks continue, thus amplify social phenomena like "pluralistic ignorance" and "lemming effects," which have been shown to have significant impact on information processing and assessment in populations of interacting persons – including in one of the most rational enterprises of modern social life.

"Even in the highly rationalised science community, people are susceptible to a social-psychological phenomenon like pluralistic ignorance, where every researcher and policymaker individually may doubt the promises made by a particular research programme but also wrongly believe that everybody else is convinced of its robustness; so they all end up collectively supporting a dubious programme which subsequently receives generous funding," professor Hendricks says and concludes:

"When researchers choose to ignore their private information and instead mimick the actions of researchers before them, they initialise a so-called lemming effect in which everybody publishes in the same journals and applies for funding for the same type of projects. Such a scientific bubble will eventually bust when the programmes' scientific explanations are put to the test, but the problem is that they may already have drained the research system from resources. And then the system will be faced with an investor confidence crisis."

### The research is part of the Humanomics Research Center at The University of Copenhagen.

Read the article Science Bubbles in Philosophy and Technology: http://link.springer.com/journal/13347/onlineFirst/page/1

Contact

Professor Vincent F. Hendricks
Department of Media, Cognition and Communication
Phone: + 45 40 16 80 63

Postdoc David Budtz Pedersen
Humanomics Research Centre
University of Copenhagen
Phone: + 45 30 29 29 74


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Sea level rise forecasts helped by insights into glacier melting

2013-11-22
Sea level rise forecasts helped by insights into glacier melting Predictions of sea level rise could become more accurate, thanks to new insight into how glacier movement is affected by melting ice in summer Predictions of sea level rise could become more ...

Continued increases in ADHD diagnoses and treatment with medication among US children

2013-11-22
Continued increases in ADHD diagnoses and treatment with medication among US children New study led by the CDC reports that half of US children diagnosed with ADHD received that diagnosis by age 6 Washington D.C., November 22, 2013 – A new study published in the Journal ...

Research team discovers 'immune gene' in Neanderthals

2013-11-22
Research team discovers 'immune gene' in Neanderthals Early humans had a selection advantage, as scientists working under the direction of the University of Bonn have learned A research group at Bonn University and international collaborators discovered ...

LSUHSC research finds combo of plant nutrients kills breast cancer cells

2013-11-22
LSUHSC research finds combo of plant nutrients kills breast cancer cells New Orleans, LA – A study led by Madhwa Raj, PhD, Research Professor in Obstetrics and Gynecology at LSU Health Sciences Center New Orleans and its Stanley S. Scott Cancer ...

Scientists have been able to grow artificial skin using stem cells from the umbilical cord

2013-11-22
Scientists have been able to grow artificial skin using stem cells from the umbilical cord 1 of the problems major burn victims have is that, using the current protocols for artificial skin, they need to wait various weeks in order for it to be grown, using ...

Satellite trio to explore the Earth's magnetic field

2013-11-22
Satellite trio to explore the Earth's magnetic field Textbook launch for the SWARM satellites In a dense fog, a Russian Rockot rocket on 22 November 2013 cleared the launchpad of the Baikonur Cosmodrome on schedule at 13:02:15 CET. In ...

Copper promises cheaper, sturdier fuel cells

2013-11-22
Copper promises cheaper, sturdier fuel cells Copper nanowires offer an efficient, inexpensive approach to solar energy harvesting DURHAM, N.C. -- Copper adorns the Statue of Liberty, makes sturdy, affordable wiring, and helps our bodies absorb iron. Now, researchers at Duke ...

New study helps explain why some ear and respiratory infections become chronic

2013-11-22
New study helps explain why some ear and respiratory infections become chronic Scientists have figured out how a bacterium that causes ear and respiratory illnesses is able to elude immune detection in the middle ear, likely contributing ...

Epigenetic changes may explain chronic kidney disease

2013-11-22
Epigenetic changes may explain chronic kidney disease PHILADELPHIA – The research of physician-scientist Katalin Susztak, MD, PhD, associate professor of Medicine in the Renal Electrolyte and Hypertension Division, at the Perelman ...

Powerful tool for genetic engineering

2013-11-22
Powerful tool for genetic engineering Researchers from Braunschweig describe new possibilities of the CRISPR-Cas-system This news release is available in German. Viruses cannot only cause illnesses in humans, they also ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Consistent policy, not “patchwork” regulations, recommended for the coexistence of crops

LEDs shed light on efficient tomato cultivation

2025 Ig Physics Nobel Prize for perfect pasta sauce

Bright squeezed light in the kilohertz frequency band

Water flowed on ancient asteroid

AI model offers accurate and explainable insights to support autism assessment

Process for dealing with sexual misconduct by doctors requires major reform

Severe pregnancy sickness raises risk of mental health conditions by over 50%

Early humans may have walked from Türkiye to mainland Europe, new groundbreaking research suggests

New study shows biochar’s electrical properties can influence rice field methane emissions

Guangdong faces largest chikungunya outbreak on record

Tirzepatide improves blood sugar control in children aged 10-17 years with type 2 diabetes inadequately controlled on existing therapies (SURPASS-PEDS trial)

An old drug, in a low dose, shown to be safe and effective in preventing progression of type 1 diabetes in children and young people (MELD-ATG trial)

Study reports potential effects of verapamil in slowing progression of type 1 diabetes

Fresh hope for type 1 diabetes as daily pill that slows onset confirms promise at 2-year follow-up

New estimates predict over 4 million missing people who would be alive in 2025 if not for inadequate type 1 diabetes care

So what should we call this – a grue jay?

Chicago Quantum Exchange-led coalition advances to final round in NSF Engine competition

Study identifies candidates for therapeutic targets in pediatric germ cell tumors

Media alert: The global burden of CVD

Study illuminates contributing factors to blood vessel leakage

What nations around the world can learn from Ukraine

Mixing tree species does not always make forests more drought-resilient

Public confidence in U.S. health agencies slides, fueled by declines among Democrats

“Quantum squeezing” a nanoscale particle for the first time

El Niño spurs extreme daily rain events despite drier monsoons in India

Two studies explore the genomic diversity of deadly mosquito vectors

Zebra finches categorize their vocal calls by meaning

Analysis challenges conventional wisdom about partisan support for US science funding

New model can accurately predict a forest’s future

[Press-News.org] Research funding has become prone to bubble formation