PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Increasing the number of insured patients is not tied to higher ICU usage in Massachusetts

Better, earlier care may mean fewer ICU admissions; implications for US as national health care reform begins

2013-11-26
(Press-News.org) Contact information: Steve Graff
stephen.graff@uphs.upenn.edu
215-349-5653
University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine
Increasing the number of insured patients is not tied to higher ICU usage in Massachusetts Better, earlier care may mean fewer ICU admissions; implications for US as national health care reform begins PHILADELPHIA- A multi-institution study led by researchers at the Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania has found that increasing the number of insured patients is not associated with higher intensive care unit (ICU) usage in Massachusetts.

Because ICU care is expensive, concerns have been raised that increasing the number of insured patients would inevitably lead to significantly higher health care costs as more of these newly insured patients would be admitted to ICUs.

The Penn-led study, published November 25 in Critical Care Medicine, found that while Massachusetts health insurance reform resulted in a significant reduction in the number of critically ill patients without health insurance (from 9.3 percent to 5.1 percent), there was no concomitant increase in ICU utilization as measured by ICU admissions per capita or ICU admissions per hospitalization.

The findings have potential implications for the nation as a whole since the Affordable Care Act (ACA) -- "health care reform" or "Obamacare" -- expands access to health insurance through several provisions modeled after the health insurance reform enacted by Massachusetts in July 2006. For example, Massachusetts health insurance reform required all adults to purchase health insurance by July 1, 2007.

This patient population stems beyond those who are directly admitted to the ICU. Many patients who have been admitted to a less intense level of care for other illnesses require subsequent ICU stays, as well as following elective procedures, including some cardiac and endovascular operations and cancer surgeries.

The study examined hospital discharge records of patients aged 18-64, comparing ICU utilization in Massachusetts to four states that did not enact health insurance reform: New York, Washington, Nebraska, and North Carolina. The comparison states were chosen because they overlap Massachusetts in population demographics while also being broadly representative of the United States as a whole.

In addition to discovering no significant changes in adjusted ICU admission rates, the study found no significant changes in discharge destination e.g., to a nursing home, or in-hospital ICU-patient mortality rates between Massachusetts and the non-reform states (although this latter association was dependent on the comparison states chosen in the analysis.)

"Greater access to care allows for better preventive care, which may reduce ICU admissions and ultimately an individual's risk of death in the ICU," said Sarah M. Lyon, MD, MSCE, a pulmonary medicine specialist in the division of Pulmonary, Allergy and Critical Care at the Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania and the study's lead author. "Individuals with insurance may also be more likely to come to us earlier in the course of their illness when their acute illness severity is lower."

The care of patients with critical illness now accounts for between 16.9 percent and 38.4 percent of total hospital costs. As the population ages, critical care costs are also expected to grow. Thus, balancing patients' need for critical care with the available resources is a policy challenge. However, the findings of the Penn study suggest that health insurance expansion may not exacerbate the projected shortage of critical care beds and providers.

"Our study provides evidence that expanding access to health insurance may not appreciably inflate ICU utilization through greater demand," said Colin R. Cooke MD, MSc, from the University of Michigan's Institute for Healthcare Policy & Innovation and the study's senior author. "Our results suggest that policymakers and health systems leaders should consider continuing to focus on improving the efficient use of existing resources."

While the study found no difference in mortality rates between ICU patients in Massachusetts and the four non-reform states, it determined that ICU-patient mortality rates remained the same in Massachusetts after health care reform was enacted -- confounding expectations that earlier access to care might lower ICU death rates. Although previous studies demonstrated that lack of health insurance is associated with increased mortality in critical illness, it could be that lack of health insurance may coincide with other socioeconomic factors, such as unemployment or underemployment and poverty, and that acquiring health insurance does not counteract the negative impact of these factors.

Additionally, according to a recent study of Medicaid expansion, reductions in adjusted all-cause mortality were not apparent until five years after the policy change. It is thus possible that in the timeframe examined in the Penn-led study, which ended 29 months after mandatory insurance began in Massachusetts, reform had not had sufficient time to improve rates of preventable ICU mortality through improved access to primary and preventable medical services; longer follow-up may be necessary to see a change in these rates.

Finally, the study's post-reform period coincided with the financial recession beginning in 2008. Population changes in healthcare utilization in response to economic hardship may have mitigated potential benefits of acquiring health insurance.

"While what happened in one state does not necessarily mean the rest of the nation will follow, it's important to use whatever data are available to anticipate and plan for what might occur under national health care reform," said Lyon.

### In addition to Lyon and Cooke, co-authors are David A. Asch and Brendan G. Carr from Penn; and Jeremy M. Kahn, University of Pittsburgh; and Hannah Wunsch, Columbia University.


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Oxytocin leads to monogamy

2013-11-26
Oxytocin leads to monogamy Researchers at the Bonn University Medical Center: Hormone stimulates the brain reward system when viewing the partner How is the bond between people in love maintained? Scientists at the Bonn University Medical Center have ...

Study examines barriers to human papillomavirus vaccination among teens

2013-11-26
Study examines barriers to human papillomavirus vaccination among teens Barriers to human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination among adolescents in the U.S. range from financial concerns and parental attitudes to social influences and concerns about the vaccination's ...

Findings not supportive of women-specific chest pain symptoms in heart attack diagnosis

2013-11-26
Findings not supportive of women-specific chest pain symptoms in heart attack diagnosis CHICAGO – Using chest pain characteristics (CPCs) specific to women in the early diagnosis of acute myocardial infarction (AMI, heart attack) in the emergency department ...

Childhood exercise may stave off some bad effects of maternal obesity

2013-11-26
Childhood exercise may stave off some bad effects of maternal obesity Prenatal exposure to high-fat diets mitigated in offspring Rats whose mothers were fed a high-fat diet during pregnancy and nursing were able to stave off some of the detrimental health effects ...

School climate key to preventing bullying

2013-11-26
School climate key to preventing bullying To prevent bullying schools need to understand positive school climate, use reliable measures to evaluate school climate and use effective prevention and intervention programs to improve the climate RIVERSIDE, ...

Flashes of brilliance

2013-11-26
Flashes of brilliance Rice U. researchers discover roots of superfluorescent bursts from quantum wells HOUSTON – (Nov. 25, 2013) – Spontaneous bursts of light from a solid block illuminate the unusual way interacting quantum particles behave when they are driven far from equilibrium. ...

The inner workings of a bacterial black box caught on time-lapse video

2013-11-26
The inner workings of a bacterial black box caught on time-lapse video VIDEO: After "turning on " the critical genes, the cyanobacteria began to construct ...

ADHD study: Expensive training programs don't help kids' grades, behavior

2013-11-26
ADHD study: Expensive training programs don't help kids' grades, behavior Many parents spend thousands of dollars on computer-based training programs that claim to help children with ADHD succeed in the classroom and in peer relationships while reducing hyperactivity ...

A touch of garlic helps kill contaminants in baby formula

2013-11-26
A touch of garlic helps kill contaminants in baby formula Garlic may be bad for your breath, but it's good for your baby, according to a new study from the University of British Columbia. The study, recently published in Applied and Environmental Microbiology, ...

Extrovert and introvert children are not equally influenced by plate size

2013-11-26
Extrovert and introvert children are not equally influenced by plate size Extroverted children are more biased by bowl sizes than introverts As dish size increases, so do portion size and the amount of food actually eaten—but could personality traits play ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

North-south autism assessment divide leaves children waiting three years longer 

Want to publish in Nature? Webinar with Prof. Willie Peijnenburg shares insider tips

Cataract surgery on both eyes can be carried out safely and effectively in one go

Personalized brain stimulation shows benefit for depression

AI uncovers hidden rules of some of nature’s toughest protein bonds

Innovative approach helps new mothers get hepatitis C treatment

Identifying the Interactions That Drive Cell Migration in Brain Cancer

ORNL receives 2025 SAMPE Organizational Excellence Award

University of Oklahoma researchers aim to reduce indigenous cancer disparities

Study reveals new evidence, cost savings for common treatments for opioid use disorder in mothers and infants

Research alert: Frequent cannabis users show no driving impairment after two-day break

Turbulence with a twist

Volcanic emissions of reactive sulfur gases may have shaped early mars climate, making it more hospitable to life

C-Path concludes 2025 Global Impact Conference with progress across rare diseases, neurology and pediatrics

Research exposes far-reaching toll of financial hardship on patients with cancer

The percentage of women who went without a Pap smear for cervical cancer screening increased following the COVID-19 pandemic, from 19% in 2019 to 26% in 2022

AI tools fall short in predicting suicide, study finds

Island ant communities show signs of ‘insect apocalypse’

Revealed: The long legacy of human-driven ant decline in Fiji

Analyzing impact of heat from western wildfires on air pollution in the eastern US

Inadequate regulatory protections for consumer genetic data privacy in US

Pinning down protons in water — a basic science success story

Scientists reveal how the brain uses objects to find direction

Humans sense a collaborating robot as part of their “extended” body

Nano-switch achieves first directed, gated flow of chargeless quantum information carriers

Scientist, advocate and entrepreneur Lucy Shapiro to receive Lasker-Koshland special achievement award

Creating user personas to represent the needs of dementia caregivers supporting medication management at home

UTIA participates in national study analyzing microbial communities, environmental factors impacting cotton development

Mizzou economists: 2025 farm income boosted by high cattle prices and one-time payments

What 3I/ATLAS tells us about other solar systems

[Press-News.org] Increasing the number of insured patients is not tied to higher ICU usage in Massachusetts
Better, earlier care may mean fewer ICU admissions; implications for US as national health care reform begins