PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Geoengineering approaches to reduce climate change unlikely to succeed

2013-12-05
(Press-News.org) Contact information: Bárbara Ferreira
media@egu.eu
49-892-180-6703
European Geosciences Union
Geoengineering approaches to reduce climate change unlikely to succeed

Reducing the amount of sunlight reaching the planet's surface by geoengineering may not undo climate change after all. Two German researchers used a simple energy balance analysis to explain how the Earth's water cycle responds differently to heating by sunlight than it does to warming due to a stronger atmospheric greenhouse effect. Further, they show that this difference implies that reflecting sunlight to reduce temperatures may have unwanted effects on the Earth's rainfall patterns. The results are now published in Earth System Dynamics, an open access journal of the European Geosciences Union (EGU).

Global warming alters the Earth's water cycle since more water evaporates to the air as temperatures increase. Increased evaporation can dry out some regions while, at the same time, result in more rain falling in other areas due to the excess moisture in the atmosphere. The more water evaporates per degree of warming, the stronger the influence of increasing temperature on the water cycle. But the new study shows the water cycle does not react the same way to different types of warming.

Axel Kleidon and Maik Renner of the Max Planck Institute for Biogeochemistry in Jena, Germany, used a simple energy balance model to determine how sensitive the water cycle is to an increase in surface temperature due to a stronger greenhouse effect and to an increase in solar radiation. They predicted the response of the water cycle for the two cases and found that, in the former, evaporation increases by 2% per degree of warming while in the latter this number reaches 3%. This prediction confirmed results of much more complex climate models.

"These different responses to surface heating are easy to explain," says Kleidon, who uses a pot on the kitchen stove as an analogy. "The temperature in the pot is increased by putting on a lid or by turning up the heat – but these two cases differ by how much energy flows through the pot," he says. A stronger greenhouse effect puts a thicker 'lid' over the Earth's surface but, if there is no additional sunlight (if we don't turn up the heat on the stove), extra evaporation takes place solely due to the increase in temperature. Turning up the heat by increasing solar radiation, on the other hand, enhances the energy flow through the Earth's surface because of the need to balance the greater energy input with stronger cooling fluxes from the surface. As a result, there is more evaporation and a stronger effect on the water cycle.

In the new Earth System Dynamics study the authors also show how these findings can have profound consequences for geoengineering. Many geoengineering approaches aim to reduce global warming by reducing the amount of sunlight reaching the Earth's surface (or, in the pot analogy, reduce the heat from the stove). But when Kleidon and Renner applied their results to such a geoengineering scenario, they found out that simultaneous changes in the water cycle and the atmosphere cannot be compensated for at the same time. Therefore, reflecting sunlight by geoengineering is unlikely to restore the planet's original climate.

"It's like putting a lid on the pot and turning down the heat at the same time," explains Kleidon. "While in the kitchen you can reduce your energy bill by doing so, in the Earth system this slows down the water cycle with wide-ranging potential consequences," he says.

Kleidon and Renner's insight comes from looking at the processes that heat and cool the Earth's surface and how they change when the surface warms. Evaporation from the surface plays a key role, but the researchers also took into account how the evaporated water is transported into the atmosphere. They combined simple energy balance considerations with a physical assumption for the way water vapour is transported, and separated the contributions of surface heating from solar radiation and from increased greenhouse gases in the atmosphere to obtain the two sensitivities. One of the referees for the paper commented: "it is a stunning result that such a simple analysis yields the same results as the climate models."



INFORMATION:

Please mention the name of the publication (Earth System Dynamics) if reporting on this story and, if reporting online, include a link to the paper or to the journal website.



ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Probiotic therapy alleviates autism-like behaviors in mice

2013-12-05
Probiotic therapy alleviates autism-like behaviors in mice Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is diagnosed when individuals exhibit characteristic behaviors that include repetitive actions, decreased social interactions, and impaired communication. Curiously, ...

NIH-funded scientists describe how mosquitoes are attracted to humans

2013-12-05
NIH-funded scientists describe how mosquitoes are attracted to humans Researchers identify compounds that reduce attraction, lure mosquitoes to traps WHAT: Scientists at the University of California, Riverside have ...

Large-scale erythrocyte production method established using erythrocyte progenitor cells

2013-12-05
Large-scale erythrocyte production method established using erythrocyte progenitor cells By transducing two genes (c-MYC and BCL-XL) into iPS cells and ES cells, a Kyoto University research team led by Prof. Koji ...

What is the central analgesic mechanism of acupuncture for migraine?

2013-12-05
What is the central analgesic mechanism of acupuncture for migraine? The central analgesic mechanism of acupuncture for migraine remains poorly understood. Acupuncture has been shown to become a recommended treatment for migraine sufferers. However, a single acupuncture ...

Who is the culprit to cause memory impairment during brain aging?

2013-12-05
Who is the culprit to cause memory impairment during brain aging? The N-methyl-D-aspartic acid (NMDA) receptor dysfunction in the brain of aged animals has been shown. In older rodents, N-methyl-D-aspartate receptor 2B subunit gene expression declines significantly ...

Pre-moxibustion and moxibustion prevent Alzheimer's disease

2013-12-05
Pre-moxibustion and moxibustion prevent Alzheimer's disease An increasing number of clinical and animal studies have confirmed that acupuncture is effective for the treatment of Alzheimer's disease. Moxibustion is reported to be more effective than electro-acupuncture ...

Better water purification with seeds from Moringa trees

2013-12-05
Better water purification with seeds from Moringa trees Seeds from Moringa oleifera trees can be used to purify water. Uppsala University leads a research group which has discovered that seed material can give a more efficient purification process than conventional ...

Crop-infecting virus forces aphids to spread disease

2013-12-05
Crop-infecting virus forces aphids to spread disease Viruses alter plant biochemistry in order to manipulate visiting aphids into spreading infection. University of Cambridge researchers have shown that viruses use aphids as pawns, discouraging the insects ...

Pulsatile blood flow unmasks new migraine features

2013-12-05
Pulsatile blood flow unmasks new migraine features With every heartbeat, the blood is sent to all our peripheral tissues, generating changes in pulsatile perfusion. Using these pulsatile changes as a source of information, researchers at the ...

Database tracks toxic side effects of pharmaceuticals

2013-12-05
Database tracks toxic side effects of pharmaceuticals Sometimes the cure can be worse than the disease. Pharmaceutical drugs are known for their potential side effects, and an important aspect of personalized medicine is to tailor therapies to individuals ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Apply for the Davie Postdoctoral Fellowship in Artificial Intelligence for Astronomy

New study finds students' attitudes towards computer science impacts final grades

Clot-buster meds & mechanical retrieval equally reduce disability from some strokes

ISHLT relaunches Global IMACS Registry to advance MCS therapy and patient outcomes

Childhood trauma may increase the risk of endometriosis

Black, Hispanic kids less likely to get migraine diagnosis in ER

Global social media engagement trends revealed for election year of 2024

Zoom fatigue is linked to dissatisfaction with one’s facial appearance

Students around the world find ChatGPT useful, but also express concerns

Labor market immigrants moving to Germany are less likely to make their first choice of residence in regions where xenophobic attitudes, measured by right-wing party support and xenophobic violence, a

Lots of screentime in toddlers is linked with worse language skills, but educational content and screen use accompanied by adults might help, per study across 19 Latin American countries

The early roots of carnival? Research reveals evidence of seasonal celebrations in pre-colonial Brazil

Meteorite discovery challenges long-held theories on Earth’s missing elements

Clean air policies having unintended impact driving up wetland methane emissions by up to 34 million tonnes

Scientists simulate asteroid collision effects on climate and plants

The Wistar Institute scientists discover new weapon to fight treatment-resistant melanoma

Fool yourself: People unknowingly cheat on tasks to feel smarter, healthier

Rapid increase in early-onset type 2 diabetes in China highlights urgent public health challenges

Researchers discover the brain cells that tell you to stop eating

Salt substitution and recurrent stroke and death

Firearm type and number of people killed in publicly targeted fatal mass shooting events

Recent drug overdose mortality decline compared with pre–COVID-19 trend

University of Cincinnati experts present research at International Stroke Conference 2025

Physicists measure a key aspect of superconductivity in “magic-angle” graphene

Study in India shows kids use different math skills at work vs. school

Quantum algorithm distributed across multiple processors for the first time – paving the way to quantum supercomputers

Why antibiotics can fail even against non-resistant bacteria

Missing link in Indo-European languages' history found

Cancer vaccine shows promise for patients with stage III and IV kidney cancer

Only seven out of 100 people worldwide receive effective treatment for their mental health or substance-use disorders

[Press-News.org] Geoengineering approaches to reduce climate change unlikely to succeed