PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Heads or tails? Random fluctuations in brain cell activity may determine toss-up decisions

2013-12-05
(Press-News.org) Contact information: Michael C. Purdy
purdym@wustl.edu
314-286-0122
Washington University School of Medicine
Heads or tails? Random fluctuations in brain cell activity may determine toss-up decisions

Life presents us with choices all the time: salad or pizza for lunch? Tea or coffee afterward? How we make these everyday decisions has been a topic of great interest to economists, who have devised theories about how we assign values to our options and use those values to make decisions.

An emerging field of study known as neuroeconomics is combining the economists' insights with scientific study of the brain to learn more about decision-making processes and how they can go awry. In the Dec. 8 issue of Neuron, one of the field's founders reports new links between brain cell activity and choices where two options have equal appeal.

"Neuroeconomics is not only helpful for the development of better economic theory, it is also relevant from a clinical point of view," said author Camillo Padoa-Schioppa, PhD, assistant professor of neurobiology, economics and of biomedical engineering at Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis. "There are a number of conditions that involve impaired economic decision-making, including drug addiction, brain injury, some forms of dementia, schizophrenia and obsessive-compulsive disorder."

Scientists know that the orbitofrontal cortex, a region of the brain behind and above the eyes, plays a key role in making decisions. Patients with injuries to this part of the brain are often spectacularly bad at making decisions. They may do things like abandon longstanding relationships, gamble away money or lose it to swindlers, or become addicted to drugs.

To study the roles brain cells play in decision-making, Padoa-Schioppa developed a system for presenting primates a choice between two drinks, such as grape juice or apple juice. The type and amount of the drink varies, and researchers record the activity of individual brain neurons as the primates choose.

Based on the decisions of a single animal over multiple trials, scientists infer the subjective value the animal assigns to each drink and then look for ways this value is encoded in brain cells.

"For example, if we offer a larger amount of apple juice versus a smaller amount of grape juice, and the primate chooses each option equally often, we infer that this primate likes the grape juice better than the apple juice," he explained. "The primate could be getting more juice by choosing the cup with apple juice, but it doesn't always do so. That implies that the primate values grape juice more than apple juice."

In 2006, Padoa-Schioppa and Harvard colleague John Assad, PhD, won international attention for using this system to identify brain cells whose firing rates encoded the subjective value of drink choices.

In a new analysis of data from the original experiment, Padoa-Schioppa showed that different groups of cells in the orbitofrontal cortex reflect different stages of the decision-making process.

"Some neurons encode the value of individual drinks; other neurons encode the choice outcome in a binary way ‒ these cells are either firing or silent depending on the chosen drink," he explained. "Yet other neurons encode the value of the chosen option."

Padoa-Schioppa then examined how different groups of cells determine decisions between options of equal value. He showed that toss-up decisions seemed to depend on changes in the initial state of the network of neurons in the orbitofrontal cortex.

"The fluctuations in the network took place before the primates were even offered a choice of juices, but they seem to somehow bias the decision," Padoa-Schioppa said. "Neuronal signals are always noisy. In essence, close-call decisions are partly determined by random noise."

He also found that decisions on choices of equal value were linked to the ease or difficulty with which nerve cells in parts of the orbitofrontal cortex communicate with each other. This property, known as synaptic efficacy, can be adjusted by the brain as part of the process of encoding information.

According to Padoa-Schioppa, these results provide new insights into the neuronal circuits that underlie economic decisions. He and his colleagues are using them to create a computational model of decision-making.

"The next step is to test that model," Padoa-Schioppa said. "For example, we would like to bias decisions by artificially manipulating the activity of specific groups of cells."



INFORMATION:

Funding from the National Institute on Mental Health (R03-MH093330) and the National Institute on Drug Addiction (R01-DA032758) supported this research.

Padoa-Schioppa C. Neuronal origins of choice variability in economic decisions. Neuron, December 8, 2013.

Washington University School of Medicine's 2,100 employed and volunteer faculty physicians also are the medical staff of Barnes-Jewish and St. Louis Children's hospitals. The School of Medicine is one of the leading medical research, teaching and patient care institutions in the nation, currently ranked sixth in the nation by U.S. News & World Report. Through its affiliations with Barnes-Jewish and St. Louis Children's hospitals, the School of Medicine is linked to BJC HealthCare.



ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

An ecosystem-based approach to protect the deep sea from mining

2013-12-05
An ecosystem-based approach to protect the deep sea from mining Five hundred miles southeast of Hawai'i, in international waters far out of sight of any land, there are vast mineral resources 5,000 meters below the sea. Manganese nodules, rich in commercially ...

New insights into how human skin attracts mosquitoes could lead to better repellants and traps

2013-12-05
New insights into how human skin attracts mosquitoes could lead to better repellants and traps Every time a mosquito is lured to the scent of your skin, you're at risk of contracting malaria, dengue fever, West Nile virus, or another deadly disease. A study published by ...

Gut bacteria linked to autism-related behavior in mice

2013-12-05
Gut bacteria linked to autism-related behavior in mice Mice whose mothers suffered from infection or inflammation during pregnancy are at greater risk for developing behaviors similar to those seen in people with autism spectrum disorders (ASD). Now, researchers reporting in ...

Those fruit flies are pickier than you think

2013-12-05
Those fruit flies are pickier than you think On your kitchen counter, it might seem as though fruit flies will show up for just about any type of fruit you leave around for them. But when given a choice about where to lay their eggs, those flies will go for citrus most ...

Scientists accelerate aging in stem cells to study age-related diseases like Parkinson's

2013-12-05
Scientists accelerate aging in stem cells to study age-related diseases like Parkinson's Stem cells hold promise for understanding and treating neurodegenerative diseases, but so far they have failed to accurately model disorders that occur late in life. A study published by ...

Electrical brain stimulation may evoke a person's 'will to persevere'

2013-12-05
Electrical brain stimulation may evoke a person's 'will to persevere' VIDEO: What gives some people the ability to persevere through difficult situations that others may find ...

Tracking exercise as vital sign associated with weight loss and better glucose control for patients

2013-12-05
Tracking exercise as vital sign associated with weight loss and better glucose control for patients Asking patients about their exercise habits was associated with weight loss in overweight patients and improved glucose control for patients with diabetes, according ...

How mosquitoes are drawn to human skin and breath

2013-12-05
How mosquitoes are drawn to human skin and breath UC Riverside researchers identify affordable, safe and pleasant-smelling compounds that can help control spread of mosquito-borne diseases RIVERSIDE, Calif. — Female mosquitoes, which can transmit deadly ...

New finding shows that mother sharks 'home' to their birthplace to give birth, like salmon and sea turtles

2013-12-05
New finding shows that mother sharks 'home' to their birthplace to give birth, like salmon and sea turtles Research suggests local shark conservation efforts by individual nations can have an impact Research conducted in Bimini in The ...

Laser light at useful wavelengths from semiconductor nanowires

2013-12-05
Laser light at useful wavelengths from semiconductor nanowires Nanowire lasers could work with silicon chips, optical fibers, even living cells Thread-like semiconductor structures called nanowires, so thin that they are effectively one-dimensional, ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

New study shows proactive forest management reduces high severity wildfire by 88% and stabilizes carbon during extreme droughts

Teen loneliness triggers ‘reward seeking’ behaviour

How fast mRNA degrades linked to autoimmune disease risk

What stiffening lung tissue reveals about the earliest stages of fibrosis

Kessler Foundation’s Trevor Dyson-Hudson, MD, honored with James J. Peters Distinguished Service Award from ASCIP

Tiny fish open new horizons for autism research.

How eye-less corals see the light

Storing breast milk for specific times of day could support babies’ circadian rhythm

Growing a new, pencil-shaped structure of gold named “quantum needles”

Transparent mesoporous WO₃ film enhances solar water splitting efficiency and stability

Protostellar jet detection in Milky Way’s outer region reveals universal star formation

New research uncovers a ‘ghost’ of the Australian bush

Study establishes link between rugby and dementia

Can courts safeguard fairness in an AI age?

Less than half of England has access to Mounjaro on the NHS months after roll-out

Study highlights cultural differences in parenting and reveals that how babies are soothed matters more than how fast

Claims on baby food fail to stack up

Potential molecular link between air pollutants and increased risk of Lewy body dementia revealed

Deaths from high blood pressure-related kidney disease up nearly 50% in the past 25 years

U.S. survey finds salt substitutes rarely used by people with high blood pressure

Researchers map key human proteins that power coronavirus replication, pointing to new treatment strategies

Single hair strand could provide biomarker for ALS, Mount Sinai study finds

Bio-oil made with corn stalks, wood debris could plug orphaned fossil fuel wells

Can the 'good' bacteria in your mouth act as probiotic cavity fighters?

This common fish has an uncommon feature: Forehead teeth, used for mating

UI Health performs first islet cell transplant with Lantidra

Study shows not all dietary proteins are digested the same way

MSU study finds accessible wireless ultrasounds are accurate

Scientists review breakthrough methods to disrupt toxic “forever chemicals” in water

Ghost sharks grow forehead teeth to help them have sex

[Press-News.org] Heads or tails? Random fluctuations in brain cell activity may determine toss-up decisions