PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Marketing loans for fertility treatments raises ethical concerns

What some doctors call a 'win-win situation' may 'encourage interventions that hold little chance at success, exacerbating the anguish of infertility,' says new commentary

2013-12-10
(Press-News.org) Contact information: Susan Gilbert
gilberts@thehastingscenter.org
845-424-4040 x244
The Hastings Center
Marketing loans for fertility treatments raises ethical concerns What some doctors call a 'win-win situation' may 'encourage interventions that hold little chance at success, exacerbating the anguish of infertility,' says new commentary An increase in the number of lenders specializing in loans for fertility treatments enables more people to afford the treatments, but it also raises ethical concerns, concludes a commentary in the Hastings Center Report. Among the concerns, doctors are marketing the loans to their patients, and some of these doctors have financial ties to specific lenders. The commentary calls for assessment and oversight of the practice.

The emergence of "fertility loans" is a response to the high cost of many fertility procedures, including in vitro fertilization and the use of donor gametes. Cost is the main obstacle to obtaining assisted reproduction in the United States, according to the commentary, because many patients have insufficient, if any, insurance coverage.

"In facilitating the process to obtain credit and, in some instances, benefiting financially through equity ownership in private lending firms, participating physicians declare this a 'win-win situation' with no clear conflict of interest," writes the author, Alisa Von Hagel, an assistant professor of political science at the University of Wisconsin-Superior. But she disputes this view.

While taking out loans to help pay for medical procedures is not uncommon in the United States, Von Hagel writes that "given the emotional and psychological vulnerability of patients seeking fertility treatments, it has unique implications for this population."

There is no law or regulation that assures that patients receive complete information about their financing, and physicians and clinics are not required to disclose their financial ties to lenders. "For individuals or couples willing to do whatever it takes to produce a child, the availability and promotion of these loans may encourage interventions that hold little chance at success, exacerbating the anguish of infertility," writes Von Hagel. "The question thus arises whether this better serves to enhance the reproductive autonomy of patients or the profit margins of fertility clinics and physicians."

Aside from the risk to patient care, Von Hagel says that marketing fertility loans poses ethical risks to the medical profession, potentially weakening patients' trust in fertility specialists. "Failing to evaluate and respond to the ethical concerns created by the loans may lead to a decline in the public's estimation of this medical field, particularly if apparent abuses of patient trust emerge," she writes.

Von Hagel says that the consequences of doctors marketing fertility loans are unknown, but she recommends that a board such as the Ethics Committee of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine review the practice and the financial ties between doctors and lenders. "Assessment and oversight of this practice need not be an overtly paternalistic effort to deprive patients of decision-making authority," she concludes. "Rather, it should contain an honest evaluation of the loans and their genuine benefit."

INFORMATION:



ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Better guidelines, coordination needed for prostate cancer specialists

2013-12-10
Better guidelines, coordination needed for prostate cancer specialists UC Davis experts cite new drug therapies as rationale for improvements (SACRAMENTO, Calif.) — With a deluge of promising new drug treatments for advanced ...

How a concussion can lead to depression years later

2013-12-10
How a concussion can lead to depression years later After brain injury, cells on 'high alert' prolong immune response, affecting behavior COLUMBUS, Ohio – A head injury can lead immune-system brain cells to go on "high alert" and overreact to later immune ...

Home teams hold the advantage

2013-12-10
Home teams hold the advantage EAST LANSING, Mich. — The home team holds the advantage over visitors – at least in the plant world. However, a mere handful of genetic adaptations could even the playing field. In the current issue of the Proceedings ...

A personal antidepressant for every genome

2013-12-10
A personal antidepressant for every genome Tel Aviv University researchers discover gene that may predict human responses to specific antidepressants Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) are the most commonly prescribed antidepressants, but ...

Kids movies send mixed messages about eating habits and obesity

2013-12-10
Kids movies send mixed messages about eating habits and obesity CHAPEL HILL, N.C. – In a world where animals often take the place of humans, sugar-sweetened beverages, exaggerated portion sizes and unhealthy snacks are common. So is TV watching, ...

Study offers economical solutions for maintaining critical delta environments

2013-12-10
Study offers economical solutions for maintaining critical delta environments Millions of people across the world live or depend on deltas for their livelihoods. Formed at the lowest part of a river where its water flow slows and spreads into ...

Hidden details revealed in nearby starburst galaxy

2013-12-10
Hidden details revealed in nearby starburst galaxy Green Bank Telescope's new vision debuts Using the new, high-frequency capabilities of the National Science Foundation's Robert C. Byrd Green Bank Telescope (GBT), astronomers have captured never-before-seen ...

Awkward Facebook encounters

2013-12-10
Awkward Facebook encounters Embarrassing Facebook posts cause certain people more anguish than others EVANSTON, Ill. --- A friend posts a picture on Facebook that shows you picking food out of your teeth. Awkward! Such Facebook faux pas are common. But depending ...

CU-Boulder scientist: 2012 solar storm points up need for society to prepare

2013-12-10
CU-Boulder scientist: 2012 solar storm points up need for society to prepare A massive ejection of material from the sun initially traveling at over 7 million miles per hour that narrowly missed Earth last year is an event solar scientists ...

NASA eyes Tropical Cyclone Madi's rainfall

2013-12-10
NASA eyes Tropical Cyclone Madi's rainfall Tropical Cyclone Madi is headed for a landfall in southeastern India, and NASA and the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency's TRMM satellite found that rainfall was heaviest north of the storm's center. The Tropical Rainfall ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Unlocking the brain’s hidden drainage system

Enhancing smoking cessation treatment for people living with HIV

Research spotlight: Mapping how gut neurons respond to bacteria, parasites and food allergy

Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation Experimental Physics Investigators awards to UCSB experimentalists opens the door to new insights and innovations

Meerkats get health benefit from mob membership

COVID-19 during pregnancy linked to higher risk of neurodevelopmental disorders in children

How a chorus of synchronized frequencies helps you digest your food

UAlbany researcher partners on $1.2 million NSF grant to explore tropical monsoon rainfall patterns

Checkup time for Fido? Wait might be longer in the country

Genetic variation impact scores: A new tool for earlier heart disease detection

The Lundquist Institute awarded $9 million to launch Community Center of Excellence for Regenerative Medicine

'Really bizarre and exciting': The quantum oscillations are coming from inside

Is AI becoming selfish?

New molten salt method gives old lithium batteries a second life

Leg, foot amputations increased 65% in Illinois hospitals between 2016-2023

Moffitt studies uncover complementary strategies to overcome resistance to KRAS G12Cinhibitors in lung cancer

National summit of experts charts unprecedented roadmap to reduce harms from firearms in new ways

Global environmental DNA (eDNA) surveys significantly expand known geographic and ecological niche ranges of marine fish, highlighting current biases in conservation and ecological modeling

Hundreds of animal studies on brain damage after stroke flagged for problematic images

Prize winner’s research reveals how complex neural circuits are correctly wired during brain development

Supershear rupture sustained in thick fault zone during 2025 Mandalay earthquake, study in research package shows

Study reveals how brain cell networks stabilize memory formation

CTE: More than just head trauma, suggests new study

New psychology study suggests chimpanzees might be rational thinkers

Study links genetic variants to higher 'bad' cholesterol and heart attack risk

Myanmar fault had ideal geometry to produce 2025 supershear earthquake

Breakthrough in BRCA2 research: a novel mechanism behind chemoresistance discovered

New funding for health economics research on substance use disorder treatments

Tying protein to fraying DNA solves mystery of illness for patients around the world

MD Anderson shares latest research breakthroughs

[Press-News.org] Marketing loans for fertility treatments raises ethical concerns
What some doctors call a 'win-win situation' may 'encourage interventions that hold little chance at success, exacerbating the anguish of infertility,' says new commentary