(Press-News.org) Contact information: Inga Kiderra
ikiderra@ucsd.edu
858-822-0661
University of California - San Diego
When a doctor's visit is a guilt trip
UC San Diego study examines patient reactions to physician-inspired guilt and shame
Have you ever left a doctor's office feeling ashamed or guilty? Chances are one in two that you answered "yes," according to research from the University of California, San Diego. And what happened next? Perhaps you were motivated to make changes in an unhealthy behavior. Or, did you just lie to that doctor on subsequent visits? Avoid him or her? Maybe even terminate treatment entirely?
Shame and guilt as a direct result of interacting with a doctor are quite common, says Christine Harris, professor of psychology in the UC San Diego Division of Social Sciences, as are both positive and negative reactions. But surprisingly little research has been done on the subject. Now, in a pair of new studies, Harris and colleagues examine the consequences of these physician-inspired feelings. They also explore why some patients react to the shame- or guilt-provoking experience in a way that promotes health while others turn to lying or avoidance.
Gaining insight into patient reactions is important, the co-authors write, because "more than one third of all deaths in the United States are still essentially preventable and largely due to unhealthy patient behavior."
Published in the journal of Basic and Applied Social Psychology, the current paper follows up on Harris' 2009 work showing that more than 50 percent of respondents had experienced shame based on something a physician said. The earlier work also documented the diversity of reactions.
In the current paper, Harris and her co-authors – recent UC San Diego psychology Ph.D. graduate Ryan Darby and current doctoral student Nicole Henniger – ran two related studies: One surveyed and analyzed the responses of 491 UC San Diego undergraduates about shame when interacting with a doctor. The second looked at both guilt and shame and included 417 participants from a wide-range of socioeconomic backgrounds, aged 18 to 75.
In the younger cohort, nearly a quarter of participants had experienced a shaming encounter with a physician. In the mixed-age group, roughly half had, Harris said.
In both studied groups, weight and sex were the most frequently cited shaming topics. Teeth came up frequently with the younger subjects as well. (Possible topics also included smoking, alcohol or substance use, not taking prescribed medications or following doctor's orders, and mental health, among others.)
Family practice doctors, gynecologists and dentists were the specialties most often cited as shaming. This is probably because, Harris said, people generally see these types of physicians more than any others.
As in the 2009 work, the emotional and behavioral reactions to the shaming experience varied widely: from making a profound lifestyle change to improve health to, on the opposite extreme, just avoiding all doctors altogether.
What matters most and seems to make the greatest difference, Harris said, is whether the patient "makes a global attribution, condemning the entire self" or just condemns the behavior at hand. Focusing on the behavior leads more often to good outcomes.
"People who report a more positive reaction focus in on a bad act not a bad self," Harris said. "Capacity to change mediates the response. In the simplest terms: Those who say 'I'm a smoker' or 'I'm a fat person' may feel resigned while those who say 'I smoke' or 'I eat too much' also seem to think 'I can stop doing that.'"
Also significant, the researchers find, is the patient's perception of the doctor's intent.
"If you perceive your doctor is intentionally trying to make you feel shame or guilt, then the reaction is exclusively negative," Harris said. "We didn't see any positive reactions at all."
There were differences by gender, too: Women reported experiencing shame and guilt during doctors' visits more often than men did. They also reported more negative reactions. But, interestingly, this doesn't seem to be because women are making more global attributions.
The reason for the gender difference remains an open research question, Harris said. It could be that doctors treat men and women differently. Or it could be that women hear the signal more strongly or have differing perceptions of the interaction.
In the meanwhile, Harris said, doctors will continue to have the unenviable task of discussing delicate subjects with their patients and with making recommendations about unhealthy behaviors, and what is clear is this: "Tough love and shaming don't always work. In fact, they can be counter-productive."
"To improve outcomes," Harris said, "doctors need to try to keep the conversation focused on the behavior (not the person) and avoid, as much as possible, being perceived as intentionally inflicting shame or guilt."
As for patients, the best advice she can give is: "Think not of what you are but what you can do."
INFORMATION:
When a doctor's visit is a guilt trip
UC San Diego study examines patient reactions to physician-inspired guilt and shame
2014-01-16
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Does taking multiple medicines increase your risk of being admitted to hospital?
2014-01-16
Does taking multiple medicines increase your risk of being admitted to hospital?
Patients with a single illness who take many drugs have an increased risk of being admitted to hospital, but for patients with multiple conditions, taking many medicines is now associated with ...
How much does it cost to have a baby in a hospital?
2014-01-16
How much does it cost to have a baby in a hospital?
UCSF study examines charges for uncomplicated deliveries
Women giving birth in California can face a huge cost difference in their hospital bills, according to a new UC San Francisco ...
In the blink of an eye
2014-01-16
In the blink of an eye
CAMBRIDGE, MA -- Imagine seeing a dozen pictures flash by in a fraction of a second. You might think it would be impossible to identify any images you see for such a short time. However, a team of neuroscientists from MIT has found ...
More than meets the eye
2014-01-15
More than meets the eye
Researchers at UCSB and University of Bristol have found that when it comes to vision, the brain can perform more than one function without sacrificing time or accuracy
Many studies suggest that pushing your brain ...
Loyola study provides guidance on drug holidays from popular osteoporosis treatments
2014-01-15
Loyola study provides guidance on drug holidays from popular osteoporosis treatments
Doctors commonly recommend drug holidays, or breaks, from certain osteoporosis drugs due to the risks associated with these treatments. Yet little has been known about the ...
Joslin finds metabolic clues to diabetic kidney failure
2014-01-15
Joslin finds metabolic clues to diabetic kidney failure
Metabolomics study examines factors that may lead to end stage renal disease
BOSTON - January 15, 2013 - About 33 percent of people with type 2 diabetes suffer kidney damage that progresses to end stage renal ...
Self-control isn't in short supply (despite what it looks like)
2014-01-15
Self-control isn't in short supply (despite what it looks like)
It might be true that people have a harder time controlling themselves when they are tired at the end of the day, but that doesn't mean that self-control is a limited resource, say authors in the Cell Press publication ...
Alaskan caribou and ptarmigan migrations recorded
2014-01-15
Alaskan caribou and ptarmigan migrations recorded
Automated cameras document northern spring movement of species across tundra
In the February issue of BioScience, biologists describe the first-of-a-kind recording of caribou and ptarmigan migrations made ...
First planet found around solar twin in star cluster
2014-01-15
First planet found around solar twin in star cluster
6-year search with HARPS finds three new planets in Messier 67
Astronomers have used ESO's HARPS planet hunter in Chile, along with other telescopes around the world, to discover three planets orbiting stars in the cluster Messier 67. ...
The internal clock and feeding rhythm set the pace of the liver
2014-01-15
The internal clock and feeding rhythm set the pace of the liver
Living organisms have adapted to the day-night cycle and, in most cases, they have evolved a "circadian clock". Its effects are not completely known yet but its functioning has been ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
The Lancet: Tens of thousands of children aged under five suffering acute malnutrition in Gaza, recent estimates suggest
Prostate testing may not target those most likely to benefit, warn experts
Global analysis shows hidden damage from men’s alcohol use
DRI recognizes Ashley Cornish as the 2025 Peter B. Wagner Memorial Award Winner for Women in Atmospheric Sciences
Unlocking the blueprint for a powerful plant-based drug
Bringing modern science to vitamin biology: Isha Jain wins NIH Transformative Research Award
University of Houston scientists learn that rare bacterium ‘plays dead’ to survive
Introduced animals change how island plants spread, new global study finds
Mayo Clinic researchers discover ‘traffic controller’ protein that protects DNA, and may help kill cancer cells
Protein sidekick exhibits dual roles in stress granule assembly and disassembly
New hope for MS
Kennesaw State professor receives grant to study cancer origins
Pain and antidepressant drug combo linked to increased seizure risk in older adults
Cancer researchers shape new strategies for immunotherapy
Physical exercise can ‘train’ the immune system
Calm red brocket deer can learn to "Come" and other commands - but the flightiest, most restless individuals struggle
China, the world's largest tea producer, is predicted to experience increases in land suitable for tea-growing under climate change, with the overall range shifting northwards, per AI modeling study
Composing crews for Mars missions
Early humans butchered elephants using small tools and made big tools from their bones
1,000-year-old gut microbiome revealed for young man who lived in pre-Hispanic Mexico
Bears and pandas in captivity develop significantly different gut microbiomes compared to their wild counterparts, and giant pandas in particular have less diverse microbiomes than their wild counterp
Prenatal and postnatal support apps might not work
Dancing dust devils trace raging winds on Mars
Raging winds on Mars
Real-time biopsies uncover hidden response to glioblastoma therapy
Repeated brain tumor sampling uncovers treatment response in patients with glioblastoma
Novel immunotherapy combination destroys colorectal liver metastases
Farmed totoaba could curb poaching
Avalanches: user-carried safety device increases survival time fivefold
It’s all in your head: Select neurons in the brainstem may hold the key to treating chronic pain
[Press-News.org] When a doctor's visit is a guilt tripUC San Diego study examines patient reactions to physician-inspired guilt and shame