PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Nothing to declare: Researchers find disclosure leads to avoiding conflicts of interest

2014-01-22
(Press-News.org) Contact information: Shilo Rea
shilo@cmu.edu
412-268-6094
Carnegie Mellon University
Nothing to declare: Researchers find disclosure leads to avoiding conflicts of interest PITTSBURGH—Professionals, such as doctors, lawyers and financial advisers, face conflicts of interest (COIs) when they have a personal, and often financial, interest in giving biased advice. Therefore, requiring COI disclosure has become a popular way to try and protect consumers from biased advice, but previous research has shown that mandatory disclosures have little impact on advice recipients, and may even lead advisers to give more biased advice. However, virtually all of the prior studies questioned the effectiveness of COI disclosures that advisers were unable to avoid.

New research from Carnegie Mellon University's George Loewenstein and Georgetown University's Sunita Sah examines situations in which advisers have the ability to not have any COIs — such as doctors who can decide whether to meet with and accept gifts from pharmaceutical companies. Published in Psychological Science, Loewenstein and Sah found that when COIs can be avoided, disclosure successfully deters advisers from accepting COIs so that they have nothing to disclose except the absence of conflicts.

"Prior research has cast doubt as to the effectiveness of disclosure for managing conflicts of interest, particularly when consumers have the burden of interpreting and reacting to the information," said Sah, lead author of the study and assistant professor of strategy, economics, ethics and public policy at Georgetown. "Our findings suggest that disclosure can become a successful intervention to managing some conflicts of interest if it motivates professionals or providers to avoid such conflicts. Stating that you have no conflicts of interest or 'nothing to declare' can be a signal of quality or integrity to regulators and consumers, which could be viewed as a competitive advantage. The ability for disclosure to change the behavior of providers in a positive way is also advantageous as it avoids relying on consumers to make use of disclosure information."

For the study, the researchers conducted three experiments to determine how COIs influence advisers. In the first experiment, 97 adviser–advisee pairs participated in an online game with Amazon.com gift cards at stake. Advisers advised the advisees on the number of filled dots on a grid. Estimators were paid based on their accuracy, but advisers had a conflict; they were paid more if advisees gave an estimate that was higher than the true value. The set up — with advisees only seeing a small subset of the complete grid — was designed to simulate a situation in which a consumer receives advice from a better informed, but conflicted professional. The results replicated previous research and showed that disclosure led advisers to give higher (and more biased) recommendations than nondisclosure.

In the second experiment, the researchers again randomly assigned pairs of advisees and conflicted advisers to conditions in which the conflict was either disclosed or not disclosed. There was, however, an important change from the first study: advisers were given a choice of whether to accept or reject the COI. Without disclosure, a majority of advisers (63 percent) chose the incentives that created a COI, but with disclosure a minority (33 percent) accepted the conflict. Advice was higher (and more biased) for those who chose conflicted incentives than for those who did not, and advisers in the disclosure condition gave significantly less biased advice than those in the nondisclosure condition. When advisers could eschew a conflict therefore, disclosure encouraged them to do so.

Finally, in a study with 248 participants, the researchers added a third condition to the second experiment: voluntary disclosure. In this third condition advisers decided both whether to choose incentives that entailed a conflict and whether to disclose whether they were conflicted. Similar to mandatory disclosure, voluntary disclosure led advisers to avoid COIs, and then disclosed their freedom from conflicts to advisees.

"Disclosure doesn't seem to be much good when conflicts are unavoidable, but it does seem to help when advisers have a choice about whether to subject themselves to conflicts," said Loewenstein, the Herbert A. Simon University Professor of Economics and Psychology in the Dietrich College of Humanities and Social Sciences. "A nice feature of disclosure is that it is, in effect, 'self-calibrating.' Doctors, for example, are unlikely to find it worth it to accept small gifts such as pens or calendars if the gifts are going to be disclosed. Although larger gifts would be more tempting, doctors are likely to be deterred from accepting them because disclosure of large gifts would be more damaging to their reputations."

### END


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Tropical cyclone lingling wraps up in Northwestern Pacific

2014-01-22
Tropical cyclone lingling wraps up in Northwestern Pacific After dropping rainfall that brought a number of casualties to the central and southern Philippines, the tropical cyclone known as Lingling, and locally as Agaton in the Philippines has finally wound down. The ...

High-protein diets, like the Dukan diet, increase the risk of developing kidney disease

2014-01-22
High-protein diets, like the Dukan diet, increase the risk of developing kidney disease An experiment by scientists at the University of Granada, Spain, shows a high-protein diet increases the chance of developing kidney stones and other renal diseases ...

E-whiskers

2014-01-22
E-whiskers Berkeley researchers develop highly sensitive tactile sensors for robotics and other applications From the world of nanotechnology we've gotten electronic skin, or e-skin, and electronic eye implants or e-eyes. Now we're on the verge of electronic ...

'Love hormone' oxytocin carries unexpected side effect

2014-01-22
'Love hormone' oxytocin carries unexpected side effect New Concordia University study shows an increase in emotional oversensitivity among off-label users This news release is available in French. Montreal, January 21, 2014 — The love hormone, the monogamy ...

Study: Possible new druggable target in Ewing's Sarcoma

2014-01-22
Study: Possible new druggable target in Ewing's Sarcoma Ewing's Sarcoma is an aggressive pediatric cancer, most commonly caused by the improper fusion of the gene EWS with the gene FLI1. Though the cause has long been known, therapeutic targeting of this fusion ...

Study finds 66 children a day treated in emergency departments for shopping cart-related injuries

2014-01-22
Study finds 66 children a day treated in emergency departments for shopping cart-related injuries Researchers call for cart design changes and tougher safety standards Although a voluntary shopping cart safety standard was implemented ...

Salamanders help predict health of forest ecosystems and inform forest management

2014-01-22
Salamanders help predict health of forest ecosystems and inform forest management Researchers suggest a balance between timber harvest and conservation biology COLUMBIA, Mo. – Woodland salamanders are small, lungless amphibians that live in moist, forest ...

Guys: Get married for the sake of your bones, but wait until you're 25

2014-01-22
Guys: Get married for the sake of your bones, but wait until you're 25 UCLA study also shows women with supportive partners have stronger bones Marriage is good for the health of men's bones - but only if they marry when they're ...

Research backs more strategies for children with autism

2014-01-22
Research backs more strategies for children with autism FPG scientists screened 29,000 articles to locate evidence-based interventions only The National Professional Development Center on Autism Spectrum Disorders has released its much-anticipated update ...

Researchers model macroscale plasmonic convection to control fluid and particle motion

2014-01-22
Researchers model macroscale plasmonic convection to control fluid and particle motion Researchers at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign have developed a new theoretical model that explains macroscale fluid convection ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

New strategies to enhance chiral optical signals unveiled

Cambridge research uncovers powerful virtual reality treatment for speech anxiety

2025 Gut Microbiota for Health World Summit to spotlight groundbreaking research

International survey finds that support for climate interventions is tied to being hopeful and worried about climate change

Cambridge scientist launches free VR platform that eliminates the fear of public speaking

Open-Source AI matches top proprietary model in solving tough medical cases

Good fences make good neighbors (with carnivores)

NRG Oncology trial supports radiotherapy alone following radical hysterectomy should remain the standard of care for early-stage, intermediate-risk cervical cancer

Introducing our new cohort of AGA Future Leaders

Sharks are dying at alarming rates, mostly due to fishing. Retention bans may help

Engineering excellence: Engineers with ONR ties elected to renowned scientific academy

New CRISPR-based diagnostic test detects pathogens in blood without amplification

Immunotherapy may boost KRAS-targeted therapy in pancreatic cancer

Growing solar: Optimizing agrivoltaic systems for crops and clean energy

Scientists discover how to reactivate cancer’s molecular “kill switch”

YouTube influencers: gaming’s best friend or worst enemy?

uOttawa scientists use light to unlock secret of atoms

NJIT mathematician to help map Earth's last frontier with Navy grant

NASA atmospheric wave-studying mission releases data from first 3,000 orbits

‘Microlightning’ in water droplets may have sparked life on Earth

Smoke from wildland-urban interface fires more deadly than remote wildfires

What’s your body really worth? New AI model reveals your true biological age from 5 drops of blood

Protein accidentally lassos itself, helping explain unusual refolding behavior

With bird flu in raw milk, many in U.S. still do not know risks of consuming it

University of Minnesota research team awarded $3.8 million grant to develop cell therapy to combat Alzheimer’s disease

UConn uncovers new clue on what is leading to neurodegenerative diseases like Alzheimer’s and ALS

Resuscitation in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest – it’s how quickly it is done, rather than who does it

A closer look at biomolecular ‘silly putty’

Oxytocin system of breastfeeding affected in mothers with postnatal depression

Liquid metal-enabled synergetic cooling and charging: a leap forward for electric vehicles

[Press-News.org] Nothing to declare: Researchers find disclosure leads to avoiding conflicts of interest