(Press-News.org) A new criminal offence of "wilful neglect" is needed for individuals and organisations in the healthcare sector, to send out a clear message that appalling care warrants public censure and sanction, say leading lawyers in the journal BMJ Quality & Safety.
Existing regulation is not up to the job, argue Professors Karen Yeung of The Dickson Poon School of Law, King's College London, and Jeremy Horder of the Department of Law at the London School of Economics.
Many patients are just as vulnerable as those who are mentally incapacitated, they point out, yet they do not enjoy the same protection against wilful neglect or ill treatment in criminal law. This must be changed, they say.
In his far reaching report into the failings of care at Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust, published a year ago, Robert Francis QC recommended legal sanctions for breaches of "fundamental standards" of care.
The recommendation was taken up and further refined in the subsequent Berwick Report into the safety of the NHS, published last summer.
The authors looked at the key tasks for criminal law to perform in the context of healthcare provision and whether these were covered by existing legislation. They then considered whether it would be fair and just to introduce a new criminal offence to support compliance with regulatory standards.
Patients can seek redress through the civil courts, but civil liability has a limited role, not least because it is essentially regarded as a private matter without public interest criteria, say the authors.
Tere are several existing criminal offences which could be applied to healthcare provision, including manslaughter by gross negligence. But this is normally applied to individuals or small companies, and would be inappropriate for the management of a hospital, regional authority, or clinical commissioning group, they argue.
Similarly, there are criminal offences under existing legislation that could be invoked for causing the death of patients, but these are unlikely to cover wilful neglect, ill treatment, catastrophic management failure or uncaring attitudes that do not result in death, they emphasise.
Robert Francis suggested that a line be drawn between "serious harm" worthy of a criminal offence and lesser harms that would not be criminalised. But, say the authors, this would be difficult, in practice, because there is no legal definition of "serious" harm.
A preferable approach, they suggest, is to focus on the element of fault—the wilful neglect or ill treatment involved in the conduct. This avoids criminalising understandable or momentary errors or lapses, but includes behaviours such as persistent verbal abuse, or discharging patients before they are well enough.
The offence, which would be more likely committed through a "couldn't care less attitude" should be eligible to be tried in either the Magistrates' or Crown Court, and attract a maximum prison sentence of 2 years or an unlimited fine in the case of an organisation, they say.
The purpose of the new law wouldn't be to foster a punitive approach to the promotion of quality care, but to act as a backstop against the worst excesses, they insist.
"The criminal law's role in this context is not to play a frontline part in deterring and coercing people into complying with proper standards of behaviour," they write. "Rather, its central function applies only to the worst kinds of unacceptable ill treatment."
As such, criminal law has a uniquely symbolic significance that less draconian regulations and civil liability do not, they say.
It is "the most powerful and important social institution through which we hold to account, and express public censure of, those who have mistreated others in a wholly unacceptable and highly culpable way," they conclude.
INFORMATION:
[How can the criminal law support the provision of quality in healthcare? Online First doi 10.1136/bmjqs-2013-002688]
New 'willful neglect' offense needed for healthcare sector, say lawyers
Would send out strong message that appalling care warrants public censure and sanction and fill gap in existing regulation
2014-03-06
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
New terms used for trainee doctors stump nurses and patients
2014-03-06
Nurses and patients are struggling to identify qualified doctors or to grade their seniority from their generic name badges, finds a survey of one hospital in England, published online in BMJ Quality & Safety.
The findings prompt the researchers to call for a review of currently used terminology, deployed since the Modernisation of Medical Careers initiative in 2009, which revamped the length of training and introduced a range of new job titles.
Staff and patients must be able to correctly identify professional status and communicate effectively, if optimal care is ...
Long-lasting device protects against HIV and pregnancy
2014-03-06
EVANSTON, Ill. --- Women's reproductive health may never be the same, thanks to Northwestern University biomedical engineer Patrick Kiser and his first-of-its-kind intravaginal ring that reliably delivers an antiretroviral drug and a contraceptive for months.
Kiser's one ring delivers two drugs that do three important things: the device is designed to protect against HIV and herpes as well as unwanted pregnancy. It will be the first device with the potential to offer this protection to be tested in women.
The easy-to-use ring delivers controlled doses of tenofovir (a ...
Gene therapy locks out HIV, paving the way to control virus without antiretroviral drug
2014-03-06
PHILADELPHIA—University of Pennsylvania researchers have successfully genetically engineered the immune cells of 12 HIV positive patients to resist infection, and decreased the viral loads of some patients taken off antiretroviral drug therapy (ADT) entirely—including one patient whose levels became undetectable. The study, appearing today in the New England Journal of Medicine, is the first published report of any gene editing approach in humans.
The phase I study was co-authored by researchers at Penn Medicine, the Albert Einstein College of Medicine and scientists ...
Human activity influences beach bacterial diversity
2014-03-06
Human activity influences ocean beach bacterial communities, and bacterial diversity may indicate greater ecological health and resiliency to sewage contamination, according to results published March 5, 2014, in the open access journal PLOS ONE by Elizabeth Halliday from Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution and colleagues.
Beaches all contain bacteria, but some bacteria are usually from sewage and may contaminate the water, posing a public health risk. In this study, scientists studied bacterial community composition at two distant beaches (Avalon, California, and Provincetown, ...
New dinosaur found in Portugal, largest terrestrial predator from Europe
2014-03-06
A new dinosaur species found in Portugal may be the largest land predator discovered in Europe, as well as one of the largest carnivorous dinosaurs from the Jurassic, according to a paper published in PLOS ONE on March 5, 2014 by co-authors Christophe Hendrickx and Octavio Mateus from Universidade Nova de Lisboa and Museu da Lourinhã.
Scientists discovered bones belonging to this dinosaur north of Lisbon. They were originally believed to be Torvosaurus tanneri, a dinosaur species from North America. Closer comparison of the shin bone, upper jawbone, teeth, and partial ...
Younger men benefit most from surgery for localized prostate cancer
2014-03-06
Boston, MA -- More than 230,000 men will be diagnosed with prostate cancer this year in the United States, but determining their course of treatment remains a source of considerable debate. A new study by researchers from Uppsala University Hospital, Sweden, Harvard School of Public Health (HSPH) and colleagues—which draws from one of the few randomized trials conducted to directly address this issue—finds a substantial long-term reduction in mortality for men with localized cancer who undergo a radical prostatectomy. While the benefit on mortality appears to be limited ...
Genetic cause found for premature ovarian failure
2014-03-06
The results, published in The New England Journal of Medicine and Human and Molecular Genetics journals, demonstrate for the first time that mutation in STAG3 gene is the major cause of human fertility disorders as it provokes a loss of function of the protein it encodes.
STAG3 encodes a meiosis-specific subunit of the cohesin ring, the biological process through which, from a diploid somatic cell, a haploid cell or gamete is produced. Cohesins are protein complexes that bind two straps of DNA and are implicated in its repair, replication and recombination, as well as ...
South Pacific Island's earliest inhabitants relied primarily on foraging, not horticulture
2014-03-06
Early Lapita inhabitants of Vanuatu, a South Pacific Island, ate fish, marine turtles, and wild or domestic animals, rather than relying on horticulture during early colonization, according to a study published March 5, 2014, in the open-access journal PLOS ONE by Rebecca Kinaston from University of Otago in New Zealand and colleagues.
Around 3000 BP, human populations with cultural and biological links to South East Asian islands, a culture or people known as Lapita, sailed to Remote Oceania (islands of the tropical Pacific Ocean) with domestic plants and animals, a ...
New guidance for preventative action against diabetes
2014-03-06
A team of academics from the University of Leicester has been instrumental in shaping National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) guidance that will influence medical policy towards diabetes prevention nationwide.
NICE's recommendations in the form of a local government briefing, which have been developed with advice from NICE's Local Government Reference Group using feedback from council officers, councillors and directors of public health, encourage local authorities and partner organisations to use body mass index (BMI) as a signal for preventive action ...
Penn team finds a new structure in dogs' eye linked to blinding retinal diseases
2014-03-06
In humans, a tiny area in the center of the retina called the fovea is critically important to viewing fine details. Densely packed with cone photoreceptor cells, it is used while reading, driving and gazing at objects of interest. Some animals have a similar feature in their eyes, but researchers believed that among mammals the fovea was unique to primates — until now.
University of Pennsylvania vision scientists report that dogs, too, have an area of their retina that strongly resembles the human fovea. What's more, this retinal region is susceptible to genetic blinding ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Immunotherapy after surgery shows promise in treating rare, aggressive skin cancer
Immunotherapy after surgery shows potential in preventing the spread of aggressive skin cancer
What is the extent of disparities in cancer clinical trials among low- and middle-income countries?
Invisible poison: Airborne mercury from gold mining is contaminating African food crops, new study warns
Nearly half of Finns with chronic conditions find medication therapy a burden
Do animals fall for optical illusions? What fish and birds can teach us about perception
New guideline emphasizes conversations about mood, mental health between patients and clinicians
Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia researchers observe significant reduction in diagnosis of food allergies following expert guidelines encouraging early peanut exposure
ESMO 2025: VT3989 continues to show promising early results in patients with advanced mesothelioma
Study finds COVID-19 mRNA vaccine sparks immune response to fight cancer
ESMO 2025: mRNA-based COVID vaccines generate improved responses to immunotherapy
Drug combo cuts risk of death in advanced prostate cancer by 40%
ADC improves outcomes for patients with advanced triple-negative breast cancer who are ineligible for immune checkpoint inhibitors
Novel treatment combination improves progression-free survival in metastatic, estrogen-receptor-positive HER-2-negative breast cancer
ESMO 2025: Trial results show belzutifan shrinks rare neuroendocrine tumors and improves symptoms in patients
ESMO 2025: Dual targeted therapy shows promise in previously treated advanced kidney cancer patients
New generation of Antibody-Drug Conjugates (ADCs) shows unprecedented promise in early-stage disease
Sylvester Cancer Tip Sheet for October 2025
Three science and technology leaders elected to Hertz Foundation Board of Directors
Jump Trading CSO Kevin Bowers elected to Hertz Foundation Board of Directors
Former Inscripta CEO Sri Kosaraju elected to Hertz Foundation Board of Directors
Citadel’s Jordan Chetty elected to Hertz Foundation Board of Directors
McGill research flags Montreal snow dump, inactive landfills as major methane polluters
A lightweight and rapid bidirectional search algorithm
Eighty-five years of big tree history available in one place for the first time
MIT invents human brain model with six major cell types to enable personalized disease research, drug discovery
Health and economic air quality co-benefits of stringent climate policies
How immune cells deliver their deadly cargo
How the brain becomes a better listener: How focus enhances sound processing
Processed fats found in margarines unlikely to affect heart health
[Press-News.org] New 'willful neglect' offense needed for healthcare sector, say lawyersWould send out strong message that appalling care warrants public censure and sanction and fill gap in existing regulation