AIBS analysis of peer review offers insights into research productivity

Ultimate citation impact correlates with peer review scores but not award amount

2014-09-04

(Press-News.org) RESTON, VA – In a paper published today in the journal PLOS One, investigators with the American Institute of Biological Sciences report findings from an analysis of the research output from a series of biomedical research grants funded after undergoing a scientific peer review process. The results, reported in 'The Validation of Peer Review Through Research Impact Measures and the Implications for Funding Strategies,' offer insights for future research on peer review and potential models for increasing research productivity.

"Some form of peer review is used at the majority of research funding organizations to determine the best research to fund," said Dr. Joseph Travis, President of AIBS and a biologist at Florida State University. "Peer review makes a significant contribution to how billions of dollars in research grants from government and private sources are awarded," said Travis, a coauthor of the study.

In recent years, this process has been questioned, particularly with regard to how well peer review predicts the ultimate impact of the funded research.

"We conducted a retrospective analysis of peer review and project output data for 2,063 projects from an eight year period. Of these, 227 were funded and we examined whether correlations exist among the assessment of scientific merit using a peer review system and the scientific output from this program," said Dr. Steve Gallo, Technical Operations Manager for AIBS and the lead investigator on the study.

Citation impact, or the number of times a research paper is referenced by others, is a common way to assess research impact. Analysis revealed that peer review scores associated with individual applications were correlated with the total time-adjusted citation output of these funded projects.

Gallo states, "citation impact did not correlate with the amount of funds awarded per application or with the total annual programmatic budget." The number of funded applications per year did correlate well with total annual citation impact, suggesting that improving funding success rates by reducing the size of awards may be one strategy to optimize the scientific impact of research program portfolios.

"This strategy must be weighed against the need for a balanced research portfolio and the inherently high costs of some kinds of research," said Travis.

The relationship observed between peer review scores and publication output lays the groundwork for establishing a model system for future prospective testing of the validity of peer review formats and procedures.

"This is something AIBS is looking at now," said Gallo. INFORMATION: END

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Breast vs. bottle feeding in rhesus monkeys

2014-09-04

(SACRAMENTO, Calif.) — Infant rhesus monkeys receiving different diets early in life develop distinct immune systems that persist months after weaning, a study by researchers from UC Davis, the California National Primate Research Center (CNPRC) at UC Davis and UC San Francisco have shown. The study, which compares breast- and bottle-fed infants, appears online September 3 in Science Translational Medicine. While the researchers expected different diets would promote different intestinal bacteria (microbiota), they were surprised at how dramatically these microbes shaped ...

Liver injury caused by herbals, dietary supplements rises in study population

2014-09-04

New research shows that liver injury caused by herbals and dietary supplements increased from 7% to 20% in a U.S. study group over a ten-year period. According to the study published in Hepatology, a journal of the American Association for the Study of Liver Diseases, liver injury caused by non-bodybuilding supplements is most severe, occurring more often in middle-aged women and more frequently resulting in death or the need for transplantation than liver injury from bodybuilding supplements or conventional medications." Nearly half of all adult Americans consume herbal ...

Most accurate measures of gene expression

2014-09-04

RNA-sequencing allows measuring the gene expression of humans or other organisms. The method has recently become very popular in bioscience and medical research, and it is being adopted to clinical applications. Compared to previous methods, RNA-sequencing enables the study of alternative gene isoforms or transcripts, which are formed for example through the process of alternative splicing. The analysis of the large amount of data produced by RNA-sequencing requires many advanced computational methods. Analysis of transcript level data is especially demanding and the ...

Yellow filters in eye result in higher visibility, UGA research finds

2014-09-04

Athens, Ga. – Human eyes naturally contain yellow pigment in the macula, a spot near the center of the retina responsible for high-resolution vision. Those with more yellow in their macula may have an advantage when it comes to filtering out atmospheric particles that obscure one's vision, commonly known as haze. According to a new University of Georgia study, people with increased yellow in their macula could absorb more light and maintain better vision in haze than others. Billy Hammond, UGA professor of brain and behavioral sciences and director of the Vision Sciences ...

Phase III FIRST (MM-020/IFM 07-01) trial of REVLIMID (lenalidomide) plus dexamethasone in newly diagnosed multiple myeloma patients who are not candidates for stem cell transplant published in New Eng

2014-09-04

SUMMIT, N.J. (Sept. 4, 2014) – Celgene Corporation (NASDAQ:CELG) today announced that data from FIRST (MM-020/IFM 07-01)—an open-label phase III randomized study of continuous REVLIMID (lenalidomide) in combination with dexamethasone in patients newly diagnosed with multiple myeloma (NDMM) who are not candidates for stem cell transplant—have been published in the Sept. 4 issue of the New England Journal of Medicine. Initial findings, including that the trial had met its primary endpoint of progression free survival (PFS), were reported during the plenary session at the ...

How good is the fossil record?

2014-09-04

Methods have been developed to try to identify and correct for bias in the fossil record but new research from the Universities of Bristol and Bath, suggests many of these correction methods may actually be misleading. The study, led by Dr Alex Dunhill, formerly at the Universities of Bristol and Bath and now at the University of Leeds, explored the rich and well-studied fossil record of Great Britain. Professional geological work has been done in the British Isles for over 200 years and the British Geological Survey (dating from the 1830s) has amassed enormous, detailed ...

To clean air and beyond: Catching greenhouse gases with advanced membranes

2014-09-04

Researchers in Japan have engineered a membrane with advanced features capable of removing harmful greenhouse gases from the atmosphere. Their findings, published in the British journal Nature Communications, may one day contribute to lower greenhouse gas emissions and cleaner skies. Greenhouse gases, originating from industrial processes and the burning of fossil fuels, blanket the earth and are the culprits behind current global warming woes. The most abundant among them is carbon dioxide, which made up 84% of the United State's greenhouse gases in 2012, and can linger ...

Curb sitting time to protect aging DNA and possibly extend lifespan

2014-09-04

Reducing sedentary activity appears to lengthen telomeres, which sit on the end of chromosomes, the DNA storage units in each cell, the findings show. Telomeres are important because they stop chromosomes from 'fraying' or clumping together and 'scrambling' the genetic codes they contain, performing a role similar to the plastic tips on the end of shoelaces, to which they have been likened. Longevity and a healthy lifestyle have been linked to telomere length, but whether physical activity can make any difference, is not clear. The researchers therefore analysed the ...

The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology: Global epidemic of diabetes threatens to jeopardise further progress in tuberculosis control

2014-09-04

The rapid increase in rates of type 2 diabetes* in low- and middle-income countries where tuberculosis (TB) is endemic could hamper global efforts to control and eliminate TB, according to a new three-part Series about TB and diabetes, published in The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology. The Series indicates that 15% of adult TB cases worldwide are already attributable to diabetes. These diabetes-associated cases correspond to over 1 million cases a year, with more than 40% occurring in India and China alone. If diabetes rates continue to rise out of control, the present ...

Ancient mammal relatives were active at night 100 million years before origin of mammals

2014-09-04

Most living mammals are active at night (or nocturnal), and many other mammal species are active during twilight conditions. It has long been thought that the transition to nocturnality occurred at about the same time as mammals evolved, around 200 million years ago. This thinking was based on on features such as the large brains of mammals (good for processing information from senses like hearing, touch, and smell) and the details of light-sensitive chemicals in the eyes of mammals. It turns out that nocturnal activity might have a much older origin among ancient mammal ...

Crystal L. Mackall, MD, FAACR, recognized with the 2025 AACR-Cancer Research Institute Lloyd J. Old Award in Cancer Immunology

A novel strategy for detecting trace-level nanoplastics in aquatic environments: Multi-feature machine learning-enhanced SERS quantification leveraging the coffee ring effect

AIBS analysis of peer review offers insights into research productivity

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES: