When vaccines are imperfect
What math can tell us about their effects on disease propagation
2014-11-20
(Press-News.org) Philadelphia, PA--The control of certain childhood diseases is difficult, despite high vaccination coverage in many countries. One of the possible reasons for this is "imperfect vaccines," that is, vaccines that fail either due to "leakiness," lack of effectiveness on certain individuals in a population, or shorter duration of potency.
In a paper publishing today in the SIAM Journal on Applied Mathematics, authors Felicia Magpantay, Maria Riolo, Matthieu Domenech de Celles, Aaron King, and Pejman Rohani use a mathematical model to determine the consequences of vaccine failure and resulting disease dynamics.
"We examined the effects of individual-level vaccine failure on the propagation of a disease through a population," says author Felicia Magpantay. "Specifically, we took into account different ways in which vaccines may fail. We distinguished between vaccine-induced immunity that is 'leaky', whereby vaccination reduces the probability of infection upon exposure but does not eliminate it; 'all-or-nothing', which leads to perfect protection in some individuals, but none in others; and 'waning', which reflects transient protection--or some combination of all three."
While leakiness, degree and duration of coverage have direct effects at the individual level, the protection from imperfect vaccines and reduced disease transmission at the population level is not easy to determine. "By carefully ensuring a like-with-like comparison of the differences in the mechanism of vaccine failure, we identified distinct epidemiological signatures at the population-level and explored their implications for disease control," Magpantay explains.
The group of professional applied mathematicians considers a systematic analysis based on the "susceptible-infectious-recovered" model used in epidemiological studies. This model allows one to calculate the number of susceptible, infectious and recovered individuals in a population, factoring in infection and recovery rates as well as contact between susceptible and infected individuals. The authors adapt this model with an added vaccine component to compare the dynamics of the three aforementioned types of imperfect vaccines.
The critical proportion of the model population that needs to be vaccinated in order to drive the disease to extinction is seen to be the same in all three cases. When vaccination coverage is maintained below the critical ratio, the disease remains endemic in the population at a higher level for leaky vaccines, compared to the other two imperfect vaccines. "Among vaccines that exhibit the same level of individual-level effectiveness, the purely leaky vaccine always leads to the highest prevalence of infection in the long run. The purely all-or-nothing and purely waning vaccines lead to the same levels of prevalence," Magpantay elaborates.
The authors then extend their ordinary differential equation model to account for age distribution in the population using a system of partial differential equations for age-specific transmission. "The age distribution of the infected class depends on the type of vaccine failure, the age-specific contact rates and the vaccine coverage. In the cases that we have considered, the waning vaccine leads to the highest mean age of first infection," Magpantay says.
The authors also show that the three imperfect vaccines have distinct transient dynamics following the initiation of vaccination in a population. "Numerical simulations suggest that vaccination with leaky and waning vaccines can bring about a long honeymoon period: a temporary period of low disease prevalence after the onset of mass vaccination," Magpantay explains. "This provides an alternative explanation for the observed resurgence of some diseases like pertussis in regions that maintain high vaccination coverage." All-or-nothing vaccines appear to show a more stable transition.
Topics for future work include examining the role of seasonality on transmission rates as well as the effect of a vaccine on infectiousness of an individual.
INFORMATION:
Source Article:
Epidemiological Consequences of Imperfect Vaccines for Immunizing Infections
[The above link is not active till the paper is published - please contact karthika@siam.org if you would like to view the full paper]
SIAM Journal on Applied Mathematics, 74 (6), 1810-1830 (Online publish date: November 20, 2014, 4:00 pm)
About the authors:
Felicia Magpantay, Maria Riolo, and Matthieu Domenech de Celles are postdoctoral fellows in the Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology at the University of Michigan. Aaron King is a professor in the Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, Department of Mathematics and the Center for the Study of Complex Systems at the University of Michigan. Pejman Rohani is a professor in the Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, Department of Epidemiology and Center for the Study of Complex Systems at the University of Michigan.
If you would like to schedule a direct interview with the paper's authors, please email karthika@siam.org.
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
2014-11-20
A new nationally representative survey of employers--the largest purchasers of health care in the country-- shows that most are unfamiliar with objective metrics of health plan quality information. The survey, conducted by The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research, also found that employers are looking to the Affordable Care Act (ACA) as they make significant decisions on the benefits they offer, with the costs of health plans as a key consideration. Funding for the survey was provided by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.
"There appears to be a serious ...
2014-11-20
PROVIDENCE, R.I. [Brown University] -- In preparation for his upcoming fieldwork, Brown University research analyst Jay Dickson took 10,000 pictures of the inside of his freezer. He wasn't investigating disappearing food or making sure the light went off when he closed the door. Dickson was making sure his new camera and timer would function properly for long periods in sub-freezing temperatures.
"Everything worked great in the freezer for five weeks," Dickson said, "so hopefully it will all work in the field."
That camera's next stop: a remote Antarctic outpost, where ...
2014-11-20
Chester, CA-- A study just published by Point Blue Conservation Science shows the benefits of an aggressive approach to restoring Sierra Nevada aspen stands (Populus tremuloides).
Most of the aspen stands that dotted the Sierra Nevada less than a century ago are gone or in poor health. Aspen stands can increase groundwater, enrich soils and support a higher diversity of plants and wildlife, relative to adjacent forest types. Keeping aspen stands as part of our forests is critical to maintaining a healthy Sierra Nevada forest ecosystem for people and wildlife.
The ...
2014-11-20
Irvine, Calif., Nov. 20, 2014 -- Recent studies showing acid ceramidase (AC) to be upregulated in melanoma, lung and prostate cancers have made the enzyme a desired target for novel synthetic inhibitor compounds. This week in Angewandte Chemie, a top journal in chemistry, UC Irvine and Italian Institute of Technology scientists describe the very first class of AC inhibitors that may aid in the efficacy of chemotherapies.
AC, which is encoded by the ASAH1 gene, plays an important role in the regulation of cell fate, setting the balance between pro-aging/death and pro-life ...
2014-11-20
A Washington family of four must spend 46 percent more on average to make ends meet today than 13 years ago, according to a new report from the University of Washington.
The Self-Sufficiency Standard for Washington State 2014, released Thursday (Nov. 20), provides a sobering look at how much it costs individuals and families statewide to meet basic needs -- and how far short they're falling.
The study found that Washington families with two adults, a preschooler and a school-aged child saw the costs of meeting their most basic requirements jump as much as 72 percent ...
2014-11-20
A new discovery about the atomic structure of uranium dioxide will help scientists select the best computational model to simulate severe nuclear reactor accidents.
Using the Advanced Photon Source (APS), a Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Science User Facility, researchers from DOE's Argonne National Laboratory and Brookhaven National Laboratory, along with Materials Development, Inc., Stony Brook University, and Carnegie Institution of Washington, found that the atomic structure of uranium dioxide (UO2) changes significantly when it melts.
UO2 is the primary ...
2014-11-20
The economic burden of diabetes in America continues to climb, exceeding more than $322 billion in excess medical costs and lost productivity in 2012, or more than $1,000 for every American, according to a study being published in the December issue of Diabetes Care that also includes a state-by-state breakdown of the prevalence and costs associated with diabetes. Additionally, increased costs associated with prediabetes and undiagnosed diabetes highlight the growing importance of prevention and early intervention.
The study, which follows up on a similar report published ...
2014-11-20
TAMPA, Fla. - Moffitt Cancer Center researchers are taking a unique approach to understanding and investigating cancer by utilizing evolutionary principles and computational modeling to examine the role of specific genetic mutations in the Darwinian struggle among tumor and normal cells during cancer growth.
Cells become malignant by acquiring genetic mutations that lead to increased survival and reproduction. Many researchers in the past have viewed cancer progression as the result of unlimited accumulation of these genetic mutations. However, Moffitt researchers ...
2014-11-20
Fast facts:
The study shows that obesity leads to subclinical heart muscle injury and increases the risk for heart failure even among people without overt heart disease and independently of other cardiovascular risk factors such as diabetes, high blood pressure and high cholesterol.
The silent heart damage was detected by using an ultrasensitive test that measures the levels of a protein released by the cells of the heart muscle during injury.
The findings suggest that obesity is an independent driver of heart muscle damage, and that obese individuals, even when free ...
2014-11-20
Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) investigators have developed a system to accurately track the dynamic process of falling asleep, something has not been possible with existing techniques. In their report in the October issue of the open-access journal PLOS Computational Biology, the research team describes how combining key physiologic measurements with a behavioral task that does not interfere with sleep onset gives a better picture of the gradual process of falling asleep. In addition to being a powerful tool for future research, the system could provide valuable ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
[Press-News.org] When vaccines are imperfect
What math can tell us about their effects on disease propagation
