The Lancet: Combining insecticide spraying and bed nets no more protective against malaria than nets alone
2014-12-09
(Press-News.org) The combined use of spraying insecticide inside homes and insecticide-treated bed nets is no better at protecting children against malaria than using bed nets alone, a study in The Gambia suggests. The findings, published in The Lancet, should encourage donors to invest their limited resources in additional bed nets, the more cost-effective solution to tackling malaria*.
Lead author Professor Steve Lindsay, a disease ecologist at Durham University in the UK explains, "Our findings do not support any universal recommendation for indoor residual spraying as an addition to long-lasting insecticidal nets (LLINs) across sub-Saharan Africa. High bed net use is sufficient to protect people against malaria in areas that have low or moderate levels of malaria like The Gambia."**
In 2012, there were an estimated 207 million cases of malaria and 627 000 deaths worldwide, mostly among African children. Low-cost solutions to prevent the disease include LLINs or indoor residual spraying, which involves spraying insecticide on walls and roofs where mosquitoes are likely to land. Both have been shown to reduce the number of deaths due to malaria. But, until now, there has been little evidence to address whether combining these interventions would give better results.
This cluster-randomised trial involved almost 8000 children aged 6 months to 14 years in 70 clusters of villages in the Upper River region of The Gambia. Village clusters were randomly assigned to receive either LLINs alone or LLINs plus indoor spraying with dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane (DDT). Cases of clinical malaria were measured in a group of children in each cluster in 2010 and 2011 using passive case detection (identifying cases that present at reporting health facilities) and annual surveys. Mosquito traps in houses were used to establish exposure to malaria-carrying mosquitoes and parasites. Coverage of indoor spraying (˃80%) and LLINS (83-95%) were high in both years of the study.
The researchers found that clinical cases of malaria were similar in both groups. In year 1, incidence of clinical malaria was 0•047 per child-month at risk in the LLIN group and 0•044 in the spraying plus LLIN group. In year 2, incidence was 0•032 per child-month at risk in the LLIN group and 0•034 in the spraying plus LLIN group (see table 4, page 6 in the Article).
What is more, insecticide spraying did not reduce the number of malaria-carrying mosquitoes collected from the treated homes, suggesting that spraying has no additional effect in deterring or killing mosquitoes.
The researchers say that in order to get a proper measure of impact, further studies are needed to assess the effectiveness of combining LLINs with indoor spraying in areas with different levels of malaria transmission. They also recommend that where net coverage is low, the cost-effectiveness of additional control with indoor insecticide spraying should be considered.
Writing in a linked Comment, Jo Lines and Immo Kleinschmidt from the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine in the UK discuss the mixed results of published trials. They caution, "All four experimental trials (including Pinder and colleagues' study in The Gambia) were designed to test the null hypothesis of no difference between the study groups, and because of this, those that did not find a significant difference should not be interpreted as proof of the absence of a benefit. The reason for this mixture of findings is not immediately clear, and a range of possible explanations related to differences in the trial settings and methods can be suggested, including vector species, insecticides used for indoor residual spraying, effective coverage (of each intervention), and insecticide resistance to one or other of the insecticides used... In view of the uncertainties that persist, it is advisable that all national malaria control programmes investing in the combined use of the two methods should include a rigorous component of monitoring and assessment."
INFORMATION:
Notes to Editors:
This study was funded by UK Medical Research Council.
*Median financial costs per person per year (in 2009 US$) of $2.20 for bed nets and $6.70 for indoor residual spraying http://www.malariajournal.com/content/10/1/337
**Quotes direct from author and cannot be found in text of Article.
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
2014-12-09
The mass die-off of nerve cells in the brains of people with Alzheimer's disease may largely occur because an entirely different class of brain cells, called microglia, begin to fall down on the job, according to a new study by researchers at the Stanford University School of Medicine.
The researchers found that, in mice, blocking the action of a single molecule on the surface of microglia restored the cells' ability to get the job done -- and reversed memory loss and myriad other Alzheimer's-like features in the animals.
The study, to be published online Dec. 8 in ...
2014-12-09
1. Breast density notification laws substantially increase costs yet save few lives
Laws requiring women to be notified of their breast density so that they may discuss supplemental screening options, including ultrasound, with their health care providers would substantially increase costs and save relatively few lives, according to an article published in Annals of Internal Medicine. More than 40 percent of women between the ages of 40 and 74 have dense breast tissue, which puts them at increased risk for breast cancer and affects how well a mammogram can detect abnormalities. ...
2014-12-09
In the most comprehensive look yet at the safety of abortion, researchers at UC San Francisco have concluded that major complications are rare, occurring less than a quarter of a percent of the time, about the same frequency as colonoscopies.
The study, published online on Monday, Dec. 8, 2014, in Obstetrics & Gynecology, analyzed data from more than 50,000 women enrolled in the Medi-Cal fee-for-service program who obtained abortions from 2009 to 2010, and looked for complications that occurred within six weeks of the procedure.
The rate is similar to what has been ...
2014-12-09
Glucose is a component of carbohydrates, and the main energy source used by brain cells.
By studying rats, a team at Imperial College London identified a mechanism that appears to sense how much glucose is reaching the brain, and prompts animals to seek more if it detects a shortfall.
The researchers believe it may play a role in driving our preference for sweet and starchy foods.
The study, funded by the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council, is published in the Journal of Clinical Investigation.
Dr James Gardiner, from the Department of Medicine, ...
2014-12-09
Patients with plasma cell dyscrasis have high amounts of an abnormal immunoglobulin, called a paraprotein, in their blood. While many patients have no outward symptoms, paraproteins can impair immune function, thicken blood, and damage organs. Plasma cell dyscrasis may be inherited, but risk factors for this disease are poorly understood. A new study in the Journal of Clinical Investigation suggests that the presence of a modified host protein is associated with plasma cell dyscrasis risk. Michael Pfreundschuh and colleagues evaluated paraproteins in blood from patients ...
2014-12-09
Glucose is the primary fuel for the brain. Therefore, it has been proposed that the brain must sense glucose and promote eating behaviors when levels are low. A new study in the Journal of Clinical Investigation reveals that activation of an enzyme, glucokinase, in a region of the hypothalamus called the arcuate nucleus specifically increases glucose uptake. Steve Bloom and colleagues at Imperial College London determined that glucokinase levels in the arcuate nucleus are dramatically increased in fasted rats. In their rodent models, activation of glucokinase in the acruate ...
2014-12-09
Saturn's largest moon, Titan, is one of the few solar system bodies - and the only planetary moon - known to have fields of wind-blown dunes on its surface. (The others are Venus, Earth and Mars.)
New research, using experimental results from the high-pressure wind tunnel at Arizona State University's Planetary Aeolian Laboratory, has found that previous estimates of how fast winds need to blow to move sand-size particles around on Titan are about 40 percent too low.
A team of scientists led by Devon Burr of the University of Tennessee, Knoxville reported the findings ...
2014-12-09
An enormous spectrum of light streams from the sun. We're most familiar with the conventional visible white light we see with our eyes from Earth, but that's just a fraction of what our closest star emits. NASA regularly watches the sun in numerous wavelengths because different wavelengths provide information about different temperatures and processes in space. Looking at all the wavelengths together helps to provide a complete picture of what's occurring on the sun over 92 million miles away - but no one has been able to focus on high energy X-rays from the sun until recently.
In ...
2014-12-09
COLUMBUS, Ohio - When it comes to specialized cancer surgery, it's generally true that the more experienced the surgeon, the better the outcome. The same might hold true for radiation therapy used to treat head and neck cancer, according to a new study led by researchers Evan Wuthrick, MD, assistant professor of radiation oncology at The Ohio State University Comprehensive Cancer Center - Arthur G. James Cancer Hospital and Richard J. Solove Research Institute (OSUCCC - James), and Maura Gillison, MD, PhD, professor of internal medicine and epidemiology at the OSUCCC - ...
2014-12-09
A team of researchers at Dartmouth College and University of Pittsburgh found respondents who had smoked water pipe tobacco but not smoked cigarettes were at increased risk of cigarette smoking two years later as recently published online in JAMA Pediatrics. The study followed 2,541 adolescents and young adults for two years.
Samir Soneji, PhD, a tobacco regulatory control researcher at Dartmouth and lead author on the study said, "We found hookah smoking increased the probability of trying cigarette smoking over the next two years by 19%."
This longitudinal study ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
[Press-News.org] The Lancet: Combining insecticide spraying and bed nets no more protective against malaria than nets alone
