Comparison of dark energy models: A perspective from the latest observational data
2010-12-04
(Press-News.org) Physicists at the Institute of Theoretical Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences and the Department of Physics at Northeastern University have made a comparison of a number of competing dark energy models. They have tested and compared nine popular dark energy models using the latest observational data. The study is reported in Issue 9 (Volume 53) of SCIENCE CHINA Physics, Mechanics & Astronomy because of its significant research value.
Over the past decade, cosmologists around the world have accumulated conclusive evidence for the fact that the cosmic expansion is accelerating. Within the framework of the standard cosmological model, this implies that about two-thirds of the cosmos is composed of an exotic component, "dark energy", which, unlike any known form of matter or energy, is gravitationally repulsive. To explain the gravitationally repulsive dark energy, physicists and cosmologists have proposed a variety of theoretical models. However, none of them are commonly accepted as the convincing theoretical explanation for dark energy. Understanding the nature of dark energy continues to be one of the major missions for fundamental physics.
In the absence of clear theoretical guidance, the physics community is reliant on comparison to observational data in selecting a correct dark energy model. In this work, nine popular dark energy models are tested and compared using the latest observational data, which includes type Ia supernovae, baryon acoustic oscillation, and cosmic microwave background. The models under consideration are the cosmological constant (CC) model, two equation of state parameterization models, the generalized Chaplygin gas model, two Dvali-Gabadadze-Porrati models, and three holographic dark energy models. All of these models are well-known dark energy candidates and have attracted considerable attention in the past.
The dark energy models have been fitted to the observational data. In this procedure, each model is assessed with a number called the IC value. Statistically, a model with fewer parameters and with a better fit to the data has a lower IC value. The models under consideration have been compared and ranked according to their IC values.
Consequently, it has been found that the CC model fits the observational data best. In addition to the CC model, five other models also provide a good fit to the current data, while the remaining three models, a Dvali-Gabadadze-Porrati model and two holographic models, clearly do not fit the observational data well. (For simplicity, we call them the five good models and the three bad models.) It is interesting to note that four of the five good models are closely related to the CC model, which may be the reason they fit the data so well, while none of the bad models can be reduced to the CC model.
Furthermore, it is interesting to note that there is one holographic dark energy model, which is not reducible to the CC model, yet it still provides a good fit to the current observational data. This model was proposed by Professor Miao Li, one of the authors of this work. As the name implies, this holographic dark energy model arises from the holographic principle of quantum gravity. The holographic principle determines the range of validity for a local effective quantum field theory to be an accurate description of the world involving dark energy by imposing a relationship between the ultraviolet and infrared cut-offs. In his well-known article, "A Model of Holographic Dark Energy", Li has shown that a form of holographic dark energy emerges if the future event horizon size of the universe is chosen as the infrared cut-off scale in the effective quantum field theory.
In summary, the CC model is still the best candidate for dark energy, according to the results from fitting models to current observational data. The authors concluded that "Given the current quality of the observational data, and with the assumption of a flat universe, information criteria indicate that the cosmological constant model is still the best one and there is no reason to prefer any more complex model". However, as new observations are made, it is possible that the preferred model could change. It is important to keep in mind that there are limitations associated with the current observational data. To precisely determine the nature of dark energy, an improvement in the accuracy of data is of essential importance. "We look forward to seeing whether this conclusion [that the CC model is the best candidate for dark energy] can be changed by future more accurate data," said the authors in the final statement of the paper.
###
This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant Nos. 10705041, 10821504, 10975032 and 10975172), and the National Basic Research Program of China (Grant No. 2007CB815401).
Li M, Li X.D. and Zhang X. SCIENCE CHINA Physics, Mechanics & Astronomy 2010; 53: 1631-1645
http://www.scichina.com:8083/sciGe/EN/abstract/abstract418713.shtml
Li M, Phys. Lett. B 2004; 603: 1-5
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science?_ob=ArticleURL&_udi=B6TVN-4DK5BG6-2&_user=2001487&_coverDate=12%2F02%2F2004&_alid=1444882558&_rdoc=1&_fmt=high&_orig=search&_origin=search&_zone=rslt_list_item&_cdi=5539&_sort=r&_st=13&_docanchor=&view=c&_ct=1&_acct=C000050602&_version=1&_urlVersion=0&_userid=2001487&md5=896c3504e3d4f65308a35e876364fbbf&searchtype=a
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
2010-12-04
The School of Nuclear Engineering and Technology at the East China Institute of Technology cooperated with the China Institute of Atomic Energy to investigate the high spin states of 84Sr. The study is reported in Issue 53 (October, 2010) of the Chinese Science Bulletin because of its significant research value.
Nuclei with Z ≈ 40 and N ≈ 45 lie in a transitional region between deformed nuclei and spherical nuclei. There are collective bands in some isotopes of nuclei of such elements as Sr, Zr and Mo, where the structures have single-particle features. 84Sr, ...
2010-12-04
An evanescent wave arises at the interface of two media when light propagates from a more to a less-dense medium under total internal reflection. The wave is distributed over a superficial area because its amplitude decays exponentially with distance from the interface. The evanescent wave intensity at the interface can be larger than that of the incident beam. Evanescent waves have widespread current use in the imaging of chemical, bio-chemical and biological phenomenon. For example, an evanescent wave is responsible for fluorophore excitation in total internal reflection ...
2010-12-04
Researchers from the College of Physical Sciences, GUCAS, have proposed to establish a new branch, unsteady aerothermodynamics, within the discipline of aerothermodynamics. The principal objectives of this new branch, to treat by theoretical means the study of physical phenomena relating to attached boundary layer flows, have been outlined in a preliminary investigation. A report based on a feasibility study has appeared in Vol. 54 No. 8 of Science China Physics, Mechanics & Astronomy.
Aerothermodynamics, a cross-discipline based mainly on aerodynamics and thermodynamics, ...
2010-12-04
Researchers from the Universidad Pablo de Olavide (UPO) and the Universidad de Sevilla (US) have found patterns of behaviour that occur before an earthquake on the Iberian peninsula. The team used clustering techniques to forecast medium-large seismic movements when certain circumstances coincide.
"Using mathematical techniques, we have found patterns when medium-large earthquakes happen, that is, earthquakes greater than 4.4 on the Richter scale," Francisco Martínez Álvarez, co-author of the study and a senior lecturer at the UPO revealed to SINC.
The research, which ...
2010-12-04
Memory difficulties such as those seen in dementia may arise because the brain forms incomplete memories that are more easily confused, new research from the University of Cambridge has found. The findings are published today in the journal Science.
Currently, memory problems are typically perceived to be the result of forgetting previously encountered items or events. The new research (using an animal model of amnesia), however, found that the ability of the brain to maintain complete, detailed memories is disrupted. The remaining, less detailed memories are relatively ...
2010-12-04
Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) play an important role as cosmological distance indicators and have been used successfully to determine cosmological parameters, which resulted in the discovery of the accelerating expansion of the Universe. However, the exact nature of SN Ia progenitors is still not well understood. There is a popular theory that SNe Ia originate from runaway thermonuclear events in carbon–oxygen white dwarves (CO WD) in binary systems. The CO WD accretes material from its companion. When the CO WD increases its mass above the maximum stable mass, it will explode.
Based ...
2010-12-04
Impairments to health and physical performance are not primarily a result of aging but of unfavorable lifestyle habits and lack of exercise. This is the position taken by Dieter Leyk and his coauthors in the new issue of Deutsches Ärzteblatt International (Dtsch Arztebl Int 2010; 107[46]: 809).
Sporty elderly people have a life expectancy that is almost 4 years higher and are often faster than younger athletes.
In their study, the sports scientists analyzed the stamina of more than 600 000 marathon and half marathon runners and asked participants about their ...
2010-12-04
Scientists from The University of Manchester say a naturally occurring chemical found in soy could prove to be an effective new treatment for a fatal genetic disease that affects children.
Dr Brian Bigger, from the University's MPS Stem Cell Research Laboratory, found that genistein – derived from soya beans and licensed in the US as an osteoporosis drug – had a dramatic effect on mice suffering from the human childhood disease Sanfilippo.
"Sanfilippo is an untreatable mucopolysaccharide (MPS) disease affecting one in 89,000 children in the United Kingdom," said Dr ...
2010-12-04
Philadelphia, PA, 2 December 2010 - Many brain imaging studies have reported that tobacco smoking is associated with large-scale and wide-spread structural brain abnormalities.
The cerebral cortex is a specific area of the brain responsible for many important higher-order functions, including language, information processing, and memory. Reduced cortical thickness has been associated with normal aging, reduced intelligence, and impaired cognition.
However, prior research had not described the impact of smoking upon cortical thickness.
A new study, published in ...
2010-12-04
People who are deemed social misfits or "losers" aren't effective leaders, even if they are crusading for a cause that would benefit a larger group, according to new research from Rice University, the University of Texas and Universitat de Valencia.
The study's authors observed the contributions of 80 participants in a repeated public-goods game and found that players were more likely to mimic the actions of a leader they perceived as a high-status individual; they ignored leaders perceived as low-status and, when they had a chance, punished them for trying to lead. ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
[Press-News.org] Comparison of dark energy models: A perspective from the latest observational data
