(Press-News.org) An update search enlarged the pool of study data, but did not change the content of the conclusion of the benefit assessment of stem cell transplantation (SCT) for multiple myeloma conducted in 2012. Overall, the evidence base remained insufficient: Until now, data on quality of life have not been recorded in any study at all. And three large studies, some of which were under German management, have not been completely published even more than 10 years after their completion. This is the conclusion of a rapid report published by the Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG) on 28 April 2015.
Now data on six of nine subindications
In January 2012, IQWiG presented a final report and a supplementary working paper on the benefit of SCT for multiple myeloma, for which the last search for studies had been conducted in January 2011. The Federal Joint Committee (G-BA) therefore commissioned IQWiG to conduct an update search to be able to include any more current findings in its consultations.
The researchers identified a total of four additional studies. Three of them had not been published in full text at the time of the first assessment, and for another one, a more current analysis was available. Hence there were now data for six of a total of nine subindications, as compared with five in 2012.
No relevant differences between treatment groups
The subindication for which now data were available for the first time was allogeneic SCT with related donor in comparison with allogeneic SCT with unrelated donor. Due to the study design however, the results of the new study published in 2012 were not very robust.
The study on allogeneic SCT with reduced-intensity conditioning in comparison with allogeneic SCT with myeloablative conditioning, which was now additionally available, had no effect on the assessment: Due to its overall low certainty of results, neither an advantage nor a disadvantage of the two treatment variants could be derived from the data.
Reduced-intensity conditioning: both advantages and disadvantages
In the subindication of allogeneic SCT with reduced-intensity conditioning compared with autologous SCT, it was possible to enlarge the study pool to six studies because of the update. Study results that had been initially available only as abstracts were available as full texts.
These supplementary data did not change the result, however: On the one hand, IQWiG sees an indication of an added benefit from longer overall survival here. On the other, there is still an indication and proof of greater harm from more frequent deaths resulting from treatment and from rejection reactions (graft-versus-host disease). These potentially fatal rejection reactions do not occur when the patient's own cells are transplanted. Whereas these risks become notable early on, improved overall survival is only recognized in the long term.
German study authors still withhold results
The search for new or supplementary study data in the subindication of multiple autologous transplantation produced no result: There are three large studies that are known from the publication of abstracts to have been completed for a long time. The complete results have still not been published, however.
In 2011 already, IQWiG had asked the study authors to make the data available, and the G-BA had now made the same enquiry - again, to no avail. "The fact that results of studies that are partly under German management and have been financed mostly by public funds are kept from the public is still unacceptable and contrary to all efforts for more transparency", says IQWiG's Deputy Director Stefan Lange. "There has been some success regarding studies on drugs that are largely financed by the drug manufacturers. There is an extensive obligation for publication of these studies. In contrast, a gap still exists in the regulation regarding so-called investigator-initiated trials and in studies on medical devices", says Lange.
Use only justified under study conditions
Due to the gaps in knowledge and the many unresolved questions, IQWiG still regards the use of certain forms of SCT for multiple myeloma to be acceptable only in the context of clinical studies. In addition, patients have to be comprehensively informed about the potential benefit and harm. For studies to help close the existing gaps in knowledge, they should be randomized if possible. They should also record data on quality of life. Until now, this important outcome criterion has not been considered in any study at all.
Process of report production
The G-BA commissioned IQWiG on 16 October 2014 to prepare the report in an accelerated process, known as a "rapid report". In contrast to the usual procedure, no preliminary reports are published here. Although a draft version of the report is reviewed by external experts, no hearing at which all interested parties can comment takes place. The report (version 1.0) was sent to the commissioning agency on 30 March 2015.
An overview of the background, methods and further results of the report is provided in the following executive summary.
INFORMATION:
When consumer budgets grow or shrink, how do spending habits change? A common view is that people with a budget will spend their money on the same number of products, even when their previous budget was lower or higher. But in order to keep their favorite items, consumers whose budgets have shrunk to a particular amount will opt for less variety than someone whose budget has increased to that same amount, according to a new study in the Journal of Marketing Research. Investors beware!
"We call this the budget contraction effect," write authors Kurt A. Carlson (Georgetown ...
(NEWARK, NJ) - April 29, 2014 - A woman is brutally assaulted, but rather than receiving the sympathy she deserves, she is blamed. If she had dressed differently or acted differently, or made wiser choices, others say, she would have been spared her ordeal. For victims, this "victim blaming" is profoundly hurtful, and can lead to secondary victimization.
Psychologists have long realized that blaming victims is a defense mechanism that helps blamers feel better about the world, and see it as fair and just. But ways to prevent victim blaming have been elusive -- until ...
The sun's surface is blisteringly hot at 10,340 degrees Fahrenheit -- but its atmosphere is another 300 times hotter. This has led to an enduring mystery for those who study the sun: What heats the atmosphere to such extreme temperatures? Normally when you move away from a hot source the environment gets cooler, but some mechanism is clearly at work in the solar atmosphere, the corona, to bring the temperatures up so high.
Clear evidence now suggests that the heating mechanism depends on regular, but intermittent explosive bursts of heat, rather than on continuous gradual ...
MISSOULA - Improved drilling technologies and energy demand have resulted in the large-scale expansion of oil and gas development, with 50,000 new wells drilled per year recently in central North America. Locations such as the Bakken, Eagle Ford and the Marcellus Shale are now commonplace, and drilling activity frequently makes news.
But what are the ecological consequences of this accelerated drilling activity? Researchers at the University of Montana have conducted the first-ever broad-scale scientific assessment of how oil and gas development transforms landscapes ...
Casting a large interdisciplinary research net has helped Simon Fraser University archaeologist Dana Lepofsky and 10 collaborators dig deeper into their findings about ancient clam gardens in the Pacific Northwest to formulate new perspectives.
Lepofsky's research team has discovered that Northwest Coast Indigenous people didn't make their living just by gathering the natural ocean's bounty. Rather, from Alaska to Washington, they were farmers who cultivated productive clam gardens to ensure abundant and sustainable clam harvests.
In its new paper published by American ...
Being bigger and bolder holds various benefits for male soldier beetles. They enjoy higher rates of successful courtship and more often land a larger, more fertile mate. These are some of the findings of a study led by Denson McLain of the Georgia Southern University in the US, published in Springer's journal Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology.
The goldenrod soldier beetle or Pennsylvanian leatherwing (Chauliognathus pennsylvanicus) is native to Northern America. During its peak reproductive season, between September to early October, it only mates once a day. This normally ...
CHICAGO -- Genetic testing of Iñupiat people currently living in Alaska's North Slope is helping Northwestern University scientists fill in the blanks on questions about the migration patterns and ancestral pool of the people who populated the North American Arctic over the last 5,000 years.
"This is the first evidence that genetically ties all of the Iñupiat and Inuit populations from Alaska, Canada and Greenland back to the Alaskan North Slope," said Northwestern's M. Geoffrey Hayes, senior author of the new study to be published April 29, 2015, in the American ...
PULLMAN, Wash.--Climate change may be responsible for the abrupt collapse of civilization on the fringes of the Tibetan Plateau around 2000 B.C.
WSU archaeologist Jade D'Alpoim Guedes and an international team of researchers found that cooling global temperatures at the end of the Holocene Climatic Optimum, a 4,000 year period of warm weather, would have made it impossible for ancient people on the Tibetan Plateau to cultivate millet, their primary food source.
Guedes' team's research recently was published online in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. ...
A vaccine containing a protein necessary for virus replication can boost an HIV-infected patient's immune system, according to clinical research published in the open access journal Retrovirology. This boost can result in increased effectiveness of antiretroviral drugs.
When people are first diagnosed with HIV they are put on antiretroviral drugs, also known as highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART). These drugs can stop the virus reproducing almost completely. When taking HAART, however, it is known that the virus can still replicate at low levels and accumulate ...
For patients in the early stage of non-small cell lung cancer, surgical resection yields optimal outcomes. Prior investigations have shown that different resection procedures have very different outcomes, with pneumonectomy associated with three-fold higher mortality than other resection types. While it is understandable that pathological and physiological factors influence a surgeon's choice of surgery for a particular patient, the results presented in this study suggest that physician discomfort with the operative complexities of a procedure may lead to selection of a ...
