(Press-News.org) Commercial providers of out of hours GP care in England are associated with poorer experience of care compared with NHS or not for profit providers, finds a study in The BMJ this week.
The researchers say further work is needed to better understand the reasons for this finding.
Out of hours GP care in England (operated between 6.30 pm and 8 am on weekdays and throughout weekends and public holidays) is currently delivered by a combination of NHS, not for profit, and commercial providers.
After concerns over variation in the quality of out of hours care, the Care Quality Commission has regulated the quality and safety of out of hours GP services since 2012. Recent inspections found many examples of good practice but also highlighted areas for improvement.
So a team led by Professor John Campbell at the University of Exeter Medical School, set out to investigate patients' experiences of using out of hours services across England.
He said: "This is a large scale and robust study, and yields interesting results that warrant further investigation and understanding. It is important to exercise caution in interpreting the results.
Although commercial providers scored lower overall, the best commercial providers scored higher than many of the NHS and not-for-profit providers. There are variations and examples of good practice among all providers, but the overall trend is that patients report less positive experiences with commercial providers, and we now need to understand why that is the case."
The team analysed data from over 900,000 patients who completed the General Practice Patient Survey 2012-13, 80,000 of whom had had contact with GP out of hours services in the preceding six months.
This included individual characteristics (such as age, ethnicity and the ability to take time off work to see a doctor) and their experience of care (timeliness, confidence and trust in the out of hours doctor or nurse, and overall experience of care).
They also examined whether the type of provider organisation (NHS, not for profit, or commercial) was associated with patient experience. Each response was analysed on a scale of 0 to 100.
Commercial providers of out of hours care were associated with poorer reports of patient experience across all three outcome measures compared with not for profit providers. Overall, NHS providers scored slightly higher than not for profit providers.
Some ethnic minorities, particularly Asian patients, reported a poorer experience than white patients, especially when asked about timeliness of care.
Inability to attend the practice because of work commitments was also significantly associated with lower scores across all three metrics of care. In contrast, individuals who reported being able to take time off from work for health related reasons reported somewhat better experiences of care.
The reasons why commercial providers were associated with poorer experience of out of hours GP care warrant further exploration, say the authors.
Future research is also required to investigate reasons for generally lower scores from patients from ethnic minority backgrounds - and to investigate why users who are unable to take time from work to attend their practice during regular hours reported poorer scores across all three questions, they conclude.
The reasons why commercial providers are associated with poorer experience of care are unclear, say researchers at the University of Leicester in an accompanying editorial. "It is possible that commercial providers are located in areas with more complex population needs, but it is also possible that patient experience is genuinely poorer."
They point to proposals to introduce seven day access to general practice, but say the practicality of this idea "is open to question" as GPs are already struggling to cope with current demand. They also suggest bringing practices together into federations "to enable the scheduling of of access beyond usual opening hours."
"Although we need more research to better understand the experience of some patients and how we should respond, further reports are not needed; it is time for action that makes a real difference," they conclude.
INFORMATION:
A new study suggests that engaging in low intensity activities such as standing may not be enough to offset the health hazards of sitting for long periods of time. On the bright side, adding two minutes of walking each hour to your routine just might do the trick. These findings were published in the Clinical Journal of the American Society of Nephrology (CJASN).
Numerous studies have shown that sitting for extended periods of time each day leads to increased risk for early death, as well as heart disease, diabetes and other health conditions. Considering that 80 percent ...
Highlight
In an observational study that followed participants for an average of just under 3 years, a "trade-off" of sedentary activity with low-intensity activity was not beneficial, but a trade-off of 2 minutes/hour of sedentary activity with an equal amount of light-intensity activity was associated with 33% lower risk of dying in the general population and a 41% lower risk of dying in the individuals with chronic kidney disease.
Previous research suggests that sitting for long periods of time may increase the risk of disease and early death.
Washington, DC ...
A new study by Johns Hopkins researchers concludes that most U.S. clinical registries that collect data on patient outcomes are substandard and lack critical features necessary to render the information they collect useful for patients, physicians and policy makers.
Findings of the study, published ahead of print April 24 in the Journal for Healthcare Quality, reveal poor data monitoring and reporting that researchers say are hurting national efforts to study disease, guide patient choice of optimal treatments, formulate rational health policies and track in a meaningful ...
"The word, virus, connotes morbidity and mortality, but that bad reputation is not universally deserved," said Marilyn Roossinck, PhD, Professor of Plant Pathology and Environmental Microbiology and Biology at the Pennsylvania State University, University Park. "Viruses, like bacteria, can be important beneficial microbes in human health and in agriculture," she said. Her review of the current literature on beneficial viruses appeared ahead of print April 24 in the Journal of Virology, which is published by the American Society for Microbiology.
In sharp contrast to ...
Scientists require high-resolution imaging of plant cells to study everything from fungal infections to reproduction in maize. These images are captured with scanning electron microscopy (SEM), where an electron microscope focuses beams of electrons to increase magnification of objects. SEM is a common technique for all fields of science.
However, preparing objects for SEM and other common imaging methods can compromise delicate biological samples. Freeze-drying of material, electron beams, and vacuum pressure in the microscope can all result in cell damage, which is ...
New research has shown that children who display increasing levels of inattention at the age of seven are at risk of worse academic outcomes in their GCSE examinations.
Researchers at the Universities of Nottingham and Bristol studied more than 11,000 children as part of the research which was funded by the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) and is published in the Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry.
The findings of the research have a range of implications for parents, teachers and clinicians.
The research was led by Kapil ...
If you're in the market for a new car, and especially if you have a trade-in, the latest research from the USC Marshall School of Business marketing department suggests you aren't getting the deal you think you are getting.
New research from USC Marshall School of Business associate professors of marketing Anthony Dukes and Sivaramakrishnan Siddarth shows that a consumer with a trade-in actually forks over more money to the dealer than consumers without a trade-in.
"The Informational Role of Product Trade-Ins for Pricing Durable Goods" is forthcoming in the Journal ...
Results to be published in the Journal of Family and Economic Issues suggest that having short-term household debt -- credit cards and overdue bills -- increases depressive symptoms. The association is particularly strong among unmarried people, people reaching retirement age and those who are less well educated, according to a new study by lead author Lawrence Berger of the University of Wisconsin-Madison.
These are the first results to show the impact of different types of debt on depression and their effects on different sectors of the US population. Little evidence ...
Scientists are using a variety of buoys and autonomous underwater vehicles to record and archive sounds from marine mammals and fish species in the western North Atlantic through a new listening network known as the U.S. Northeast Passive Acoustic Sensing Network (NEPAN).
Stretching from the northern Gulf of Maine to the New York Bight in the northwest Atlantic Ocean, NEPAN provides year-round, long-term information on the presence and physical distribution of vocal whales, dolphins and porpoises and some fish species. The archived and near-real-time data comes from recorders ...
Researchers at Aalto University (Finland) and Amherst College (USA) have observed a point-like monopole in a quantum field itself for the first time. This discovery connects to important characteristics of the elusive monopole magnet. The results were just published in Science magazine.
The researchers performed an experiment in which they manipulated a gas of rubidium atoms prepared in a nonmagnetic state near absolute zero temperature. Under these extreme conditions they were able to create a monopole in the quantum-mechanical field that describes the gas.
'In this ...
