(Press-News.org) Britain, Queensland, Israel, Poland - 2015 has been a year of electoral polling failure and it could have major implications on election outcomes, say QUT economics researchers.
The recent definitive Conservative win in the recent British elections, when polling had produced the near universal prediction of a 'hung parliament', mirrors Labor's surprise win in Queensland where the election outcome was unrelated to the poll prediction, says Professor Lionel Page from QUT's Queensland Behavioural Economics Group (QuBE).
"The magnitude of the failure to predict these elections' outcomes left pollsters gobsmacked," Professor Page said.
"But beyond the surprise, a QuBE study suggests that errors in polling forecasts can actually bias the electoral results themselves.
"In the Queensland election, the poll indicated the LNP would be returned, albeit with a reduced majority, whereas in the British election all the opinion polls predicted a hung parliament.
"In a third 2015 example, Israel's pollsters were completely disproved - the re-election of Benjamin Netanyahu in March went against all poll predictions of an opposition victory."
Professor Page said the QUT behaviour economics study of how exit polling influenced French elections, published in the European Economic Review (July 2015), could provide answers.
"We found that the precise exit polls released in mainland France in the 2002 presidential elections influenced voters casting their vote French territories in later time zones around the world," he said.
"When the exit polls were released at 8pm on election day in France, it was only 2pm in Guadalupe and 9am in Tahiti which meant these voters knew the result of the election in mainland France before they had voted.
"France then changed the law in 2007 so that voting in its territories closed one day before the mainland election. We compared voter behaviour in the following presidential election with the 2002 one and found two significants effects.
"Firstly, in the 2002 election the turnout in the territories was 11 percent higher than in the subsequent election.
"Secondly there was the 'bandwagon effect' - when voters knew who was going to win, the voting share of the expected winner was higher but disappeared after the change in the law."
"This indicates people are less likely to vote when they expect their candidate to lose."
Professor Page said, using this insight, it could be that the record turnout of British voters was due to a fear of a hung parliament suggested by most pre-election polls.
""People were afraid that if there wasn't a definitive outcome, a hung parliament would give the Scottish National Party the balance of power in the UK.
"In Queensland, voters were motivated by the polls to avoid a hung parliament but never expected the ousting of the Liberal Government."
Professor Page said poor opinion polls could sway the outcome of elections.
"Because our study found that polls do influence voter behaviour, some elections could, therefore, end up being decided by the effect of random polling error," he said.
"Even UK Prime Minister David Cameron's advisor Lynton Crosby acknowledges: 'polls have become part of the political process so they're not an independent measurement that says this is what's going on, they actually influence what's going on.'.
"Indeed, it is said that Crosby knew from private polling that the Conservatives were ahead but kept it quiet because he knew fear of a hung parliament would motivate voters to vote for the Tories.
"What can be done? In the connected world a ban on polls in the last stages of a campaign is not a solution. Our results show that improving polling techniques and possibly regulating polling practices is important if we do not want elections to potentially end up being the result of a dice throw (ie the direction of a polling error)."
INFORMATION:
The study, Exit polls, turnout, and bandwagon voting: Evidence from a natural experiment was conducted by Professor Page, Professor Benno Torgler from QuBE with Professor Rebecca Morton from New York University Abu Dhabi and Dr Daniel Muller from the University of Mannheim.
This news release is available in Spanish. Bovine leukemia virus (BLV) is an infectious disease that affects the immune system of cattle, causing immunodeficiency and in some cases triggering the development of leukemia or solid tumors in the form of lymphomas. This illness causes significant losses in productivity and even premature death of animals mostly in dairy farms. It also raises sanitary barriers for commerce of livestock and derived goods. As such, it has become a very prevalent veterinary issue, notably in Uruguay, which needs urgent solving. BLV is a virus ...
Coral colonies are more genetically diverse than it has been assumed to date. This is the conclusion drawn by biologists at Ruhr-Universität Bochum, who have conducted comprehensive studies into the genetic variability in individual colonies of different reef-forming coral species. "However, this doesn't mean we should expect that this variability can compensate for corals dying worldwide due to climate change," says Maximilian Schweinsberg from the Department of Animal Ecology, Evolution and Biodiversity, headed by Prof Dr Ralph Tollrian. In collaboration with colleagues, ...
A systematic review publishing today in the journal Human Reproduction Update has found that women who suffer from polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) could manage some of the symptoms by combining a change in lifestyle with taking the drug metformin.
PCOS is associated with a range of features including irregular cycles, infertility, obesity, diabetes, and depression. Researchers at Monash University in Australia compared the effects of change in lifestyle alone or with placebo, to lifestyle plus metformin. They found that lifestyle changes combined with taking metformin ...
A previously unknown link between the immune system and the death of motor neurons in Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), also known as Lou Gehrig's disease, has been discovered by scientists at the CHUM Research Centre and the University of Montreal. The finding paves the way to a whole new approach for finding a drug that can cure or at least slow the progression of such neurodegenerative diseases as ALS, Alzheimer's, Parkinson's and Huntington's diseases.
The study, published today in Nature Communications, shows that the immune system in the animal model C. elegans, ...
New York, June 10 -- A new paper in the British Medical Journal by Jan Blustein, M.D., Ph.D., of New York University's Wagner School and a professor of Medicine and Population Health at NYU School of Medicine and Jianmeng Liu, M.D., Ph.D., of Peking University examines the evidence as to whether newborns delivered by Cesarean section are more likely to develop chronic diseases later in life. While the jury is still out and research is ongoing, recent studies underscore the need for health care providers to discuss with expectant parents the risk of babies born through cesarean ...
Companies are spending increasing amounts on cybersecurity tools, but aren't convinced their data is truly secure and many chief information security officers believe that attackers are gaining on their defenses, according to a new RAND Corporation study.
Charting the future of cybersecurity is difficult because so much is shrouded in secrecy, no one is entirely certain of all the methods malicious hackers use to infiltrate systems and businesses do not want to disclose their safety measures, according to the report.
While worldwide spending on cybersecurity is close ...
CLEVELAND, June 10 -- The use of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) is increasing for the treatment of menopausal symptoms but often without the guidance of a clinician. That's according to a new study reported online today in Menopause, the journal of the North American Menopause Society (NAMS). As a result, the authors suggest that healthcare providers -- in particular family medicine practitioners -- need to be more aware of the various CAM therapies and take a more active role in guiding patients through their options to more safely and effectively coordinate ...
Almost one in every 150 babies born in the UK is stillborn or dies soon after birth. A research team led from the University of Leicester has identified large differences across the UK in the numbers and rates of babies who die, even after taking account of known factors that influence the rate of death such as poverty, mother's age and ethnicity.
A new report by MBRRACE-UK*, a team of academics, clinicians and charity representatives (commissioned by the Healthcare Quality Improvement Partnership** as part of the Maternal, Newborn and Infant Clinical Outcome Review Programme), ...
Brood parasites are reproductive cheats that evolve ways of duping other birds into raising their young. Examples such as mimicry of host eggs, chicks and fledglings by brood parasitic eggs, chicks and fledglings are amongst the most iconic examples of animal deception in nature.
New research shows that adult brood parasitic female cuckoo finches have evolved plumage colours and patterns to mimic a harmless and abundant species, such as southern red bishops, to deceive possible host birds and reduce the risk of being attacked when approaching host nests to lay their eggs. ...
A young woman has become the first in the world to give birth to a healthy child after doctors restored her fertility by transplanting ovarian tissue that had been removed and frozen while she was a child.
A report of the case is published today in Human Reproduction [1], one of the world's leading reproductive medicine journals. While there have been reports of successful pregnancies after ovarian transplantation using tissue that had been removed from patients when they were adults, there have been none using tissue taken from girls before puberty and the ability of ...
