(Press-News.org) Two decades ago, the Brain Trauma Foundation published its first set of guidelines for treating traumatic brain injury.
Now, a study by the Los Angeles County Trauma Consortium -- which includes several physicians from UCLA -- has found that compliance with those guidelines doesn't necessarily translate into better results for patients.
In research published online by the peer-reviewed journal JAMA Surgery, the consortium analyzed 2009 and 2010 data from all 14 L.A. County trauma centers and found no evidence that compliance with the guidelines led to lower mortality rates.
"There is no direct connection between the rate at which a hospital does what it is supposed to do for traumatic brain injury patients and how likely their patients are to die from their injuries after we adjust for other important patient characteristics," said Dr. Aaron Dawes, the study's lead author and a resident in general surgery at the David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA.
The consortium is made up of health services researchers from UCLA and the University of Southern California, and representatives of the trauma centers and the county's Emergency Medical Services Agency.
Researchers calculated how often trauma centers follow the guidelines, which include management strategies and specific criteria for use of two invasive procedures -- intracranial pressure monitoring and craniotomy.
Intracranial pressure monitoring involves drilling a small hole in the skull in order to insert a specialized device that can directly monitor for pressure building up against the brain. The device can alert doctors to rising intracranial pressure before it can cause brain damage or death. Craniotomy, the surgical removal of part of the skull, can be used either to help relieve this pressure or to treat intracranial bleeding, which causes elevated intracranial pressure and can lead to death if left untreated.
The researchers analyzed data from 734 adults who sustained severe traumatic brain injury. They found:
The percentage of patients who died from their injuries varied by medical center, but ranged from 20 percent to 50 percent.
Risk-adjusted mortality rates -- which take into account the patients' age and other medical conditions -- ranged from 24.3 percent to 56.7 percent.
Only 46.1 percent of patients whose injuries called for intracranial pressure monitoring according to the guidelines actually underwent monitor placement, and only 45.6 percent of the patients whose injuries called for craniotomy underwent the procedure.
Hospitals' compliance with the guidelines ranged from 9.6 percent to 65.2 percent for intracranial pressure monitoring, and from 6.7 percent to 76.2 percent for craniotomies.
"Overall, patients received the procedures recommended by the guidelines only about half the time -- and even less at some centers," Dawes said. "This tells us that we need to do a better job providing evidence-based care, but it also showed that the pattern of how often hospitals follow the guidelines does not appear to be associated with other, more validated measures of hospital quality.
"All hospitals need to improve, but our findings show that simply getting them to follow the guidelines more closely might not necessarily lead to better outcomes for patients."
The researchers suggest that the study highlights a key problem with the trauma foundation guidelines: They address only whether intracranial monitoring should be performed, but not how the clinical team should use the information that the monitors provide.
"For example, two identical patients could have monitors placed," said Dawes, a Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Clinical Scholar. "But one patient's medical team might not use information from the monitor -- or might not use it as well as the other patient's team. Blunt metrics like the ones we studied simply can't get at that level of clinical decision-making."
These findings already have prompted consortium members to re-evaluate how they treat brain trauma, which could lead to better care for Los Angeles patients, Dawes said.
"Forming this consortium and working together on these issues has created a framework for quality improvement throughout the county," he said. "Its most important contribution has been getting the entire trauma system to start talking about quality and how to improve it."
There were some limitations to the study. It included only patients with the most severe traumatic brain injuries in Los Angeles County, so the results may not apply to other regions or people with less severe injuries. Also, practices at some medical centers might have changed during the time between data collection and data analysis. Finally, the sample size at some hospitals was too small to make certain comparisons.
"Despite improvements in care, mortality from [traumatic brain injury] remains both common and variable from hospital to hospital," the study stated. "Our results demonstrate no association between hospitals' compliance with two [Brain Trauma Foundation] guidelines and risk-adjusted mortality, suggesting that neither measure should be used as an independent marker of hospital quality."
INFORMATION:
The study co-authors are Dr. Greg Sacks, Dr. H. Gill Cryer, Marilyn Cohen, David McArthur, Dr. Marcia Russell, Dr. Melinda Maggard-Gibbons and Dr. Clifford Ko, all of UCLA; Dr. J. Peter Gruen of USC; and Christy Preston and Deidre Gorospe of the County of Los Angeles Department of Health Services. Dawes, Sacks, Russell, Maggard-Gibbons and Ko are also associated with the VA Greater Los Angeles Healthcare System.
The VA/Robert Wood Johnson Clinical Scholars Program and VA Office of Academic Affiliations supported Dawes and Sacks during their work on the study.
Media Contact:
Enrique Rivero
310-794-2273
erivero@mednet.ucla.edu
Researchers at Barrow Neurological Institute have spent years of medical sleuthing across three continents to uncover a brain surgery that changed history.
After more than two-years of international investigation, the scientists have concluded that Napoleon likely would have conquered Russia in 1812 if not for the life-saving brain surgery performed on Russian general Mikhail Kutuzov by the French surgeon Jean Massot, who operated on Kutuzov after bullets twice passed through his head.
"It's a story of how medicine changed the course of civilization," says Mark C. Preul, ...
Berlin, 29th July 2015 - Acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) is the most common type of cancer in children. It can occur in various forms, differing not only by specific changes in the genetic material of the leukemia cells but also by their response to therapies. Now, an international team of scientists from Berlin, Düsseldorf, Hannover, Heidelberg, Kiel, and Zurich have succeeded in decoding the molecular characteristics of an as yet incurable subtype of leukemia, paving the way for new therapeutic approaches. Their results have been published in the current issue ...
Politicians, children, teachers, Europeans... what do they have in common? As discovered in a study led by Luca Piretti and his colleagues from SISSA (International School for Advanced Studies) of Trieste, they are all social groups, a special semantic category for the human brain that is closely linked with emotions.
Until recently, most neuroscientists believed that the representation of knowledge in the brain was based on two distinct systems: one involved in representing animate objects (or, generally, anything organic), and the other for representing inanimate objects ...
When they reach for the glass, they often know no limits: Hazardous drinking is fairly common among young Swiss men. The good news: Based on a survey of around 5,700 young Swiss men with a mean age of 20, scientists from the University of Zurich reveal that legal regulations - such as the minimum legal drinking age and restrictions on the sale or advertising of alcoholic beverages - have a preventive effect on young consumers.
Around half of the respondents are high-risk drinkers, which means they consume at least six or more alcoholic drinks in a single session every ...
A promising agent for the treatment of cancer has so far had little effect on the most common lung tumours, but new research from The University of Manchester has suggested how this resistance might be overcome.
In two papers released in the journal PNAS, the research team examined factors which mean that the most common type of lung cancer - itself the most common cause of cancer deaths - is resistant to a cytokine called TRAIL that causes cell death in many other types of tumour.
The researchers found that in non-small cell lung cancer, which accounts for around 85 ...
Mice that have a particular brain chemical switched off become hyperactive and sleep for just 65 per cent of their normal time.
This discovery, published in the journal Neuron, could help researchers to develop new drugs that promote better sleep, or control hyperactivity in people with the medical condition mania.
Scientists altered the neurochemistry of mice to help investigate why we need to sleep, what controls our wakefulness, and how a balance between these two states influences brain functions like concentration and memory and our general health.
The chemicals ...
From slight sparrows to preening peacocks to soaring falcons, birds have long been known to possess distinct abilities in their sense of smell, but little has been known about the evolution of olfaction.
Now, a large comparative genomic study of the olfactory genes tied to a bird's sense of smell has revealed important differences that correlate with their ecological niches and specific behaviors.
Authors Agostinho Antunes et al., in a new study published in the advanced online edition of Molecular Biology and Evolution, analyzed olfactory receptor genes (OR gene ...
Physicists at the University of York have revealed a new understanding of nucleosynthesis in stars, providing insight into the role massive stars play in the evolution of the Milky Way and the origins of the Solar System.
Radioactive aluminium (aluminium-26, or Al26) is an element that emits gamma radiation through its decay enabling astronomers to image its location in our galaxy. Studying how Al26 is created in massive stars, scientists have distinguished between previously conflicting assumptions about its rate of production by nuclear fusion.
Funded by the Science ...
University of Adelaide research has shown for the first time that, despite not having a nervous system, plants use signals normally associated with animals when they encounter stress.
Published today in the journal Nature Communications, the researchers at the Australian Research Council (ARC) Centre of Excellence in Plant Energy Biology reported how plants respond to their environment with a similar combination of chemical and electrical responses to animals, but through machinery that is specific to plants.
"We've known for a long-time that the animal neurotransmitter ...
Bari, Italy, July 28, 2015 -- A new study by researchers at the University of Bari Aldo Moro, Bari, Italy, Geriatric Unit & Laboratory of Gerontology and Geriatrics, IRCCS "Casa Sollievo della Sofferenza", San Giovanni Rotondo, Foggia, Italy, and Istituto Superiore di Sanità (ISS), Roma, Italy, estimates the association between change or constant habits in coffee consumption and the incidence of mild cognitive impairment (MCI), evaluating 1,445 individuals recruited from 5,632 subjects, aged 65-84 year old, from the Italian Longitudinal Study on Aging (ILSA), a population-based ...
