PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Men appear to bully more commonly than women in academic medicine

More than two thirds of perpetrators are men, more than half the victims are women and less than a third of victims report the bullying they have experienced, say researchers

2021-07-13
(Press-News.org) A greater proportion of men than women exhibit bullying behaviours during medical training and academic practice, and only a minority of victims report their experiences, suggests new research published in the online journal BMJ Open.

Previous studies have reported that bullying is common in medicine with likely impacts on mental health, professional interactions, and career advancement. Surveys from the UK's NHS have reported 55% of staff experienced bullying and around a third were doctors in training. The prevalence of academic bullying within medical settings is unknown.

Therefore a team of researchers led by Dr Harriette Van Spall from McMaster University in Hamilton, Canada, set out to investigate the dynamics and consequences of bullying in academic medical settings and identify useful interventions by reviewing existing studies.

They systematically reviewed 68 suitable studies carried out between 1999 and February 2021 that represented 82,349 consultants or trainees collectively, based in hospitals or clinics that were affiliated with universities or had trained medical students, residents or fellows.

The included studies addressed either the prevalence of and impact of bullying behaviours, characteristics of perpetrators and victims, barriers and facilitators of academic bullying, or potential interventions. Most of the included studies were set in the US and the UK.

The term "academic bullying" was described as the abuse of authority that impeded the education or career of the victim through punishing behaviours that included overwork, destabilisation and isolation in academic settings.

In their review and analysis, the researchers found that among individuals who responded about bullying patterns in 28 studies, the most commonly described (38.2% of respondents) was undue pressure to produce work.

In addition, among individuals in 33 studies who reported the impact of bullying, the most common impact was psychological distress (39.1% of respondents).

Collectively, respondents identified the most common bullies to be consultants (53.6% of respondents in 30 studies), followed by residents (22%), and nurses (14.9%).

Among demographic groups, men were identified as the most common perpetrators (67.2% of respondents in five studies) while women were the most common victims (56.2% of respondents in 27 studies).

Despite being bullied, less than a third of victims (28.9% of victims in 25 studies) reported the bullying and more than half (57.5%) of those who made a formal report did not have a positive outcome. Fear of career impact and lack of perceived benefit were the most common reasons cited for not reporting bullying.

Institutional factors that perpetuate bullying included hierarchical power structures, normalisation of bullying, and a lack of enforcement of anti-bullying policies.

In addition to addressing the hierarchies and permissive environments that make academic bullying common, a range of strategies were described in 49 of the studies reviewed.

These included anti-bullying policies, education, anti-bullying oversight committees, institutional support for victims, and mandatory workshops on mistreatment. The strategies had varying levels of success and the methods used to test these interventions in the studies were not robust.

The authors acknowledge several limitations in the surveys that they analysed, including the lack of a consistent definition of academic bullying, the variation in questions across studies, suboptimal response rates, the lack of validation of instruments, and selection bias.

Nevertheless, the authors' research was broad in scope with a large, diverse cohort including several specialties of medicine and countries.

They conclude: "Bullies are commonly men and senior consultants, and more than half the victims are women. The fear of reprisal, lack of impact of reporting, and non-enforcement of anti-bullying policies are the greatest barriers to addressing academic bullying. Methodologically robust trials of anti-bullying interventions are needed."

INFORMATION:

Externally peer reviewed? Yes
Evidence type: Systematic review
Subjects: People



ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

New study supports medical safety of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT)

New study supports medical safety  of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT)
2021-07-13
Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) is a medically safe mental health intervention, according to a new study led by CAMH researcher Dr. Tyler Kaster as part of his doctoral studies at ICES and the University of Toronto. The study was published today in the journal The Lancet Psychiatry, and is among the largest and most comprehensive to compare the safety of ECT with standard treatment amongst individuals with depression. Multiple studies over a period of decades have confirmed the effectiveness of ECT as a mental health intervention for people with treatment-resistant depression. Up to 80 per cent of people with severe depression who receive ECT achieve remission. However, despite this success rate, only one per cent of people with severe depression ever ...

When a single tree makes a difference

2021-07-13
A single tree along a city street or in a backyard can provide measurable cooling benefits, according to a new study from American University. The research shows that "distributed" trees, those that are stand-alone and scattered throughout urban neighborhoods, can help to reduce evening heat. The research suggests that planting individual trees can be a strategy to mitigate urban heat, particularly in areas where land for parks can be scarce. "There are plenty of good reasons to plant trees, but our study shows we shouldn't underestimate the role that individual trees can play in mitigating heat in urban areas," said Michael ...

Do more visits with kidney specialists improve dialysis patient-reported outcomes?

2021-07-13
Highlights Patients with kidney failure did not report better experience with care from more frequent face-to-face visits with kidney specialists at dialysis facilities. In fact, more frequent visits were linked with slightly lower patient-reported experiences with kidney-related care. Washington, DC (July 12, 2021) -- In a recent analysis, more frequent kidney specialists' visits to clinics where patients with kidney failure undergo outpatient hemodialysis were not associated with more favorable patient-reported experiences with care. In fact, more frequent visits were associated with slightly lower patient-reported experiences. The findings will appear in an upcoming ...

Discovery of 10 faces of plasma leads to new insights in fusion and plasma science

Discovery of 10 faces of plasma leads to new insights in fusion and plasma science
2021-07-13
Scientists have discovered a novel way to classify magnetized plasmas that could possibly lead to advances in harvesting on Earth the fusion energy that powers the sun and stars. The discovery by theorists at the U.S. Department of Energy's (DOE) Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory (PPPL) found that a magnetized plasma has 10 unique phases and the transitions between them might hold rich implications for practical development. The spatial boundaries, or transitions, between different phases will support localized wave excitations, the researchers found. "These findings could lead to possible applications of these exotic excitations ...

Emotions and culture are most important for acceptance of carnivore management strategies

Emotions and culture are most important for acceptance of carnivore management strategies
2021-07-13
Emotions towards and cultural importance of large carnivores are better predictors of the acceptance of management strategies by local communities than the extent of livestock depredation. This is the result of a new interdisciplinary investigation led by scientists from the Leibniz Institute for Zoo and Wildlife Research (Leibniz-IZW). They conducted 100 questionnaires with Maasai pastoralists in Ngorongoro Conservation Area, Tanzania, focusing on three large carnivore species (spotted hyenas, lions and leopards) and three management strategies (no action, relocation and lethal control). An emphasis on socio-cultural variables is key to ...

Phasecraft reveals a more efficient method for modelling electrons in materials

Phasecraft reveals a more efficient method for modelling electrons in materials
2021-07-13
One of the most significant challenges in the global R&D effort towards better energy technologies -- efficient and accurate material simulation -- may be one step closer to being solved, based on new techniques released by UK-based quantum software startup Phasecraft. The new peer-reviewed study in the Physical Review B journal from the American Physical Society sets out a novel technique for modelling fermionic particles -- like electrons -- which significantly reduces the quantum hardware resources needed to perform simulations. Phasecraft's Joel Klassen, who co-led the study, explained, "One of the most exciting potential applications for quantum computing ...

Study shows forests play greater role in depositing toxic mercury across the globe

Study shows forests play greater role in depositing toxic mercury across the globe
2021-07-13
LOWELL, Mass. - Researchers led by a UMass Lowell environmental science professor say mercury measurements in a Massachusetts forest indicate the toxic element is deposited in forests across the globe in much greater quantities than previously understood. The team's results underscore concern for the health and well-being of people, wildlife and waterways, according to Prof. Daniel Obrist, as mercury accumulating in forests ultimately runs off into streams and rivers, ending up in lakes and oceans. Mercury is a highly toxic pollutant that threatens fish, birds, mammals and humans. Hundreds of tons of it are ...

Marijuana legalization linked to temporary decrease in opioid-related emergency visits

Marijuana legalization linked to temporary decrease in opioid-related emergency visits
2021-07-12
PITTSBURGH, July 12, 2021 - States that legalize recreational marijuana experience a short-term decline in opioid-related emergency department visits, particularly among 25- to 44-year-olds and men, according to an analysis led by the University of Pittsburgh Graduate School of Public Health. Published today in the journal Health Economics, the study shows that even after the temporary decline wears off, recreational cannabis laws are not associated with increases in opioid-related emergency department visits. "This isn't trivial--a decline in opioid-related emergency department visits, even if only for six months, is a welcome public health development," said lead author Coleman Drake, Ph.D., assistant professor ...

AAN issues ethical guidance for dementia diagnosis and care

2021-07-12
MINNEAPOLIS - The American Academy of Neurology (AAN), the world's largest association of neurologists with more than 36,000 members, is issuing ethical guidance for neurologists and neuroscience professionals who care for people with Alzheimer's disease and other dementias. The new position statement is published in the July 12, 2021 online issue of Neurology®, the medical journal of the American Academy of Neurology. This update to the 1996 AAN position statement was developed by the Ethics, Law, and Humanities Committee, a joint committee of the American Academy of Neurology, American Neurological Association and Child Neurology Society. "Dementia care and scientific understanding have advanced considerably, including greater recognition of non-Alzheimer's dementias and advances ...

Officers' tone of voice reflects racial disparities in policing

2021-07-12
The Black Lives Matter movement has brought increasing attention to disparities in how police officers treat Black and white Americans. Now, research published by the American Psychological Association finds that disparity may exist even in subtle differences in officers' tone of voice when they address Black and white drivers during routine traffic stops. In the study, published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, researchers gathered short audio excerpts from police body camera footage and found that when officers spoke to Black men at traffic stops, their tone of voice conveyed less warmth, respect and ease than when they spoke to white men. The researchers also found that these subtle negative interactions ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Study reveals root-lesion nematodes in maize crops - and one potential new species

Bioinspired weather-responsive adaptive shading

Researchers uncover what drives aggressive bone cancer

Just as Gouda: Improving the quality of cheese alternatives

Digital meditation to target employee stress

Electronic patient-reported outcome system implementation in outpatient cardiovascular care

Knowledge and use of menthol-mimicking cigarettes among adults in the US

Uncurling a single DNA molecule and gluing it down helps sharpen images

Medicare Advantage beneficiaries did not receive more dental, vision or hearing care

Green hydrogen: Big gaps between ambition and implementation

Global study pinpoints genes for depression across ethnicities

Epigenetics ensures placenta functioning

New computer models open door to far more targeted antibiotics

Researchers discover how cigarette smoke impairs critical lung immune cells

Commonly prescribed medications increase fall risk and related injuries in people with COPD

This metaphorical cat is both dead and alive – and it will help quantum engineers detect computing errors

Digitizing hope: Collaboration helps preserve a species on the brink of extinction

The Dark Side of the ocean: New giant sea bug species named after Darth Vader

Roman urbanites followed medical recommendations for weaning babies

Strength connected to sexual behavior of women as well as men

Eating pork linked with better handgrip strength, vegetable intake in Korean older adults

Direct discharge electrical pulses for carbon fiber recycling

Scientists uncover rapid-acting, low-side-effect antidepressant target

Diamond continues to shine: new properties discovered in diamond semiconductors

Researchers find the key to Artificial Intelligence’s learning power – an inbuilt, special kind of Occam’s razor

Genetic tweak optimizes drug-making cells by blocking buildup of toxic byproduct

University of Birmingham researchers awarded grant to tackle early-stage heart disease in chronic kidney disease

Researchers harness AI to predict cardiovascular risk from CT scans

Samsung takes top spot in U.S. patents for third year running while TSMC rises into second place; after four-year falloff, grants increase nearly 4%

HKU ecologist highlights critical gaps in global wildlife trade monitoring

[Press-News.org] Men appear to bully more commonly than women in academic medicine
More than two thirds of perpetrators are men, more than half the victims are women and less than a third of victims report the bullying they have experienced, say researchers