(Press-News.org) A new type of regulation is needed to support and encourage organisations to comply with equality and human rights law because enforcement alone is ineffective, a new study says.
The introduction of the Public Sector Equality Duty and the Human Rights Act were intended to establish an equality and human rights culture within public authorities. The research highlights how this culture has failed to take hold.
An alternative is needed to the current model of regulation (the enforcement pyramid) under which penalties increasingly progress until noncompliers comply. The study says the current model cannot recognise innovation, good practice or the reasons why organisations struggle to comply. Some organisations may lack confidence or feel overwhelmed rather than intentionally choosing not to follow the rules.
Dr David Barrett, from the University of Exeter Law School, analysed original empirical data and interviewed individuals within regulators and inspectorates and ombudsmen. He found firms are implementing the duty in three ways: strong implementation (where individuals make the most of the resources they have and drive ever deeper implementation), mixed implementation (where individuals oscillate between deeper and perfunctory implementation), and weak implementation (where individuals avoid taking meaningful action due to feeling overwhelmed and in need of rescue).
Dr Barrett said: “Equality and human rights laws require organisations to adjust and reconfigure themselves to mainstream the values of equality and human rights. This requires a model of enforcement that assists organisations, builds capabilities and ultimately sanctions organisations if they fail to comply.
“Ever severe punishment is unlikely to secure meaningful mainstreaming and instead is likely to result in minimal and perfunctory performance. What is needed is encouragement and support, but this cannot be adequately provided by the current enforcement pyramid.”
The study recommends there should be a “strength-based” pyramid, which would work alongside the enforcement based pyramid. This would involve increasing incentives in the form of education and persuasion, validation and encouragement, grants and awards, that would hopefully work to incentivise individuals and their organisations to embed equality and human rights ever deeper into the organisation.
Dr Barrett found a significant barrier to implementation is the finite number of resources - including money, staff and time. Even where staff had more interest in equality and human rights, time was still a significant constraint. Most staff have knowledge of the sector that they oversee rather than equality and human rights, meaning that it is difficult to integrate these norms into the work of the organisation.
Confidence was an important issue in relation to staff and often deterred staff from taking action. The majority of interviewees operated outside the top leadership of the organisation, and many spoke of the challenges imposed by the senior leadership.
The study recommends, as part of a strength-based system, organisations could apply either singularly or collectively (for example a network) for grants to further the implementation of equality and human rights. Eligibility requirements could be established to incentivise moving up the pyramid.
Organisations that had particularly excelled in equality and human rights could apply to be accredited. Awards could also be given to individual implementers to recognise and encourage innovation.
END
A new regulatory model which supports and encourages needed to help organizations comply with equalities legislation, study says
2023-09-20
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Stabilizing precipitate growth at grain boundaries in alloys
2023-09-20
Materials are often considered to be one phase, but many engineering materials contain two or more phases, improving their properties and performance. These two-phase materials have inclusions, called precipitates, embedded in the microstructure. Alloys, a combination of two or more types of metals, are used in many applications, like turbines for jet engines and light-weight alloys for automotive applications, because they have very good mechanical properties due to those embedded precipitates. The average precipitate size, however, tends to increase ...
Researchers discover biomarker for tracking depression recovery
2023-09-20
Using a novel deep brain stimulation (DBS) device capable of recording brain signals, researchers have identified a pattern of brain activity or “biomarker” related to clinical signs of recovery from treatment-resistant depression. The findings from this small study are an important step towards using brain data to understand a patient’s response to DBS treatment. The study was published in Nature and supported by the National Institutes of Health’s Brain Research Through Advancing ...
NIH awards $3.1 million to study human mitochondrial disorders
2023-09-20
The Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development awarded $3.1 million to the University of Arkansas to study a spectrum of pediatric mitochondrial disorders caused by mutations in the mitochondria. These disorders often impact different organs requiring energy and can lead to mitochondria-induced multiple organ disorder syndromes, or MIMODS.
Shilpa Iyer, an associate professor of biological sciences, will serve as the principal investigator on the five-year award. Iyer and her team conduct research on mitochondrial diseases and have received grants from Arkansas ...
Newly discovered bone stem cell causes premature skull fusion
2023-09-20
Craniosynostosis, the premature fusion of the top of the skull in infants, is caused by an abnormal excess of a previously unknown type of bone-forming stem cell, according to a preclinical study led by researchers at Weill Cornell Medicine.
Craniosynostosis arises from one of several possible gene mutations, and occurs in about one in 2,500 babies. By constricting brain growth, it can lead to abnormal brain development if not corrected surgically. In complex cases, multiple surgeries are needed.
In the study, which appears Sept. 20 in Nature, the researchers examined in detail what happens in the skull of mice with one of the most common mutations found in human ...
Disrupting a core metabolic process in T cells may improve their therapeutic efficacy
2023-09-20
SEPTEMBER 20, 2023, NEW YORK – In exploring an aspect of how killer T cells generate the raw materials required for their proliferation, a Ludwig Cancer Research study has uncovered an unexpected link between the immune cells’ metabolism, regulation of gene expression, persistence and functional efficacy that could be exploited using existing drugs to improve cancer immunotherapy.
Researchers led by Ludwig Lausanne’s Alison Jaccard and Ping-Chih Ho along with their University of Lausanne colleagues Mathias Wenes and Pedro Romero were exploring how proliferating T cells in the low-oxygen environment of tumors make citrate, a molecule essential to manufacturing membranes, which ...
Exercise and muscle regulation: implications for diabetes and obesity
2023-09-20
How do our muscles respond at the molecular level to exercise? Researchers at Helmholtz Munich and the German Institute of Human Nutrition Potsdam-Rehbrücke (DIfE) have unraveled the cellular basis and signaling pathways responsible for the positive impact of physical activity on our overall health. Regulatory T cells, a type of immune cell, play a critical role in ensuring proper muscle function. These novel insights are paving the path towards precision medicines targeting metabolic disorders like obesity and diabetes, as well as muscle-related illnesses. Their discoveries are published in Cell Metabolism.
Obesity and type ...
Study reveals structure of crucial receptor in brain development, function
2023-09-20
Scientists have revealed the molecular structure of a type of receptor that’s crucial to brain development and function.
Known as Type A GABA receptors, these receptors are already targeted by pharmaceutical anesthetics, sedatives and antidepressants because of their important role in brain function. The discovery, published today in the journal Nature, reveals the dominant assemblies and states of the GABA receptor, a finding that could enable the development of new compounds that more specifically target a range of medical disorders.
“It is the main player that balances excitation and inhibition in the ...
How to tackle the global deforestation crisis
2023-09-20
Imagine if France, Germany, and Spain were completely blanketed in forests — and then all those trees were quickly chopped down. That’s nearly the amount of deforestation that occurred globally between 2001 and 2020, with profound consequences.
Deforestation is a major contributor to climate change, producing between 6 and 17 percent of global greenhouse gas emissions, according to a 2009 study. Meanwhile, because trees also absorb carbon dioxide, removing it from the atmosphere, they help keep the Earth cooler. ...
Language acquisition may work differently in people with autism
2023-09-20
You’re looking at a truck. You’re with a young child and he follows your gaze. He’s interested in the object you’re looking at without you pointing at it. This is called joint attention and it is one of the primary ways children learn to connect words with objects and acquire language.
Lack of joint attention is a core feature of autism. Until now, it was thought that stimulating joint attention in people with autism would help them express themselves verbally. But a meta-analysis of 71 studies on autism challenges this assumption and suggests that people with autism spectrum disorders may acquire language differently.
The study – by Laurent Mottron, ...
Upgrading iron and steel plants could save equivalent of two years of global carbon emissions
2023-09-20
Upgrading, or retrofitting, the world's iron and steel processing plants early could reduce carbon emissions by up to 70 gigatonnes by 2050, roughly equivalent to two years' worth of net global carbon emissions, according to a new study led by UCL researchers.
Published in the journal Nature, the researchers found that by upgrading the world’s iron and steel production facilities, carbon emissions can be reduced by 58.7 gigatonnes between 2020 and 2050, roughly equivalent to two years’ worth of net global carbon emissions. ...