(Press-News.org) Key Takeaways
Young women under the age of 30, Black women, and women with lower education levels are disproportionately affected by intimate partner homicide during pregnancy, reflecting the need to better serve and protect these vulnerable populations.
Particularly by firearms, increasing rates of intimate partner homicide of women who are pregnant or recently pregnant are occurring in states that have limited access to abortion.
Researchers describe a ‘dire need’ to develop effective interventions that break the cycle of intimate partner violence and prevent further deaths.
CHICAGO: Pregnant women living in states with limited access to abortion are experiencing higher rates of intimate partner homicide, particularly by firearms, according to a new study published in the Journal of the American College of Surgeons (JACS).
In an analysis of 9,140 homicides of women aged 12-50 years old, researchers at the University of Chicago found that women who were pregnant or recently pregnant (defined as up to one year post-partum) at the time of their death were 14% more likely to die from homicide at the hands of an intimate partner compared to women who were not pregnant.
They also found that homicides of women who are pregnant or recently pregnant occur at significantly higher rates in states that have limited access to abortion. This state-based trend was not observed in homicides of men, suggesting that access to reproductive health care services may be one factor of many that increase a woman’s risk of intimate partner homicide, the authors said.
“This study reveals that in the United States, there’s an epidemic of preventable violence that disproportionately affects vulnerable populations, including peripartum people,” said Grace Keegan, a third-year medical student at the University of Chicago Pritzker School of Medicine and lead author of the study. “There’s a stark reality that the U.S. health care system lags behind many comparable nations in the prioritization of women’s health. Our country’s maternal mortality rates are extremely high, and what’s even more striking is that the greatest contributor to the high mortality rate is homicide.”
The researchers analyzed data from the National Violent Death Reporting System (NVDRS) of homicides that occurred between the years 2018-2020, before the U.S. Supreme Court decision that overturned Roe v. Wade in 2022. States were classified as restrictive, neutral, or protective towards access to abortion based on classification from the Guttmacher Institute.
Among other key findings of the study:
Between 2018-2020, nearly 500 women aged 12-50 years old were killed by an intimate partner during their peripartum period.
Women who were victims of homicide during the peripartum period were younger (27 years old vs. 33 years old), had lower education status, and were less likely to be married (17% vs. 20%) compared to women not in the peripartum period.
Black women, who make up about 13% of the U.S. population, were disproportionately affected by intimate partner homicide during the peripartum period, accounting for half of the victims. The authors note that this disparity reflects factors in our social and economic systems that contribute to reduced access to reproductive health care in this population.
Firearms were the most frequent weapon used in peripartum homicide, accounting for 63.4% of homicides among the peripartum group compared to 49.5% in women who were not pregnant or recently pregnant.
States categorized as being restrictive to abortion access had a 75% higher rate of peripartum homicide. Peripartum homicide deaths per total state population were highest overall in two states considered restrictive to abortion, Louisiana and Missouri, and one state considered protective to abortion, Nevada.
As a comparison, homicides of men across the same age range and state-based categories did not show the same trends.
“These numbers are staggering. Compared to other high-income countries, the U.S. is a standalone nation in the number of peripartum homicides that we’re seeing,” said co-author Tanya Zakrison, MD, MPH, FACS, a professor of surgery and director of critical trauma research at University of Chicago Medicine. “Intimate partner homicide is absolutely an epidemic of preventable violence, and I think something else that was shocking is how firearms figure so predominantly in the peripartum homicide group compared to the non-peripartum homicide group.”
Although this research did not focus on why women may be most vulnerable to violence during or just after pregnancy, previous research has revealed that several social determinants of health, including food insecurity, psychosocial stress, and housing instability, are associated with an increased risk of firearm violence. These factors are likely exacerbated during pregnancy, when couples may experience increased demands and economic vulnerability.
Breaking a vicious cycle
In their paper, the authors say there is a ‘dire need’ of increased universal screening efforts and effective interventions to break the cycle of violence. Several screening tools for intimate partner violence (IPV) are available, but medical professionals may not be adequately trained on how to provide women with tangible resources once they screen positive for IPV.
“As a society, we need to address the intersectional root causes that have driven our society to this sad reality that we’re in today,” said senior author Justin Cirone, MD, an assistant professor of surgery at Wake Forest School of Medicine in Charlotte, North Carolina.
Stephanie L. Bonne, MD, FACS, FCCM, FAMWA, Chair of the ACS IPV Task Force who was not involved with the research study, noted that all medical professionals should be aware that IPV is a serious, preventable cause of mortality in the U.S. Data from this paper should serve as a warning call to improve resources for vulnerable populations.
“The authors of this peer-reviewed study have shown a specific risk to pregnant women, one that is increased by lack of access to abortion care and easy access to firearms,” said Dr. Bonne, who also serves as chief of trauma and surgical critical care at Hackensack University Medical Center in Hackensack, New Jersey. “These data can be used to inform the development of specific health, policy, and social interventions that can mitigate this problem and keep women and their children safe and healthy.”
The authors noted some limitations of their study. While the NVDRS database is one of the most comprehensive databases of violent deaths, the study is retrospective and does not include near-death experiences that may have occurred. In addition, the researchers could not discern from the data women who were killed but did not know they were pregnant at the time of their death; other reports may be lacking if the police homicide report did not note a recent pregnancy.
“There’s a near certainty that we’re missing many more women than were actually documented,” Dr. Cirone noted.
Lastly, the authors excluded four states from the analysis (Florida, Idaho, North Dakota, and South Dakota) because these states joined the NVDRS in 2018 and had incomplete data at that time; the data also includes the year 2020, during which COVID-19 pandemic lockdowns were prevalent and domestic violence was reported to be higher than usual.
Study coauthors are Mark Hoofnagle, MD, PhD; Julie Chor, MD, MPH; David Hampton, MD; Jennifer Cone, MD, FACS; Abid Khan, MD; Susan Rowell, MD, MBA, FACS; Timothy Plackett, DO, MPH; Andrew Benjamin, MD; Neha Bhardwaj, MD, MS; Selwyn O. Rogers, MD, FACS.
The study is published as an article in press on the JACS website. The study was also presented at the American Association for the Surgery of Trauma (AAST) Annual Meeting on September 21, 2023, in Anaheim, California.
Resources on IPV for Patients
Resources on IPV for Surgeons
Disclosures: This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors. Dr. Zakrison is supported by the NIH (1UG3HD111325, 3UG3HD111325), the Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention, and the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. The authors have no disclosures to report related to the scope of this research.
Citation: Keegan G, Hoofnagle M, Chor J. State-Level Analysis of Intimate Partner Violence, Abortion Access, and Peripartum Homicide: A Call for Screening and Violence Interventions for Pregnant Patients. Journal of the American College of Surgeons, 2024. DOI: 10.1097/XCS.0000000000001019
# # #
About the American College of Surgeons
The American College of Surgeons (ACS) is a scientific and educational organization of surgeons that was founded in 1913 to raise the standards of surgical practice and improve the quality of care for all surgical patients. The ACS is dedicated to the ethical and competent practice of surgery. Its achievements have significantly influenced the course of scientific surgery in America and have established it as an important advocate for all surgical patients. The ACS has approximately 90,000 members and is the largest organization of surgeons in the world. “FACS” designates that a surgeon is a Fellow of the ACS.
Follow the ACS on social media: X | Instagram | YouTube | LinkedIn | Facebook
Pregnant women living in states with limited access to abortion face higher levels of intimate partner homicide
Study finds significant differences in homicide rates of pregnant women, particularly by firearms, between states based on policies regarding abortion access
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Researchers uncover genetic factors for severe Lassa fever
While combing through the human genome in 2007, computational geneticist Pardis Sabeti made a discovery that would transform her research career. As a then postdoctoral fellow at the Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard, Sabeti discovered potential evidence that some unknown mutation in a gene called LARGE1 had a beneficial effect in the Nigerian population. Other scientists had discovered that this gene was critical for the Lassa virus to enter cells. Sabeti wondered whether a mutation in LARGE1 ...
Leader in robotics at U-M and beyond elected to National Academy of Engineering
Feb. 8, 2024 Contact: Katherine McAlpine, 734-647-7087, email@example.com Image Leader in robotics at U-M and beyond elected to National Academy of Engineering Dawn Tilbury is recognized for advances in manufacturing network control and human-robot interaction, as well as engineering leadership ANN ARBOR—Dawn Tilbury, the Ronald D. and Regina C. McNeil Department Chair of Robotics at the University of Michigan, has been recognized with one of engineering's greatest honors—election to the National Academy of Engineering. NAE members are outstanding researchers, ...
16 UTA scholars receive McNair federal research award
A competitive U.S. Department of Education program that prepares undergraduate students interested in careers in academic research has selected 16 undergraduate students from The University of Texas at Arlington to join. The McNair Scholars Program was named for physicist and astronaut Ronald E. McNair, the second Black astronaut in U.S. history and one of several crew members killed when the space shuttle Challenger exploded on Jan. 28, 1986. The program assists qualified first-generation ...
Nanofiber bandages fight infection, speed healing
ITHACA, N.Y. – Cornell University researchers have identified a new way to harness the antioxidant and antibacterial properties of a botanical compound to make nanofiber-coated cotton bandages that fight infection and help wounds heal more quickly. The findings are especially important given the increasing prevalence of multidrug-resistant bacteria. Cotton gauze is one of the most common wound dressings; it’s inexpensive, readily available, comfortable and biocompatible. However, it doesn’t promote healing or fight infection. “Cotton alone cannot provide an answer for these ...
Newly discovered genetic malfunction causes rare lung disease
The macrophage is one of the body’s most important inhabitants. Meaning “big eater” in Greek, this immune cell consumes and digests problematic elements from microbes and cancer cells to dust and debris. Macrophages are especially important in the lungs, where they both fight bacterial infection and clear the lungs of excess surfactant, a protein- and lipid-rich layer that’s essential to healthy function but can create a sticky buildup if not controlled. In a recent study, investigators from Rockefeller University ...
Even with resolution, acute kidney injury in newborns can be life-threatening from very first episode
Our resilient kidneys are invaluable members of the body’s purification system, and they excel at bouncing back after injury. This even holds true for most sick infants in the neonatal intensive care unit. Because of this remarkable ability, dips in kidney function in infants were often overlooked historically in favor of other pressing diseases or symptoms. But physicians and researchers have shown increased interest in understanding kidney health in newborns and young infants within the last decade, leading to the AWAKEN study (Assessment of Worldwide Acute Kidney Epidemiology in Neonates). With initial ...
High-profile incidents of police brutality sway public opinion more than performance of people’s local law enforcement, new study from NYU Tandon reveals
National media coverage of police brutality influences public perceptions of law enforcement more than the performance of people’s local police departments, according to data analysis from NYU Tandon School of Engineering, challenging the assumption that public confidence in police depends mostly on feeling safe from local crime. In a study published in Communications Psychology, a NYU Tandon research team tracked media coverage of police brutality in 18 metropolitan areas in the United States – along with coverage of local crimes – and analyzed tweets from those cities to tease out positive attitudes from negative ...
Why politics bring out the worst in us
Tap into any social media platform, turn on the television or cue up a podcast, and it is easy to find examples of hypocrisy or bad behavior in political discourse, and new research from University of Nebraska–Lincoln political scientists may explain why. The findings from a large survey study, co-authored by Kyle Hull, Kevin Smith and Clarisse Warren, demonstrate the willingness of people to bend their morals — even behave unethically — when engaging in the political realm. Results also suggest that hostility toward outgroups (i.e., opposing party) is the driving factor for the moral ambiguity exercised ...
How fruit flies control the brain's "steering wheel"
When we walk down the street, we have an internal sense of which way we are heading, from looking at street signals and physical landmarks, and also a sense of where we’d like to go. But how does the brain coordinate between these directions, doing the mental math that tells us which way to turn? Now, new research describes such a neural process in fruit flies, providing insight into how an animal’s brain steers it in the right direction. The study, published in Nature , shows how neurons that signal the direction in which a fly is currently oriented work together with neurons that signal the direction in which way the ...
SwRI’s Dr. Alan Stern named AIAA Fellow
SAN ANTONIO — February 8, 2024 —Dr. Alan Stern, a planetary scientist and associate vice president of Southwest Research Institute’s Space Sector, has been named a Fellow of the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics (AIAA). Fellows are recognized for their notable and valuable contributions to the arts, sciences or technology of aeronautics and astronautics. AIAA cited Stern “for outstanding contributions to the exploration of the solar system and the development of commercial spaceflight.” “I am honored beyond words to be named an AIAA Fellow and thank my nominators very much, including SwRI Vice President Dr. Ben Thacker, who led the nomination,” ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Many older adults receiving home care do not receive palliative care before death
Reforestation schemes are not enough to recover the carbon created by harvesting wood, research suggests
Antidepressant dispensing to adolescents and young adults surges during pandemic
Healthcare leaders plea to reinstate the Canadian hypertension control program to prevent death and disability
Drug limits dangerous reactions to allergy-triggering foods, Stanford Medicine-led study of kids finds
Measuring the properties of light: Scientists realise new method for determining quantum states
For faster access to gene and cell therapies in Europe
Scientists deliver portable total chemical analysis without pumps and tubes
A very long, winding road: Developing novel therapeutics for metastatic tumors
Unlocking health: How In Our DNA SC is pioneering genetic screening for South Carolinians
Down Under Demo: ONR touts additive manufacturing tech at Australian event
Study shows benralizumab is effective as a treatment for eosinophilic granulomatosis with polyangiitis, a rare form of vasculitis
Researchers identify new choice of therapy for rare autoimmune disease EGPA
NJIT marketing experts measure brain waves and skin current to predict emotions
Babies use immune system differently, but efficiently
Cloud clustering causes more extreme rain
Mindfulness at work protects against stress and burnout
Scientists closer to solving mysteries of universe after measuring gravity in quantum world
Revolutionary brain stimulation technique shows promise for treating brain disorders
Global warming increases the diversity of active soil bacteria
Patient mindset training helps care teams
Dual-energy harvesting device could power future wireless medical implants
Study: ‘Hexaplex’ vaccine aims to boost flu protection
New structural insights could lead to mechanical enhancement in alloys
New research challenges conventional picture of Parkinson's disease
Dairy cows fed botanicals-supplemented diets use energy more efficiently
Aston University receives nearly half a million pounds to create safer and greener batteries
New study shows glycan sugar coating of IgG immunoglobulin can predict cardiovascular health
Sir Peter Rigby appointed as honorary chair of Aston University’s new Digital Futures Institute[Press-News.org] Pregnant women living in states with limited access to abortion face higher levels of intimate partner homicide
Study finds significant differences in homicide rates of pregnant women, particularly by firearms, between states based on policies regarding abortion access