PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

New study shows individuals prefer when firms stay apolitical on polarizing issues

2025-05-06
(Press-News.org) Customers often prefer companies aligned with their values, but it has been less clear how they react to firms taking a stance on a polarizing topic. A new study published in Strategic Management Journal explores how individuals respond to firms' communications around a polarizing political issue: whether firms take an apolitical stance, say nothing, or choose an ideological stance. The findings highlight how firm and communication characteristics influence the ways in which individuals' opinions of the firm are affected by management’s political activism, and how individuals may prefer firms to stay neutral.

The research team — Tommaso Bondi of Cornell University, Vanessa C. Burbano of Columbia University, and Fabrizio Dell'Acqua of Harvard Business School — were curious to better explore how the ways in which a company takes a political stance affects individuals’ responses. They also wanted to include options of not taking a stance, either expressly or passively, as a choice that CEOs can make.

“That particular distinction was an important one to delineate,” Burbano says. “It's not necessarily the same for a company to explicitly say, ‘We're not going to wade into politics,’ versus staying silent, [which are] potential strategic choices for firms.”

For their research, the team focused on three questions: How does a firm's expected political leaning influence individuals’ responses to its political communication? Do people react differently to the communication of a stance that is backed by the promise of a monetary commitment versus not? And, lastly, the researchers wanted to differentiate between the strategic choice of communicating an explicitly apolitical stance versus staying silent, thus asking: Do individuals prefer communication of an apolitical stance to either communication of an ideological stance or remaining silent, and if so, under what circumstances?

The researchers conducted two survey-based vignette experiments between November 2020 (prior to the U.S. presidential elections) and January 2021 (right after the storming of the U.S. Capitol building), a time period when CEOs were actively communicating stances on political issues. In the first study, the researchers manipulated the information provided to survey respondents about a hypothetical firm's stance regarding an issue, as well as firm characteristics likely to influence individuals' expectations about the firm's positioning (i.e., whether the firm is left-leaning, right-leaning, or centrist). In the second study, the team also manipulated whether the firm’s communication of a partisan stance is backed by the promise of monetary support.

The researchers found that, for an issue with split opinions, a CEO’s partisan communication in either direction will result in negative perceptions of the firm on average. So while individuals who agree with the stance respond positively and individuals who disagree with the stance respond negatively, the negative effects generally outweigh the positive. In addition, the negative average effect is even stronger for firms that are expected to be neutral in their positioning.

Communicating an apolitical stance, the team found, actually increases individuals' perceptions of the firm on average, in particular among Republicans and Independents, when the firm is otherwise expected to lean in one ideological direction or another. The researchers found no additional benefit from communicating an apolitical stance if the organization was considered neutral.

“Silence may not be perceived as neutral,” Bondi says. “If you're a tech firm in California or an oil firm in Alaska, you might still be perceived as political, because there are prior assumptions made by individuals. In that case, it brings a benefit to the firm to just very clearly say, ‘We are absolutely indifferent between these two options.’”

The researchers also determined that, for a less polarizing political issue about which opinion is largely homogeneous, communicating a political stance that aligns with the prevailing opinion on the issue increases positive opinion of the firm on average, compared to either silence or communicating an apolitical stance. Additionally, referencing monetary backing of the political stance serves to strengthen the effects of the stance, whether positive or negative.

The findings suggest that individuals do not want firms to talk about polarizing politics in business: either staying silent when expected to be politically neutral or communicating an apolitical stance when expected to lean in one ideological direction led to the most positive perceptions of the firm.

“You could benefit from being perceived as apolitical,” Burbano says. “If there is a way to adjust people's perceptions from viewing you as a partisan, ideologically aligned company to one that is apolitical and focused on doing what's best for its customers, our study suggests that that's probably the best path forward.”

To read the full context of the study and its methods, access the full paper available in the Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal.

About the Strategic Management Society

The Strategic Management Society (SMS) is the leading global member organization fostering and supporting rigorous and practice-engaged strategic management research. SMS enjoys the support of 3,000 members, representing more than 1,100 institutions and companies in more than 70 countries. SMS publishes three leading academic journals in partnership with Wiley: Strategic Management Journal, Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal, and Global Strategy Journal. These journals publish top-quality work applicable to researchers and practitioners with complementary access for all SMS Members. The SMS Explorer offers the latest insights and takeaways from the SMS Journals for business practitioners, consultants, and academics.

Click here to subscribe to the monthly SMS Explorer newsletter.

Click here to learn more about the programs and opportunities SMS has to offer.

END


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

University of Tennessee designated a National Center of Academic Excellence in Cybersecurity

2025-05-06
The number and sophistication of cyberattacks has increased significantly in recent years. According to the United States Federal Bureau of Investigation, economic losses from cybercrime in the US exceeded $4 billion in 2020 and skyrocketed to $16 billion in 2024. Beyond their monetary impacts, cyberattacks can cause significant harm. “A significant number of cyberattacks are on critical infrastructure, like smart electrical grids or water meters,” said Himanshu Thapliyal, an ...

Research update: Okra, fenugreek extracts remove most microplastics from water

2025-05-06
The substances behind the slimy strings from okra and the gel from fenugreek seeds could trap microplastics better than a commonly used synthetic polymer. Previously, researchers proposed using these sticky natural polymers to clean up water. Now, they report in ACS Omega that okra and/or fenugreek extracts attracted and removed up to 90% of microplastics in ocean water, freshwater and groundwater. Rajani Srinivasan and colleagues have been exploring nontoxic, plant-based approaches to attract ...

Heat and drought are quietly hurting crop yields

2025-05-06
More frequent hot weather and droughts have dealt a significant blow to crop yields, especially for key grains like wheat, barley, and maize, according to a Stanford study published this week in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. The analysis finds that warming and air dryness – a key factor in crop stress – have surged in nearly every major agricultural region, with some areas experiencing growing seasons hotter than nearly any season 50 years ago. The study also pointed to two important ways that models have missed the mark ...

Gender characteristics of service robots can influence customer decisions

2025-05-06
UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — The hospitality industry can leverage the gender characteristics of service robots to influence customers’ decisions, according to new research from a team in the Penn State School of Hospitality Management. Service robots with characteristics typically associated with males may be more persuasive when interacting with women who have a low sense of power, according to the researchers. The team also found that “cute” features in the design of robots — such as big eyes and raised cheeks — may reduce the effect of portrayed robot gender on persuasiveness, as male and female ...

Ultra-thin bismuth holds unexpected promise for green electronics: researcher

2025-05-06
Electronic devices rely on materials whose electrical properties change with temperature, making them less stable in extreme conditions. A discovery by McGill University researchers that challenges conventional wisdom in physics suggests that bismuth, a metal, could serve as the foundation for highly stable electronic components. The researchers observed a mysterious electrical effect in ultra-thin bismuth that remains unchanged across a wide temperature range, from near absolute zero (-273°C) to room temperature. “If we can harness this, it could become important for green electronics,” said Guillaume ...

Discovery: a better, more targeted termite terminator

2025-05-06
Drywood termites, the ones that hide in wooden structures, molt about seven times in their lives. UC Riverside researchers have found a chemical preventing them from growing new exoskeletons will also end their infestation of your home. The chemical, bistrifluron, and its ability to kill about 95 percent of a termite colony without off-target effects on mammals, are documented in a paper published in the Journal of Economic Entomology. “This chemical is more environmentally friendly than ones traditionally used for drywood termite infestations,” said Nicholas Poulos, corresponding author of the paper and a doctoral student in UCR’s Department of Entomology. ...

Researchers harness brain activity to look at how we perceive faces from other racial groups differently

2025-05-06
U of T Scarborough researchers have harnessed artificial intelligence (AI) and brain activity to shed new light on why we struggle to accurately recognize faces of people from different races.  Across a pair of studies, researchers explored the Other-Race-Effect (ORE), a well-known phenomenon in which people recognize faces of their own race more easily than others. They combined AI and brain activity collected through EEG (electroencephalography) to reveal new insights into how we perceive other-race faces, including visual distortions more deeply ingrained in our brain than previously ...

New research finds leadership-backed training key to better policing

2025-05-06
BALTIMORE, MD, May 6, 2025 – As communities across the U.S. continue grappling with public safety and police reform, a new study published in the INFORMS journal Management Science offers compelling evidence for a path forward: procedural justice training for police officers, backed by leadership support, can significantly improve officer behavior and strengthen community trust. “At a time when communities are calling for both safer streets and meaningful police reform, our findings offer an important starting point,” says Rodrigo Canales, lead author of the study and professor at Boston University. “When backed by leadership, ...

Slickrock: USU geologists explore why Utah's Wasatch Fault is vulnerable to earthquakes

2025-05-06
LOGAN, UTAH, USA -- About 240 miles long, Utah’s Wasatch Fault stretches along the western edge of the Wasatch Mountains from southern Idaho to central Utah, running through Salt Lake City and the state’s other population centers. It’s a seismically active normal fault, which means it is a fracture in the Earth’s crust that has moved many times in the past. “Normal faults are observed along different tectonic systems, where the tectonic plates are moving apart,” says Utah ...

„Looking Through Objects. Women in Contemporary Polish Design” – exhibition at Design Museum Brussels

2025-05-06
„Looking Through Objects. Women in Contemporary Polish Design” – exhibition at Design Museum Brussels The traveling exhibition spotlighting Polish women designers is making its way to Belgium. Opening on May 8 at Design Museum Brussels, Looking Through Objects brings together works of 16 creatives who have been shaping the evolving landscape of Polish design. The curatorial team behind the show includes Agnieszka Jacobson-Cielecka, dean of Faculty Design at SWPS University in Warsaw, along with Gian Luca Amadei and Dario Lombardi.  A story of women shaping Polish ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Pondering artistic beauty encourages ‘big picture’ thinking, study finds

Research debunks long-held psychology traditions and mental health myths

Replanted rainforests may benefit from termite transplants

AI has untapped potential to advance biodiversity conservation, study finds

Study of velvet worm slime could revolutionize sustainable material design

New drone-assisted 3D model offers a more accurate way to date dinosaur fossils

New study reveals how inter-species interactions control structure and mechanics of double networks materials

Researchers identify two new crocodile species

Study suggests we don’t just hear music, but ‘become it’

McGill researchers develop practical new tool for detecting nanoplastics and microplastics in the environment

The ISSCR announces Montréal as the location for its 2026 Annual Meeting 8-11 July 2026

New study shows individuals prefer when firms stay apolitical on polarizing issues

University of Tennessee designated a National Center of Academic Excellence in Cybersecurity

Research update: Okra, fenugreek extracts remove most microplastics from water

Heat and drought are quietly hurting crop yields

Gender characteristics of service robots can influence customer decisions

Ultra-thin bismuth holds unexpected promise for green electronics: researcher

Discovery: a better, more targeted termite terminator

Researchers harness brain activity to look at how we perceive faces from other racial groups differently

New research finds leadership-backed training key to better policing

Slickrock: USU geologists explore why Utah's Wasatch Fault is vulnerable to earthquakes

„Looking Through Objects. Women in Contemporary Polish Design” – exhibition at Design Museum Brussels

NCCN Policy Summit builds bridges between primary care and oncology for better cancer outcomes

Physician-led online nutrition intervention program is practical, cost-effective, and successful at improving patient health

Long COVID may cause long-term changes in the heart and lungs and may lead to cardiac and pulmonary diseases

Albert Einstein College of Medicine launches Data Science Institute

Half of U.S. adults acknowledge health benefits of eating a plant-based diet

Food as medicine: How diet shapes gut microbiome health

Bridging Worlds: USU physicists develop novel test of the Holographic Principle

Silver nanoparticles produced by fungus could be used to prevent and treat COVID-19

[Press-News.org] New study shows individuals prefer when firms stay apolitical on polarizing issues