(Press-News.org) What makes us care about others? Scientists studying empathy have found that people are more likely to choose to empathize with groups rather than individuals, even though they find empathizing equally difficult and uncomfortable in both cases. The scientists suggest that the sight of groups of people could offer more context information which helps people decide whether to empathize, and therefore increases the chances that they choose to do so.
“People’s willingness to empathize is different depending on who the target is: a single individual or a group of people,” said Dr Hajdi Moche of Linköping University, Sweden, lead author of the article in Frontiers in Psychology. “Specifically, people were more willing to empathize with a group than an individual, although empathizing was rated as more effortful and distressing compared to staying objective – for both the individual and the group.”
What is empathy?
The researchers defined empathy as understanding, feeling, and sharing in another’s world, while maintaining the understanding that it’s not the same as your world. Empathy can come at a price, whether it’s paid in time, money, or emotion: feeling others’ pain tends to be painful. They wanted to learn whether people were more likely to choose to pay this price when they were dealing with individuals or with groups. Although an experiment in the lab doesn’t equate directly to the choices someone might make in real life, understanding how people empathize differently with groups and individuals could help us understand the part that empathy plays in natural disasters or wars.
To investigate this, the researchers recruited 296 participants to take part in an experiment called the Empathy Selection Task, which invites participants to choose between two decks of cards, one of which will ask them to empathize and one of which will ask them to remain objective. Their willingness to empathize is gauged by how often they choose the empathy deck.
Pick a card
Each participant underwent a two-block test – one block of pictures of individuals and one of groups. Each block had 20 different stock photos depicting a diverse range of people, with (as far as possible) neutral expressions and plain backgrounds. Participants were given the two decks and asked to choose a card from one of them. Then they were given a picture to react to, writing down three keywords that described either the feelings of the people in the images or their external appearance. After each block, participants were asked questions which aimed to understand their experience of performing the tasks.
The scientists found that participants chose to avoid empathizing more often during the block of individual pictures, choosing to empathize 34% of the time on average. However, during the block of group pictures, they chose to empathize 53% of the time. Even though they found empathizing harder and more distressing than staying objective, participants chose to pay that price more often during the test of group images.
“The task of trying to share the internal experiences of the other requires more effort, imagination, and understanding of what the person might feel compared to describing external features like hair color,” said Moche. “To share in the internal experiences might be especially hard when the information at hand is only a neutral facial expression without any body language or background context.”
Choosing to care
It’s possible that the group pictures, containing multiple people, both provide more context for participants to help them empathize and make describing feel more effortful, so that empathizing becomes easier by comparison – participants reported that describing groups was harder than describing individuals. Participants also rated their own effectiveness in empathizing with groups higher: this could have boosted their confidence and encouraged them to empathize.
It’s also possible that the neutral facial expressions and lack of body language in the individual pictures made it harder to understand people’s feelings and discouraged people from choosing to try. Different facial expressions or different amounts of context information might affect the choices people make.
“It would be interesting to test this further by directly pitting the individual and group against each other and letting participants choose which of these they would prefer to empathize with, and then in another round, which one they would prefer to stay objective in relation to,” concluded Moche. “In this way, we would have a direct comparison in willingness to empathize when the target is an individual versus a group of people.”
END
Humans prefer to put more effort into empathizing with groups than with individuals
Study participants asked to choose whether to empathize with or describe people preferred to empathize with groups, despite finding it difficult and distressing
2025-05-07
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Development of high-performance proton exchange membrane for electrochemical LOHC hydrogen storage
2025-05-07
A Korean research team has developed a new proton exchange membrane (PEM) that significantly enhances the performance of electrochemical hydrogen storage systems.
Dr. Soonyong So of the Korea Research Institute of Chemical Technology (KRICT) and Professor Sang-Young Lee of Yonsei University have developed a next-generation PEM for LOHC-based electrochemical hydrogen storage using a hydrocarbon-based polymer called SPAES (sulfonated poly(arylene ether sulfone)). This SPAES membrane reduces toluene ...
Feat of ‘dung-gineering’ turns cow manure into one of world’s most used materials
2025-05-07
The study, published in The Journal of Cleaner Production, describes the new ‘pressurised spinning’ innovation and its potential to create cellulose materials more cheaply and cleanly than some current manufacturing methods, using a waste product from the dairy farming industry, cow dung, as the raw material.
The advance is the first time that manufacturing-grade cellulose has been derived from animal waste and is a prime example of circular economy, which aims to minimise waste and pollution by reusing and repurposing resources wherever possible.
The ...
Women with serious mental health conditions likely ill-equipped for menopause transition
2025-05-07
CLEVELAND, Ohio (May 7, 2025)—Many women struggle to find resources to help manage their menopause symptoms. For women living with a serious mental illness, the need for additional support and education during the menopause transition is even greater. A new scoping review confirmed the paucity of research on this topic and suggested a need for more psychoeducation programs. Results of the study are published online today in Menopause, the journal of The Menopause Society.
Serious mental illnesses are a group of mental health conditions often characterized by their chronicity and severity of symptoms that lead to significant functional impairment. ...
Vapour-deposited perovskite semiconductors power next generation circuits
2025-05-07
A research team led by Professor Yong-Young Noh and Dr. Youjin Reo from the Department of Chemical Engineering at POSTECH (Pohang University of Science and Technology) has developed a groundbreaking technology poised to revolutionize next-generation displays and electronic devices. The project was a collaborative effort with Professors Ao Liu and Huihui Zhu from the University of Electronic Science and Technology of China (UESTC), and the findings were published in Nature Electronics on April 28th.
Every time we stream videos or play games on our smartphones, thousands of transistors operate tirelessly ...
Sunlight unlocks secrets to how Earth works
2025-05-07
When our planet and the incoming sunlight align just right, stunning phenomena such as rainbows and halos can occur. More often, sunlight - or shortwave radiation - interacts with Earth in subtle but curious ways.
A new perspective study, published in Advances in Atmospheric Sciences, lays out how shortwave radiation research has led to improved fundamental understanding of Earth. The study also shares exciting prospects for how such advances can continue into the future.
Scientific insights derived from shortwave ...
A healthy diet in childhood is linked to starting menstrual periods later, regardless of BMI or height
2025-05-07
Eating a healthy diet as a child is linked to girls having their first menstrual period at an older age than those who consumed a less healthy diet, according to a new study published today (Wednesday) in Human Reproduction [1], one of the world’s leading reproductive medicine journals.
The findings remained unaltered by the girls’ body mass index (BMI) or height, both of which have been associated with the earlier onset of periods.
The study has implications for health in later life as it is well known that women who started their periods at an early age may be at higher risk for diabetes, ...
More social parrots have a better vocabulary
2025-05-07
In the urban parks of Barcelona, Spain, the calls of a tropical parrot fill the air. The bright green monk parakeet, native to South America, has found a new home in European cities. Monk parakeets thrive in huge colonies where they communicate with each other using many distinct sounds—offering scientists a unique window into understanding the interplay of individual social relationships with vocal variety.
For social animals, communication is a key that unlocks the benefits of group living. It’s well known that animals with more complex social lives tend to have more intricate ...
T. rex’s direct ancestor crossed from Asia to North America
2025-05-07
Tyrannosaurus rex evolved in North America, but its direct ancestor came from Asia, crossing a land bridge connecting the continents more than 70 million years ago, according to a new study led by UCL researchers.
The study, published in Royal Society Open Science, also found that the rapid growth in size of tyrannosaurids (the group that included the T. rex) as well as a closely related group called megaraptors coincided with a cooling of the global climate following a peak in temperatures 92 million years ago.
This suggests T. rex and its cousins might have been better suited to cooler climates than other dinosaur groups at the time, perhaps due to having feathers or a more warm-blooded ...
Pondering artistic beauty encourages ‘big picture’ thinking, study finds
2025-05-06
Since the dawn of philosophy, thinkers from Plato to Kant have considered how beauty affects human experience, and whether it has the power to transform our state of mind.
Now, a new study from the University of Cambridge suggests that stopping to contemplate the beauty of artistic objects in a gallery or museum boosts our ability to think in abstract ways and consider the “bigger picture” when it comes to our lives.
Researchers say the findings offer empirical evidence that engaging with artistic beauty helps us escape the “mental trappings of daily life,” such as current anxieties and to-do lists, and induce “psychological distancing”: ...
Research debunks long-held psychology traditions and mental health myths
2025-05-06
New research challenges traditional views and myths in psychology, such as the long-held belief that parenting is the biggest influence on adult personalities.
A comprehensive review of current psychology has revealed that many long-held beliefs about mental health and the function of the brain need significant revision. Renowned psychologist Michael W. Eysenck pulls apart some of these commonly-held beliefs in a new book, Rethinking Psychology: Finding Meaning in Misconceptions.
Popular psychological myths debunked
One of the myths held under ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
School dinners may encourage picky teenagers to eat better, says new study
Study suggests loss of lung capacity begins between the ages of 20 and 25
California chief nurse officer recognized as national champion for women’s health
Dental and vision services among veterans in Medicare Advantage vs traditional Medicare
Under embargo: Mount Sinai experts to present new research on preeclampsia, doula care and more at 2025 2025 ACOG Annual Clinical and Scientific Meeting
Study reveals a deep brain region that links the senses
Bismuth’s mask uncovered: Implications for quantum computing and spintronics materials
Two HIV vaccine trials show proof of concept for pathway to broadly neutralizing antibodies
Ewell joins Gerontological Society of America’s Board of Directors
Large study traces prehistoric human expansion into South America, where genomic studies have been lacking
Millions of previously undocumented genetic variants discovered in Brazil’s highly admixed population
Limited evidence for “escalator to extinction” in mountain ecosystems under climate change
Asians made humanity’s longest prehistoric migration and shaped the genetic landscape in the Americas, finds NTU Singapore-led study
OHSU study reveals impact of oft-overlooked cell in brain function
World’s largest bat organoid platform paves the way for pandemic preparedness
Mapping the genome of the Brazilian population, with implications for healthcare
Proof of concept for Amsterdam UMC-led HIV vaccination
MSK researchers identify key player in childhood food allergies: Thetis cells
Link between ADHD and obesity might depend on where you live
Scientists find two brain biomarkers in long COVID sufferers may be what’s causing their brain fog, other cognitive issues
Empowering cities to act: The Climate Action Navigator highlights where climate action is most needed
KAIST's pioneering VR precision technology & choreography tool receives spotlights at CHI 2025
Recently, a joint Chinese–American research team led by Dr. HU Han from the Institute of Vertebrate Paleontology and Paleoanthropology (IVPP) of the Chinese Academy of Sciences and Dr. Jingmai O’Conno
Nationally recognized emergency radiologist Tarek Hanna, MD, named new chair of Diagnostic Radiology & Nuclear Medicine at the University of Maryland School of Medicine
“Chicago archaeopteryx” unveiled: New clues on dinosaur–bird transition revealed by Chinese–American research team
‘Rogue’ immune cells explain why a gluten-free diet fails in some coeliac patients
World's first patient treated with personalized CRISPR gene editing therapy at Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia
Infant with rare, incurable disease is first to successfully receive personalized gene therapy treatment
Digital reconstruction reveals 80 steps of prehistoric life
GSA and GSA Foundation announce record support for the geosciences
[Press-News.org] Humans prefer to put more effort into empathizing with groups than with individualsStudy participants asked to choose whether to empathize with or describe people preferred to empathize with groups, despite finding it difficult and distressing