PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Individual merit, not solidarity, prioritized by early childhood education policies

In a global survey, only four countries acknowledge uncontrollable factors in success such as health and climate disasters

2025-07-02
(Press-News.org) Do we climb the social ladder alone or with help from our communities? Early childhood education (ECE) policies are betting on the former, according to a study published July 2, 2025, in the open-access journal PLOS One by Katarzyna Bobrowicz from the University of Luxembourg and University of Liège in Belgium, and colleagues. A 53-country survey of global ECE policies indicates favoritism of competition over cooperation, individualism over solidarity and talent over luck.

Recent decades have seen a rising belief in meritocracy: a 1950s-era Western ideal that one’s individual merit (i.e., their skill and talent), begets success rather than random, uncontrollable factors such as health or family status. In parallel, global governments are increasingly investing in ECE. With this study, Bobrowicz and colleagues explored the extent to which new-and-improved ECE policies promote economic meritocracy.

The researchers examined 92 official ECE documents from the European Union (EU) and Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) and from 53 countries across Africa, the Americas, Asia, Europe and Oceania between 1999-2023. Using text coding and statistical analysis, they searched for references to four contributors to lifelong success: individual skills, individual agency, uncontrollable factors (e.g., health, childhood, climate) and reliance on others (e.g., teachers, family and community).

Results indicate that overall, the countries surveyed embrace economic meritocracy in their ECE policies, promoting individual skill and agency over solidarity and community reliance. Further, countries perceived individual agency as integral to success, and only four countries — Ireland, New Zealand, Malaysia and the Philippines — acknowledged that uncontrollable factors may have an impact. The researchers acknowledged that the OECD and the EU reiterated the importance of universal, equitable access to ECE.

The researchers note that economic meritocracy is reported to strain health and psychological wellbeing, adding that “the peace and prosperity of future societies hinge on social cohesion” rather than hyper-independence. They posit that ECE curricula should be designed to prepare students for collaboration and global cohesion as adults.

Due to this study’s limitations in scope and scale, the researchers recommend further inquiry into local and regional variation in ECE policy, differences (rather than similarities) among the cultures studied, and changes across time.

Katarzyna Bobrowicz adds: “In the last two decades, globally, societies have shared the belief that life outcomes in adulthood are closely tied to individual skills and agency, or, to put it simply, that adults get what they hustle for, what they make of themselves, ultimately - what they deserve. We were curious whether this belief had been inscribed into documents that, in principle at least, determine what toddlers and preschoolers learn in childcare facilities.”

“We expected that this might be the case, and it indeed was. At the outset, we thought that the pivotal role that teachers, parents, peers, and others - who produce food and cook meals, drive the school bus, clean the school corridors - would be actively highlighted and appreciated in the documents. However, to our surprise, this role was missing from most of the analyzed texts, which comprised both government-endorsed curricula and international advisory reports. Finally, we found that the impact that uncontrollable external events, such as illness, misfortune, or inherited social (dis)advantage, have on individual outcomes made way to less than 10% of the analyzed curricula.”

“What children learn in early childhood, or, in fact, at any stage of formal education, is never neutral, values-free, immune to dominant discourses, and so young children may implicitly assume the beliefs promoted by national and international education stakeholders in documents that shape such education. We showed that these stakeholders currently promote the role of individual skills and agency far more than solidarity or social cohesion, and overlook a number of external factors that shape individual outcomes beyond individual agency. We hope that this work will fuel conversations among teachers, parents, and the civil society at large, as to whether they wish for children to be exposed to economic meritocratic beliefs in early childhood education.”

“I was born in a post-communist state, shortly before the Soviet Union was to collapse, into a society where power was up for grabs. My family has not grabbed it, not to the same extent as many others at least, but I nevertheless grew up with opportunities that were available to many of my peers. Like many in the West, or even around the world, I grew up thinking that my merit and my actions would crucially shape my future, and to some extent they perhaps did. But as I chatted with my family and strangers at work or in the streets across Europe, and saw what life opportunities are actually available and to whom in the society, I finally realized the obvious: that ultimately I will never have access to opportunities that many of my peers would have due to parental socioeconomic advantage or network, or personality that was a better fit in formal structures, to name but a few. Then, I listened to an eBook of ‘The Meritocracy Trap’ by Daniel Markovits as I was painting the walls in yet another rental apartment in 2021, and I could not help but wonder whether economic meritocratic beliefs described there, in the context of college education, may set in already in early education. Since this is the educational context in which I typically conduct my studies, I decided to find out whether this might be the case.”

Pablo Gracia adds: “Internationally, early childhood education (ECE) programs disproportionately promote skills and values linked to individual competition, whereas skills and values favoring solidarity and social cohesion are largely neglected.”

 

 

In your coverage, please use this URL to provide access to the freely available article in PLOS One: http://plos.io/3TxUcPj

Citation: Bobrowicz K, Gracia P, Teuber Z, Greiff S (2025) The meritocracy trap: Early childhood education policies promote individual achievement far more than social cohesion. PLoS One 20(7): e0326021. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0326021

Author countries: Belgium, Spain, Luxembourg, Germany.

Funding: The author(s) received no specific funding for this work.

END


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Preclinical study unlocks a mystery of rapid mouth healing

2025-07-02
Your mouth is a magician. Bite the inside of your cheek, and the wound may vanish without a trace in a couple of days. A preclinical study co-led by Cedars-Sinai, Stanford Medicine and the University of California, San Francisco (UCSF), has discovered one secret of this disappearing act. The findings, if confirmed in humans, could one day lead to treatments that enable rapid, scarless recovery from skin wounds on other parts of the body. The study was published in the peer-reviewed journal Science Translational Medicine. “Our research began with two ...

Extraterrestrial habitats: bioplastics for life beyond earth

2025-07-02
Key takeaways SEAS researchers grew green algae inside shelters that recreated pressure conditions on Mars. The shelters were made from bioplastics derived from algae. The experiments demonstrate the possibility of closed-loop, sustainable habitats in space. If humans are ever going to live beyond Earth, they’ll need to construct habitats. But transporting enough industrial material to create livable spaces would be incredibly challenging and expensive. Researchers at the Harvard John A. Paulson School of Engineering and Applied Sciences (SEAS) think there’s a better way, through biology.  An international team of researchers led by Robin Wordsworth, ...

U.S. military spending reductions could substantially lower energy consumption

2025-07-02
A new analysis suggests that reductions in U.S. military spending could result in significant decreases in energy consumption by the Department of Defense, leading to reduced greenhouse gas emissions. Ryan Thombs of Penn State University, U.S., and colleagues present these findings in the open-access journal PLOS Climate on July 2. Of all the world’s institutions, the U.S. military produces the most greenhouse gas emissions. This occurs through such activities as maintaining bases, continual preparations and training, research and development, and transporting people, supplies, and weapons worldwide. According to military ...

Air pollution is linked to adverse birth outcomes in India

2025-07-02
Prenatal exposure to ambient fine particulate matter and climatic factors, such as temperature and rainfall, are associated with adverse birth outcomes in India, according to a study published July 2nd, 2025, in the open-access journal PLOS Global Public Health by Mary Abed Al Ahad from the University of St Andrews, U.K. Ambient air pollution poses a global threat to human health, with a disproportionate burden of its detrimental effects falling on those residing in low and middle-income countries. Referred to as the silent killer, ...

Using viral load tests to help predict mpox severity when skin lesions first appear

2025-07-02
In August 2024, the World Health Organization declared a second “Public Health Emergency of International Concern” for mpox. The current outbreak in Africa is driven mainly by the clade I variant, with multiple countries reporting their first-ever mpox cases of this more severe strain. Nagoya University researchers and their collaborators have found that measuring the amount of virus in the blood when skin lesions first appear can help predict whether patients will experience mild or severe progression of the disease. The study analyzes viral loads during early infection to predict how sick patients will get, potentially improving treatment strategies ...

Engineered cell cross-talk unlocks CAR-T potential against glioblastoma

2025-07-02
A team of researchers from the San Raffaele-Telethon Institute for Gene Therapy (SR-TIGET, Milan), led by Nadia Coltella and Luigi Naldini, has unveiled a powerful strategy to rejuvenate the effectiveness of chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T cell therapy against glioblastoma, one of the most lethal and treatment-resistant brain tumors. The findings, published in Science Translational Medicine, highlight how gene therapy targeting immune stimulating cytokines to the tumor microenvironment (TME) and enabling their private cross-talk with CAR-T cells not only restores CAR-T killer activity but also boost a broader immune response that inhibits tumor growth and extends host ...

Regional disparities in US media coverage of archaeology research

2025-07-02
What archaeological discoveries are considered newsworthy by U.S. media outlets and audiences? A new analysis of “pop-science” reporting reveals topical and regional disparities, including an apparent underrepresentation of Chinese archaeology and preference for findings relevant to white Christian histories. The skewed coverage raises concerns as archaeology influences notions of identity and cultural achievement, and has been misappropriated by racist, nationalist ideologies.  Mass ...

Coral larvae travelling further makes populations stronger

2025-07-02
Understanding how far Great Barrier Reef corals are from their parents could be key to identifying and protecting at risk populations, University of Queensland research has found. PhD candidate Zoe Meziere said well-connected coral populations had a better chance of adapting to climate change and other environmental pressures. “Quantifying genetic connectivity can predict the fate of populations as more isolated reefs with lower levels of genetic variation are likely more vulnerable,” Ms Meziere said. “Species that don’t disperse or breed as far are more likely to form isolated populations, reducing their capacity to recover from bleaching events ...

First of its kind study for children with arthritis reveals possible new disease targets

2025-07-02
A new groundbreaking study by researchers from University of Birmingham, UCL, Great Ormond Street Hospital and Birmingham Children’s Hospital has revealed important clues into what is driving disease in children with arthritis. Cutting-edge techniques have allowed scientists for the first time to uncover the unique architecture of cells and signals inside the joint as inflammation takes hold. The new study published in Science Translational Medicine looks at arthritis in children, caused by the immune system mistakenly attacking joints. Juvenile idiopathic arthritis affects more than 10,000 children in the UK. It causes swelling, ...

Financing innovation: proposal for novel adaptive platform trial fund offers new model for ALS drug development

2025-07-02
A team of researchers from the MIT Sloan School of Management, the Sean M. Healey & AMG Center for ALS at Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH), Questrom School of Business at Boston University, and QLS Advisors have introduced a new approach to funding clinical trials for amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) therapies. The study “Financing Drug Development via Adaptive Platform Trials,” published today in PLOS One, outlines a financing model that merges the efficiencies of adaptive platform trials — lower costs and shorter durations — with an innovative royalty-based investment structure designed to accelerate therapeutic development ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Is this what 2,500-year-old honey looks like?

Economic evaluation of wastewater surveillance for COVID-19 testing in long-term care settings

Announcing Deep Origin as a sponsor of ARDD 2025

Cancer cells ‘power up’ when literally pressed to the limit

Huge hidden flood bursts through the Greenland ice sheet surface

The brain shapes what we feel in real time

New study confirms post-pandemic surge in gut-brain disorders

Through the shot glass, and what can be found in liverworts

Stepping for digital rewards

Developing next-generation analytical technique for gene and cell doping and ensuring ethics and fairness in sports

Debunking a life-threatening myth: "Tongue swallowing prevention" maneuvers delay CPR and might contribute to brain injury or death for collapsed athletes

Female pilots perform better under pressure, study finds

Hydroquinone-buffered covalent organic frameworks for long-term photocatalytic hydrogen peroxide production

From coal to chemicals: Breakthrough syngas catalysis powers green industrial future

AI detects the stiffness of cancer cell exosomes: DGIST develops deep learning-based lung cancer diagnostic technology

Positive ethnic identity fosters STEM career aspirations

Wildlife show wide range of responses to human presence in U.S. national parks

Great Tits show early signs of splitting up: Oxford researchers uncover social clues to bird 'divorce'

From the lab to the hand: nanodevice brings personalized genomics closer to reality

Women politicians receive more identity-based attacks on social media than men, study finds

Idaho National Laboratory accelerates nuclear energy projects with Amazon Web Services cloud and AI technologies

Kavraki elected to European Academy of Sciences

UK teens who currently vape as likely to start smoking as their peers in the 1970s

Higher ultra processed food intake linked to increased lung cancer risk

Exercise rehab lessens severity, frequency + recurrence of irregular heart rhythm (AF)

Deep heat beneath the United States traced to ancient rift with Greenland

Animals in national parks remained wary of human footprint during 2020 COVID shutdown

Stevens INI receives prestigious contract to advance women’s brain health

Fulbright funds OU professor’s biodiversity research

Antiviral treatment fails to slow early-stage Alzheimer’s

[Press-News.org] Individual merit, not solidarity, prioritized by early childhood education policies
In a global survey, only four countries acknowledge uncontrollable factors in success such as health and climate disasters