(Press-News.org) A groundbreaking new study published in Management Science challenges conventional wisdom about Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) policies in college football, demonstrating they actively enhance competitive balance and broaden opportunities for athletes. Researchers Tim Derdenger from Carnegie Mellon University’s Tepper School of Business and Ivan Li at the Naveen Jindal School of Management, University of Texas at Dallas, find that NIL has led to a wider distribution of talent across college programs, directly benefiting athletes who seek to maximize their brands and earning potential. This research overturns the “rich get richer” narrative, asserting that college athletics now fosters a more dynamic and competitive environment for aspiring collegiate players.
The comprehensive study analyzed pre- and post-NIL recruitment patterns for 3, 4, and 5-star (a method for ranking football recruits based on on-field accomplishments, physical traits, etc.) recruits, uncovering a significant increase in talent dispersion throughout the college football landscape. Contrary to initial predictions, NIL opportunities empower lower-ranked football programs to attract higher-quality recruits, particularly among 5-star and lower-ranked 4-star athletes. This shift provides more athletes with greater leverage and diverse options, ensuring that talent does not solely concentrate within a select few elite institutions. Athletes now actively evaluate their options based on financial prospects alongside athletic ambition, driving a healthier market for their skills. “Our findings clearly show that NIL is not just about the top institutions; it’s empowering a broader range of schools to compete for elite talent, directly benefiting more student-athletes,” states Ivan Li, coauthor of the paper.
Furthermore, the research conclusively shows that competitive balance across college football has improved since the implementation of NIL. Sportsbooks now establish smaller point differentials for games, even after accounting for talent levels, team performance, and transfer portal activity. This evidence strongly indicates that NIL fosters more competitive matchups, increasing engagement and excitement for fans and participants alike. The policy creates a more unpredictable and thrilling sport where a broader array of teams can vie for top-tier talent and achieve success. Coauthor Tim Derdenger adds, “We’ve observed a tangible shift in competitive dynamics. These data speak volumes: NIL makes college football a more exciting and less predictable sport, which is a win for everyone involved.”
The study also highlights that 3-star recruits, post-NIL, increasingly prioritize NIL earnings over traditional academic selectivity, often choosing colleges with lower SAT class averages or graduates with lower mid-career incomes. This demonstrates the profound influence of NIL on athletes’ decision-making processes, as they strategically weigh immediate financial benefits against long-term academic or career considerations. Athletes now possess more agency in their collegiate choices, actively pursuing avenues that align with individual priorities and financial goals.
Policymakers should encourage NIL adoption across all programs and implement legally binding regulations for collectives, including mandatory registration and disclosure of deals for a more equitable and competitively balanced college football environment. Additionally, they should prioritize educating student athletes about NIL and the contractual norms and obligations by requiring NIL counseling and monitoring the long-term effects of NIL through regular research and policy adjustments.
END
How NIL boosts college football’s competitive balance
2025-09-15
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Moffitt researchers develop machine learning model to predict urgent care visits for lung cancer patients
2025-09-15
TAMPA, Fla. (Sept. 15, 2025) — A new study published in JCO Clinical Cancer Informatics demonstrates that machine learning models incorporating patient-reported outcomes and wearable sensor data can predict which patients with non–small cell lung cancer are most at risk of needing urgent care during treatment. The study was led by researchers and clinicians at Moffitt Cancer Center.
Patients undergoing systemic therapy for non-small cell lung cancer often experience treatment-related toxicities that can result in unplanned urgent care visits. In this study, Moffitt researchers tested whether integrating multiple ...
Construction secrets of honeybees: Study reveals how bees build hives in tricky spots
2025-09-15
On a hot summer day in Colorado, European honeybees (Apis mellifera L.) buzz around a cluster of hives near Boulder Creek. Worker bees taking off in search of water, nectar and pollen mingle with bees that have just returned from the field. Inside the hives, walls of hexagons are beginning to take shape as the bees build their nests.
“Building a hive is a beautiful example of honeybees solving a problem collectively,” said Orit Peleg, associate professor in CU Boulder’s Department of Computer Science. “Each bee has a little bit of wax, and each bee knows where to deposit it, ...
Wheat disease losses total $2.9 billion across the United States and Canada between 2018 and 2021
2025-09-15
A new multiyear study has revealed that between 2018 and 2021, wheat diseases caused the loss of approximately 560 million bushels—valued at US$2.9 billion, or $18.10 per acre, in farmer revenue—across 29 U.S. states and Ontario, Canada.
Published in Plant Health Progress™, the study was led by Andrew Friskop (Department of Plant Pathology, North Dakota State University) in collaboration with dozens of university-based specialists and the Crop Protection Network. It represents the most comprehensive survey of wheat-related losses to date. The findings underscore the widespread economic impact of ...
New funding fuels development of first potentially regenerative treatment for multiple sclerosis
2025-09-15
Toronto, ON (September 15, 2025) – A Canadian-led international research team, spearheaded by Dr. Fang Liu at the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (CAMH) has received nearly $800,000 US ($1,137,868 CAD) in new funding to advance a promising therapy for multiple sclerosis (MS). Supported by Brain Canada, the National MS Society’s Fast Forward program, and Health Canada through the Canada Brain Research Fund, the project is developing a novel approach to treatment that may halt disease progression and repair nerve damage and restore function.
Around ...
NJIT student–faculty team wins best presentation award for ant swarm simulation
2025-09-15
Think twice about eliminating those pesky ants at your next family picnic. Their behavior may hold the key to reinventing how engineering materials, traffic control and multi-agent robots are made and utilized, thanks to research conducted by recent graduate Matthew Loges ’25 and Assistant Professor Tomer Weiss from NJIT's Ying Wu College of Computing.
The two earned a best presentation award for their research paper titled “Simulating Ant Swarm Aggregations Dynamics” at the ACM SIGGRAPH Symposium for Computer Animation (SCA), and a qualifying poster nomination for the undergraduate research competition at the 2025 ACM SIGGRAPH conference.
SIGGRAPH, ...
Ants defend plants from herbivores but can hinder pollination
2025-09-15
Around 4,000 plant species from different parts of the world secrete nectar outside their flowers, such as on their stems or leaves, through secretory glands known as extrafloral nectaries. Unlike floral nectar, extrafloral nectar does not attract pollinators; rather, it attracts insects that defend plants, such as ants. These insects feed on the sweet liquid and, in return, protect the plant from herbivores. However, this protection comes at a cost.
A study published in the Journal of ...
When the wireless data runs dry
2025-09-15
To train artificial intelligence (AI) models, researchers need good data and lots of it. However, most real-world data has already been used, leading scientists to generate synthetic data. While the generated data helps solve the issue of quantity, it may not always have good quality, and assessing its quality has been overlooked.
Wei Gao, associate professor of electrical and computer engineering at the University of Pittsburgh Swanson School of Engineering, has collaborated with researchers ...
Inquiry into the history of science shows an early “inherence” bias
2025-09-15
Early scientific theories—such as those explaining basic phenomena like gravity, burning, and the movement of molecules in water—centered on presumed inherent properties rather than external factors, thereby misleading famous philosophers and scientists, from Aristotle to Scottish botanist Robert Brown, in their theorizing.
A new study by a team of psychology researchers has now found that this tendency is in fact common in the history of science. Moreover, through a series of experiments and surveys, the paper’s authors conclude these misfires were likely driven by cognitive constraints, among scientists and non-scientists alike, that have acted ...
Picky eaters endure: Ecologists use DNA to explore diet breadth of wild herbivores
2025-09-15
LOGAN, UTAH, USA – It’s not easy eating green. Most plants are heavily defended with chemicals to deter plant eaters. For these herbivores, getting enough to eat, while minimizing exposure to toxins, is a persistent challenge that shapes their foraging choices.
Understanding how these animals navigate these choices is fundamental to understanding what these creatures need to survive and how species respond to changing conditions, says Utah State University ecologist Sara Weinstein.
Woodrats (genus Neotoma) provide an unexpected model for studying animal diets, she says. Native to North America, these herbivorous rodents ...
Study suggests most Americans would be healthier without daylight saving time
2025-09-15
Every spring, Americans dutifully adjust their clocks forward to daylight saving time, and every fall, back to standard time — but no one seems very happy about it. The biannual time shift is not only inconvenient, it’s also known to be acutely bad for our health. The collective loss of an hour of sleep on the second Sunday in March has been linked to more heart attacks and fatal traffic accidents in the ensuing days.
Now, a study by Stanford Medicine researchers finds there are longer-term hazards as well — and better alternatives.
The researchers compared how three ...