(Press-News.org) In 2013, the US Department of Justice quietly launched a program called Operation Choke Point. Its aim was to pressure some banks into cutting ties with businesses that, while legal, were deemed risky from a social or reputational standpoint. Included in the operation were payday lenders, firearm and ammunition dealers, tobacco vendors, online gambling sites, and even escort services.
The strategy was simple: If targeted banks refused to lend to these controversial companies, their access to capital would dry up, eventually squeezing them out of the marketplace. The idea was a form of financial suffocation, achieved not through new laws or regulations but by warning banks that doing business with the controversial clients could invite heightened government scrutiny, investigations, or other unspecified sanctions.
Now, more than a decade later, a team of economists from the University of Rochester, University of Michigan, University of Maryland, and the Federal Reserve Board examined the results of Operation Choke Point. Their conclusion, published in the Journal of Financial Economics, is clear—the choking didn’t really work.
“We found a decline among targeted banks and firms. But overall it didn’t work because the operation singled out only a subset of banks,” says Billy Xu, an assistant professor of finance at the University’s Simon Business School, who is a coauthor of the study. “What we got, essentially, was a decline in committed loans only among the targeted banks, but the targeted firms were able to establish new relationships with non-targeted banks.”
That is, the targeted banks complied and tightened their lending to these so-called risky companies, while most of the businesses just walked next door and found other non-targeted lenders.
Firms adapt, banks relent
Operation Choke Point created a real-world laboratory to test whether restricting credit can discipline industries that regulators or society don’t like or approve of.
“If you are trying to stop the water but you turn the taps off in one place only—it’s likely not enough. You’ll have to turn them off everywhere else, too, which can be costly or infeasible.”
Using confidential data from the Federal Reserve, covering more than 5,600 affected firms, the researchers found that the targeted banks singled out by the Justice Department did indeed reduce lending. Small and medium-sized businesses in controversial industries saw about a 10 percent drop in their credit lines. Borrowing became harder as loan maturities shortened, collateral lending requirements increased, and some banking relationships were abruptly terminated.
Yet, large businesses barely flinched as their credit lines stayed intact. In some cases, they even secured more lending to hedge against future government actions. The team surmises that’s because large companies usually have more sway with lenders—their own or new ones.
The critical finding: Affected firms simply switched banks. Companies, many of them thoroughly profitable enterprises, that lost credit at targeted banks opened accounts with non-targeted banks instead.
“As one bank gives up business,” Xu notes, “another bank steps in and takes advantage of that.”
Overall, the researchers found no meaningful reduction in the borrowing ability of controversial firms, nor did their investment, profitability, or business performance change.
Bottom line: While Operation Choke Point succeeded at pressuring some banks, it failed to choke the industries themselves.
The limits of financial pressure
Why didn’t it work? One explanation could be that the operation targeted only a subset of large banks—and not the entire financial system.
Xu likens it to a row of running faucets: “If you are trying to stop the water but you turn the taps off in one place only—it’s likely not enough. You’ll have to turn them off everywhere else, too, which can be costly or infeasible.”
Moreover, the policy relied on informal coercion rather than formal legislation. In the end, the operation was terminated in 2017 after congressional criticism and lawsuits accused regulators of intimidation and overreach.
“Targeted credit rationing is largely ineffective at imposing costs on firms in controversial industries,” the team writes.
Operation Choke Point was a test case of how financial pressure might police morality. The results show the limits of that strategy as credit can be redirected, and firms are resilient in finding new sources of funding. For policymakers, investors, and activists who hope that cutting off financing will reshape industries, the message may be sobering—starving companies of money is much harder than it sounds.
END
When Washington tried to starve industries of loans—and failed
When federal regulators pressured banks to withdraw from controversial industries most companies simply borrowed elsewhere, a new study finds
2025-10-01
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Cassini proves complex chemistry in Enceladus ocean
2025-10-01
Scientists digging through data collected by the Cassini spacecraft have found new complex organic molecules spewing from Saturn’s moon Enceladus. This is a clear sign that complex chemical reactions are taking place within its underground ocean. Some of these reactions could be part of chains that lead to even more complex, potentially biologically relevant molecules.
Published today in Nature Astronomy, this discovery further strengthens the case for a dedicated European Space Agency (ESA) mission to orbit and land on Enceladus.
In 2005, ...
Parkinson’s ‘trigger’ directly observed in human brain tissue for the first time
2025-10-01
Scientists have, for the first time, directly visualised and quantified the protein clusters believed to trigger Parkinson’s, marking a major advance in the study of the world’s fastest-growing neurological disease.
These tiny clusters, called alpha-synuclein oligomers, have long been considered the likely culprits for Parkinson’s disease to start developing in the brain, but until now, they have evaded direct detection in human brain tissue.
Now, researchers from the University of Cambridge, UCL, the Francis Crick Institute ...
Next-generation CAR T cells could expand solid cancer treatment options
2025-10-01
Chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T cell therapy, which uses a patient’s own immune cells to fight cancer, has emerged as a powerful way to treat lymphoma and other blood cancers. But researchers have struggled to adapt the treatment for solid tumors—including prostate, breast, lung and ovarian cancer—which make up about 90% of all cancer cases.
Now, a research team from the USC Norris Comprehensive Cancer Center, in collaboration with City of Hope, a national cancer research and treatment organization, ...
Fungi set the stage for life on land hundreds of millions of years earlier than thought
2025-10-01
New research published in Nature Ecology & Evolution sheds light on the timelines and pathways of evolution of fungi, finding evidence of their influence on ancient terrestrial ecosystems. The study, led by researchers from the Okinawa Institute of Science and Technology (OIST) and collaborators, indicates the diversification of fungi hundreds of millions of years before the emergence of land plants.
The five paths to a complex world
Professor Gergely J. Szöllősi, author on this study and head of the Model-Based Evolutionary ...
DNA evidence closes gaps in global conservation databases for Amazon wildlife
2025-10-01
PHOTOS: https://sandiegozoo.box.com/s/h8ne3q1md09rpor6ewp7070qvzv9k7nh
SAN DIEGO (Oct. 1, 2025) – Recent studies led by an international consortium of researchers, including scientists from the San Diego Zoo Wildlife Alliance and the Museo de Historia Natural de la Universidad Nacional Mayor de San Marcos, unveiled groundbreaking findings in biodiversity conservation through in situ DNA barcoding in the Peruvian Amazon.
Measuring the earth’s biological richness in one of its most remote and biodiverse regions is no small task. The Peruvian Amazon is in imminent danger of losing species to wildfires and habitat ...
New software tool aims to help scientists better analyze complex spatial data from tissues
2025-10-01
New York, NY [October 1, 2025]—Researchers at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai in New York, Boston Medical Center, and Boston University Chobanian & Avedisian School of Medicine, have developed a software platform to help scientists more easily analyze the molecular structure of tissue in both healthy and disease states. Details on the platform, called Giotto Suite, were reported in the October 1 online issue of Nature Methods [DOI: 10.1038/s41592-025-02817-w].
In recent years, new technologies have made it possible to capture detailed maps of RNA and proteins within intact tissues—a field known as spatial omics. These ...
And Swiss glaciers continue to melt
2025-10-01
Even the United Nations International Year of Glaciers' Preservation has seen further massive melting of glaciers in Switzerland. A winter with little snow was followed by heat waves in June 2025 that saw glaciers nearing the record levels of losses of 2022. Snow reserves from the winter were already depleted in the first half of July, and the ice masses began to melt earlier than had rarely ever been recorded. The cool weather in July provided some relief and prevented an even worse outcome. Nevertheless, almost a further three per cent of the ice volume was lost across Switzerland this year, ...
Scientists discover a key role of protons and superoxide ions in the respiratory chain
2025-10-01
Researchers from the Institute for Bioengineering of Catalonia (IBEC) and CIBER-BBN, in collaboration with teams from the University of Barcelona (UB) and the Institute of Chemical Research – cicCartuja, University of Seville-CSIC, have discovered that long-distance charge transport between two key proteins in the mitochondrial respiratory chain — cytochrome c and respiratory complex III — is mediated by protons and superoxide ions, which are reactive oxygen species. The study was recently published in the journal Small ...
Rare fossil reveals ancient leeches weren’t bloodsuckers
2025-10-01
A newly described fossil reveals that leeches are at least 200 million years older than scientists previously thought, and that their earliest ancestors may have feasted not on blood, but on smaller marine creatures.
“This is the only body fossil we’ve ever found of this entire group,” said Karma Nanglu, a paleontologist with the University of California, Riverside. He collaborated with researchers from the University of Toronto, University of São Paulo, and Ohio State University on a paper describing the fossil, which is now published in PeerJ.
Roughly ...
Study links shift work to higher risk of kidney stones, influenced by lifestyle factors
2025-10-01
Rochester, MN, October 1, 2025 – A study evaluating how various shift work patterns contribute to kidney stone risk has revealed that shift workers have a 15% higher risk of developing kidney stones, especially younger workers and those with low levels of manual labor. Body mass index (BMI), fluid intake, and other lifestyle factors play key roles contributing to the occurrence of kidney stones. The findings of the novel study in Mayo Clinic Proceedings, published by Elsevier, indicate that kidney stone prevention efforts should extend to shift workers.
Long-term shift work, identified ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
New AI enhances the view inside fusion energy systems
Combined resources will improve cardiovascular-kidney-metabolic care
Chatbots the new ‘doc?’ FAU researchers explore AI in health behavior coaching
A step toward diagnosing the flu with your tongue
Pathogenic yeast strains found in urban air but not along the coast
NYU Grossman School of Medicine leader to receive the 2025 Research Achievement Award
New AI tool detects hidden warning signs of disease
Astrocyte-endothelial cell interaction in the aging brain
When Washington tried to starve industries of loans—and failed
Cassini proves complex chemistry in Enceladus ocean
Parkinson’s ‘trigger’ directly observed in human brain tissue for the first time
Next-generation CAR T cells could expand solid cancer treatment options
Fungi set the stage for life on land hundreds of millions of years earlier than thought
DNA evidence closes gaps in global conservation databases for Amazon wildlife
New software tool aims to help scientists better analyze complex spatial data from tissues
And Swiss glaciers continue to melt
Scientists discover a key role of protons and superoxide ions in the respiratory chain
Rare fossil reveals ancient leeches weren’t bloodsuckers
Study links shift work to higher risk of kidney stones, influenced by lifestyle factors
Stronger together: Community involvement is key for new transport adoption
Scientific evidence that pianists can change timbre through touch
A polygenic risk score may predict future breast cancer in patients with early-stage diagnoses
Genetic test can predict who could develop invasive breast cancer
Uncovering the molecular basis of long COVID brain fog
Poor sleep may accelerate brain ageing
The Lancet Infectious Diseases: New study suggests risk of long COVID in children may be twice as high after a second infection
Risk of long COVID in kids doubles after second infection
Patient-reported outcome analysis of NRG Oncology trial in limited-stage small cell lung cancer suggests quality of life benefit with twice - (vs once -) daily radiation
NRG Oncology trial analysis shows improvement in survival outcomes for glioblastoma patients receiving proton therapy, trial moves to phase III
In a landmark move, ECMWF is poised to announce a new phase in its data sharing strategy
[Press-News.org] When Washington tried to starve industries of loans—and failedWhen federal regulators pressured banks to withdraw from controversial industries most companies simply borrowed elsewhere, a new study finds