(Press-News.org) CATONSVILLE, Md., Nov. 11, 2025 – A new peer-reviewed study in the INFORMS journal Decision Analysis finds that while generative AI (GenAI) can help define viable objectives for organizational and policy decision-making, the overall quality of those objectives falls short unless humans intervene.
In the field of decision analysis, defining objectives is a foundational step. Before you can evaluate options, allocate resources or design policies, you need to identify what you’re trying to achieve.
The research underscores that AI tools are valuable brainstorming partners, but sound decision analysis still requires a “human in the loop.”
The study, “ChatGPT vs. Experts: Can GenAI Develop High-Quality Organizational and Policy Objectives?” was authored by Jay Simon of American University and Johannes Ulrich Siebert of Management Center Innsbruck.
The researchers compared objectives generated by GenAI tools—including GPT-4o, Claude 3.7, Gemini 2.5 and Grok-2—to objectives created by professional decision analysts in six previously published Decision Analysis studies. Each GenAI-generated set was rated across nine key criteria from value-focused thinking (VFT), such as completeness, decomposability and redundancy.
They found that while GenAI frequently produced individually reasonable objectives, the sets as a whole were incomplete, redundant and often included “means objectives” despite explicit instructions to avoid them. “In short, AI can list what might matter, but it cannot yet distinguish what truly matters,” the authors wrote.
“Both lists are better than most individuals could create. However, neither list should be used for a quality decision analysis, as you should only include the fundamental objectives in explicitly evaluating alternatives,” said Ralph Keeney, a pioneer of value-focused thinking, in response to two AI-produced lists of objectives in the study.
To improve GenAI output, the researchers tested several prompting strategies, including chain-of-thought reasoning and expert critique-and-revise methods. When both techniques were combined, the AI’s results significantly improved—producing smaller, more focused and more logically structured sets of objectives.
“Generative AI performs well on several criteria,” said Simon. “But it still struggles with producing coherent and nonredundant sets of objectives. Human decision analysts are essential to refine and validate what the AI produces.”
Siebert added, “Our findings make clear that GenAI should augment, not replace, expert judgment. When humans and AI work together, they can leverage each other’s strengths for better decision making.”
The study concludes with a four-step hybrid model for decision-makers that integrates GenAI brainstorming with expert refinement to ensure the objectives used in analysis are essential, decomposable and complete.
Read the study here.
About INFORMS and Decision Analysis
INFORMS is the world’s largest association for professionals and students in operations research, AI, analytics and data science and related disciplines. It serves as a global authority advancing cutting-edge practices and fostering an interdisciplinary community of innovation.
Decision Analysis, a leading journal published by INFORMS, features research on modeling and supporting decision-making under uncertainty. INFORMS empowers its community to improve organizational performance and drive data-driven decision making through its journals, conferences and resources.
Learn more at www.informs.org or @informs.
END
New study finds generative AI can brainstorm objectives but needs human expertise for decision quality
2025-11-11
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
New analysis yields clearer picture of toxin-producing blue-green algae blooms
2025-11-11
CORVALLIS, Ore. – A long-term analysis shows that a major Oregon reservoir abruptly swapped one type of toxic algae for another midway through the 12-year study period, absent any obvious cause.
The project provides a novel look at harmful algal blooms, or HABs, which pose multiple health risks to people and animals worldwide.
Harmful algal blooms in lakes and reservoirs are explosions of cyanobacteria, often referred to as blue-green algae. Microscopic organisms ubiquitous in all types of water around the globe, cyanobacteria use sunlight to make their own food and in warm, nutrient-rich environments can quickly multiply, resulting in blooms that spread across ...
Trainer identification project treads new ground
2025-11-11
Forensic experts are inviting the public to put their trainer knowledge to the test – and contribute to an award-winning research project.
Led by University of Staffordshire and West Yorkshire Police, When All is Tread and Done is exploring new forensic techniques to help identify criminals by their shoes.
Project lead Professor Claire Gwinnett explained: “While CCTV, body-worn cameras and mobile footage is increasingly used in criminal investigations, suspects often cover their faces.
“Shoes, however, can be a distinguishing feature in CCTV footage or images and that is what our research is ...
Parsa & Ascoli studying neuromorphic spintronics
2025-11-11
Principal Investigator Maryam Parsa, Assistant Professor of Electrical and Computer Engineering, College of Engineering and Computing (CEC), and co-Principal Investigator Giorgio Ascoli, Distinguished Professor of Bioengineering and Neuroscience, College of Science, received funding from the U.S. Department of Energy for the project: “GAINS: Generalizable, Analog, Izhikevich-Based Neuromorphic Spintronics for Next-Generation Computing.” PI-Parsa is leading this collaborative project with two other co-PIs from University of Wisconsin–Madison (Prof. Akhilesh Jaiswal) and Northwestern University ...
Cancer quality improvement program cuts missed radiation appointments by 40%
2025-11-11
Key Takeaways
Cancer patients who frequently miss radiation appointments experience worse clinical outcomes than those who complete their recommended treatment.
Transportation barriers, unrelated illnesses, and not wanting to continue with treatment are the most common reasons patients miss radiation appointments.
Providing patients with structured and individualized support can reduce missed radiation therapy appointments by almost half, a national quality improvement project found.
CHICAGO — A national quality improvement program led by the American College of Surgeons (ACS) found that transportation barriers and illness are among the top reasons cancer patients miss critical ...
Innovation turns building vents into carbon-capture devices
2025-11-11
A nanofiber air filter developed by the University of Chicago Pritzker School of Molecular Engineering (UChicago PME) could turn existing building ventilation into carbon-capture devices while cutting homeowners’ energy costs.
In a paper recently published in Science Advances, researchers from the lab of UChicago PME Asst. Prof. Po-Chun Hsu developed a distributed carbon nanofiber direct air capture (DAC) filter that could potentially turn every home, office, school or other building into a small carbon-capture system working toward the global problem of airborne CO2.
A ...
Discussion approach improves comprehension for 4th, 5th graders, study finds
2025-11-11
UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — Small-group discussions designed to help elementary students engage in conversations that promote critical analytic thinking, reasoning and deeper understanding of the content they read increased critical thinking over time for fourth- and fifth-grade students, according to a new study by a team that includes researchers from the Penn State College of Education. It’s the latest evidence in support of Quality Talk, the “deliberate approach to discussion that transforms student engagement” developed by P. Karen Murphy, associate dean for research and outreach in the Penn State College ...
Non-native plant species adapt to natural ecosystems faster than expected
2025-11-11
For a long time, scientists assumed that newly established plants in Europe served less often as food or hosts for native animals and fungi, since they share no common evolutionary history with local fauna and could therefore spread particularly aggressively. According to Staude, the study confirms this initial phase. However, the study also showed that this changes over time: after a few centuries, many of these plants are increasingly used by plant parasites. Unlike pollinators, plant parasites are usually highly specialised in native plants – which makes the findings all the more surprising, according to Staude. “We also observe in this context that ...
It’s not just in your head: Stress may lead to altered blood flow in the brain
2025-11-11
UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — While the exact causes of neurodegenerative brain diseases like Alzheimer's and dementia are still largely unknown, researchers have been able to identify a key characteristic in affected brains: reduced blood flow. Building upon this foundational understanding, a team at Penn State recently found that a rare neuron that is extremely vulnerable to anxiety-induced stress appears to be responsible for regulating blood flow and coordinating neural activity in mice.
The researchers found that eliminating type-one nNOS neurons — which make up less than 1% of the brain’s 80 billion neurons and die off when exposed to too much stress — resulted ...
Automated high-throughput system developed to generate structural materials databases
2025-11-11
A NIMS research team has developed an automated high-throughput system capable of generating datasets from a single sample of a superalloy used in aircraft engines. The system successfully produced an experimental dataset containing several thousand records—each consisting of interconnected processing conditions, microstructural features and resulting yield strengths (referred to as “Process–Structure–Property datasets” below)—in just 13 days. Datasets are generated over 200 times faster than when using conventional methods. The system’s ability to rapidly produce large-scale, comprehensive datasets has the potential to significantly ...
PolyU research drives commercialization of energy-efficient solar cell technology towards 40% efficiency milestone
2025-11-11
Third-generation solar cell technology is advancing rapidly. An engineering research team at The Hong Kong Polytechnic University (PolyU) has achieved a breakthrough in the field of perovskite/silicon tandem solar cells (TSCs), focusing on addressing challenges that include improving efficiency, stability and scalability. The team has conducted a comprehensive analysis of TSC performance and provided strategic recommendations, which aim to raise the energy conversion efficiency of this new type of solar cell from the current maximum of approximately 34% to ...