PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

WI Court Upholds Father's Right to Sue for Death of Unborn Fetus

Wisconsin appellate court finds that mothers owe a duty of care to the unborn fetus.

2010-09-09
September 09, 2010 (Press-News.org) This past July, a Wisconsin appellate court ruled that the father of an unborn child has a right to bring a lawsuit against the mother for her negligence in causing the death of the fetus.

Trial Court Finds No Liability for Insurance Company

In February 2003, Alicia Vander Meulen was hit by a pickup truck after pulling out of Culvers in Wisconsin Rapids, WI. At the time, she was 27 weeks pregnant. As a result of the automobile accident, the fetus was stillborn at birth.

The father of the child, Shannon Tesar, argued that Meulen and the driver of the pick-up truck, Brett Anderson, were negligent in causing the death of his unborn child. Tesar brought a wrongful death action against Anderson and against American Family Insurance, which insured both Anderson and Meulen.

American Family argued that it was not responsible for the negligence of Vander Meulen that led to the fetus's death. The trial court agreed, holding that under Wisconsin law, pregnant women do not owe a duty of care to their unborn children and that even if Meulen had owed such a duty, liability could not be imposed against American Family based on public policy reasons. The trial court then dismissed the suit against American Family.

Appellate Court Finds Mother Breached Duty of Care

On appeal, the 4th District Court of Appeals reversed the lower court's ruling. The court pointed out that Wisconsin follows the dissenting opinion in Palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad Co. 162 NE 99 (NY 1928), which holds that individuals owe a duty of care to the world at large to refrain from acts that unreasonably harm or threaten the safety of others. Most states follow the majority rule in Palsgraf: that the duty of care is owed not to the world, but to the specific person complaining of the harm.

Following the dissent in Palsgraf, the appellate court reasoned that the correct question in this case was not whether Meulen owed a duty of care to the fetus, but whether she owed a duty of care to the world to operate her vehicle in a reasonably safe manner. The court said that she did owe such a duty and that by breaching it, Meulen harmed Tesar by causing the death of the fetus.

The appellate court also found that public policy does not prevent liability from being imposed against American Family. In Wisconsin, courts will release liability on public policy grounds only under "unusual and extreme conditions" in which it would shock the public conscience to impose liability. After looking at the six most common grounds for dismissing liability for public policy reasons, the court concluded that they did not apply in this case.

Appellate Court Rejects "Slippery Slope" Argument

American Family argued that if the court found there was an affirmative duty of care to an unborn fetus, it would open the door to an "unprecedented and invasive expansion of the law into the mother's womb." The insurance company said that such a precedent would allow fathers to bring lawsuits against mothers for other harms against the fetus, including smoking, poor diet, and failing to take prenatal vitamins.

The 4th District, however, disagreed with American Family. The court said that it was well-established law to hold insurance companies liable for the negligent acts of their policyholders, including suits brought by children and fathers against negligent mothers in car accident cases.

The court also rejected American Family's arguments that it should follow the precedent of other jurisdictions that have held pregnant women do not owe a duty to unborn fetuses. For example, in an Illinois case brought by a child against the mother for injuries caused to the child in-utero during an automobile accident, the Illinois Supreme Court held that the mother did not owe a legal duty to the fetus.

The Wisconsin appellate court, however, was not persuaded.

Article provided by Clancy Law
Visit us at www.clancylaw.com


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Texting Drivers Elude Police, But Not Accidents

2010-09-09
Eight months after Illinois enacted a statewide ban on texting while driving, police across the state report limited results from the program. The law forbids drivers from reading, composing or sending electronic messages. However, enforcing this law has proven difficult. Drivers often keep their phones out of sight, or put them away when in the vicinity of police officers. Some communities have set up targeted undercover operations or found other successfully means of enforcement. In Buffalo Grove, an officer stood at an intersection with a donation can. He wasn't ...

Know Your Legal Rights When Severe Storms Cause Damage and Injuries

2010-09-09
The storm that hit the D.C. metro area on Sunday, July 25 caused widespread damage in Virginia, Maryland, and Pennsylvania. Four people died as a result of the storm; one on a personal watercraft on Chesapeake Bay, two from falling trees, and one from electrocution from a downed power line. The term "acts of God" is sometimes used to describe events such as a tree falling through a house due to a storm, and the term convincingly captures the random, unpredictable nature of these storms. But the destruction these storms cause is not wholly random--often it begins with ...

The Real Dangers of Truck Driver Fatigue

2010-09-09
They're the biggest things on the road: semi-trucks rolling on our nation's highways and interstates at high speeds. Fatigued drivers of the super-sized trucks are disproportionately involved in fatal crashes and accidents involving serious injuries. The National Transportation Safety Board states that "truck driver fatigue may be a contributing factor in as many as 30 to 40 percent of all heavy truck accidents." Fatigue Behind the Wheel of a Big Truck When the driver of an 80,000-pound commercial truck is fatigued or otherwise failing to drive safely, bad things ...

Congress Passes Law to Increase Safety on Commercial Flights

2010-09-09
This August, President Obama signed the Airline Safety and Federal Aviation Administration Extension Act of 2010 (P.L. 111-216) into law. The Act is the first piece of major federal legislation aimed at strengthening airline safety standards passed in the last 20 years. Most notably, the Act requires all commercial airline pilots to have completed a minimum of 1500 flight hours in addition to "appropriate" operational experience before they may begin piloting commercial passenger flights. Prior to the law's enactment, pilots needed to complete as little as 250 hours ...

Kuoni Reveals its Top 10 Holiday Hotlist

2010-09-09
Kuoni has announced the launch of the Kuoni Holiday Hotlist, a collection of top hotels and tours selected to suit a range of travel needs.  Realising that every traveller wants different things from their individual holiday, Kuoni travel experts have searched the world personally checking and hand-picking the best resorts to make it easier for customers to choose between them. The Hotlist includes the Top 10 Holiday destinations for value, romance, wellness, all-inclusive and culture, in worldwide destinations for travel between October 2010 and June 2011. The Kuoni ...

Promethean and BrainPOP Announce Integrated Assessments for Learning

2010-09-09
BrainPOP, the award-winning creator of animated, educational resources, is pleased to announce that its curriculum-based quizzes are now fully integrated with Promethean's learner response systems, ActiVote and ActivExpression. The integration of ActiVote and ActivExpression, the industry-leading learner response system, with BrainPOP's quizzes - including all BrainPOP Jr. (K-3) topics - makes it easier than ever for teachers to improve learning outcomes by providing highly individualized instruction and assessment. Linking BrainPOP's content to learner response devices ...

Debenhams Breaks Ranks and Launches New Season with Designer Discounts

2010-09-09
Department store retailer Debenhams turned the convention of the sale on its head by reducing prices at the start of the Autumn/Winter season, rather than the end of it. The innovative move sees tens of thousands of new season lines reduced by up to 25 per cent, across new to store stock including womenswear, accessories, menswear, childrenswear, home, cosmetics, lingerie, sports and leisure and gifting. The move will no doubt be popular with consumers, with many remaining cautious due to the continuing, challenging economic climate following spending cuts and the ...

The Harley Medical Group Reports an Increase in Bald Patch Treatments

2010-09-09
The Harley Medical Group has reported demand from male patients for laser rejuvenation treatments is up +93% over the last quarter, across its 30 clinics. Laser rejuvenation treatments now account for 11% of all non-surgical treatments carried out during June, July and August at the UK's largest cosmetic surgery group. More unusual requests received this year are for skin regeneration treatments on receding hairlines, including laser treatment and chemical peels to reduce the appearance of aging sun spots. Laura Marshall, specialist nurse counsellor at The Harley ...

MyBritishColumbiaInfo.com Reaching International Travellers Via Social Networking

2010-09-09
MyBritishColumbiaInfo.com, a member of the award-winning MyDestinationInfo.com travel network, continues to grow in popularity since its first few months of launching on the network and is now adding social media tools to further reach travellers and directly interact with visitors of the website. MyBritishColumbiaInfo.com provides a range of options that assist visitors in connecting directly with businesses and services in British Columbia. Promoting the best of Canada's westernmost province, MyBritishColumbiaInfo.com showcases its travel industry sector from popular ...

Hays Reports Millions Being Spent on Coaching Without a Business Purpose

2010-09-09
Hays Senior Finance reports that while multi-millions of pounds are spent on coaching across the UK, 15% of organisations admit they have absolutely no measurements in place to assess the impact of their programmes. A new survey from Hays Senior Finance, working with expert coach/ mentors LeaderShape, shows that coaching is often undertaken without evaluating the return on investment. The survey also shows that 68% of businesses fail to use coaching directly to address corporate objectives and outcomes are often simply referenced at a personal level. According to ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Chung-Ang University researchers unveil the biogenesis and role of transfer RNA fragments in cancer progression

Secret of the female orgasm uncovered by psychologists

Breakthrough in zinc-based rechargeable batteries: A safer, sustainable alternative

"Superman" bacteria offer a sustainable boost to chemical production

FunMap reveals a functional network of genes and proteins in human cancer

First full characterization of kidney microbiome unlocks potential to prevent kidney stones

IMDEA Software researchers present MixBuy, a protocol for secure and privacy-preserving digital purchases

Having a good breakfast reduces cardiovascular risk

New study reveals provincial and territorial inequities and inadequacies in access to medications and treatment for cardiovascular conditions in Canada

Pre-seed funding to recolor the world greener

New research unlocks jaw-dropping evolution of lizards and snakes

Cardiorespiratory fitness linked to preservation of cognitive abilities in older age

Around 1 in 5 of the world’s under 50s living with genital herpes (HSV)

Cutting early life exposure to parental smoking may lower MS risk in genetically prone

High-flow nasal oxygen vs noninvasive ventilation in patients with acute respiratory failure

Flexible hibernation could help hedgehogs adapt to environmental changes

What is a unit of nature? New framework shows the challenges involved with establishing a biodiversity credit market

NYCEDC and NYU Tandon launch applications for new digital game design incubator

Soda taxes don’t just affect sales. They help change people’s minds.

Early restrictive vs liberal oxygen for trauma patients

Enabling AI to explain its predictions in plain language

A greener, cleaner way to extract cobalt from ‘junk’ materials

Better environmental performance boosts profits and cuts costs

Making self-driving cars safer, less accident prone

Rethinking the quantum chip

When does waiting stop being worth it?

Nationwide study looks at when and where EV owners use public charging stations

A new discovery about the source of the vast energy in cosmic rays

Cancer ‘fingerprint’ can improve early detection

Rethinking the brain pacemaker: How better materials can improve signals

[Press-News.org] WI Court Upholds Father's Right to Sue for Death of Unborn Fetus
Wisconsin appellate court finds that mothers owe a duty of care to the unborn fetus.