(Press-News.org) General Medical Council (GMC) decisions about doctors who qualified outside the UK are more likely to have far reaching consequences (high impact decisions), finds research published on bmj.com today.
The authors, led by Professor Charlotte Humphrey from King's College London, say there is no clear reason why overseas doctors do worse in GMC fitness to practise processes than their UK-trained peers.
Humphrey argues that perhaps "real differences exist in fitness to practise between groups of doctors who are referred to the GMC" or "that the GMC processes tend to discriminate against certain groups of doctors."
However, the authors stress that their research makes it "difficult to reach a conclusion that clearly supports either of these potential explanations and both might be valid."
The study looked at GMC cases between 1 April 2006 and 31 March 2008. The researchers reviewed the background to 7,526 inquiries to the GMC concerning 6,954 doctors. They assessed how many inquiries were referred for further investigation, how many were investigated and then referred for adjudication, and how many resulted in doctors being erased or suspended from the medical register.
The results show that of the 7,526 inquiries, 4,702 related to doctors who had qualified in the UK, 624 in the European Union (EU) and 2,190 who had qualified outside the EU. At the initial GMC stage (triage) 29% of inquiries concerning UK qualified doctors had a high impact decision compared with 43% for EU doctors and 46% for non-EU doctors.
At the adjudication stage 1% of UK qualified doctors were erased or suspended from the medical register compared to 4% of EU doctors and 3% of non-EU doctors.
The authors conclude that their research raises questions about the GMC fitness to practise processes. They speculate that perhaps inquiries involving UK-qualified doctors are being assessed less seriously than those involving non-UK qualified doctors.
Humphrey and colleagues also question whether some non-UK qualified doctors may not be well placed to defend themselves or challenge decisions compared to their UK-trained colleagues.
In an accompanying editorial, Marcella Nunez-Smith, Assistant Professor at Yale University School of Medicine, says that given the rise in the dependence on foreign-trained doctors in countries like the UK and US, it is essential to determine "whether international medical graduates offer the same quality of care as doctors who train and practise in destination countries."
Nunez-Smith argues that Humphrey's research is a critical contribution to the debate but that "additional research on the association between other doctor related characteristics, such as ethnicity, and the fitness to practise process is needed."
INFORMATION: END
Medical and military leaders have come together today to warn that climate change not only spells a global health catastrophe, but also threatens global stability and security.
"Climate change poses an immediate and grave threat, driving ill-health and increasing the risk of conflict, such that each feeds upon the other," they write in an editorial published on bmj.com today. Their views come ahead of an open meeting on these issues to be held at the British Medical Association on 20 June 2011.
The authors point to several reports, highlighting the threat that climate ...
Research led by Warwick Medical School at the University of Warwick has found that Metformin, a drug treatment used to treat diabetes and also in women with Polycystic vary syndrome (PCOS), may potentially provide protection against endometrial cancer.
Endometrial cancer is the most common malignancy of the female genital tract and the fourth most common cancer in women in the UK and the US. Up to a third of PCOS women also have endometrial hyperplasia which, in turn predisposes these women to endometrial cancer. PCOS affects 5%-10% of women of reproductive age, where ...
Bremerhaven/Vienna, 05.04.2011. Over the past few days ozone-depleted air masses extended from the north pole to southern Scandinavia leading to higher than normal levels of ultraviolet (UV) radiation during sunny days in southern Finland. These air masses will move east over the next few days, covering parts of Russia and perhaps extend as far south as the Chinese/Russian border. Such excursions of ozone-depleted air may also occur over Central Europe and could reach as far south as the Mediterranean. On an international press conference by the World Meteorological Organisation ...
Berlin's Theatertreffen is one of the most important events of the year for fans of German-language theatre.
Taking place at the Haus der Berliner Festspiele between Friday May 6th and Monday May 23rd, this 'theatre meeting' is based around a showcase of the ten best productions from the previous season.
The plays are selected by an independent jury of experts from a list of approximately 400 productions staged in the German capital.
In addition, Theatertreffen includes a varied programme of discussions, premieres, prize ceremonies, concerts and exhibitions.
The ...
Devices which could be used to rehabilitate the arms and hands of people who have experienced a stroke have been developed by researchers at the University of Southampton.
In a paper to be presented this week (6 April) at the Institution of Engineering and Technology (IET) Assisted Living Conference, Dr Geoff Merrett, a lecturer in electronic systems and devices, will describe the design and evaluation of three technologies which could help people who are affected by stroke to regain movement in their hand and arm.
Dr Merrett worked with Dr Sara Demain, a lecturer in ...
Kid Koala is poised to give a demonstration of his world-renowned turntable skills in Bilbao later this month.
The Montreal-based DJ - real name Eric San - will appear at the Spanish city's Kafe Antzokia on Friday April 29th, when fans of his inventive and idiosyncratic style are expected to be out in force.
Having released several albums on the influential British dance music label Ninja Tune, Kid Koala has established an international fan base and performed to packed venues around the world.
The artist, who has also published his own full-length graphic novel, ...
The sudden death of a young athlete always prompts full media attention, most recently spurring a call for preventative screening methods, including costly electrocardiogram (EKG) tests for all school-age athletes. But a new study by Dr. Sami Viskin of Tel Aviv University's Sackler Faculty of Medicine found that these screening measures, which are now mandatory in Israel and other countries, does not reduce the incidence of sudden death syndrome.
"There's a lot of debate about this in the U.S. right now," says Dr. Viskin, even though cardiac arrest in athletes remains ...
Every year on May 1st, the people of Rome gather for a special day of music in the Piazza San Giovanni.
Known as the Primo Maggio concert, this free event represents the Italian capital's first festival of the spring season and is usually attended by people from all over the country.
The line-up is traditionally announced just days before the festival, so visitors will have to wait to see who is performing.
However, the event usually features a number of well-known Italian pop bands, solo acts and international artists, with the likes of Hard-Fi and Marlene Kuntz ...
Research published in the Cancer Cell journal in March was a significant step in knowing the causes of cancer better, especially breast cancer, revealing that the lack or loss of a protein in the cells known as SIRT3, induces the proliferation of this disease and thereby, this protein can be an may be a therapeutic target in the development of effective therapies for cancer. The research was led by Dra. Marcia Haigis of the Harvard Medical School, with the participation of Dr. Arkaitz Carracedo, from the Proteomics Laboratory at CIC bioGUNE.
One of the grand aims of the ...
Visitors to Naples next month may get a chance to see the city's football team take on Udinese in a crucial Serie A fixture.
Both sides are chasing the title in Italy's top domestic league, as Napoli currently occupy third place in the table and their rivals from the north-east are just three points behind in fourth.
The two sides will face each other at the famous Stadio San Paolo in Naples on Sunday April 17th, with the match shaping up to be a decisive moment in the season.
Although league leaders AC Milan and second-placed Internazionale are considered more ...
