(Press-News.org) With a push to make hospitals and doctors more accountable for health care quality, more attention must be paid to the accuracy and reliability of measures used to evaluate caregivers, says a prominent Johns Hopkins patient safety expert.
Writing in the April issue of the journal Health Affairs, Peter J. Pronovost, M.D., Ph.D., a professor of anesthesiology and critical care medicine at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, argues that as the desire to evaluate and improve health care intensifies, there remains little consensus as to which measures are scientifically valid and accurate assessments of quality. This risks misinforming patients who may make decisions based on metrics that poorly reflect the state of health care provided by hospitals and may ultimately lead to a failure to make improvements in hospitals where quality is judged to be better than it is, he says.
"There is bipartisan support behind efforts to start paying for value rather than volume," Pronovost says. "This is great, but we act as if there's a whole library of reliable outcome measures for us to use and the fact is that serious work needs to be done to create them. We can't shrink from doing this science. We need to be guided by it."
Acknowledging that substantial shortcomings in the quality of care persist, causing needless patient harm and increasing health care costs, Pronovost says fixes can't be put in place until rigorous scientific data show exactly where systems are broken and until hard comparative evidence points to what types of repairs work best.
In the absence of such safety and efficacy science, he says, there will remain little consensus among hospitals and physicians about the best methods to judge quality or improvement. For example, he notes that overall hospital death rates are an imperfect reflection of quality of care, but in some cases they are the only measures used.
Pronovost, writing with Richard Lilford, Ph.D., an epidemiologist at University of Birmingham in England, points also to research that compared four different measurement services used to assess the same data from the same hospitals to determine in-hospital mortality. Forty-three percent of hospitals that showed higher-than-expected mortality by one commercially available metric showed lower-than-expected mortality by another.
Pronovost and Lilford call for the creation of an independent agency, the equivalent of a Securities and Exchange Commission for health care, to create rational and standardized outcome measures similar to the accounting rules the SEC creates for businesses. "The goal is to make the process of determining quality standard and transparent, and make data meaningful for consumers and usable by clinicians, ultimately improving patient outcomes," Pronovost says.
Doctors support the use of outcome measures if they are valid and reliable enough to enable conclusions to be drawn about the quality of care, Pronovost says. Too often, he says, they aren't. Hospitals, he notes, once were being fined for hospital bloodstream infections after government regulators screened billing claims for codes signifying infections to calculate infection rates. "That measurement gets it right only one in four times — 25 percent of the time," he says. "Clinicians have never used that data because they thought that it was useless, because it was useless."
Now, government regulators make judgments based on Centers for Disease Control and Prevention data, which include lab tests, temperature readings and other signs and symptoms of infection — far more accurate measures, he says.
Meanwhile, Pronovost says some states penalize institutions for what they deem are preventable complications contracted by patients during their hospital stays. But, he says, hospitals don't know exactly what they are being judged on because those states use a proprietary algorithm created by a private company to determine which hospitals are "successful" and which ones should be sanctioned. Clinicians and the public neither know how accurate the measures are nor how they were calculated.
"The process should be transparent and reproducible; instead it's a black box," he says. "We don't know if it gets it 5 percent right or 95 percent. We ought to know how imperfect it is."
In a second article also published in Health Affairs, Pronovost, along with Jill A. Marsteller, Ph.D., of the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, and Christine A. Goeschel, Sc.D., R.N., M.P.A., M.P.S., in the Department of Anesthesiology and Critical Care Medicine, present a case study of a success story in measuring outcomes: central line-associated bloodstream infections.
The group outlines the Hopkins-led effort to virtually eliminate bloodstream infections in intensive-care units throughout Michigan, which is now in nearly every state and has reduced the number of deaths. Infection rates have fallen dramatically in ICUs where Pronovost's cockpit-like checklist and culture-of-safety program were implemented. This is one of the few, perhaps only, national success stories documenting measurable improvements in patient outcomes. The Hopkins program is now being implemented across the United States. Data from the first 22 states that have participated in the program for over a year suggests infections have been reduced by approximately 40 percent.
"There are precious few outcome measures deemed valid by clinicians," he says. "This is one of them."
### END
Unreliable 'outcomes' measures hamper efforts to assure better, safer care
Johns Hopkins patient safety expert argues that current 'metrics' don't paint clear picture of quality
2011-04-08
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Evolution of the animal temperature sensor: The functional adaptation to environmental change
2011-04-08
The animals on the earth have adapted themselves to the environmental temperature changes such as hot in deserts, or cold in the glacial epochs. However, the molecular mechanism for adaptation to thermal environments in the evolutionary process involving temperature sensors was not well understood. Professor Makoto Tominaga and Assistant Professor Shigeru Saito at The National Institute for Physiological Sciences (Okazaki Institute for Integrative Bioscience) demonstrate that the molecule called TRP channels, serve as temperature sensors in animals, sense different temperature ...
Fukushima-related measurements by the CTBTO
2011-04-08
Since the double disaster of the 9.0 magnitude earthquake and tsunami that affected hundreds of thousands of people and seriously damaged the Fukushima Daichi power plant in Japan on 11 March 2011, minute traces of radioactive emissions from Fukushima have spread across the entire northern hemisphere. A monitoring network designed to detect signs of nuclear explosions picked up these traces from the stricken power plant.
To date, more than 30 radionuclide stations that are part of the International Monitoring System (IMS) have provided information on the spread of radioactive ...
NASA telescopes join forces to observe unprecedented explosion
2011-04-08
WASHINGTON -- NASA's Swift, Hubble Space Telescope and Chandra X-ray Observatory have teamed up to study one of the most puzzling cosmic blasts yet observed. More than a week later, high-energy radiation continues to brighten and fade from its location.
Astronomers say they have never seen anything this bright, long-lasting and variable before. Usually, gamma-ray bursts mark the destruction of a massive star, but flaring emission from these events never lasts more than a few hours.
Although research is ongoing, astronomers say that the unusual blast likely arose when ...
Lifesaving antibiotics face doubtful future
2011-04-08
[April 7, 2011, WASHINGTON] – To head off a health care disaster, the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA) has developed a plan to combat deadly antibiotic-resistant "super bugs" and is rolling out the multi-pronged plan today, on World Health Day 2011.
Infections are becoming increasingly resistant to existing antibiotics, while the number of new antibiotics being developed has plummeted. IDSA warns that unless sweeping actions are taken now, the future could resemble the days before these miracle drugs were developed. People will die of common infections and ...
Scientists exploit ash tree pest's chemical communication
2011-04-08
This release is available in Spanish.
A newly identified chemical sex attractant, or pheromone, of the emerald ash borer could mean improved traps for monitoring and controlling the tree-killing beetle. That's the goal of U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) entomologist Allard Cossé and his colleagues.
Cossé has been searching for such attractants since 2007 as part of a multidisciplinary team of scientists from USDA's Agricultural Research Service (ARS), Forest Service (FS) and Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS). Early success came with the identification ...
Starch-controlling gene fuels more protein in soybean plants
2011-04-08
AMES, Iowa – A newly discovered gene introduced into soybean plants has increased the amount of protein in the plant's seed and could hold promise for helping meet nutritional needs of a hungry world.
Eve Wurtele, professor of genetics, development and cell biology; and Ling Li, an adjunct assistant professor and an associate scientist working in her laboratory, have placed a gene found only in Arabidopsis plants into soybean plants and increased the amount of protein in the soybean seeds by 30 to 60 percent.
The results were a pleasant surprise to the researchers as ...
CasinoAUS Network produces EUR22,409.30 Prog Slots Winner
2011-04-08
Australian-themed online casino operators, the CasinoAUS.com Network, have awarded their registered patron KB with the sum of EUR22,409.30 on the player's having won on the Progressive Jackpot slots game LotsaLoot, a highly popular gaming title on the Network. The CasinoAUS.com Network boasts a gaming portfolio of 24 separate titles, 18 of which fall under the online casino slots gaming subcategory. The popularity of Progressive Jackpot games in the online arena - specifically of the online slots variety - is undisputed in the online gaming industry. The reason for this ...
Video games effective treatment for stroke patients: study
2011-04-08
TORONTO, Ont., April 7, 2011 – Virtual reality and other video games can significantly improve motor function in stroke patients, according to research from St. Michael's Hospital.
Patients who played video games, such as Wii and Playstation, were up to five times more likely to show improvements in arm motor function compared to those who had standard therapy.
"Virtual reality gaming is a promising and potentially useful alternative to enhance motor improvement after stroke," said Dr. Gustavo Saposnik, the lead author of the study and the director of the Stroke Outcomes ...
Monitoring system warns of slippery slopes
2011-04-08
Doren in the Austrian Bregenzerwald, February 2007: a slope 650 meters long breaks, resulting in a massive slide into the valley below. The nearest residential buildings are very close to the 70-meter-high rim. This barely avoided catastrophe is not the only incident. Geologists have been monitoring increasingly unstable masses of earth over the past few years in the Alps and other Alpine regions, which have slipped down slopes and on slid unchecked down valleys to more stable substrates. The scientists are primarily looking at heavy rainfall and snowmelt caused by climatie ...
Utah's Immigration Law: A Saner State Solution to a National Issue?
2011-04-08
Border states from California to Texas have been the site of some of the most heated rhetoric over U.S. immigration policy in recent years. After Arizona's passage of its notorious state law dominated American headlines for weeks in 2010, politicians in many states around the country followed suit by introducing similar legislation. Recent legislation approved by the Utah legislature and awaiting its governor's signature is receiving praise as a rare example of "sane" immigration policy.
Key features of the Utah immigration reform bill include enhanced law enforcement, ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Who does Darth Vader vote for? Not the same party as Harry Potter
Ground breaking advances in construction robotics in extreme environments unveiled in review
New strategies to enhance chiral optical signals unveiled
Cambridge research uncovers powerful virtual reality treatment for speech anxiety
2025 Gut Microbiota for Health World Summit to spotlight groundbreaking research
International survey finds that support for climate interventions is tied to being hopeful and worried about climate change
Cambridge scientist launches free VR platform that eliminates the fear of public speaking
Open-Source AI matches top proprietary model in solving tough medical cases
Good fences make good neighbors (with carnivores)
NRG Oncology trial supports radiotherapy alone following radical hysterectomy should remain the standard of care for early-stage, intermediate-risk cervical cancer
Introducing our new cohort of AGA Future Leaders
Sharks are dying at alarming rates, mostly due to fishing. Retention bans may help
Engineering excellence: Engineers with ONR ties elected to renowned scientific academy
New CRISPR-based diagnostic test detects pathogens in blood without amplification
Immunotherapy may boost KRAS-targeted therapy in pancreatic cancer
Growing solar: Optimizing agrivoltaic systems for crops and clean energy
Scientists discover how to reactivate cancer’s molecular “kill switch”
YouTube influencers: gaming’s best friend or worst enemy?
uOttawa scientists use light to unlock secret of atoms
NJIT mathematician to help map Earth's last frontier with Navy grant
NASA atmospheric wave-studying mission releases data from first 3,000 orbits
‘Microlightning’ in water droplets may have sparked life on Earth
Smoke from wildland-urban interface fires more deadly than remote wildfires
What’s your body really worth? New AI model reveals your true biological age from 5 drops of blood
Protein accidentally lassos itself, helping explain unusual refolding behavior
With bird flu in raw milk, many in U.S. still do not know risks of consuming it
University of Minnesota research team awarded $3.8 million grant to develop cell therapy to combat Alzheimer’s disease
UConn uncovers new clue on what is leading to neurodegenerative diseases like Alzheimer’s and ALS
Resuscitation in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest – it’s how quickly it is done, rather than who does it
A closer look at biomolecular ‘silly putty’
[Press-News.org] Unreliable 'outcomes' measures hamper efforts to assure better, safer careJohns Hopkins patient safety expert argues that current 'metrics' don't paint clear picture of quality