May 08, 2011 (Press-News.org) Florida Legislature Looks at Better Criminal Identification Procedures
TV crime programs tend to suggest that every aspect of solving a crime lends itself to forensic science, as if CSI has been reduced to a magical formula. But in many criminal investigations, identification of the alleged perpetrator is still dependent on the recollections of eyewitnesses. And all too often, a false identification can lead to a prosecution of the wrong suspect in a homicide, sexual assault or theft case, all due to a convergence of unfortunate circumstances.
Florida legislators are currently considering measures that are intended to make identification of criminal suspects more reliable. HB 821 and SB 1206, the Eyewitness Identification Reform Act, would mandate specified procedures for conducting lineups intended to identify criminal suspects.
One key to such reforms is the use of a "double blind" lineup, wherein the officer administering the process, like the witness, does not know the identity of the suspect among the people in the lineup. Eyewitnesses must sign an acknowledgement that proper instructions were given. The bill also requires the Criminal Justice Standards and Training Commission to provide educational materials to law enforcement agencies and conduct ongoing training programs.
One clear indicator of the extent of the problem can be found in cases where a convicted felon was later exonerated due to exculpatory DNA evidence. Of twelve such past exonerations in Florida, nine convictions were dependent on witness misidentification of the suspect. Data suggests that three quarters of the nearly 300 DNA exonerations that have occurred nationwide featured faulty identifications.
An unreliable witness identification was at the heart of the case of Derrick Williams, who became Florida's thirteenth exonerated prison inmate in April after serving 18 years of a life sentence for rape. "This case highlights the need for prosecutors to closely scrutinize identifications before trial and for judges in Florida to be more open to hearing from scientific experts who can help the juries better understand how to properly evaluate such IDs if they do come in at trial," said Innocence Project of Florida Executive Director Seth Miller.
Florida Criminal Defense Lawyers Must Hold Prosecutors to Their Evidentiary Burden
Regardless of the nature of the alleged offense -- from a violent crime to complex illegal financial actions -- a defense attorney's primary job is to protect the client from the worst consequences of a conviction. Whether a witness misidentified his or her assailant or a series of misunderstood transactions leads to allegations of fraud against a financial professional, counsel must examine every aspect of the evidence to cast doubt in the minds of prosecutors, if possible, before charges are filed.
The prosecution's burden of proof beyond a reasonable doubt is not just a slogan. Our criminal justice system requires proof that an accused person actually committed the crime, and judges and juries cannot be allowed to depend on assumptions. By advocating for better identification procedures and other improvements of evidence gathering, Florida criminal defense lawyers work to ensure justice for all defendants.
Article provided by Rothman & Associates, P.A.
Visit us at www.tandrlaw.com
Florida Legislature Looks at Better Criminal Identification Procedures
Florida legislators are currently considering HB 821 and SB 1206, the Eyewitness Identification Reform Act, intended to make identification of criminal suspects more reliable.
2011-05-08
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
From a bucket of seawater, new understanding of the ocean
2011-05-08
NEW BRUNSWICK, N.J. – From a bucket of seawater, scientists have unlocked information that may lead to deeper understanding of organisms as different as coral reefs and human disease. By analyzing genomes of a tiny, single-celled marine animal, they have demonstrated a possible way to address diverse questions such as how diseased cells differ from neighboring healthy cells and what it is about some Antarctic algae that allows them to live in warming waters while other algae die out.
Debashish Bhattacharya, professor of ecology, evolution and natural resources in Rutgers' ...
Mars Express sees deep fractures on Mars
2011-05-08
Newly released images from ESA's Mars Express show Nili Fossae, a system of deep fractures around the giant Isidis impact basin. Some of these incisions into the martian crust are up to 500 m deep and probably formed at the same time as the basin.
Nili Fossae is a 'graben' system on Mars, northeast of the Syrtis Major volcanic province, on the northwestern edge of the giant Isidis impact basin. Graben refers to the lowered terrain between two parallel faults or fractures in the rocks that collapses when tectonic forces pull the area apart. The Nili Fossae system contains ...
Bard Avaulta Surgical Mesh Lawsuits
2011-05-08
Bard Avaulta Surgical Mesh Lawsuits
Implantable medical devices from artificial hips to heart values have made it possible for people to have healthier, longer and more productive lives. There can be a dark side to these devices, however, as sometimes they are more harmful than helpful.
For example, in October 2008, the FDA issued a warning regarding the potential danger of surgical meshes after receiving more than 1,000 adverse-event reports. Since the FDA warning, a number of women have filed product liability lawsuits against C.R. Bard, Inc. and other mesh manufacturers ...
Leading experts call for urgent action to avoid stroke crisis across Asia-Pacific region
2011-05-08
Experts from medical and patient communities call on national policymakers in the Asia-Pacific region to take urgent action against preventable strokes that strike millions of people with atrial fibrillation (AF) each year
Countries in the Asia-Pacific region carry a disproportionate share of the burden of stroke with millions of people affected; a burden that will grow as life expectancy rises1
AF, the most common, sustained abnormal heart rhythm, increases the risk of stroke five-fold and is responsible for 15-20% of all strokes, and for 20% of all ischaemic strokes ...
Options For Homeowners Facing Foreclosure
2011-05-08
Options For Homeowners Facing Foreclosure
If you have missed a payment on your mortgage or have received notice from your lender they are filing a foreclosure action, you still have some options. You may be able to save your house and prevent being saddled with unmanageable debt.
Foreclosure
A foreclosure is the legal process where a mortgage lender takes back a piece of property from the party to whom it loaned funds to originally. Foreclosure permits the lender to evict the occupier, resell the property and potentially assess a deficiency balance (the difference ...
JAMIA reports on people, their information needs and social networks
2011-05-08
The May issue of JAMIA, the top-ranked journal reporting on informatics in biomedical and health informatics, features new scientific research—in print and online—on healthcare's hottest HIT-related topics, written by prominent experts working in health and biomedicine. Editor-in chief Lucila Ocho-Machado bullets some of the rich content in the newly released, current issue:
"A secure protocol for protecting the identity of providers when disclosing data for disease surveillance" (Editor's Choice, available free online) — Lead author Khaled El Emam of Children's Hospital ...
New guidelines for cardiovascular genetic testing
2011-05-08
An international panel of experts from The Heart Rhythm Society and the European Heart Rhythm Association issued new guideline recommendations for all health care professionals about cardiovascular genetic testing at the Heart Rhythm Society's 32nd Annual Scientific Sessions.
Silvia G. Priori, MD, PhD, a leader in the field of inherited cardiovascular diseases and director of the Cardiovascular Genetics Program at NYU Langone Medical Center, was co-lead author of the HRS/EHRA Expert Consensus Statement on the State of Genetic Testing for the Channelopathies and Cardiomyopathies. ...
Economy Not Recovering Fast Enough for Some
2011-05-08
Economy Not Recovering Fast Enough for Some
Economists and other financial experts speak continually about signs of improvement in the US economy. With the overall number of bankruptcy and foreclosure filings showing moderate decreases nationally, some are saying this is an indication that the country is coming out of the recession. Others, however, are not so convinced, especially with the national unemployment rate hitting over 10 percent in February - the same percentage as one year ago. While foreclosure and bankruptcy rates are declining in North Carolina, the economy ...
Discovery demonstrates potential MS therapy could kill brain cells
2011-05-08
Edmonton – Researchers with the Faculty of Medicine & Dentistry at the University of Alberta have discovered that some "protective" T-cells can kill neurons. This finding is significant because a specific type of T-cell therapy is being touted in the medical community as a potential treatment for MS and other autoimmune conditions.
Dr. Fabrizio Giuliani and his post-doctoral fellow, Yohannes Haile, both from the Division of Neurology, collaborated on this research which was recently published in the Journal of Leukocyte Biology, a peer-reviewed medical journal.
"Using ...
Study finds livestock-related 'Staph' strain in child care worker
2011-05-08
A new strain of Staphylococcus aureus bacteria associated with exposure to livestock was recently discovered in one Iowa child care worker who reported no contact with livestock, according to University of Iowa researchers.
The discovery was an unexpected finding in a study of Staphylococcus aureus in child day care facilities conducted by Erin Moritz, a doctoral student in epidemiology in the UI College of Public Health, for her dissertation. The finding was reported in a letter written by Moritz and her advisor, Tara Smith, Ph.D., assistant professor of epidemiology ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Breaking free from dependence on rare resources! A domestic high-performance permanent magnet emerges!
Symptoms of long-COVID can last up to two years after infection with COVID-19
Violence is forcing women in Northern Ireland into homelessness, finds new report
Latin American intensivists denounce economic and cultural inequities in the global scientific publishing system
Older adults might be more resistant to bird flu infections than children, Penn research finds
Dramatic increase in research funding needed to counter productivity slowdown in farming
How chemistry and force etch mysterious spiral patterns on solid surfaces
Unraveling the mysteries of polycystic kidney disease
Mother’s high-fat diet can cause liver stress in fetus, study shows
Weighing in on a Mars water debate
Researchers ‘seq’ and find a way to make pig retinal cells to advance eye treatments
Re-purposed FDA-approved drug could help treat high-grade glioma
Understanding gamma rays in our universe through StarBurst
Study highlights noninvasive hearing aid
NASA taps UTA to shape future of autonomous aviation
Mutations disrupt touch-based learning, study finds
Misha lived in zoos, but the elephant’s tooth enamel helps reconstruct wildlife migrations
Eat better, breathe easier? Research points to link between diet, lung cancer
Mesozoic mammals had uniform dark fur
Wartime destruction of Kakhovka Dam in Ukraine has long-term environmental consequences
NIH’s flat 15% funding policy is misguided and damaging
AI reveals new insights into the flow of Antarctic ice
Scientists solve decades-long Parkinson’s mystery
Spinning, twisted light could power next-generation electronics
A planetary boundary for geological resources: Limits of regional water availability
Astronomy’s dirty window to space
New study reveals young, active patients who have total knee replacements are unlikely to need revision surgery in their lifetime
Thinking outside the box: Uncovering a novel approach to brainwave monitoring
Combination immunotherapy before surgery may increase survival in people with head and neck cancer
MIT engineers turn skin cells directly into neurons for cell therapy
[Press-News.org] Florida Legislature Looks at Better Criminal Identification ProceduresFlorida legislators are currently considering HB 821 and SB 1206, the Eyewitness Identification Reform Act, intended to make identification of criminal suspects more reliable.