(Press-News.org) AMES, Iowa -- Douglas Gentile is painfully aware of how research on the effects of video games on kids is often oversimplified to say that games are either "good" or "bad." The associate professor of psychology at Iowa State University has had his own research typecast on the "bad" side with studies on violent video game's effects and video game addiction, even though he's also done studies demonstrating the benefits of games.
A new article by Gentile appearing in the journal Child Development Perspectives argues that existing video game literature can't be classified in black and white terms. Instead, there's a vast grey area when considering the multiple dimensions of video game effects on children and adolescents.
Gentile writes that there are at least five dimensions on which video games can affect players simultaneously -- amount of play, content of play, game context, structure of the game, and the mechanics of game play.
"Parents tend to care about either how much time their kids play or what types of games their kids play," Gentile said. "But when I did a study where the effects couldn't be explained by the amount someone played or the content of the game, it made me realize there's a lot more going on here. And in puzzling through what that more was, I realized there are at least five dimensions on which games have effects."
In his article, which was posted online first by the journal Tuesday, Gentile references some of the most cited literature documenting video game effects in the five dimensions.
Many studies have found associations between the amount of game play and several negative outcomes, Gentile said. But he contends it's likely that some of those outcomes -- such as findings that kids who spend more time playing video games typically experience poorer grades -- may not be due exclusively to the amount of play.
"It is possible to argue that this relation might be due to the children themselves, rather than to game time," Gentile reports. "It is likely that children who perform more poorly at school are likely to spend more time playing games, where they may feel a sense of mastery that eludes them at school. Nonetheless, every hour playing games is one not spent doing homework."
While Gentile writes that there is no standard definition of "content," most definitions focus on the "script" elements or themes of the game. And previous research has found it is clear that children learn game content, and that learning can affect future behaviors. "This is how violent, prosocial, or educational games have most of their documented effects," Gentile said.
The least researched dimension of game effects, according to Gentile, is how the game context alters or creates effects.
"It could be that as you play a violent game with a group of your friends, that context increases the aggression affect because you're getting social support from people you care about for being aggressive in the game," he said. "Or it might be that context might have a teamwork motivation and prosocial orientation that you're trying to help your team -- which negates the aggression affect."
The way a game is structured on the screen (to provide meaningful information to the player) also changes the psychological meaning of the content Gentile writes. This is the level at which games cause improvements to visual attention skills.
And game mechanics -- or the type of controller a video game requires -- could increase fine motor skills (such as with a thumb controller), gross motor skills (swinging the Wii remote like a baseball bat), or even balancing skills (with the Wii balance board), according to Gentile.
By considering all these dimensions, he concludes that the same game can have both perceived positive and negative effects on players.
"There are several benefits to this approach," Gentile said. "One is that it gets us past the dichotomous thinking that games are 'good' or 'bad.'
"It also gives us testable hypotheses, and that's good for science," he continued. "And it also tells a game designer that if you're looking to design a game for maximum impact, you need to focus on these five dimensions."
Gentile is currently working on a study involving "The Beatles: Rock Band"© that looks at three dimensions -- structure, mechanics and content -- independently.
INFORMATION:
Child Development Perspectives can be accessed online at: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/journal/cdep.
Noted researcher addresses multiple dimensions of video game effects in new journal article
Iowa State's Douglas Gentile cites at least five dimensions on which video games can affect players simultaneously
2011-05-11
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Wide-reaching report finds strong support for nurse and pharmacist prescribing
2011-05-11
Greater powers introduced by the government to enable specially trained nurses and pharmacists to prescribe medication in England have been successfully adopted, according to a new report.
Health service researchers from the universities of Southampton and Keele found widespread acceptance of the new powers among patients and that prescribing practices were safe and appropriate for the type of medical conditions being treated.
The Department of Health-funded report, published today (Tuesday, 10 May 2011), gives a national 'snapshot' of how successfully nurse and pharmacist ...
As good as gold
2011-05-11
Similar to humans, the bacteria and tiny plants living in the ocean need iron for energy and growth. But their situation is quite different than ours — for one, they can't exactly turn to natural iron sources like leafy greens or red meat for a pick-me-up.
So where does their iron come from? New research published by "Nature Geoscience" points to a source on the seafloor: minute particles (called nanoparticles) of pyrite, or fool's gold, from hydrothermal vents at the bottom of the ocean.
Scientists already knew the vents' cloudy plumes emitted from the earth's interior ...
It all depends on the coffee
2011-05-11
This release is available in French and German.
Capsule systems for making coffee are convenient and practical and therefore very popular. In terms of their environmental friendliness, however, a large question mark hangs over them. Roland Hischier, Empa's ecobalance expert, has just finished investigating various capsule systems as well as fully automatic machines, filter and soluble coffee making techniques, and has prepared a simplified life cycle analysis. This shows that it is the content which matters most. "A well-informed choice of coffee is in any case the ...
The sweet mysteries of the nervous system
2011-05-11
The antibody 5750 recognises a specific sugar residue on the cell surface, which is called LewisX. The research group lead by Prof. Dr. Andreas Faissner has now been able to use LewisX for the first time to separate different types of stem cells. The researchers report on their results in the Journal of Biological Chemistry.
Unexpected sugar diversity
Antibodies that recognise the LewisX sugar residue are used routinely to identify so-called neural stem cells from which the various cells of the nervous system originate. Prof. Faissner's team has now shown that the designation ...
Los Angeles Criminal Attorney, Matian and Moaddel, Provide Expungement Services to Help Their Clients Have a Better Life
2011-05-11
The process to expunge criminal record in California is a legal relief for many people with a criminal charge in their record. More people are learning that the mistakes they have made in the past are now coming back to haunt them due to public background checks. The law firm of Matian and Moaddel is now extending their legal services to expunge criminal charges from permanent criminal records to help people live a normal and peaceful life.
People can make poor decisions in life and go through an arrest and get charged for a criminal offense. The convicted person may ...
Study: Pace of brain development still strong in late teens
2011-05-11
PROVIDENCE, R.I. [Brown University] — Boys and girls have put many of the trappings of teenagerhood behind them by the age of 18 or 19, but at least some of the brain resculpting that characterizes the decade of adolescence may still be going as strong as ever, according to findings in a new study that measured brainwaves of subjects in their midteens and again in their late teens.
One of the kinds of neurological changes underway in a teen brain is a pruning of unneeded connections forged earlier in life — the brain invests in developing some connections but sheds a ...
Wild animals age too
2011-05-11
Until now, the scientific community had assumed that wild animals died before they got old. Now, a Spanish-Mexican research team has for the first time demonstrated ageing in a population of wild birds (Sula nebouxii) in terms of their ability to live and reproduce.
"It was always thought that senescence was something particular to humans and domestic animals, because we have an extended life expectancy", Alberto Velando, lead author of the study and a researcher at the Ecology and Animal Biology Department of the University of Vigo, tells SINC.
However, the idea that ...
Bacterium Salmonella enterica regulates virulence according to iron levels found in its surroundings
2011-05-11
Salmonella enterica, one of the main causes of gastrointestinal infections, modulates its virulence gene expression, adapting it to each stage of the infection process, depending on the free iron concentration found in the intestinal epithelium of its host. Researchers at Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona (UAB) have demonstrated for the first time that the pathogen activates these genes through the Fur protein, which acts as a sensor of iron levels in its surroundings.
The research, published online in the journal PLoS ONE and entitled "Fur activates the expression of ...
Vitamin D deficiency in pneumonia patients associated with increased mortality
2011-05-11
A new study published in the journal Respirology reveals that adult patients admitted to the hospital with pneumonia are more likely to die if they have Vitamin D deficiency.
Vitamin D is known to be involved in the innate immune response to infection.
The team of researchers at Waikato Hospital and the Universities of Waikato and Otago, measured vitamin D in the blood samples of 112 adult patients admitted with community acquired pneumonia during the winter at the only acute-care hospital in Hamilton, New Zealand.
The researchers found that Vitamin D deficiency was ...
Herschel Space Observatory discovers the clearing out of star-forming gas
2011-05-11
(WASHINGTON) -- The European Space Agency (ESA) Herschel Space Observatory, home to the largest single mirror telescope in space, has detected massive amounts of molecular gas gusting at high velocities — in some cases in excess of 1000 kilometers per second — from the centers of a sample of merging galaxies. Herschel was built by a European-led, multi-national team, including U.S. contributions from researchers at NASA's JPL, Caltech, and the Naval Research Laboratory (NRL). It opens a new terahertz window on the cold and dusty Universe, enabling its scientific objective: ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Remaking psychiatry with biological testing
Caution required when heading soccer balls
Intermittent fasting comparable to traditional diets for weight loss
Community based mentoring in Sierra Leone for pregnant adolescents and their babies doubles survival rates
Positive life outlook may protect against middle-aged memory loss, 16-year study suggests
Scientists find three years left of remaining carbon budget for 1.5°C
Anti-aging drug Rapamycin extends lifespan as effectively as eating less
Babies can sense pain before they can understand it
Consensus statement on universal chemosensory testing calls for better standardization, infrastructure, and education in the field
Two-part vaccine strategy generates a stronger, longer-lasting immune boost against HIV
How lottery-style bottle returns could transform recycling
Researchers with UTHealth Houston School of Public Health awarded $5 million to study cancer risk among firefighters in Texas
C-Path’s translational therapeutics accelerator announces new grant award for drug development project in type 1 diabetes
What is a brain age gap, and how may it affect thinking and memory skills?
Food insecurity, neighborhood, lack of social support, linked to worse stroke recovery
Scientists discover new approach to gene therapy
A statement on the Supreme Court decision
Low social support and a tendency to compare yourself to others may be associated with problematic social media use, per study of 403 Italian adolescents
Which therapy works best for knee arthritis?
Seeing through a new LENS allows brain-like navigation in robots
Organ sculpting cells may hold clues to how cancer spreads
Wildfires that keep us inside might drive the spread of infectious disease, per study of the U.S. West Coast wildfires of 2020
Catching excitons in motion—ultrafast dynamics in carbon nanotubes revealed by nano-infrared spectroscopy
New research proposes framework to define and measure the biology of health
Earliest evidence of humans in the Americas confirmed in new U of A study
Tracking microbial rhythms reveals new target for treating metabolic diseases
Funding for Public Health Law teaching announced
Addictive use of social media, not total time, associated with youth mental health
Hey Doc, you got something for snails?
Social factors may determine how human-like we think animals are
[Press-News.org] Noted researcher addresses multiple dimensions of video game effects in new journal articleIowa State's Douglas Gentile cites at least five dimensions on which video games can affect players simultaneously