Feeding the five thousand -- or was it three?

Researchers claim most crowd estimations are unreliable

2011-08-25

(Press-News.org) The public should view crowd estimation with scepticism, say the authors of a study published today in Significance, the magazine of the Royal Statistical Society and the American Statistical Association, as they suggest more reliable alternatives to current estimating methods.

Estimates of crowd sizes vary greatly, and the success of an event is often measured by the size of the crowd. Organisers of the 2007 "Stop the War" demonstration in London reported crowds of 60,000, whereas the police reported just 10,000. The US Government's estimate of the crowds at Obama's inauguration ceremony was 1.8 million, while other estimates were much less, closer to one million. "In the absence of any accurate estimation methods, the public are left with a view of the truth coloured by the beliefs of the people making the estimates," claims Professor Paul Yip, of the University of Hong Kong, one of the authors of the study.

Such a huge discrepancy in estimates is currently not unusual and suggests the use of crowd sizes as a political tool. Larger crowd sizes are a means of recruiting others to the cause, and it is more difficult for the authorities to ignore demands. "The authorities are sometimes put in a difficult position," says Yip. "It is important to highlight the shortcomings of existing estimating methods."

In today's study, the authors reveal several more accurate, more reliable methods of estimating crowd sizes. Currently, even when searching for the truth, there is a wide margin of error. The authors recommend organisers and authorities use an area x density estimating method for static crowds, which reduces the margin of error to less than 10%. Furthermore, they have devised an entirely new method of reliably estimating mobile crowds. Two inspection points are placed along the route where the number of participants is estimated, not too close together and with one near the end. In applying this two-inspection-point method to the Hong Kong 1st July march (a demonstration of widely-varying claimed size and of great political sensitivity) since 2003, more reliable estimates can then be obtained.

"It is important to rectify the myth of counting people. The public would be better served by estimates less open to political bias. Our study shows that crowd estimates with a margin of error of less than 10% can be achieved with the proposed method," Yip concludes.

### END

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Three-quarters of those who have lost jobs and health insurance are skipping needed health care

2011-08-25

New York, NY, August 24, 2011— Nearly three-quarters (72%) of people who lost their health insurance when they lost their jobs over the last two years said that they skipped needed health care or did not fill prescriptions because of cost, according to a new Commonwealth Fund report. The same proportion is also struggling with medical bills or medical debt, compared to about half (49%) who lost jobs but not their health insurance. Six in 10 working Americans rely on health insurance obtained through their employer, and when an estimated 15 million working-age adults ...

Atlanta Bankruptcy Law Firm Clark & Washington Offers Twelve Convenient Locations

2011-08-25

The Atlanta bankruptcy lawyers at Clark & Washington invite the residents of the Atlanta area to visit the firm at any of their twelve locations within the vicinity. As Georgia's largest bankruptcy filer, Clark & Washington offers legal assistance to individuals experience financial difficulties throughout the metro Atlanta area at the location most convenient for the client. The Atlanta bankruptcy attorneys at Clark & Washington maintain law offices within the metro Atlanta area at each of the following twelve locations: Chamblee-Tucker 3300 Northeast ...

Scientists identify point of entry for deadly Ebola virus

2011-08-25

FINDINGS: Where all of us inherit one copy of each chromosome from each of our two parents, cell lines exist with only a single set, and thus with a single copy of each individual gene, instead of the usual two. Using an unusual human cell line of this type, Whitehead Institute researchers and their collaborators performed a genetic screen and identified a protein used by Ebola virus to gain entry into cells and begin replicating. The discovery may offer a new approach for the development of antiviral therapeutics. RELEVANCE: Ebola virus, the cause of Ebola hemorrhagic ...

Researchers produce detailed map of gene activity in mouse brain

2011-08-25

A new atlas of gene expression in the mouse brain provides insight into how genes work in the outer part of the brain called the cerebral cortex. In humans, the cerebral cortex is the largest part of the brain, and the region responsible for memory, sensory perception and language. Mice and people share 90 percent of their genes so the atlas, which is based on the study of normal mice, lays a foundation for future studies of mouse models for human diseases and, eventually, the development of treatments. Researchers from the National Human Genome Research Institute (NHGRI), ...

Lawrenceville Doctors Office in Gwinnett County Offers Back to School Health Checks for Students

2011-08-25

Rodriguez MD, a leading Lawrenceville clinic and bilingual Lawrenceville family practice in Gwinnett County, GA, is currently offering Back to School Health Checks and sports physicals for preschool through college age students. Available beginning in August 2011, the medical practice will accept patients by appointment and walk-in for Health Checks. Patients will be able to learn about their physical condition and treatment if a problem is identified. Available services at Rodriguez MD's Gwinnett family clinic include: - Physicals - Lab Tests - Blood Pressure - ...

Exercise can substitute effectively as second 'medication' for people with depression

2011-08-25

DALLAS – Aug. 24, 2011 – Exercise can be as effective as a second medication for as many as half of depressed patients whose condition have not been cured by a single antidepressant medication. UT Southwestern Medical Center scientists involved in the investigation, recently published in the Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, found that both moderate and intense levels of daily exercise can work as well as administering a second antidepressant drug, which is often used when initial medications don't move patients to remission. The type of exercise needed, however, depends ...

Cluster headache -- it's nice when it stops

2011-08-25

Cluster headache has a substantial detrimental effect on quality of life. New invasive procedures, such as hypothalamic deep brain stimulation and bilateral occipital nerve stimulation, may help patients with chronic refractory headache. This is one of the conclusions reached by Charly Gaul and co-authors from the Department of Neurology at the University Medical Center Essen in the current issue of Deutsches Ärzteblatt International (Dtsch Arztebl Int 2011; 108(33): 543-9). Cluster headache is the commonest trigemino-autonomic headache, affecting some 120,000 people in ...

A question of gene silencing

2011-08-25

When investigating cancer cells, researchers discovered numerous peculiarities: Particular RNA molecules are present in large numbers, particular genes are overactive. Do these characteristics have a relation to cancer? Do they promote cell growth? Do they inactivate growth brakes or are they just a whim of nature? To find clues for answering these questions scientists perform what are called loss-of-function analyses. They knock out (silence) the gene of interest in living cells or whole organisms and subsequently look for any changes in the cells' metabolism, physiology ...

Scented laundry products emit hazardous chemicals through dryer vents

2011-08-25

The same University of Washington researcher who used chemical sleuthing to deduce what's in fragranced consumer products now has turned her attention to the scented air wafting from household laundry vents. Findings, published online this week in the journal Air Quality, Atmosphere and Health, show that air vented from machines using the top-selling scented liquid laundry detergent and scented dryer sheet contains hazardous chemicals, including two that are classified as carcinogens. "This is an interesting source of pollution because emissions from dryer vents are ...

Standard Life Reveals University Debt Headache for Parents

2011-08-25

Standard Life has revealed that more than half of parents potentially underestimate the maximum amount of debt their child could leave university with. When asked to take into account the increase in tuition fees to a maximum of GBP9,000 per year from 2012, and any other debts accumulated from living expenses, student loans, bank loans etc. 58 per cent of parents think the maximum debt their children could leave with is GBP40,000 or under, including many who think this would be a lot less. This total is well under the maximum figure of GBP54,000 calculated by the long-term ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Large-scale TMIST breast cancer screening trial achieves enrollment goal, paving the way for data that provides a precision approach to screeninge

Study published in NEJM Catalyst finds patients cared for by MedStar Health’s Safe Babies Safe Moms program have better outcomes in pregnancy, delivery, and postpartum

New West Health-Gallup survey finds incoming Trump administration faces high public skepticism over plans to lower healthcare costs

THE LANCET DIABETES & ENDOCRINOLOGY: Global Commission proposes major overhaul of obesity diagnosis, going beyond BMI to define when obesity is a disease.