Court Decision Imposes Liability on Trucking Company for Contractors

Trucking companies may be liable for independent contractors actions and negligence.

2011-08-31

August 31, 2011 (Press-News.org) Commercial freight companies often conduct business through complex relationships with contracted carriers. Traditionally, while companies are legally responsible for the negligent actions of their direct agents (i.e., their employees acting within the scope of their employment), they are generally not liable for the negligent conduct of independent contractors.

Respondeat superior, the legal theory that allows employer liability, is grounded in part on the concept that companies have control over the conduct of their workers or the right to control their employees' conduct. Many trucking companies exercise a substantial level of control over contracted carriers. A new Illinois court decision has expanded the doctrine of employer liability to make freight companies legally responsible for independent contractors in certain situations.

Verdict Against C.H. Robinson Freight Company Upheld

In 2004, truck driver DeAn Henry was involved in an accident on Interstate 55 in Illinois that left two dead and another seriously injured. Henry admitted she failed to reduce her speed to avoid the accident and had made false entries in her logbook.

At the time of the crash, Henry had been working for Dragonfly Express, a carrier contacted by trucking giant C.H. Robinson Worldwide for the load. Henry was found to be negligent, and her contribution to the crash resulted in a jury award of over $23 million against herself, Dragonfly Express and C.H. Robinson.

C.H. Robinson appealed the verdict, arguing that it was not responsible for the actions of an independent contractor or its driver.

An Illinois appellate court reviewed the case, and found that C.H. Robinson forced independent contractors to comply with stringent operational stipulations. In fact, C.H. Robinson's guidelines would have made it impossible for Henry to deliver her load on time without violating speed limits and hours of service regulations. This direct management of an independent contractor made Henry the functional equivalent of an employee.

In March, a panel of the Illinois Appellate Court, Third District upheld the verdict against C.H. Robinson.

Good News for Plaintiffs Injured In Accidents

Since the 2004 accident, Dragonfly Express has gone out of business, and it is unlikely Henry herself ever had sufficient financial resources to contribute to the $23 million judgment. The verdict against C.H. Robinson means that those injured and the families of those killed in truck accidents involving some independent contractors will be able to collect damages for their losses from the large trucking companies that utilize their services.

The decision of the Illinois Appellate Court could have an expansive impact. Potentially, more injured plaintiffs involved in automobile accidents involving trucks and tractor trailers will be able to secure the compensation they deserve, and freight companies will be unable to dodge liability by masking an agency relationship as an independent contractor arrangement.

If your life has been impacted by a trucking accident, contact an attorney today to ensure you recover appropriate damages from all responsible parties.

Article provided by Law Office of William S Wojcik
Visit us at www.wojciklaw.com

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Double damage: Partner violence impacts mental health of over half-million Californians

2011-08-31

Victims who suffer violence at the hands of a spouse, boyfriend or girlfriend, or other intimate partner aren't only brutalized physically; they also suffer disproportionately higher rates of mental health distress, according to a new policy brief from the UCLA Center for Health Policy Research. Using data from the 2009 California Health Interview Survey (CHIS), researchers found that of the 3.5 million Californians who reported ever having been the victim of intimate partner violence (IPV), more than half a million — 594,000 — said they experienced recent symptoms ...

Using ground covers in organic production

2011-08-31

This press release is available in Spanish. Studies by U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) scientists indicate that organic farmers who need to periodically amend their soils with compost after planting can still control weeds--and hold down costs--by using fabric ground covers. This will be welcome news to organic farmers who till composted manure into their crop fields after planting. Agricultural Research Service (ARS) soil scientist Larry Zibilske, who works at the agency's Integrated Farming and Natural Resources Research Unit in Weslaco, Texas, set out to see ...

Wolves may aid recovery of Canada lynx, a threatened species

2011-08-31

CORVALLIS, Ore. – As wolf populations grow in parts of the West, most of the focus has been on their value in aiding broader ecosystem recovery – but a new study from Oregon State University also points out that they could play an important role in helping to save other threatened species. In research published today in Wildlife Society Bulletin, scientists suggest that a key factor in the Canada lynx being listed as threatened under the Endangered Species Act is the major decline of snowshoe hares. The loss of hares, the primary food of the lynx, in turn may be caused ...

Transvaginal Mesh Devices Can Cause Injury, Says FDA

2011-08-31

Transvaginal mesh devices are usually implanted to strengthen a woman's vaginal tissue and support the weight of the surrounding organs after a woman experiences pelvic organ prolapse (POP). Recent reports from the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) indicate that these transvaginal mesh devices can cause injury in women who have had the potentially defective device implanted. What Is Pelvic Organ Prolapse (POP)? It is not uncommon following a pregnancy or other medical condition for a woman's vaginal tissue to weaken. When this happens, a woman may experience POP, ...

Computers are oversold and underused

2011-08-31

After studying current school inspection and review reports as well as an independent impact study report commissioned by United States Agency for International Development (USAID), author Michael Lightfoot stated that many technology-related policies overlook the real needs of students. Lightfoot wrote that while ICT infrastructure aims to incorporate electronic classes and teaching systems that enhance students' and teachers' technological abilities, in reality it has become little more than a way to mechanically optimize the operation of equipment and to perpetuate cultural ...

Parents' stress leaves lasting marks on children’s genes: UBC-CFRI research

2011-08-31

Researchers at the University of British Columbia and the Child & Family Research Institute have shown that parental stress during their children's early years can leave an imprint on their sons' or daughters' genes – an imprint that lasts into adolescence and may affect how these genes are expressed later in life. The study, published online today in the journal Child Development, focused on epigenetics – the expression of genes as opposed to the underlying sequence of DNA. A central component of epigenetics is methylation, in which a chemical group attaches to parts ...

Cycling Can Be Dangerous on Michigan's Local Streets

2011-08-31

In late June, three young state residents facing disabilities were recognized by the Michigan Legislature for their efforts to make bicycling safer. Nineteen-year-old James Kleimola of Ypsilanti, along with Katie Birchmeier and Conor Waterman of Saline, both 10, are involved in the Programs to Educate All Cyclists (PEAC). Last year, their testimony before the Michigan House and Senate Transportation committees as well as the Disability Caucus helped shepherd into law Complete Streets legislation that will ensure future transportation plans across the state take into ...

Natural anti-oxidant deserts aging body

2011-08-31

When the body fights oxidative damage, it calls up a reservist enzyme that protects cells – but only if those cells are relatively young, a study has found. Biologists at USC discovered major declines in the availability of an enzyme, known as the Lon protease, as human cells grow older. The finding may help explain why humans lose energy with age and could point medicine toward new diets or pharmaceuticals to slow the aging process. The researchers showed that when oxidative agents attack the power centers of young cells, the cells respond by calling up reinforcements ...

Novel alloy could produce hydrogen fuel from sunlight

2011-08-31

Scientists from the University of Kentucky and the University of Louisville have determined that an inexpensive semiconductor material can be "tweaked" to generate hydrogen from water using sunlight. The research, funded by the U.S. Department of Energy, was led by Professors Madhu Menon and R. Michael Sheetz at the UK Center for Computational Sciences, and Professor Mahendra Sunkara and graduate student Chandrashekhar Pendyala at the UofL Conn Center for Renewable Energy Research. Their findings were published Aug. 1 in the Physical Review Journal (Phys Rev B 84, 075304). The ...

Memphis, Tennessee Ranked Fifth Among Deadliest Cities for Pedestrians

2011-08-31

A new study by Transportation For America takes a state-by-state look at pedestrian safety in the U.S. In the wake of public awareness campaigns for motorcycle safety and distracted driving, pedestrian safety has seen less public attention, resources and funding. The study found that, between 2000 and 2009, over 47,700 pedestrians were killed nationwide and an additional 688,000 pedestrians were injured. Data from the study ranks Memphis as the fifth deadliest metro area for pedestrians out of a list of 54 cities with populations over 1 million. Memphis had the highest ...

Court Decision Imposes Liability on Trucking Company for Contractors

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES: