Virginia Man Relents, Pleads Guilty After Questioning DWI Blood Draw

Can the police draw a person's blood for alcohol testing without their consent or a search warrant?

2011-09-01

September 01, 2011 (Press-News.org) Driving drunk on Easter Sunday, Virginia resident William Daniels blew through a Utica, New York stop sign and plowed into another car, killing the driver. Daniels himself was injured and charged with aggravated vehicular manslaughter, aggravated vehicular assault and aggravated DWI (driving while intoxicated).

Daniels initially pled not guilty to the charges and contested the warrantless drawing of his blood at the crash scene while he was unconscious. Though unconscious when blood was drawn for alcohol testing, Daniels may have been talking after the crash and admitted to drinking. He eventually pled guilty to the charged offenses, but his situation raises an important question: can the police draw a person's blood for alcohol testing without their consent or a search warrant?

If an individual consents to blood being drawn, there is no issue. However, if a suspected drunk driver refuses to take a breath test to determine its alcohol content, the police must get a search warrant to draw blood for alcohol testing. Drawing blood is a search of a person under the U.S. Constitution's Fourth Amendment and it requires either a search warrant or a specific warrant exception.

Somewhere in between is the unconscious, suspected drunk driver who can neither consent nor refuse. Every state has different laws regarding who can draw blood for alcohol testing, and under what circumstances. New York and Virginia law both contain a legal doctrine called "implied consent," which presumes that given the chance, everyone would consent to a blood draw. An unconscious person cannot refuse so their consent is implied and no warrant is necessary. It was likely because of this legal doctrine that William Daniels decided to plead guilty and forego challenging the blood draw.

The consequences of vehicular crimes like the ones William Daniels faced are serious. Had he not entered a plea agreement, Daniels could have spent between eight and 25 years in prison.

If you or a loved one has been charged with a DWI or other vehicular offense, contact an experienced criminal defense attorney to discuss your situation, your rights and your options.

Article provided by Ronald E. Smith, P.C.
Visit us at www.ronaldsmithlaw.com

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

News tips from the journal mBio®

2011-09-01

New Strategy for Developing Rapid Diagnostics An international consortium of researchers has devised a novel strategy for developing rapid, inexpensive diagnostic tests for microbial infections. Effective treatment of microbial infection is critically dependent on early diagnosis and identification of the causative organism. One inexpensive, rapid and adaptable to point-of-care diagnostic method is immunoassay for microbial antigens that are shed into bodily fluids during infection. A major barrier to developing these diagnostics is determining which of the hundreds ...

NASA satellite observes unusually hot July in the Great Plains

2011-09-01

Much of the United States sweated through an unusually humid heat wave during July, a month that brought record-breaking temperatures to many areas across the Great Plains. As temperatures soared, NASA satellites observed the unusual weather from above. The Atmospheric Infrared Sounder (AIRS), an instrument launched on the Aqua satellite in 2002, is unique in its ability to yield highly accurate data about the troposphere, the lowest layer of the atmosphere and the part that most directly affects life on Earth. Hot temperatures struck Texas and Oklahoma particularly ...

Trucking Accidents Decline; Motorist Safety Remains Priority

2011-09-01

More and more vehicles are hitting the roads during this busy driving season. Unfortunately, with this extra traffic comes an increase in motor vehicle accidents - some of the more dangerous involving large trucks. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 3,380 people were killed in crashes involving commercial trucks in 2009, a 20 percent decrease from the previous year. Although fatalities from semi truck crashes are declining, motorists should still be aware that large trucks' size, weight, visibility and braking abilities make semi trucks ...

Scholars Explore Traumatic Brain Injury at the Workplace

2011-09-01

It comes as no surprise that workers in certain physically intensive fields are more susceptible to serious on the job injuries. However, until quite recently, research on work-related traumatic brain injury (TBI) has been sorely lacking, despite its status as a leading cause of death. A new study published in the American Journal of Preventive Medicine has identified the most at-risk groups, and will hopefully inspire employers to engage in targeted strategies to protect their workers from TBI. Construction Accidents: Common Causes Almost 7,300 workers died as a ...

Tropical Depression 8E forms on Mexican coastline, watches up

2011-09-01

The Mexican government has issued a tropical storm watch for the coast of southwestern Mexico from Zihuatanejo to Punta San Telmo as Tropical Storm 8E formed this morning. The GOES-11 satellite captured an image of its rounded clouds hugging this coast this morning, and NASA's TRMM satellite noticed some heavy rainfall in the system yesterday. Forecasters noticed the depression develop more rounded characteristics on imagery from NOAA's GOES-11 satellite today. The image was created by the NASA GOES Project at NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center, Greenbelt, Md. On Aug. ...

Many Factors Influence Property Division in Georgia

2011-09-01

The division of marital property, or property acquired during a marriage, is often one of the most complicated and difficult aspects of the divorce process. Disputes may arise about when the property was acquired, or how much certain assets are worth. When a couple disagrees on how to divide shared property, the question will more than likely end up decided by the courts. In Georgia, a judge's decision about how to divide marital property is based on a system of "equitable distribution." The equitable distribution system is based on the idea that property ...

NASA sees Tropical Storm Nanmadol's landfall, Talas headed to Japan

2011-09-01

Tropical Storm Nanmadol made landfall in southeastern China's Fujian Province and is now a depression, while further east, Tropical Storm Talas is still headed for Japan. Infrared satellite imagery from The Atmospheric Sounder Instrument (AIRS) aboard NASA's Aqua satellite shows two different stories in the tropical cyclones. AIRS captured an infrared image of Nanmadol on Aug. 31 at 1:05 EDT dissipating quickly over mainland China with a lack of high, thunderstorm clouds. Most of the remnants of Nanmadol are lower, warmer clouds. Tropical Storm Nanmadol made landfall ...

FBI Cyber-Crime Work: Balancing Child-Porn and National Security

2011-09-01

With the recent court convictions of a U.S. airman, Boy Scout camp director and Kansas man for child pornography, the FBI can proudly claim many successes in its efforts to stop online crimes involving the sexual exploitation of children. However, the agency has another daunting job: to fight illegal computer activity that threatens national security. A recent audit found that less than one-fifth of the FBI's cyber agents worked on "national security intrusion investigations" in 2009. Since the creation of its cyber-crimes divisions, the FBI has tackled such ...

Blood Alcohol Levels May Lead to DUI Arrest

2011-09-01

The breathalyzer is a breath alcohol-testing device invented in 1954 to assist police in assessing blood alcohol concentration (BAC) levels. Breathalyzer devices do not measure exact levels of blood alcohol concentration. Rather, the devices make estimates based on measurements of alcohol in the breath. When a person drinks alcoholic beverages, the alcohol is absorbed into the blood stream through the mouth, stomach and intestines. The blood then moves through the lungs where some of the alcohol enters the air sacks and is exhaled, providing an indicator of how much ...

TRMM satellite sees heavy rain, towering clouds in Tropical Storm Katia

2011-09-01

While parts of the East Coast and New England are still recovering from Hurricane Irene, a new storm is brewing in the Atlantic, Tropical Storm Katia. The TRMM satellite looked "under the hood" of the storm and saw heavy rainfall rates and towering clouds providing a clue that she was going to strengthen and may become a hurricane later today. Katia began as an area of low pressure that had moved away from the coast of Africa south of the Cape Verde Islands in the central eastern Atlantic. This area of low pressure became the twelfth tropical depression of the season ...

The Lancet: COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy decreased over time, though mistrust persists among certain groups, study of over 1 million people in England suggests

Virginia Man Relents, Pleads Guilty After Questioning DWI Blood Draw

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES: