Pressure for positive results puts science under threat, study shows

Scientific research may be in decline across the globe because of growing pressures to report only positive results, new analysis suggests

2011-09-13

(Press-News.org) Scientific research may be in decline across the globe because of growing pressures to report only positive results, new analysis suggests.

A study by the University of Edinburgh examined more than 4,600 scientific research papers published between 1990 and 2007 and found a steady decline in studies in which the findings contradicted scientific hypotheses.

Papers reporting null or negative findings are in principle as useful as positive ones, but they attract fewer readers and citations, so scientific journals tend to reject them.

It is acknowledged among scientists that this problem might be worsening, because competition in science is growing and jobs and grants are given to scientists who publish frequently in high-ranking journals. Many researchers, therefore, have speculated that scientists will increasingly pursue predictable outcomes and produce positive results through re-interpretation, selection or even manipulation of data.

The study examined research papers in which a hypothesis had been tested, in various scientific disciplines. Over the period studied, positive results grew from around 70 per cent in 1990 to 86 per cent in 2007. The growth was strongest in economics, business, clinical medicine, psychology, psychiatry, pharmacology and molecular biology.

The findings, published in Scientometrics, also show that papers reporting positive results are more frequent in the US than in Europe.

Dr Daniele Fanelli of the University's Institute for the Study of Science, Technology and Innovation, who led the study, said: "Either journals are rejecting more negative results, or scientists are producing more positives. It is most likely a combination of both.

"Without negative evidence in the literature, scientists might misestimate the importance of phenomena and waste resources replicating failed studies. The higher frequency of US papers reporting positive findings may suggest that problems linked to competition are greater in the US than elsewhere."

### END

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Researchers find way to measure effect of Wi-Fi attacks

2011-09-13

Researchers from North Carolina State University have developed a way to measure how badly a Wi-Fi network would be disrupted by different types of attacks – a valuable tool for developing new security technologies. "This information can be used to help us design more effective security systems, because it tells us which attacks – and which circumstances – are most harmful to Wi-Fi systems," says Dr. Wenye Wang, an assistant professor of electrical and computer engineering at NC State and co-author of a paper describing the research. Wi-Fi networks, which allow computer ...

Reliant Technology Announces NetApp Storage Continuity Program

2011-09-13

NetApp reseller Reliant Technology is proud to announce the expansion of its Used NetApp Storage Division with the introduction of the NetApp Storage Continuity Program. The program provides Reliant Technology customers with a cost-effective option for upgrading their NetApp FAS systems, reducing maintenance costs, and extending the life of NetApp End Of Life systems. The NetApp Storage Continuity Program is designed to help current NetApp storage customers protect their IT investments and expand the life of their NetApp FAS systems, while reducing the cost of acquiring ...

A deep male voice helps women remember

2011-09-13

Men take note: If you want women to remember, speak to them in a low pitch voice. Then, depending on what they remember about you, they may or may not rate you as a potential mate. That's according to a new study by David Smith and colleagues from the University of Aberdeen in the UK. Their work shows for the first time that a low masculine voice is important for both mate choice and the accuracy of women's memory. The research is published online in Springer's journal, Memory & Cognition. In a series of two experiments, Smith and colleagues show that memory in women ...

Innovating to improve women and children's health

2011-09-13

LONDON - For less than $100, poor, pregnant women in India can now give birth in a private hospital focusing on low-income families, with comparable quality to expensive, private ones. This is an alternative to overcrowded, poorly staffed government-funded hospitals. Lifespring is a rapidly growing chain of hospitals in India that provides maternity and delivery care. For one low price, as little as $90, it provides complete delivery services. This is one-third to one-half of the fees charged at other hospitals. The first pilot hospital opened in 2005. Within a year, ...

A tale of (more than) 2 butterflies

2011-09-13

Flitting among the cool slopes of the Appalachian Mountains is a tiger swallowtail butterfly that evolved when two other species of swallowtails hybridized long ago. It's a rarity in the animal world, biologists have found. They discovered that the Appalachian tiger swallowtail, Papilio appalachiensis, evolved from mixing between the Eastern tiger swallowtail, P. glaucus, and the Canadian tiger swallowtail, P. canadensis. The Appalachian tiger swallowtail rarely reproduces with its parental species and is a unique mixture of the two in both its outward traits and ...

Reach Out and Read Hands Out 1.5 Million Books in 80 Days

2011-09-13

Impacting the lives of children across the nation, Reach Out and Read pediatricians distributed nearly 1.5 million free books during the summer of 2011. Recognized by the New York Times and MSNBC, Reach Out and Read is an early literacy initiative that prepares America's youngest children to succeed in school by partnering with doctors to prescribe books and encourage families to read together. Over an 80 day period, 28,000 pediatricians and medical providers handed out an average of 25,600 books per day - - giving out more books per day than the crowd capacity at ...

The Limousines Headline Left Coast Live 2011

2011-09-13

The Limousines will headline the third annual Left Coast Live (LCL) music festival on Saturday, October 8, 2011 in downtown San Jose, CA. The 2011 lineup also features The Postelles, Orgone, Mara Hruby, Chico Mann and more than 20 other regional and local acts. This year's festival takes place on three outdoor stages and smaller venues between South 1st and South Market, and features a beer garden, silent disco, and an Urban Food Zone where fans can sample the best of the local food truck scene. Headliner: The Limousines Since signing to Dangerbird Records in 2010, ...

'Oscar Madison' approach to solar cells may outshine 'Felix Unger' design

2011-09-13

In the race to enhance the efficiency of solar cells, spending the time and effort to get tiny nanowires to line up neatly on the top of ordinary silicon wafers may not be worth the effort. An international team of researchers has for the first time demonstrated that random, haphazardly grown silicon nanowires can significantly boost the power-producing capabilities of solar cells by trapping a broad spectrum of light waves and capturing sunlight streaming in from a wide variety of angles. The nanowires, which are wrapped in a shell of silicon oxide, serve as an antireflective ...

Researcher launches teen contraceptive website

2011-09-13

Friends, the mainstream media and the internet, all potentially unreliable sources, continue to be the way America's young adults find their health information. Research has found that while they trust health professionals and health educators, they often do not turn to them for information, especially when it comes to their sexual health. In an attempt to provide a reliable and trustworthy source for reproductive health information for teenagers, one physician-researcher at Women & Infants Hospital of Rhode Island has launched the website Ask A Doc RI. "My thought ...

As New Research Cites Family Travel, Grandparent Trips & "Life Events" as Key Travel Motives, Travel Insured Urges Multi-Generation Coverage

2011-09-13

New research from the 2011 "Portrait of American Travelers" by the YPartnership / Harrison Group this summer identifies ongoing travel movement by multiple generations of U.S. families as the leading driver of leisure travel activity. The March 2011 survey polled 2,539 U.S. households with annual incomes of $50,000 or more who took a leisure trip of 75 miles or more requiring overnight accommodations in the previous 12 months. Among the findings were that seven in 10 leisure travelers (70%) took a "celebration vacation" to mark a "life event," ...