Researchers evaluate teaching program for breaking bad news to patients

Medical students find feedback helpful from interactions with 'standardized patients'

2012-02-23

(Press-News.org) TAMPA, Fla. (Feb. 22, 2012) – Researchers at Moffitt Cancer Center in Tampa, Fla., and the University of South Florida (USF) College of Medicine evaluated the experience of medical students who participated in videotaped sessions where they practiced conveying difficult news to "standardized patients" (SPs). The SPs role-played patients with a variety of cancers and who were receiving bad medical news.

The study aimed at both evaluating student perceptions of the methods used in teaching how to break bad news and also at determining the effectiveness of the educational program designed for conveying difficult news.

The study appeared in a recent issue of the Journal of Cancer Education.

"One of the biggest challenges a physician will face is conveying difficult news to a patient," said study co-author Gwendolyn Quinn, Ph.D., director of the Survey Methods Core Facility at Moffitt. "Despite the importance of this skill, formal education in conveying bad news to patients has been limited."

Medical students at USF are required to complete a two- to three-hour training session, involving three to five students, covering how to communicate difficult medical news. Following this instruction they have a videotaped encounter with a standardized patient who is trained to act the part of a patient who is hearing bad medical news.

"Many of the SPs are cancer survivors, so they have a personal connection," said co-author John V. Kiluk, M.D., F.A.C.S., an assistant member of Moffitt's Don and Erika Wallace Comprehensive Breast Program.

Videotaped sessions take place in fully equipped learning labs with bi-directional video cameras that activate when the students enter the exam rooms for their 15-minute encounter with an SP. SPs are asked to focus on the emotional aspects of hearing bad news rather than ask questions about treatment.

Following the encounter, medical students gather in groups of three to five to review their videotaped sessions with a surgical oncologist. This physician subsequently points out strengths and weaknesses of each student's communication technique and offers suggestions on improvement. An important part of the evaluations is having the SP offer the patient's perception of the student's technique or style.

Students also discuss their verbal and nonverbal interactions with the SPs. There is an emphasis on nonverbal communication, such as eye contact, and also on verbal skills related to helping patients deal with denial, shock and tears.

Students also fill out a follow-up questionnaire.

When evaluating medical student surveys and student discussions about their videotaped encounters with the SPs, researchers found that medical students reported having "improved comfort" in addressing difficult topics with patients.

"When we analyzed the clinical experience of medical students during the Interdisciplinary Oncology Clerkship, we found that while 95 percent had witnessed the sharing of bad news during their medical education, only half the medical students had personal experience in delivering bad news," said co-author Sophie Dessureault, M.D., Ph.D., an associate member of Moffitt's Gastrointestinal Tumor and Immunology programs. "After the small group interaction, students overwhelmingly agreed that the exercise was helpful and that the SPs were 'realistic.' They also agreed strongly that the post-interview discussion was the most advantageous feature and that, overall, their knowledge of best practices had increased."

According to the researchers, it is important that the "art of medicine" should not be forgotten and that developing a relationship with a patient and their family can often be forgotten during the fast pace of clinical work.

"Medical students can learn communication techniques from observing mentors," said Quinn. "However, senior clinicians seldom have the time to role-play to help students develop skills."

The researchers concluded that videotaping and a subsequent evaluation was superior to instructor comments alone, and that a combination of videotaping and assessor comments was "highly beneficial."

"Although these encounters cannot replace actual patient interactions, these exercises provide a safe learning environment for the student," concluded the authors. "As a result, the students will have a solid background from which to begin developing good communication skills in the oncology setting."

###

About Moffitt Cancer Center
Follow Moffitt on Facebook: www.facebook.com/MoffittCancerCenter
Follow Moffitt on Twitter: @MoffittNews
Follow Moffitt on YouTube: MoffittNews

Located in Tampa, Moffitt Cancer Center is a National Cancer Institute-designated Comprehensive Cancer Center, which recognizes Moffitt's excellence in research and contributions to clinical trials, prevention and cancer control. Moffitt is also a member of the National Comprehensive Cancer Network, a prestigious alliance of the country's leading cancer centers, and is listed in U.S. News & World Report as one of "America's Best Hospitals" for cancer.

Media release by Florida Science Communications

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Paying research volunteers raises ethical concerns, study concludes

2012-02-23

(Garrison, NY) Researchers almost always offer money as an incentive for healthy volunteers to enroll in research studies, but does payment amount to coercion or undue inducement to participate in research? In the first national study to examine their views on this question, the majority of institutional review board members and other research ethics professionals expressed persistent ethical concern about the effects of offering payment to research subjects. But they differed in their views of the meaning of coercion and undue influence and how to avoid these problems ...

Researchers confirm WIC breastfeeding rate data

2012-02-23

Los Angeles, (February 22, 2012)—While medical professionals have long known breastfeeding positively impacts infant and maternal health, few effective tools are available to measure breastfeeding practices nationally. According to a new study, one preexisting government-funded program is a potential wealth of accurate data about the breastfeeding practices of low-income mothers. This study was published in a recent issue of the Journal of Human Lactation (published by SAGE). The Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants and Children (WIC), a USDA-funded ...

Researchers reveal how cancer cells change once they spread to distant organs

2012-02-23

NEW YORK (Feb. 22, 2012) -- Oncologists have known that in order for cancer cells to spread, they must transform themselves so they can detach from a tumor and spread to a distant organ. Now, scientists at Weill Cornell Medical College have revealed critical steps in what happens next -- how these cells reverse the process, morphing back into classical cancer that can now grow into a new tumor. Their findings, now published online and in a upcoming issue of Cancer Research and funded through a National Cancer Institute grant to the Cornell Center on the Microenvironment ...

New study confirms low levels of fallout from Fukushima

2012-02-23

Fallout from the 2011 Fukushima Dai-ichi nuclear power facility in Japan was measured in minimal amounts in precipitation in the United States in about 20 percent of 167 sites sampled in a nationwide study released today. The U.S. Geological Survey led the study as part of the National Atmospheric Deposition Program (NADP). Levels measured were similar to measurements made by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency in the days and weeks immediately following the March 2011 incidents, which were determined to be well below any level of public health concern. Many NADP ...

For disaster debris arriving from Japan, radiation least of the concerns

2012-02-23

CORVALLIS, Ore. – The first anniversary is approaching of the March, 2011, earthquake and tsunami that devastated Fukushima, Japan, and later this year debris from that event should begin to wash up on U.S. shores – and one question many have asked is whether that will pose a radiation risk. The simple answer is, no. Nuclear radiation health experts from Oregon State University who have researched this issue following the meltdown of the Fukushima Dai-ichi nuclear plant say the minor amounts of deposition on the debris field scattered in the ocean will have long since ...

To celebrate prairie landscapes, research says to take an aesthetic approach

2012-02-23

MANHATTAN, KAN. -- A Kansas State University researcher and former park ranger is helping people take a new view of the prairie and see it as more than a seemingly empty landscape. Tyra Olstad, doctoral student in geography, North Tonawanda, N.Y., is studying the rich -- although sometimes hidden -- beauty of Kansas landscapes. It's an abstract, yet important, field of study that may help develop new ways to promote and celebrate Kansas tourism, history and geography. "I became interested in the pejoratives that people layer on prairie landscapes," Olstad said. "I wanted ...

ACGME announces plan to transform graduate medical education

2012-02-23

CHICAGO, February 22, 2012 – The Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) today announced major changes in how the nation's medical residency programs will be accredited in the years ahead, putting in place an outcomes-based evaluation system where the doctors of tomorrow will be measured for their competency in performing the essential tasks necessary for clinical practice in the 21st century. Summarized in a paper published in the February 22, 2012 online edition of the New England Journal of Medicine, the ACGME's next accreditation system for graduate ...

Smoking cessation drug improves walking function in patients with spinocerebellar ataxia type 3

2012-02-23

Tampa, FL (Feb. 22, 2012) -- A nicotinic drug approved for smoking cessation significantly improved the walking ability of patients suffering from an inherited form of ataxia, reports a new clinical study led by University of South Florida researchers. The randomized controlled clinical trial investigated the effectiveness of varenicline (Chantix®) in treating spinocerebellar ataxia type 3, or SCA3. The findings were published online earlier this month in Neurology, the journal of the American Academy of Neuroscience. Lead author Dr. Theresa Zesiewicz and colleagues ...

Sky Poker Introduces Priority Membership

2012-02-23

Following their recent string of promotions this festive season, Sky Poker is now offering players membership to the Sky Poker Priority Club, aimed to benefit and reward those who regularly play poker online with Sky. To join, players simply need to accrue over 10,000 Sky Poker Points each month by entering online games and tournaments. The membership status of each player is determined Sky Poker according to the previous months' play. Some of the fantastic advantages available to Sky Poker Priority Club members are: Direct Buy-ins to Sky Poker Tour events If playing ...

Solved! Mystery that stumped ecosystem modelers

2012-02-23

As scientists warn that the Earth is on the brink of a period of mass extinctions, they are struggling to identify ecosystem responses to environmental change. But to truly understand these responses, more information is needed about how the Earth's staggering diversity of species originated. Curiously, a vexing modeling mystery has stymied research on this topic: mathematical models have told us that complex ecosystems, such as jungles, deserts and coral reefs, in which species coexist and interact with another, cannot persist--even though they obviously do. But now, ...

Researchers evaluate teaching program for breaking bad news to patients

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES: