Change on the Horizon for Small Claim Copyright Infringement?

A current study explores alternatives to the prohibitive nature of the costs tied to copyright infringement cases.

2012-03-15

March 15, 2012 (Press-News.org) An exclusive right to produced work is cemented within the Constitution. When works of art, works of authorship or screenplays are produced, the creators have the right to protect their works.

These protections are provided by the federal Copyright Act, which has a broad reach, including both small, individual works and colossal, multimillion-dollar movie productions. Just as the range of protected work varies, so do the resources available to bring lawsuits claiming copyright infringement.

Those attempting to file suits for relatively small claims are often dissuaded by the high cost of litigation. As a result, Congress has called upon the U.S. Copyright Office to assess whether the cost deters copyright holders from protecting their rights. If the cost is prohibitive, the Office is asked to offer potential solutions.

Remedies for Small Copyright Claims

If an infringement is alleged, the claim must be brought in federal court. Generally, this process is beneficial because copyright law is federal, and federal courts are familiar with the complex issue of copyright analysis.

Unfortunately, no "small claims" court exists for cases seeking lower damage awards. Accordingly, a single artist claiming infringement of a piece of art and seeking an award of a few thousand dollars goes through the same process as a large movie production studio claiming damages well into the millions.

US Copyright Office's Position in 2006

Problems connected to this system were brought to light in 2006 by a group of photographers. The primary complaint: high cost.

Unfortunately, many copyright holders do not have access to significant amounts of funding. Filing and pursuing a small copyright claim is often a substantial cost with the prospect of a very small damage award.

At the time, the Copyright Office noted the issue warranted further review in the future.

Congress' Incentive for Commissioning New Study

Congress reacted by requesting that the Copyright Office outline the legal obstacles faced by small copyright claimholders. The study is currently underway and the Copyright Office's charge is the following:
- To determine whether authors and other copyright owners are prevented from seeking relief by constraints in the current system
- If so, to provide recommendations geared towards allowing all copyright owners to realize the promise of exclusive rights

The investigation is actively reviewing various alternatives for small copyright claims, ranging from establishing a streamlined small court system to allowing state court involvement.

Throughout the process, investigators and legislators note that copyright infringement is a serious violation of rights. If you have been the victim of copyright infringement, it is important to contact an experienced copyright litigation lawyer to discuss protection of your legal rights.

Article provided by The Simon Law Firm, P.C.
Visit us at www.contingencyfeeip.com/

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Researchers attempt to solve problems of antibiotic resistance and bee deaths in one

2012-03-15

The stomachs of wild honey bees are full of healthy lactic acid bacteria that can fight bacterial infections in both bees and humans. A collaboration between researchers at three universities in Sweden – Lund University, the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences and Karolinska Institutet – has produced findings that could be a step towards solving the problems of both bee deaths and antibiotic resistance. The researchers have now published their results in the scientific journal PLoS ONE and the legendary science photographer Professor Lennart Nilsson from Karolinska ...

Economic and social growth of developing nations may increase obesity

2012-03-15

Developing nations experiencing economic and social growth might also see growing waistlines among their poorest citizens, according to a new study from Rice University and the University of Colorado. The researchers found that while growth of developing countries may improve conditions such as malnutrition and infectious disease, it may increase obesity among people with lower socio-economic status. "It's a troubling finding," said Rice sociology professor Justin Denney, who co-authored the study with University of Colorado sociology professors Fred Pampel and Patrick ...

UNH researchers find African farmers need better climate change data to improve farming practices

2012-03-15

DURHAM, N.H. – Researchers from the University of New Hampshire have found that many African farmers inaccurately perceive changes in climate and rainfall when compared with scientific data, highlighting the need for better climate information to assist them to improve farming practices. "Quantifying local people's perceptions to climate change, and their assessments of which changes matter, is fundamental to addressing the dual challenge of land conservation and poverty alleviation in densely populated tropical regions," said Joel Hartter, assistant professor of geography ...

A new treatment option for Clostridium difficile: Fecal transplantation

2012-03-15

Fecal transplantation through colonoscopy is an effective treatment for recurrent Clostridium difficile infection (CDI), according to a new study in Gastroenterology, the official journal of the American Gastroenterological Association. Additionally, the mortality rate in this study does not appear to be greater than in some previously reported series, suggesting that fecal transplantation itself seems to be a rather safe procedure. CDI is a common cause of both community- and hospital-acquired diarrhea, usually occurring after exposure to antibiotics. "Our results suggest ...

Study finds a quarter of adults with HIV were abused as children

2012-03-15

DURHAM, N.C. -- One in four HIV patients was found to have been sexually abused as a child, according to a two-year Duke University study of more than 600 HIV patients. Traumatic childhood experiences were also linked to worse health outcomes among these patients, who are aged 20 to 71. More than half of these patients in the Coping with HIV/AIDS in the Southeast (CHASE) study had experienced sexual or physical abuse in their lifetimes, according to researchers from the Duke Center for Health Policy and Inequalities Research (CHPIR). Half of the patients had experienced ...

How muscle cells seal their membranes

2012-03-15

Every cell is enclosed by a thin double layer of lipids that separates the distinct internal environment of the cell from the extracellular space. Damage to this lipid bilayer, also referred to as plasma membrane, disturbs the cellular functions and may lead to the death of the cell. For example, downhill walking tears many little holes into the plasma membranes of the muscle cells in our legs. To prevent irreparable damage, muscle cells have efficient systems to seal these holes again. Researchers at Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT) and Heidelberg University have ...

Offshore Drilling Company Attempts to Avoid Liability in Workers Deaths

2012-03-15

The dangers of offshore drilling are well known. And, because of their isolated locations, work accidents can be devastating. One such accident occurred in September 2011 in the Gulf of Mexico and resulted in the death four workers. The media is bringing renewed attention to the accident not because of the death toll, but because of the company's recent activity in the courtroom. The company that owned the operation filed a petition in federal court to limit liability in the fatal drilling rig accident. Details of Accident The accident involved a liftboat, which ...

Gene chip invented by CHOP scientist pinpoints new target to prevent heart disease

2012-03-15

A large international study indicates that anti-inflammatory drugs may become a new tool for preventing and treating coronary heart disease (CHD), the leading global cause of death. In investigating a specific gene variant linked to inflammation and heart disease, the researchers used the Cardiochip, a gene analysis tool designed by Brendan J. Keating, Ph.D., a researcher in the Center for Applied Genomics at The Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, and co-author of the study. Scientists already knew that inflammation is associated with atherosclerosis, the buildup of ...

Beating heart surgery may increase risk to patients

2012-03-15

Coronary artery bypass surgery performed whilst the heart is still beating may carry an increased likelihood of death, according to a systematic review by Cochrane researchers. The researchers suggest beating heart surgery should not be recommended except in specific cases where stopping the heart might be risky. Heart surgery in patients with heart disease caused by narrowed arteries has for many years been performed "on-pump", by stopping the heart and introducing a bypass to artificially pump the patient's blood. It is now possible to perform surgery without stopping ...

Hiding in plain sight, a new frog species with a 'weird' croak is identified in New York City

2012-03-15

In the wilds of New York City — or as wild as you can get so close to skyscrapers — scientists have found a new leopard frog species that for years biologists mistook for a more widespread variety of leopard frog. While biologists regularly discover new species in remote rain forests, finding this one in the ponds and marshes of Staten Island, mainland New York and New Jersey — sometimes within view of the Statue of Liberty — is a big surprise, said the scientists from UCLA, Rutgers University, UC Davis, and The University of Alabama who worked together to make the unexpected ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Early diagnosis of bladder cancer, now conveniently at home

People who are autistic and transgender/gender diverse have poorer health and health care

Gene classifier tests for prostate cancer may influence treatment decisions despite lack of evidence for long-term outcomes

Association of waist circumference with all-cause and cardiovascular mortalities in diabetes from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey 2003–2018