(Press-News.org) Irish playwright George Bernard Shaw once described England and America as two countries separated by a common language.
Now research from the Johns Hopkins Children's Center suggests that common language may also be the divide standing between mothers of critically ill newborns and the clinicians who care for them.
The study, published August 16 in the Journal of Perinatology, found that miscommunication was common, and that the most serious breakdown in communication occurred when mothers and clinicians discussed the severity of the baby's condition. Misunderstanding was common even when both the doctor and the mother agreed their conversations went well, suggesting a startling lack of awareness of the problem, the researchers say.
"One thing that we, clinicians, must always keep in mind is that talk doesn't equal communication, and just because we spoke with a parent we cannot assume that our message got across," says senior investigator Renee Boss, M.D., M.H.S., a neonatologist at Hopkins Children's Center.
The consequences of a communication breakdown, the researchers say, can be serious, hampering critical short-term and long-term treatment decisions and aggravating already high levels of parental stress, a situation often compounded by the new mother's own fragile medical state.
"Poor understanding of a baby's prognosis can lead to maternal frustration and dissatisfaction with the treatment plan, which ultimately undermines the goal of teamwork between families and clinicians," says study lead investigator Stephanie de Wit, M.D., a former neonatology fellow at Hopkins, now an attending neonatologist at MedStar Franklin Square Medical Center.
The findings, based on a survey of 101clinician-mother pairs, underscore the need for physicians and nurses to carefully gauge maternal understanding of the complexity of a baby's diagnosis, to communicate regularly with families and to help parents become more meaningful participants in their infant's care, de Wit says.
For their study, the researchers asked clinicians (physicians, neonatal nurse practitioners, nurses and respiratory therapists) and English-speaking mothers whose newborns were treated at The Johns Hopkins Hospital neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) to fill out questionnaires about their discussions of the baby's condition and prognosis. Most clinicians (89 percent) and mothers (92 percent) described their conversations as productive, but when the investigators looked at the actual survey results they noticed a notable gap between maternal and clinician perceptions about the severity of a baby's disease. In other words, the Hopkins team says, being satisfied with the conversation had nothing to do with how effective it actually was.
Nearly all mothers (94 of 101) could name at least one of their child's diagnoses and treatments. Yet, nearly half of the mothers (45 percent), disagreed with the clinicians' assessment of the severity of their baby's illness. Among mothers who disagreed with clinicians, nearly two-thirds (63 percent) believed the child was less sick than the clinician had indicated. Even mothers of children with serious or life-threating conditions such as sepsis, extreme prematurity or bladder exstrophy minimized the severity of the disease and described their babies as "not sick," "somewhat sick" or "pretty healthy."
"When it comes to discussing a critically ill newborn's condition, parents and doctors often seem to be speaking the same, yet different, languages," de Wit says.
For example, de Wit explains, the word "sick" may have notably different meanings to clinicians and parents. Parents tend to perceive as "sick" as a child who is in discomfort, vomiting or feverish, but to a clinician "sick" usually means a serious condition with poor or uncertain prognosis, the researchers says.
The investigators recommend that NICU doctors and nurses take the following steps to ensure effective communication:
Talk with parents as often as possible and regularly update them on any treatments their baby needs and why.
Be direct and unequivocal about the baby's condition, treatments and prognosis.
Eliminate medical jargon, complex terminology and doctor speak.
Be specific and define even the simplest terms and diagnoses.
Be sympathetic and warm.
Test maternal understanding by asking follow-up questions.
Ask the mother to summarize what she took away from the conversation.
The researchers caution that not all misunderstandings stem from failure to communicate.
"We cannot exclude the possibility that the sheer force of hope fueled unrealistically optimistic expectations, even when mothers fully grasped the objective reality of their child's condition," Boss says.
INFORMATION:
Co-investigators on the research team included Pamela Donohue, Sc.D., PA-C, and Jennifer Shepard, C.R.N.P., both of Hopkins.
Related
Journal of Perinatology
Teen Parents of Critically Ill Newborns Don't Get Severity of Illness
Parents Of Dying Newborns Need Clearer Explanation Of Options
Founded in 1912 as the children's hospital at The Johns Hopkins Hospital, the Johns Hopkins Children's Center offers one of the most comprehensive pediatric medical programs in the country, treating more than 90,000 children each year. Hopkins Children's is consistently ranked among the top children's hospitals in the nation. Hopkins Children's is Maryland's largest children's hospital and the only state-designated Trauma Service and Burn Unit for pediatric patients. It has recognized Centers of Excellence in dozens of pediatric subspecialties, including allergy, cardiology, cystic fibrosis, gastroenterology, nephrology, neurology, neurosurgery, oncology, pulmonary, and transplant. For more information, please visit www.hopkinschildrens.org
END
SALT LAKE CITY – Scientists have discovered that poxviruses, which are responsible for smallpox and other diseases, can adapt to defeat different host antiviral defenses by quickly and temporarily producing multiple copies of a gene that helps the viruses to counter host immunity. This discovery provides new insight into the ability of large double-stranded DNA viruses to undergo rapid evolution despite their low mutation rates, according to a study published by University of Utah researchers in the Aug. 17, 2012, issue of Cell.
Poxviruses are a group of DNA-containing ...
VIDEO:
Dr. James Bradner talks about how he and other researchers at Dana-Farber Cancer Institute and Baylor College of Medicine used a small molecule compound to generate reversible birth control in...
Click here for more information.
BOSTON—The development of a male contraceptive pill has long proven to be elusive, but findings from a new study may point scientists in the right direction to making oral birth control for men a reality.
Researchers at Dana-Farber Cancer ...
In multiple sclerosis, the immune system attacks nerves in the brain and spinal cord, causing movement problems, muscle weakness and loss of vision. Immune cells called dendritic cells, which were previously thought to contribute to the onset and development of multiple sclerosis, actually protect against the disease in a mouse model, according to a study published by Cell Press in the August issue of the journal Immunity. These new insights change our fundamental understanding of the origins of multiple sclerosis and could lead to the development of more effective treatments ...
LA JOLLA, CA – August 16, 2012 – Scientists at The Scripps Research Institute have made a breakthrough in understanding a class of cells that help wounds in skin and other epithelial tissues heal, uncovering a molecular mechanism that pushes the body into wound-repair mode.
The findings, which appear in an advance, online version of the Immunity on August 16, 2012, focus on cells known as γδ (gamma delta) T cells. The new study demonstrates a skin-cell receptor hooks up with a receptor on γδ T-cells to stimulate wound healing.
"This is a major activation ...
Coral Reefs, the Journal of the International Society for Reef Studies, has published online a study co-written by Dr. Gordon Hendler of the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County (NHM) about an invasive species of brittle star, Ophiothela mirabilis. The species was previously restricted to Pacific waters, but surprisingly, growing populations have established themselves at distant points in the Atlantic. Its presence near Brazilian and Caribbean ports indicates that O. mirabilis could have been spread by shipping.
The marine animal is colorful and six-rayed. It ...
In the face of a changing climate many species must adapt or perish. Ecologists studying evolutionary responses to climate change forecast that cold-blooded tropical species are not as vulnerable to extinction as previously thought. The study, published in the British Ecological Society's Functional Ecology, considers how fast species can evolve and adapt to compensate for a rise in temperature.
The research, carried out at the University of Zurich, was led by Dr Richard Walters, now at Reading University, alongside David Berger now at Uppsala University and Wolf Blanckenhorn, ...
Specialised group yoga classes could provide a cost-effective way of treating patients with chronic or recurrent low back pain, according to the UK's largest ever study of the benefits of yoga.
Led by the University of York, and funded by Arthritis Research UK, the study provides an evaluation of a specially-developed 12-week group yoga intervention programme compared to conventional general practitioner (GP) care alone.
The results published in Spine, show that the yoga intervention programme – 'Yoga for Healthy Lower Backs' - is likely to be cost effective for both ...
The growth of high topography on the Tibetan Plateau in Sichuan, China, began much earlier than previously thought, according to an international team of geologists who looked at mountain ranges along the eastern edge of the plateau.
The Indian tectonic plate began its collision with Asia between 55 and 50 million years ago, but "significant topographic relief existed adjacent to the Sichuan Basin prior to the Indo-Asian collision," the researchers report online in Nature Geoscience.
"Most researchers have thought that high topography in eastern Tibet developed during ...
Eribulin (trade name: Halaven®) was approved in March 2011 for women with locally advanced or metastasizing breast cancer in whom the disease has progressed despite prior drug therapy.
In an early benefit assessment pursuant to the "Act on the Reform of the Market for Medicinal Products" (AMNOG), the German Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG) examined whether eribulin offers an added benefit compared with the present standard therapy.
According to the results of the assessment, the currently available evidence provides "hints" that eribulin ...
COLUMBUS, Ohio - Almost 41 percent of Ohioans have visited a lake, pond, river or creek in the state in the past year, and of those, nearly one-half usually spend their water-related recreational time at Lake Erie, according to preliminary findings in a new report.
These figures and other findings in the report suggest that Ohio residents value their lakes and rivers, and particularly Lake Erie, as natural resources, but also help to clarify the risk that Ohioans face from contaminants in those same bodies of water, researchers say.
Among the risks: Some blue-green ...
