ANN ARBOR, MI, September 23, 2012 (Press-News.org) Nearly 50 years ago Congress passed the Higher Education Act of 1965, which bans colleges, universities and other higher-education institutions from using incentive-based systems for paying recruiters and admissions personnel. According to the Government Accountability Office, this Act is intended to "eliminate abusive recruiting practices" -- in other words, recruiting students to the institution whether they are qualified or not so that the institution can receive student-aid money.
In the last decade more than a dozen False Claims Act lawsuits have been brought against for-profit universities, like the 2007 lawsuit against Education Management Corp., which operates more than 100 campuses throughout the United States. That lawsuit alleged the institution defrauded the government of approximately $11 billion since 2003. The Education Management case was one of the first where government lawyers chose to prosecute the case themselves. In prior cases, such as the University of Phoenix which settled with an agreement involving more than $67 million to be repaid to the government, the government had declined to intervene. In both of these cases it was university employees that blew the whistle on the federal student loan fraud and received millions of dollars in finder's fees for bringing the case on behalf of the government.
The wave of recent False Claims Act lawsuits against higher-education institutions have mostly involved recruiting practices and mostly focused on for-profit institutions. The lawsuits against Education Management and Phoenix claimed the institutions violated the Higher Education Act by illegally using incentive-based pay for its admissions staff. However, the federal laws protecting against government fraud are not limited to recruitment practices or just to for-profit institutions.
Higher-Education Whistleblower Claims
Incentivizing recruiting is only one of several types of higher education false claims actions that may be brought by whistleblowers; in fact, any falsification in a program involving federal funding potentially can invite a False Claims Act lawsuit. For example, Title IV of the Higher Education Act ensures that students have access to higher-education institutions through grants and financial programs such as Pell Grants and the Federal Family Educational Loan (FFEL) program. To be eligible to receive federal student funding under Title IV, higher-education institutions must fulfill certain requirements like entering into a Program Participation Agreement (PPA) and either be accredited or pre-accredited by an agency approved by the Secretary of Education.
Further, grant monies from federal agencies also play a big role in the research being conducted in colleges and universities. Agencies often award research grants to institutions that will conduct research into areas or topics that interest the agency. To ensure the institution begins or continues to receive federal grants or student funding, there is an incentive to lie; whether that be about accreditation or the subject of the research to be conducted -- both of which are fraudulent acts. If an institution knows that it does not comply and yet still promises compliance, each of these areas can potentially give rise to a whistleblower false claim action against the university.
Research institutions in particular depend heavily on university research grants from agencies like the National Institutes of Health, the Department of Energy, the Department of Transportation or the Department of Defense, just to name a few. When university grant recipients knowingly lie about the research they are conducting or the results they are getting, the grant money becomes tainted. For those that are pursuing an education and a career dependent on these programs, the risk of coming forward can be very high. That is why the qui tam provisions of the False Claims Act were designed to reward and protect whistleblowers who would take such high risks. Whistleblowers who come forward to expose higher education fraud on the government may be entitled to recover a finder's fee as a portion of the amount the government recovers.
Title IV of the Higher Education Act (HEA) was enacted to benefit students by providing them with access to education through grants and financial aid programs. See 20 USC Section 1070. The Secretary of Education is charged with creating programs to carry out the purposes of the HEA. Id. Section 1070(b). These programs include the federal Pell Grants, the Family Educational Loan (FFEL) program, the William D. Ford Federal Direct Loan Program and the federal Perkins Loan Program. 20 USC Sections 1070a, 1071-1087, 1087a-j, 1087aa-ii respectively. For an institution of higher education to be eligible to receive federal student funding, the institution must enter into a Program Participation Agreement (PPA) with the Secretary of Education. 34 CFR Section 668.14(a)(1). The PPA "conditions the initial and continued participation of an eligible institution in any Title IV, HEA program upon compliance with the provisions of this part, the individual program regulations, and any additional conditions specified in the [PPA] that the Secretary requires the institution to meet." Id.
In addition to PPAs, an institution of higher education must also be accredited or pre-accredited in order to qualify for federal student assistance funding. 34 CFR Section 600.4(a)(5). While the federal government does not accredit institutions of higher education, the Secretary of Education is responsible for establishing the criteria under which accrediting agencies operate. 20 USC Section 1099B. In addition, the Secretary must publish a list of nationally recognized accrediting agencies that the Secretary has deemed to be reliable authorities.
Subpart F of Part 668 of the federal regulations regarding the general provisions of student assistance deal specifically with misrepresentation. An eligible institution is "deemed to have engaged in substantial misrepresentation when the institution itself, one of its representatives, or any ineligible institution, organization, or person with whom the eligible institution has an agreement to provide educational programs, marketing, advertising, recruiting or admissions services, makes a substantial misrepresentation regarding the eligible institution, including the nature of its educational program, its financial charges, or the employability of its graduates." 34 CFR Section 668.71(b); 20 USC Section 1094(c)(H)(3)(a)-(b).
Regarding financial charges, the regulations state that a "[m]isrepresentation concerning the nature of an eligible institution's financial charges includes, but is not limited to, false, erroneous, or misleading statements concerning . . . (b) whether a particular charge is the customary charge at the institution for a course." 34 CFR Section 668.73; 20 USC Section 1094. The regulations define a substantial misrepresentation as "[a]ny misrepresentation on which the person to whom it is made could reasonably be expected to rely, or has reasonably relied, to that person's detriment." 34 CFR Section 668.71(c).
If the Secretary of Education determines that an eligible institution has engaged in substantial misrepresentation, as described above, the Secretary has the authority to "(1) revoke the eligible institution's program participation agreement; (2) impose limitations on the institution's participation in the title IV, HEA programs; (3) deny participation applications made on behalf of the institutions; or (4) initiate a proceeding against the eligible institution under subpart G of this part." 34 CFR Section 668.71(a).
How the Federal False Claims Act Works
The False Claims Act ("FCA") is a civil statute that provides for damages and penalties for the knowing submission of false and/or fraudulent claims to the government for payment. The False Claims Act provides that any person who knowingly submits a false or fraudulent claim to the Federal Government for payment or approval is liable to the government for a civil penalty of not less than $5,500 and not more than $11,000 for each claim, plus three times the actual damages that the government sustained. 31 U.S.C. Section 3729(a). A university or other recipient of taxpayer money acts knowingly when it has actual knowledge of the information, acts in deliberate ignorance of the truth or falsity of the information, or acts in reckless disregard of the truth or falsity of the information. The Act also permits assessment of the civil penalty even without proof of specific damages. Id. Section 3729(b)(1).
In the context of higher education university student loan funding, the act of applying, renewing, and/or certifying compliance with the statutes and regulations required for participation in an institution's Program Participation Agreement, as well as the representations made to accrediting agencies as authorized by the Secretary of Education, are a precondition to Defendant's receipt of federal funds under Title IV.
Rewarding Risk Taking And Protecting Whistleblowers
Federal government lawyers did not initiate the Education Management Corp. lawsuit; a former admissions worker at Education Management brought it on behalf of the government under the False Claims Act (the federal government and other governments like the state of Minnesota later intervened in the case). Because it is nearly impossible for the government to catch all instances of fraud, the False Claims Act encourages employees and other knowledgeable people to "blow the whistle" on schemes that defraud the government. To do so, people with knowledge of fraud file lawsuits, known as qui tam lawsuits, on behalf of the government against universities or companies allegedly committing fraud against the government.
If the lawsuit is successful, the whistleblower may be eligible to receive a percentage of the government's monetary recovery. If the government intervenes in the case, the whistleblower may receive between 15 and 25 percent of the recovery; if the government declines to intervene, the whistleblower may receive between 25 and 30 percent.
Further, the False Claims Act protects employees from retaliation -- such as demotion, harassment or firing -- by their employers for bringing forth qui tam lawsuits. Employees that are retaliated against may receive their job back, compensation or other damages. The laws recognize that the stakes are high and that strong protections and personal rewards are the only way to get employee whistleblowers to come forward.
Incentive-based recruiting, misleading federal agencies about the research being conducted or eligibility to receive student funding are just a few examples of the many, many ways universities and government contractor companies are defrauding the taxpayers paying for our government. If you believe your employer is actively committing fraud against the government, speak with an attorney about blowing the whistle.
From our offices throughout southeastern Michigan, Nacht Law forcefully advocates all types of cases in all forums, concentrating in employment law, business litigation, civil rights and criminal defense. The firm has experience in corporate/commercial negotiation and trial litigation and represents clients in a wide variety of appellate work. We also provide corporations, governmental entities, and non-profit organizations with training and advice about human resources compliance, risk management and ethics issues. For additional information, please visit us online at www.nachtlaw.com.
False Claims Act Goes to College: Higher Education and Blowing the Whistle on Government Fraud at Universities
In the last decade more than a dozen False Claims Act lawsuits have been brought against for-profit universities; any falsification in a program involving federal funding potentially can invite a False Claims Act lawsuit.
2012-09-23
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Bike-Car Accidents: The Struggle for Safe Bicycling in New York City
2012-09-23
Common injuries from bike accidents include broken bones, burned or cut skin, teeth injury and head trauma that can cause brain injury, skull fractures and more.
Bicycle Use Growing
The New York City Department of Transportation, known as the NYCDOT, reports that commuting via bicycle in the city has "more than doubled" in the past six years or so, and about 500,000 residents use bicycles. The administration of Mayor Michael Bloomberg has aggressively promoted a pro-bicycle agenda, adding 255 bike-lane miles to city streets and expanding both indoor and ...
SSM Industries' Lightweight Flame Resistant Cotton Innovation
2012-09-23
Tennessee based SSM Industries, Inc. introduces PRO-C FR 12 CAL, the industries' lightest weight flame resistant cotton fabric to achieve an Arc Thermal Protection Value (ATPV) of 12 cal/cm2. PRO-C FR 12 CAL is a 6.25 osy fabric, made in the USA, flame resistant cotton knit fabric with a 12 calorie arc rating. This fabric innovation offers an increased measure of safety and comfort.
The utility industry has been calling for a single layer clothing solution with a 12 cal/cm2 ATPV rating. To help meet that need, SSM Industries, Inc. developed the fabric with the most ...
Meet Your Soulmate While Playing Bingo at The Bingo Cafe
2012-09-23
While we all know there are various sites flaunting their own chat rooms as being the best for finding love, but you should realize that you can fall in love using a better and a more exciting option. For people who love bingo games, the chat rooms of the gaming sites such as Bingo Cafe can help you find the right match.
A regular chat room consists only of men or women, desperate to find a partner. Some, who claim to be women, might actually be men who are trying to fool people and get attention. Due to this, most women, who are looking out for a prospective partner, ...
The effect of body mass index on blood pressure varies by race among children
2012-09-22
Obesity in black children more severely impacts blood pressure than in white children who are equally overweight, according to a new study presented at the American Heart Association's High Blood Pressure Research 2012 Scientific Sessions.
Researchers examined the effect of age and body weight on blood pressure in children at an obesity clinic. While age and body weight were similar among black and white patients, black children had significantly higher blood pressure compared to their white counterparts.
On average, the black children's blood pressure was 8 percent ...
Relation of poor sleep quality to resistant hypertension
2012-09-22
For people who already have high blood pressure, insomnia can have serious consequences, according to a new study presented at the American Heart Association's High Blood Pressure Research 2012 Scientific Sessions.
Researchers studied the sleeping patterns of 234 people with high blood pressure. Most participants slept six or fewer hours, and those who also reported poor sleep quality were twice as likely to have resistant hypertension as those who slept well.
Your blood pressure is considered resistant if you are taking three or more blood pressure medications but ...
New study shows providing non-caloric beverages to teens can help them avoid excessive weight gain
2012-09-22
Boston, Mass., September 21, 2012 –A new study published today in the New England Journal of Medicine shows that adolescents who eliminated sugar-sweetened beverages for one year gained less weight than those who didn't, shedding light on an effective intervention to help combat adolescent obesity.
This is one of the first high-quality randomized control trials to examine the link between the consumption of sugar-sweetened beverages and their direct impact on weight and body mass index (BMI), as well as how a teen's home environment impacts sugar-sweetened beverage consumption ...
Regular consumption of sugary beverages linked to increased genetic risk of obesity
2012-09-22
Researchers from Harvard School of Public Health have found that greater consumption of sugar-sweetened beverages (SSBs) is linked with a greater genetic susceptibility to high body mass index (BMI) and increased risk of obesity. The study reinforces the view that environmental and genetic factors may act together to shape obesity risk.
The study appears September 21, 2012 in an advance online edition of the New England Journal of Medicine.
"Our study for the first time provides reproducible evidence from three prospective cohorts to show genetic and dietary factors—sugar-sweetened ...
Cell death discovery suggests new ways to protect female fertility
2012-09-22
VIDEO:
Researchers have identified a protein which is important for the death of egg cells in the ovaries. The finding could lead to new ways to prevent infertility in cancer patients...
Click here for more information.
Melbourne researchers have identified a new way of protecting female fertility, offering hope to women whose fertility may be compromised by the side-effects of cancer therapy or by premature menopause.
The researchers, from the Walter and Eliza Hall Institute, ...
New ways to protect female fertility
2012-09-22
New research offers hope to women whose fertility has been compromised by the side-effects of cancer therapy or by premature menopause.
In a study published today in Molecular Cell, researchers from the Walter and Eliza Hall Institute (WEHI), Monash University and Prince Henry's Institute of Medical Research found that two proteins, PUMA and NOXA, cause the death of egg cells in the ovaries. Blocking the activity of the proteins may lead to new strategies to protect women's fertility.
The team, including Associate Professor Jeffrey Kerr from Monash, Associate Professor ...
Researchers examine how characteristics of automated voice systems affect users' experience
2012-09-22
The personality and gender of the automated voices you hear when calling your credit card company or receiving directions from your GPS navigational system may have an unconscious effect on your perception of the technology. Human factors/ergonomics researchers have studied how the gender and tone selected for an interactive voice response system, or IVR, affects its user-friendliness and will present their findings at the upcoming HFES 56th Annual Meeting in Boston.
IVRs have become increasingly popular, particularly with the introduction of mobile technology such as ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Houston Methodist researchers shed light on increased rates of severe human infections caused by Streptococcus subspecies
Auburn University hosts 62nd Hands-On Workshop on Computational Biophysics, featuring the new VMD 2.0
The Salton Sea — an area rich with lithium — is a hot spot for child respiratory issues
University of Maryland-YouGov poll: Alsobrooks dominates Hogan, amendment to state constitution garners broad support
Exposure to particular sources of air pollution is harmful to children’s learning and memory, a USC study shows
Change of ownership in home health agencies may lead to increased Medicare spending and reduced staffing levels, according to UTHealth Houston research
More resources needed to protect birds in Germany
Mission to International Space Station launches research on brain organoids, heart muscle atrophy, and cold welding
nTIDE November 2024 Jobs Report: Disability employment remains near historic highs over past 18 months
Researchers aim to streamline cancer detection with new method for liquid biopsies
New Huntington’s treatment prevents protein aggregation
Bee gene specifies collective behavior
Jennifer Bickel, M.D., named MD Anderson Vice President and Chief Wellness Officer
Evolutionary paths vastly differ for birds, bats
Political pros no better than public in predicting which messages persuade
Investment in pediatric emergency care could save more than 2,100 young lives annually
The dynamic core of black holes
Improving energy production by boosting singlet fission process
Smoking cessation and incident cardiovascular disease
Cannabis use during early pregnancy following recreational cannabis legalization
Research shows Cleveland Clinic’s therapeutic virtual yoga program can be effective for chronic low back pain
Closing in on Parkinson’s Disease proteins in extracellular vesicles in the blood
Regional and global experts convene in Accra, Ghana to update cancer treatment guidelines for Sub-Saharan Africa
China University of Geosciences (Beijing) unveils clues to an enigmatic geological process
Fueling greener aviation with hydrogen
Education, occupation, and wealth affect the risk of cognitive impairment
Revealing causal links in complex systems
Alzheimer disease as a clinical-biological construct— an international working group recommendation
Press registration now open for the EULAR 2025 Congress in Barcelona
New research identifies ways to protect neurons from the negative effect of high-fat diet on multiple sclerosis progression
[Press-News.org] False Claims Act Goes to College: Higher Education and Blowing the Whistle on Government Fraud at UniversitiesIn the last decade more than a dozen False Claims Act lawsuits have been brought against for-profit universities; any falsification in a program involving federal funding potentially can invite a False Claims Act lawsuit.