(Press-News.org) During presidential campaigns, it's not unusual to hear candidates from both parties say they will focus on strengthening the nation's economy. But how well have presidents delivered on that promise once in the White House?
On a newly-released report card that grades presidents on their economic performance, Franklin D. Roosevelt, Warren G. Harding and Rutherford B. Hayes are at the top of the class, while Chester Arthur, Herbert Hoover and Martin Van Buren receive failing grades.
The first-of-its-kind study by the Georgia Institute of Technology analyzed up to 220 years of data to estimate an economic "grade point average" for presidents who served from 1789 to 2009. The research, conducted by Mark Zachary Taylor, assistant professor in Georgia Tech's Sam Nunn School of International Affairs in the Ivan Allen College of Liberal Arts, appears in the October edition of PS Political Science & Politics.
On Taylor's report card, William McKinley and Millard Filmore round out the top five, and founding father George Washington still makes the honor roll with a grade of A-. Notable presidents such as John Adams, Harry Truman and John F. Kennedy rank slightly lower in the A-/B+ range. Bill Clinton and Ronald Reagan are the best-rated recent presidents, earning a grade of B.
Most existing presidential ranking systems tend to be clouded by partisan bias, subjective judgments and other aspects of presidential performance, Taylor said. This economic ranking system is based on objective, statistical data and is meant to be a serious way to gauge presidential economic performance.
"Put simply, if 'it's the economy, stupid,' then we need to make stronger efforts to properly judge economic performance and to assign credit and blame where they are most deserved," Taylor said. "These rankings are meant to constitute a scientific step in this direction."
Taylor analyzed data from the Measuring Worth Project at the University of Illinois at Chicago. He then graded the presidents individually using the traditional A-F (4-0 point) scale based on how well each performed in eight economic areas such as unemployment, inflation, interest rates, stock market returns and currency strength.
The professor used multiple and competing statistical measurements, ranking algorithms and time lags to ensure the data was unbiased. No historical or ethical judgments were used to adjust the findings.
Taylor's objective approach yielded some surprises, such as the high ranking of presidents who traditionally have been poorly regarded including Harding, Hayes and Fillmore. Also some national heroes – Abraham Lincoln, James Madison, John Quincy Adams and Andrew Jackson – each receive a D for poor economic performance.
"It makes sense when you dig into the history," Taylor said. "In the case of Lincoln, to fight a war, you have to print money and go into debt. That's bad for the economy in the long run, but sometimes there are more important things than the economy, such as staying united as one nation."
Taylor also found correlations between the characteristics of presidents and their economic performance. For example, presidents who have been good for the U.S. economy tend to belong to pro-business political parties, work with a Congress in which only one house is dominated by their same party, serve during wartime and were raised in middle-class environments.
Presidents with below average economic performance often belong to parties that are relatively pro-farmer, pro-laborer or pro-consumer. They tend to enter a single-party federal government in which one congressional house flipped parties, and they typically were raised in lower-class environments, the research shows.
Interestingly, presidential economic performance did not correlate with the person's pre-political career, birth order, historical "greatness" or whether he was a "dark horse" versus a well-vetted president, Taylor said.
Taylor cautions that these findings refer to the past performance of a group and cannot be applied to the 2012 election to predict whether Republican nominee Mitt Romney or U.S. President Barack Obama would be better for the economy. The study also did not include President Obama's first term because it is not completed and the data will not be available until 2015, Taylor said.
What the research does suggest is that a president can affect the economy, even though the executive branch may appear on paper to have a limited role.
"It is tempting to dismiss these rankings as the product of dumb luck: getting elected at the top or bottom of the business cycle," Taylor said. "Randomness surely plays some role in these rankings, but presidents also bear responsibility for making their own luck."
### END
Grading US presidents on the economy
Reagan and Clinton rate best among recent presidents
2012-11-02
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Cancer bound
2012-11-02
A person doesn't have to go far to find a polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH). These carcinogen precursors are inhaled through automobiles exhaust during the morning commute, are present in a drag of cigarette smoke, and are part of any barbequed meal.
Once ingested or inhaled, these big, bulky multi-ringed molecules are converted into reactive carcinogenic compounds that can bind to DNA, sometimes literally bending the double helix out of its normal shape, to form areas of damage called lesions. The damaged DNA can create errors in the genetic code during replication, ...
Navy researchers look to rotating detonation engines to power the future
2012-11-02
WASHINGTON--With its strong dependence on gas-turbine engines for propulsion, the U.S. Navy is always looking for ways to improve the fuel consumption of these engines. At the Naval Research Laboratory (NRL), scientists are studying the complex physics of Rotating Detonation Engines (RDEs) which offer the potential for high dollar savings by way of reduced fuel consumption in gas-turbine engines, explains Dr. Kazhikathra Kailasanath, who heads NRL's Laboratories for Computational Physics and Fluid Dynamics.
Many Navy aircraft use gas-turbine engines for propulsion, with ...
Solar system's birth record revised
2012-11-02
Some 4.567 billion years ago, our solar system's planets spawned from an expansive disc of gas and dust rotating around the sun. While similar processes are witnessed in younger solar systems throughout the Milky Way, the formative stages of our own solar system were believed to have taken twice as long to occur. Now, new research lead by the Centre for Star and Planet Formation at the Natural History Museum of Denmark, University of Copenhagen, suggests otherwise. Indeed, our solar system is not quite as special as once believed.
Using improved methods of analysis of ...
Disaster defense: Balancing costs and benefits
2012-11-02
Do costly seawalls provide a false sense of security in efforts to control nature? Would it be better to focus on far less expensive warning systems and improved evacuation procedures that can save many lives?
Seth Stein, a Northwestern University geologist, has teamed up with his father, Jerome Stein, an economist at Brown University, to develop new strategies to defend society against natural disasters like Hurricane Sandy as well as the effects of climate change.
The approach, which considers costs and benefits while looking for the best solution, is based on a ...
Were dinosaurs destined to be big? Testing Cope's rule
2012-11-02
Boulder, CO, USA – In the evolutionary long run, small critters tend to evolve into bigger beasts -- at least according to the idea attributed to paleontologist Edward Cope, now known as Cope's Rule. Using the latest advanced statistical modeling methods, a new test of this rule as it applies dinosaurs shows that Cope was right -- sometimes.
"For a long time, dinosaurs were thought to be the example of Cope's Rule," says Gene Hunt, curator in the Department of Paleobiology at the National Museum of Natural History (NMNH) in Washington, D.C. Other groups, particularly ...
Study: Alcohol, drug abuse counselors don't always require total abstinence
2012-11-02
WASHINGTON – Compared to a survey conducted nearly 20 years ago, about twice the proportion of addiction counselors now find it acceptable for at least some of their patients to have a drink occasionally – either as an intermediate goal or as their final treatment goal, according to a new study published by the American Psychological Association.
The researchers surveyed 913 members of the National Association of Alcoholism and Drug Addiction Counselors from across the United States. About 50 percent of the respondents said it would be acceptable if some of their clients ...
Difficult-to-read font reduces political polarity, study finds
2012-11-02
CHAMPAIGN, lll. — Liberals and conservatives who are polarized on certain politically charged subjects become more moderate when reading political arguments in a difficult-to-read font, researchers report in a new study. Likewise, people with induced bias for or against a defendant in a mock trial are less likely to act on that bias if they have to struggle to read the evidence against him.
The new research, reported in the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, is one of two studies to show that subtle manipulations that affect how people take in information can ...
Abstract thinking can make you more politically moderate
2012-11-02
CHAMPAIGN, lll. — Partisans beware! Some of your most cherished political attitudes may be malleable! Researchers report that simply answering three "why" questions on an innocuous topic leads people to be more moderate in their views on an otherwise polarizing political issue.
The research, described in the journal Social Psychological and Personality Science, explored attitudes toward what some people refer to as the ground zero mosque, an Islamic community center and mosque built two blocks from the site of the former World Trade Center in New York City. When the Islamic ...
Researchers 'watch' antibiotics attack tuberculosis bacteria inside cells
2012-11-02
NEW YORK (Nov. 1, 2012) -- Weill Cornell Medical College researchers report that mass spectrometry, a tool currently used to detect and measure proteins and lipids, can also now allow biologists to "see" for the first time exactly how drugs work inside living cells to kill infectious microbes. As a result, scientists may be able to improve existing antibiotics and design new, smarter ones to fight deadly infections, such as tuberculosis. The new study was published in today's early online edition of Science.
"The development of antibiotics has been stalled for several ...
Why seas are rising ahead of predictions
2012-11-02
Boulder, CO, USA – Sea levels are rising faster than expected from global warming, and University of Colorado geologist Bill Hay has a good idea why. The last official IPCC report in 2007 projected a global sea level rise between 0.2 and 0.5 meters by the year 2100. But current sea-level rise measurements meet or exceed the high end of that range and suggest a rise of one meter or more by the end of the century.
"What's missing from the models used to forecast sea-level rise are critical feedbacks that speed everything up," says Hay. He will be presenting some of these ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Researchers reveal role of zeolite zcid site accessibility in syngas conversion
Gender gap in teenage depression is twice as large in London than in Tokyo, new study finds
Coffee-making robot breaks new ground for AI machines
Protecting crops: Researchers open up new avenue to combat a widespread plant virus
UCLA discovers first stroke rehabilitation drug to repair brain damage
Only around 1 in 10 common non-surgical and non-invasive treatments for back pain effective
Installing safety nets on Golden Gate Bridge linked to 73% decline in suicides
Increasing fruit, fiber, dairy and caffeine linked to lower risk of tinnitus
Does BMI become useless as we age?
Rice statistician earns $1 million CPRIT award to advance AI-powered precision medicine for prostate cancer
Whose air quality are we monitoring?
Team Hope rides (again) for cancer research at the Tour de Scottsdale
Researchers find missing link in autoimmune disorder
‘Democratizing chemical analysis’: FSU chemists use machine learning and robotics to identify chemical compositions from images
Leveraging data science for disease prediction in the fight against rheumatoid arthritis
Kennedy Krieger screening model improves early autism diagnosis for underserved communities
Blood pressure patterns during pregnancy predict later hypertension risk, study finds
Latest Alzheimer’s drug shown less effective in females than males
Moffitt study finds vaccine may improve breast cancer treatment outcomes
Adoption of international auditing standards leads to better financial reporting
Internal displacement in Syria used to reshape the country’s political and social landscape, new study shows
Building a safer future: Rice researcher works to strengthen Haiti’s earthquake resilience
Diverging views of democracy fuel support for authoritarian politicians, Notre Dame study shows
Bacteria invade brain after implanting medical devices
New platform lets anyone rapidly prototype large, sturdy interactive structures
Non-genetic theories of cancer address inconsistencies in current paradigm
Food and non-alcoholic drink products in Mexico were substantially reformulated to be healthier following the 2020 introduction of warning labels identifying products with excessive content of calorie
Conservation efforts are bringing species back from the brink, even as overall biodiversity falls
Conservation efforts analysis reveals which actions are most helpful for endangered species status
JSCAI special issue explores the transformative role of artificial intelligence in interventional cardiology
[Press-News.org] Grading US presidents on the economyReagan and Clinton rate best among recent presidents