PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Massachusetts Court: Anxiety During Traffic Stop Not Grounds for Search

Massachusetts court rules that anxiety alone is not sufficient grounds for a search during a traffic stop.

2012-11-06
November 06, 2012 (Press-News.org) Picture in your mind the last time you got pulled over by the police. Between the loud siren, the flashing lights and the approaching police officer -- never mind the looming threat of an expensive traffic ticket -- you were probably pretty nervous, right? Maybe you fumbled with your wallet a little bit or acted anxious when you spoke with the police officer?

If so, you probably didn't think that your reaction was all that unique or suspicious. In a recent case, the Massachusetts Appeals Court agreed. It ruled that nervous behavior alone is not sufficient evidence to give police justification to conduct a protective sweep of a person's vehicle. Instead, there must be actual evidence to indicate a threat of violent crime.

Commonwealth v. Johnson

The case stemmed from a traffic stop in a known high-crime area in the Roxbury section of Boston. Two Boston police officers and one Massachusetts state trooper were driving in an unmarked car when they noticed that the vehicle ahead of them had ignored a red light and made an illegal right turn without signaling. After looking up the vehicle's information, they decided to pull over the vehicle on the basis of the traffic violations alone.

When officers approached the vehicle, the driver started behaving as if he was very nervous. According to the officers, he kept looking at his passenger and rubbing his hands on his thighs. In addition, officers said the drivers hands were shaking and he fumbled while removing his license from his wallet. The passenger was also apparently behaving nervously. At no point did either the driver or the passenger make furtive gestures or hide their hands. It was also discovered that the driver had an outstanding warrant for an earlier traffic violation.

Eventually, both the driver and the passenger were ordered to get out of the car. Then, the police officers searched the vehicle, claiming that the driver and passenger's nervous behavior raised questions that there might be a weapon in the car. During the search, officers found a handgun wrapped in a sock in the backseat.

Ultimately, the defendant was convicted of unlawful possession of a firearm. He appealed, claiming that police had searched the vehicle in violation of his constitutional right to be free from unreasonable searches and seizures.

Evidence of threat required for protective search

The Massachusetts Court of Appeals held that officers can only conduct a "protective sweep" of a vehicle when there is a reasonable fear that the safety of others might be in jeopardy. As part of that standard, officers must have specific information that indicates there might be a weapon in the car. The mere fact that a driver or passenger seems anxious is not enough. Similarly, the fact that the driver had an outstanding warrant was not sufficient, since the warrant was for a nonviolent motor vehicle offense and there was nothing to suggest that either the driver or the passenger had any history of violence or weapons possession.

As a result of the court's decision, the driver's conviction was reversed. When police violate the constitution in conducting a search, the evidence gathered from that search cannot be used in court. In this case, there was not enough evidence to uphold the driver's conviction once the gun was taken out of consideration. The case was therefore dismissed.

The court's decision makes it clear that police need to comply with constitutional standards before making an invasive search of a suspect or his property. Unfortunately, police officers sometimes try to unreasonably interpret these standards -- or disregard them altogether. If you have been arrested following a traffic stop, contact an experienced criminal defense attorney. An attorney can make sure that the rules were followed and ensure that your constitutional rights are protected.

Article provided by David Yannetti Attorney at Law
Visit us at www.davidyannetti.com


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Wisconsin Law Combats Distracted Driving Among Novice Drivers

2012-11-06
Wisconsin safety agencies are extremely concerned with the dangerous habit of distracted driving, which is commonly practiced among teen motorists. Did you know that car accidents kill more teenagers in Wisconsin than any other cause of death? Distracted driving is a major issue that contributes to this statistic. To combat the issue, Wisconsin recently passed a new state law that prohibits drivers with an instruction permit or probationary license from using a phone while driving. The law takes effect in November 2012. A driver violating the restriction on cellphone ...

Dozens of Food Poisoning Cases at North Carolina County Fair

2012-11-06
Recent events involving widespread E. coli, listeria and salmonella poisoning, as well as pharmaceutical steroids tainted with fungal meningitis, serve as a troubling reminder of the hazards we all face from food and drugs on a daily basis. Businesses and institutions that are entrusted with providing safe and sanitary food and medicines to others are rightfully subject to product liability or premises liability claims when their products or unsanitary conditions cause illness or wrongful death. More than 100 attendees at the Cleveland County Fair fell ill in October ...

Two New Research Fields May Help Improve Lives With Paralysis

Two New Research Fields May Help Improve Lives With Paralysis
2012-11-06
Paralysis works almost unimaginably profound changes on the lives of those it touches. Daily activities become difficult and nearly insurmountable challenges. While technology has made some strides to help people deal with paralysis, paralyzed New Yorkers and other Americans have long waited for a bigger breakthrough. Two areas are showing increasing promise and paralyzed people may have a new reason to hope for more progress. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) recently approved a new human study to continue exploring a treatment program that worked well in animals. ...

Atlanta Pest Control Company Team Pest USA Discusses the Correlation Between Heat and Insect Population

Atlanta Pest Control Company Team Pest USA Discusses the Correlation Between Heat and Insect Population
2012-11-06
Atlanta pest control company Team Pest USA would like to take some time to discuss the correlation between heat and insect population growth. You may have noticed the incredible amount of insects that seem to be buzzing around and biting each summer. There is in fact quite a disparity between insect populations in warmer months over fall and winter.. Last winter and fall were unusually warm. What this meant for insect populations was a lengthened breeding season. This longer breeding season last year lead to larger populations this past summer wreaking havoc on outdoor ...

Danny Bacher, CEO of Atlanta Limo Company Topper Worldwide, to Speak at the 2013 International LCT Show

Danny Bacher, CEO of Atlanta Limo Company Topper Worldwide, to Speak at the 2013 International LCT Show
2012-11-06
Danny Bacher, CEO of Atlanta limousine service Topper Worldwide, will be speaking at the 2013 International LCT Show, to be held February 5th through 7th, 2013, in Las Vegas. Bacher is a repeat presenter at the International LCT Show, having most recently presented at last year's conference. The International LCT Show is the largest limousine, charter, and tour industry show in the world. For 29 years, the International LCT Show has offered talks from a wide variety of industry experts, as well as networking opportunities, product showcases, and seminars at the MGM Grand ...

Georgia Health Insurance Broker McCart Insurance Discusses Common Dorm Illnesses

2012-11-06
Georgia health insurance broker McCart Insurance knows that going away to college can lead to home sickness, but that's not the biggest concern that dormitory residents face. Every year, college students face upper respiratory infections, stomach flu, conjunctivitis and mononucleosis. Some even face meningitis. The common thread of these dorm illnesses is that they are virus spread through human contact. While some, like the flu, are most often just an inconvenience, some dorm illnesses can be very dangerous to someone without a Georgia health insurance plan. Mononucleosis ...

GreenStar Waste Recommends Using Its Atlanta Junk Removal Specialists for Your Empty Nest Clean Out

GreenStar Waste Recommends Using Its Atlanta Junk Removal Specialists for Your Empty Nest Clean Out
2012-11-06
GreenStar Waste would like to recommend that you use a roll off dumpster in Atlanta for your empty nest clean out. When the kids move away to college, the house can start to feel a bit empty. That is, until realize that massive amounts of junk that they have left behind. Once you have made your peace with living in a home that is a bit more peaceful and feel ready to reclaim all of your space, it is time to work on clearing out the wreckage. By utilizing GreenStar dumpsters, the job will be a breeze. After you have decided which items are too precious to part with, ...

Yellow Ribbon Tree Experts Offers Complete Tree Services in Alpharetta

2012-11-06
Atlanta tree removal company Yellow Ribbon Tree Experts would like to remind residents of Alpharetta that the company offers complete tree services in that area. Whether you need a tree removed or trimmed, the Alpharetta tree services team at Yellow Ribbon can help. "We serve the entire Atlanta metro area, including Alpharetta," explains Gary Robertson, owner of Yellow Ribbon Tree Experts. "If you are in Alpharetta and need a tree removed, inspected, or trimmed, Yellow Ribbon can help." The Alpharetta tree removal team at Yellow Ribbon can do it ...

Atlanta Staffing Agency TRC Staffing Services, Inc., Notices an Uptick in Temporary Staffing

2012-11-06
One of the hardest hit industries during the worst of the recession was the temporary help industry, which lost over a third of its workforce. However, TRC Staffing Services, Inc., a staffing agency in Atlanta, has noticed that the demand for temporary help has risen almost back to pre-recession levels. Though this time of year traditionally sees an increase in temporary staffing due to the upcoming holiday season, this improvement appears to be a longer term trend. Temporary staffing has regained over 87% of the workers it lost during the recession's lowest point. Historical ...

Atlanta Granite Countertop Fabricator Premier Surfaces Announces Its New "In the Community" Page

Atlanta Granite Countertop Fabricator Premier Surfaces Announces Its New "In the Community" Page
2012-11-06
Atlanta granite countertop fabricator Premier Services is proud to announce that its new "In the Community" page is up and running on the company website. To access the page just visit the Premier Services website, hover your mouse over the blue "About Us" tab at the top of the screen, and then click "In the Community". Or, you can simply jump there directly at http://www.premiersurfaces.com/Community.htm. Once you are on the page you can learn about all of the past and current ways that Premier Services reaches out to the community, ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

A root development gene that’s older than root development

Research reveals missed opportunities to save George Floyd’s life

HKUST discovers novel elastic alloy achieving 20x temperature change and 90% carnot efficiency in solid-state heat pumping

Early prediction of preterm birth in cell-free RNA may revolutionize prevention strategies

Largest phase 3 trial of novel treatment for hypertension shows promising results

European regulation needed to prevent the birth of children with inherited cancer-causing genetic mutation after sperm donation

Assembly instructions for enzymes

Rice geophysicist Ajo-Franklin wins Reginald Fessenden Award for pioneering work in fiber optic sensing

Research spotlight: New therapeutic approach stops glioblastoma from hijacking the immune system

‘Hopelessly attached’: Scientists discover new 2D material that sticks the landing

Flowers unfold with surprising precision, despite unruly genes

Research spotlight: Study provides a window into public perceptions about technological treatment options for brain conditions

Sound insulation tiles at school help calm crying children #ASA188

More young adults than ever take HIV-prevention medication, but gaps remain

Why are some rocks on the moon highly magnetic? MIT scientists may have an answer

Unique chemistry discovered in critical lithium deposits

Numerical simulations reveal the origin of barred olivine crystals in early solar system

Daytime boosts immunity, scientists find

How marine plankton adapts to a changing world

Charge radius of Helium-3 measured with unprecedented precision

Oral microbiota transmission partially mediates depression and anxiety in newlywed couples

First vascularized model of stem cell islet cells

US excess deaths continued to rise even after the COVID-19 pandemic

Excess US deaths before, during, and after the COVID-19 pandemic

Millions of HealthCare.gov participants face coverage loss due to burdensome reenrollment policies, according to new research

Study: DNA test detects three times more lung pathogens than traditional methods

Modulation of antiviral response in fungi via RNA editing

Global, regional, and national burden of nontraumatic subarachnoid hemorrhage

Earliest use of psychoactive and medicinal plant ‘harmal’ identified in Iron Age Arabia

Nano-scale biosensor lets scientists monitor molecules in real time

[Press-News.org] Massachusetts Court: Anxiety During Traffic Stop Not Grounds for Search
Massachusetts court rules that anxiety alone is not sufficient grounds for a search during a traffic stop.